Continuing scandal

Statistics confirm that the criminal justice system is inefficient, and prejudiced against minorities and poor.

By: Express News Service | Published: October 5, 2015 12:02 am

The National Crime Records Bureau figures for 2014 point to a problem that is still with us: almost 68 per cent of the inmates of India’s overflowing prisons are undertrials, and 70 per cent of those convicted are illiterate.

Affluent states like Goa, Punjab, Gujarat and Haryana top the list of states with the highest percentage of undertrials who have been in prison for more than three months. Notably, 21.1 per cent of undertrials in jails are Muslim, even as their percentage among convicts is only 16.4 per cent, closer to the community’s composition in the country’s population. These statistics are yet more confirmation that India’s criminal justice system remains grossly inefficient and blatantly prejudiced against the minorities and the poor. The cost of justice is kept prohibitively high by infrastructural flaws and deficiencies, while unreformed mindsets operating in a setting of poorly institutionalised norms contribute to the entrenched prejudices.

In 1987, the Law Commission, recognising that the low judge-to-population ratio is leading to pendency in courts, had recommended that India raise the number of judges from an average of 10 judges for a million people to 50 for a million. In the quarter-century since, the ratio has not improved. But missing judicial officers are only one part of the story. Physical infrastructure needs to be expanded and the necessary support staff provided to declog the system. The 13th Finance Commission had provided states with Rs 5,000 crore for developing judicial infrastructure, and the 12th Plan (2012-17) working group of the Union ministry of law and justice came up with a series of recommendations to overhaul the judicial system — but there is little to show by way of implementation and reform. For instance, the government proposed setting up 5,000 gram nyayalays in 2009 to ensure that “opportunities for justice were not denied to any citizen by reason of social, economic or other disabilities” — only 159 had been set up by March 2015.

Delays in investigation slow down the trial process. The police force in most states is understaffed, short on equipment, ill-trained in modern investigation methods and all too vulnerable to political interference and control. Notably, Muslim representation is at an abysmal 6.5 per cent, contributing to an institutional prejudice against minorities that is often on display. The bottomline is this: An overworked and underequipped force with a lopsided recruitment strategy and weakly institutionalised norms of independence and impartiality is unlikely to be an unprejudiced and effective instrument of law enforcement, and of the criminal justice system.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

    Live Cricket Scores & Results