Victor and the vanquished

BJP’s dominance could turn into hubris. But what if opposition’s despair turns into more timidity?

Written by Pratap Bhanu Mehta | Published:March 13, 2017 12:46 am
Narendra Modi, Modi Assembly results, Election 2017, Election results, BJP Modi, Modi BJP, UP Modi, UP results, BJP UP,  BJP opponents, BJP dominance, Congress, BJP Congress, India news Varanasi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his road show in Varanasi on Sunday. (PTI Photo)

Narendra Modi has scripted another spectacular political triumph. Before the election, there was a lot of hollow speculation; after the election, there will be many post-mortems. But there is no denying one straightforward fact: Modi is an unprecedented phenomenon in the annals of popular politics. He has reduced his competition to minions fighting over scraps. He has weathered every criticism. He has taken every risk and put himself on the line. He has defied every prediction, and written his own script of popular acclamation. No conventional wisdom of politics applies to him. Modi still manages to make other parties look like tired, corrupt, negative emblems of the past; people still repose faith in him as the energetic, clean, dynamic, hopeful repository of the future. No matter where you stand on the political spectrum, it will be churlish not to acknowledge this political fact.

The election consolidates the BJP’s dominance. The BJP’s triumph in UP, coming on the heels of a strong showing in local polls in Maharashtra and Orissa, consolidates its electoral dominance. This is made more robust by its social dominance — its social base now has an unprecedented depth and breadth. It has negated ossified logics of caste arithmetic to win over substantial numbers of OBCs and Dalits in addition to upper castes. The unacknowledged social story in the BJP’s rise is its transformation of the rules of caste politics and aligning them to a larger narrative. Almost no other party is able to tap into this transformative urge.

As far as electoral politics goes, the obsession with the mathematics of every sub-caste tells us more about an elite trying to do cheap sociology, entirely ignoring the fact that people are willing to vote big mandates, if they seem convinced of your sincerity and capability. And now, the BJP is also poised to increase its institutional dominance; the victory has profound implications for its ability to shape so many institutions, from the Rajya Sabha to the presidency. And electoral, social and institutional dominance will inevitably lead to unchallenged ideological ascendancy as well. Now, Modi is a position to contemplate even far-reaching constitutional reforms like simultaneous elections.

We are entering a new era of extraordinary dominance by the BJP. All institutions will be tested. We can discuss criticisms of Modi to death. But one thing is clear — whatever validity they might have, they do not have any legitimacy. We can speculate on what enabled the BJP to achieve this. If Modi has built popular acclaim, Amit Shah and his team built extraordinary organisational capacity that can work with a strength and single-minded purpose that is unmatched. But the ideological narrative is harder to pin down. Is it nationalism, the civic aura that demonetisation created, the undercurrent of majoritarian consolidation, or just the sense many still have that Modi is at least trying to do something? These interpretations will reveal more about the political preferences of the interpreters than they will describe reality. There has been, since 2014, a new political language and aspiration in the making whose full contours we do not quite grasp. It has elements of populism, but not of a conventional kind that merely panders to popular comfort zones — after all, this prime minister asked the people to bear with him while he inflicted hardship on them. And they responded. It has elements of nationalism and majoritarianism. But it also fuses these with elements of progressive hope that makes it more than reactionary.

But what should worry the opposition is that Modi has managed to outmanoeuvre them on every faultline of politics. He always had the nationalism space. Now, he has occupied the anti-corruption space more credibly by demonetisation and the projection of his image. More remarkably, he has also managed to occupy the pro-poor narrative that parties like the Congress and BSP thought were their natural territory — the opposition is simply not finding an issue on which to outflank him.

The Congress will take consolation in the fact that the AAP has not displaced it as opposition. It will cling to solace from its victory in Punjab and strong showings in Goa and Manipur. But when all is said, there is no getting around the fact that Rahul Gandhi is now an unmitigated liability for the party; Punjab happened despite him and is a credit to Amarinder Singh. But Congress has almost no state leaders of this kind left. What diminishes the party even more is that there are no challengers to Rahul — the very lack of open revolt diminishes the party’s character to the point where it is now the object of outright contempt. The young guard in the party does not have the courage and risk-taking appetite to revolt against a leader whose consistent losing streak, misjudgement, lack of imagination and symbolic value as an exemplar of the corrupt old order has brought the party to an unprecedented low in UP: If they do not have the courage to stand up to Rahul Gandhi, what leadership would you expect from them on any other score?

The elementary lessons of politics that have propelled Modi into a popular figure are lost on the Congress — power is not an entitlement, it has to be created and wrested away from others.

