Polls apart

Clubbing general election with assembly polls goes against the spirit of federalism.

By: Express News Service | Published: June 9, 2016 12:15 am
 elections, lok sabha elections, state assembly elections, Election Commission of India, EC, parliament elections, modi poll clubbing, poll clubbing, lok sabha polls, narendra modi on clubbing polls, Clubbing general election, federalism, indian express editorial Election Commission of India. Express archive

The push from a section of the political class to have simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies appears to have found a resonance with the Election Commission of India (EC). The EC has informed the Union Law Ministry it could undertake the exercise if the logistical and financial challenges, it had flagged in its response to a parliamentary panel that studied the feasibility of simultaneous elections, are addressed. The challenges listed by the EC, though not “insurmountable”, are substantial and the cost involved may outweigh the financial gains claimed if Parliament and assembly elections are held together. From beefing up infrastructure and machinery to building a political consensus on drawing up a common poll schedule, the EC had outlined the many impediments that could make the exercise expensive and cumbersome. These apart, there are political reasons that ought to be considered before the proposal is pushed to its logical conclusion.

Though the first general election and elections to state assemblies were held together, the cycle diverged soon due to the federal character of the nation. States have followed their own poll cycles independent of the Centre, often necessitated by political realignments within. In a way, the separation of the poll cycle was the inevitable outcome of the constitutional federalism that defines relations between the Union and the states. The rise of powerful regional parties, often in opposition to the dominant Centre, further strengthened the federal element in the polity. The assertion of regional aspirations has contributed to the making of a fragmented polity and fractured verdicts, leading to the phenomena of coalition politics. A common poll schedule for the Lok Sabha and assemblies could lead to fixed terms for Houses, making coalitions a necessity than a virtue.

Assembly elections are now fought on local issues and, in the true spirit of federalism, parties and leaders are judged in the context of their work done in the state. Clubbing them with the general election could lead to a situation where the national narrative submerges the regional story. This could mean a regress for the federal character of the polity, which is best avoided.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. J
    Sep 6, 2016 at 7:20 pm
    periodic evaluation of party at the centre by the electorate through State embly elections' veridicts is an important instrument in the hands of voters which should not be snatched from them under the garb of financial costs etc. In the present era when Political parties use all the available marketing strategies to win the elections, burdening the voter-consumer with making two different choices at the same time will militate against the spirit of Free and Fair elections as enshrined under article 324 of our Consution.
    1. A
      Jun 9, 2016 at 10:52 am
      The very concept of fixed tenure at one stroke removes the fear of facing the electorate from the minds of elected representative and may lead to very different kind of calculations which we may not imagine at this time. Known devil is always better. What election commission can definitely do is to reduce the number of phases and the duration of actual voting period. The total span of almost two months is punishing for all including EC, unless EC has closed mind , it can always hold voting on same day all over India , at least for the " safe peaceful consuencies" as was done before .