The result is a big shock for the BSP and SP. Unless there is a spectacular turn of events, it is difficult to see the BSP rebounding from this jolt. Narrow caste-based parties are now a thing of the past. Social fragmentation is not an obstacle to large-scale political consolidation. The AAP will be disappointed that an opening did not translate into victory. They will now also face a tactical dilemma — except in rare circumstances, any gains they make are, in the initial phases, likely to come at the expense of the Congress more than BJP. This is a real possibility in Gujarat — one that could help the BJP.

The opportunities and risks Modi’s dominance poses should be left for another occasion. Today, we should humbly acknowledge that Modi’s star is soaring, while the opposition is crashing to the ground. Rather than begrudging Modi his victory, his critics need to ask, why is their political credibility so low? Some worry that the BJP’s dominance will turn into hubris. But the more immediate worry is that the despair of the opposition may turn into even more timidity and stupidity.

The writer is president, CPR Delhi, and contributing editor, ‘The Indian Express’

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. O
    Onkar Singh
    Mar 13, 2017 at 4:25 pm
    Since nothing succeeds like success,writers will overlook the underhand means the BJP might have tried because the numbers are in BJP favour.Only the voters are the people who did not vote for the BJP and despite that BJP candidate won.Returning back to the ballot box can reveal the truth under CCTV cameras surveillance.This election should make the opposition sit up and ponder over where they have been duped by the BJP.
    Reply
    1. S
      Sridhar Sridhar
      Mar 13, 2017 at 3:45 pm
      A simple lesson from UP victory is: if people think you are sincere, they will vote for you. In the absence of a good candidate, votes are cast on caste or religious lines.lt;br/gt;Modi needs to deliver in UP to consolidate his future political career which is on the upswing at the present moment. Politics is a funny game and even the best have taken a hit. I remember Indira hi was humbled by a clown Raj Narain. lt;br/gt;Only safe bet is: delivering on the promises. The days of empty promises are over.
      Reply
      1. B
        Bedoon Esam
        Mar 13, 2017 at 10:22 am
        And what is the alternative believe in the megalomani of AAP or go back to the corruption of Congress, all these doomsday scenarios you predict will be overcome by market forces, Capitalism is the only ism that works compare numbers how many people have jholawalas taken out of poverty as compared to the number of sufficiently paid employees in the Ambani Adani companies
        Reply
        1. K
          Kiran
          Mar 13, 2017 at 2:38 am
          Dude, read the first phrase "Whatever validity they may have" ! These armchair leftists still believe their manufactured lies.
          Reply
          1. S
            SubbuI
            Mar 13, 2017 at 1:22 pm
            THIS WRITTER BHANU PRATAB MEHTA HAVE TO PONDER OVER THE UN EXPECTES AND MORE SUSPECTED UP RESULTS AND COULD HAVE ANALYSED THAT PART OF THE TALE TOO. NO ONE EVEN MOST PRO BJP ANALYSERS HAVE NOT EVEN EXOECTED 280 BUT WHERE COMES 315 SIR. THERE MUST BE A SOLID REASON OTHER THAN NALAYAK NMODI MAGIC. YES LET SOMRE OF THIS CHAMALEON BLOGERS PUT SOME HEAD ON IT.YES MODI IS THE WINNER WE KNOW THAT BUT HOW 315 SEATS? SOME THING AMISS FOR SURE
            Reply
            1. S
              SubbuI
              Mar 14, 2017 at 5:33 am
              MR MEHTHA A REGULAR IN IE IS VERY CONSTRUCTIVE COLOUMIST.IT WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER IF HE HAIS PONDER OVER SOME WHERE AS PART OF HIS OBSERVATION THAT HOW AND WHY BJP COULD GET 315 WHICH ARE EVEN THE MOST PRO BJP ANALALYSERS AND THEIR OWN ONES ALSO GAVE MAXIMUM 250 SEATS? NO TWO HOW IN THETHE MUSLIM DOMINATED AREAS BJP BY AND LARGE WON MMMM M MMM MAXIMUM SEATS? THIRD BUT MOST IMPORTANT KARYAKARTHAS OF SANGH AND BJP IN LARGE NOS WARNED MUSLIM VOTERS TO VOTE KAMAL OR THERE WILL BE DAMAAL. ALSO GAVE GUJATATH EXAMPLE WHICH IS FREE OF RIOTS SINCE 2002 AS THEY STARTED VOTING MODI THEN AFTER. THEN THAT" FEAR FACTOR " WORKED? THEY SAY "FEAR WASTHE KEY " FOR SUCCESS IN U P ELECTIONS THIS TIME. THE NEW INDIA IS ON MAKING?
              Reply
              1. K
                K SHESHU
                Mar 13, 2017 at 2:04 pm
                He has exploited political vacuum with deft handling
                Reply
                1. A
                  Amit
                  Mar 13, 2017 at 12:57 pm
                  Good analysis in IE after a long time.
                  Reply
                  1. A
                    Amit
                    Mar 13, 2017 at 12:59 pm
                    Mulla ya AAPya ya Communit ya pseudo-liberal. These four breeds have got a 10000 Watt shock
                    Reply
                    1. Z
                      zizek
                      Mar 13, 2017 at 3:21 am
                      While reading this article, there were moments when I couldn't believe that PBM has written it. Such an ability to grasp and present the reality as-it-is is a thing of the past for you scholars sir, is it not? But now, after this jolt I think your senses have awakened and you want to stroll down the critical thinking lane. So, welcome back Monsieur!lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Now a days when Pundits are going wrong -- and they are going wrong like anything, by Jove -- they are attributing it to the 'foolishness' of people and not to their own prejudices which prevented them from perceiving the reality. So, when BJP wins, it is because people are gullible and they were tricked by Modi. That's very offensive!lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;The Modi phenomenon may purify and put sense to a number of insutions and cles - political parties, 'intellectuals', Media houses etc. It's now time when either you mend your ways or you count your days!
                      Reply
                      1. J
                        Joe
                        Mar 15, 2017 at 8:18 am
                        Say people with dumb binary brains incapable or uninterested in representing the complexity of reality honestly.
                        Reply
                        1. A
                          Ajay G
                          Mar 13, 2017 at 9:21 am
                          Biggest tribute to organizational behaviour of BJP and RSS. No other political or social organization is cader based growth like BJP and RSS. lt;br/gt; lt;br/gt;Gradually that culture is decaying there also. None other than BJP can defeat itself.
                          Reply
                          1. A
                            ak dev
                            Mar 13, 2017 at 3:11 am
                            Congress and Left parties have a credibility crisis since 2002 Gujarat riots. Since then they have focused on discrediting Modi with false accusations and their media friends. Their w electioneering is based on abusing and ridiculing Modi. Contrary to opposition, Modi talks about the aspirations of people and what he will do for them. But when he does any thing, opposition creates obstacles in every possible way. Are Indians so unintellectual that they can't see through the game plan of opposition?
                            Reply
                            1. A
                              ak dev
                              Mar 13, 2017 at 2:57 am
                              Modi has rightly taken the centrist position as a government should not take sides.
                              Reply
                              1. A
                                ak
                                Mar 13, 2017 at 12:31 pm
                                Bravo Sir
                                Reply
                                1. A
                                  akbar khan
                                  Mar 13, 2017 at 9:05 am
                                  Eating crow has served your brain well. Good article for once.
                                  Reply
                                  1. A
                                    Aloena
                                    Mar 13, 2017 at 11:19 am
                                    As I mentioned, find one parameter on which Gujarat was better than TN.lt;br/gt;Coming to economist, it has been critical on many modi policies.
                                    Reply
                                    1. A
                                      Aloena
                                      Mar 13, 2017 at 8:58 am
                                      Modi ruled Gujarat for 12 years. Compare Gujrat in 2002 against TN in 2002 and for every year and find me 5 parameters where Gujarat was above TN by 2014.lt;br/gt;Now, compare India of 2004 against 2014. Compare that against India between 2014 to 2017 on different parameters - prices of essential goods, railway fares, railway accidents, soldier deaths - and understand the difference between good and not-good PM
                                      Reply
                                      1. A
                                        Aloena
                                        Mar 13, 2017 at 6:06 am
                                        Most opposition parties are found wanting. If they can see the picture and unite under someone (Nitish Kumar?), BJP will be defeated. The question is - will the opposition see the obvious and forget their ego to come together.
                                        Reply
                                        1. A
                                          Anti-corruption
                                          Mar 14, 2017 at 4:10 am
                                          Its a topic of Discussion the way Opposition is being out numbered by BJP govt. For democracy to run smoothly, for democracy to exist, a strong opposition in the Parliament is important... I do not oppose the mandate of BJP, as the current situation is a fruits of the seeds that Congress, and other so called secular parties has been sowing over the years.I am worried that if there is a decision which is not in the favor of public, would be ped easily now in parliament.....
                                          Reply
                                          1. H
                                            Homer
                                            Mar 13, 2017 at 3:45 am
                                            A jealous acceptance of the fact that the communal parties and Muslim league franchisees have been decimated and a nation building capable patriotic party led by a leader found only in pre-ndependence India has been gifted us. He is a clean open hard-working intelligent visionary with his body and soul surrendered to the service if his country and its people. THER IS NO OTHER PARRY LEADER WITH THESE QUALITIES.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments