Across the aisle: The people have voted; now, we hope

After slipping badly in Bihar, Modi has regained his prime position as a master of communication.

Written by P Chidambaram | Updated: March 12, 2017 12:24 am
uttar pradesh assembly elections 2017, Narendra Modi, Modi, PM Modi, UP polls, UP polls results, Up elections winners, Uttarakhand, Uttarakhand elections 2017, BJP, Congress, samajwadi party, Congress-sp, bsp, Rahul gandhi, akhilesh yadav, election news, india news, indian express news The man of the moment is Mr Narendra Modi. (File photo)

I was permitted by the editors to hold back this column for a day to take into account the results of the five state elections. That was necessary. It was also a wise decision.

There is no doubt whatsoever that the victories in Uttar Pradesh (UP) and Uttarakhand have re-confirmed that Mr Narendra Modi is the most dominant political leader in the country today. The scale of the BJP’s victory in these two states is unprecedented and mind-boggling. No one had been prepared for this — until the exit polls put out these numbers. I have to admit that, this time, the pollsters got it right and the election experts (including Mr Prashant Kishor’s team) got it wrong, reversing the Bihar experience!

Punjab also has delivered a clear verdict in favour of the Amarinder Singh-led Congress. Mr Rahul Gandhi’s decision to name Mr Amarinder Singh as the candidate for chief minister dispelled all doubts and gave the voters a recognisable name in which they could repose their faith after 10 years of misgovernance.

As I sign off this column at 4 pm on Saturday, Manipur and Goa seem to have delivered mixed verdicts. Small states with small-sized legislatures electing ‘hung’ houses does not augur well for good governance in those states.

Carefully crafted strategy

The man of the moment is Mr Narendra Modi. He has convincingly demonstrated that his appeal is pan-Indian. It extends from Gujarat and Goa to Assam and Manipur. After slipping badly in Bihar, he has regained his prime position as a master of communication. The text of his message in 2014 was development; in 2017, he has cleverly altered the text to development +, and the debate has to now focus on that elusive and indefinable element that he has added to the text of his message. The sab in ‘Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas’ has been subtly altered to include certain sections of the people and exclude others.

Uttar Pradesh was the laboratory to try the new, altered message. It was the perfect setting. Long divided and exploited on caste lines, with religious animosity just under the surface, the BJP tried to ‘Hinduise’ the castes and set them apart from the non-Hindu sections of the people (which in the case of UP meant the Muslims). The messaging was subtle: land for kabristan, but equal land for shamshan too. Electricity for Eid, but electricity for Diwali too. A fact-check revealed that there was no instance of discrimination as insinuated, but facts are not important when latent prejudices and animosities are brought to the surface. The BJP’s messaging found its target, the master communicator was at his best, and the results have proved that the BJP’s strategists were right.

Uttar Pradesh has a population as large as Brazil’s. The size of the Muslim population in UP is larger than the population of many overwhelmingly Islamic countries. Yet, the BJP claimed that it could not find a single eligible person among Muslims that it could field as a candidate in any of the 403 seats! The message was clear: Muslims will not vote for us or support us, so we are not required to field Muslims or support Muslims. The message was not so much directed toward the Muslims as it was to the castes that were to be brought under the project of ‘Hinduisation’.

I must also acknowledge that Mr Narendra Modi, after nearly three years as Prime Minister, remains an indefatigable campaigner. He is, at his core, a pracharak and he loves prachar. He set aside convention and conventional wisdom to campaign for three full days in his constituency, Varanasi. Since he has delivered an unparalleled result, I suppose no one is complaining!

Brace for the consequences

The results of the five state elections will have consequences.

On the eve of the Bihar election I had said that “win or lose, the BJP could move in either direction”. I had hoped that the BJP would pause, take stock, pull back and steer the country on the path of development. The BJP government did not. It pressed on with its agenda of hyper-nationalism. Self-appointed commissars asserted themselves in public spaces, universities and colleges (and recently even on the streets of Kochi). Dalits, religious minorities, young girls, women, gays, NGOs, social activists, journalists, academics and writers live in fear, in different degrees of course, but nonetheless fear. As a result of these distractions, the government has taken its eyes off the ball (of economy).

The so-called surgical strike across the LoC, the hard, militarist policy in the Kashmir Valley and demonetisation were major disruptions. I admit that large sections of the people are willing to believe the Prime Minister that these disruptive policies will be good in the long run, and I am perhaps in a minority. Nevertheless, the fact is that the growth rate of the economy measured by GVA (‘Gross Value Added’, favoured by the government) has slowed down perceptibly since Q4 of 2015-16. The growth rates of GVA in the last four quarters (that is calendar 2016) were: 7.83, 6.89, 6.69 and 6.61 per cent. GVA growth rates excluding government, agriculture and utilities were 8.76, 7.35, 6.47 and 5.73 per cent.

I cling to the hope that the BJP government will pause, take stock, pull back and steer the country on the path of good governance and development for all the people. We hope that jobs will be created, that investments will be made, that farmers will have better returns, that incomes will rise, that welfare measures for the poor will continue to be implemented, and that we will remain an open, free, liberal and democratic country.

Website: pchidambaram.in @Pchidambaram_IN

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. P
    Prashant
    Mar 12, 2017 at 4:50 am
    During MMS rule ,,govt used to show GDP,,,,,now during Modi rule u are using GVA ???😊😊,,,,sheer hypocrisy!!!!! ,,,Now my take is that nor GDP is important nor is the GVA,,,,it is the 65 lakhs LPG distributed in UP at free of cost did the magic,,,,,, Harvard scientist fails to understand that it's real benefits to the people shd rise,,not the GDP or GVA numbers,,,
    Reply
    1. O
      Onkar Singh
      Mar 12, 2017 at 11:51 am
      It's a superficial article paying paens to Modi as a master communicator.Thats the problem with people like PC.They do not think critically to examine the games the communalists have pla in the UP elections.Because the agenda of the communalists is to slowly advance their agenda of dividing the castes against castes, there by heightening caste tensions.And song nothing to less the inequalities in the rural heartland of the Hindi cow belt.Playing the lower castes against the OBC Yadavs they managed to draw a wedge in the BSP's vote bank.It will be some time from now that the other parties realise the divisive strategy of the BJP!!!!!
      Reply
      1. I
        indian
        Mar 12, 2017 at 2:45 pm
        2g, coal, tatra, augusta Westland, bofors, adarsh, vadra land, antrix.....
        Reply
        1. I
          Indian
          Mar 12, 2017 at 11:29 am
          Very convenient article from mr PC.. we will do nothing for 10 years (expect taking benefit of Vajpayee govt policies) and will give lecture to current govt when we r in opposition.
          Reply
          1. P
            PCr anpan
            Mar 12, 2017 at 1:44 am
            Your relent less efforts will bear fruits but not at godspeed. Dominitization will kill them. Many bers will follow. What can we expect if people are not educated. Hindutva caste divide and democracy does not go well. It shall produce such heady initially, but slow killer potions. Let them drink this "amruth" and become intoxicated. We will relentlessly go forward. It is not Modi its the mes 40% thats the problem.
            Reply
            1. N
              N S
              Mar 12, 2017 at 4:14 am
              Can we stop personally attacking some one having a contra view ? I am a 70 person with out any social security cover. The Retail Inflation remains unabated. While everyone is brazenly talking about Fiscal and Monetary Deficit, GDP calculation, NSO etc, no one even is even remotely remorseful about the high prices of essential commodities. May be the Government and fellow citizens clearly think that we have no place in the country and may be allowed die unceremoniously. Neither Congress nor BJP has ever treated it's Senior Citizens with any dignity. Will the present dispensation pay some attention to this neglected lot ?
              Reply
              1. S
                Seitheee
                Mar 12, 2017 at 7:02 am
                Mr.P.Chidambaram is clearly shocked by the win of BJP. A complete dishonest person as minister of Finance and Home, he should keep his mouth shut on what BJP should do. It is for BJP to decide whom they field as candidates. If it is true that Muslims are not voting for BJP, BJP has every right not to filed Muslims. Congress is a fraudulent party which divided this nation on caste and religious basis first and they do not have any moral standing to advise BJP. Namo is great and he will develop India and will do only good for the people even Muslims if they vote or not. It is better for PC to keep quiet after these elections.
                Reply
                1. S
                  Sumer
                  Mar 12, 2017 at 4:54 am
                  What a soar looser he is..........
                  Reply
                  1. S
                    Skillan
                    Mar 11, 2017 at 11:41 pm
                    A victory for a post-truth PM. Hard work is misinterpreted. Harvard is seen as elitist opportunity for rich kids and hardly as temple of knowledge. Wavimg to crowds and campaigning is missed for hard work. Reading is not. lt;br/gt;Inspite of all this the truth will triumph. If if doesn't it is not gping to hurt it it will hurt people. People like you had given sufficient early warning signals if it falls on feaf ears of 40% people then god save or spoil this country. Thanks for efucating us.
                    Reply
                    1. S
                      SubbuI
                      Mar 12, 2017 at 6:23 am
                      AMERICANS NOW REALIZE THEIR FAULT IN ELECTING TRUMPH AS THEIR PRESEDENT WITH THUMPING MEJORITY WHEN THEY SEE HE IS EXEEDING ALL LIMITS AND ACTING EACH MOMENT ACCORDING TO HIS WHIMS AND MOODS. WE INDIANS ARE MORE OPTIMISTIC AND PATIENT UNLIKE AMERICANS AND THEIR PRESS WHO ARE MORE ALERT AND TRUMPH WILL PAY FOR HIS MISDDEDS AND MAY NOT COMPLETE THE TERM AS HE CAN BE IMPEACHEDlt;br/gt;MODI IS BETTER PLACED AND CAN GETAWAY.FOR FUUL TERM AND CAN EVEN WIN AGAIN IN 2019 TOO.lt;br/gt;WHAT WE NEED IS AEFFECTIVE AND VERY SMART OPPOSITION STATERGY TO COUNTER THE MAN LIKE MODI WHO CAN CELL DREAMS AND CONVERT IT TO VOTES.MODI IS FLYING FAST AND FLYING TOO HIGH.BUT ONE DAY ANY THING GOES UP HAS TO COME DOWN. HISTORY IS WITNESS TO SUCH PEOPLE AND MODI IS NOT THE FIRST OS SUCH NOR THE LAST
                      Reply
                      1. S
                        STEP friend
                        Mar 12, 2017 at 12:00 am
                        You have done great work for this nation when you are in power. You delivered the dream budget 97. You delivered highest economic growth ever. You ensured more than 40 crore evacuated out of poverty and rescued to relative safety. You ensured best reformslt;br/gt; Now in opposotion you stood guard in parliament, tried to unite fearlesly the opposition. History will vindicate you very verry soon. Thanks sir.
                        Reply
                        1. A
                          Atul Sharma
                          Mar 12, 2017 at 6:04 am
                          Well done !! BJP once again.
                          Reply
                          1. V
                            V.O.C. Trichy
                            Mar 11, 2017 at 11:54 pm
                            You have once again as usual have done a great job in educating the people. But people are refusing to learn and placed their simple naive hope on PM. Atleast 40% of them. Demonitization had given frog in hot water syndrome. Now its lukewarm and cosy for the frog (people and PM), but before it turns boiling the frog may or may noy be able to escape. But it has to vacate surely and Let us see. You did a great work for the nation and is continuing to do so. Thanks sir. The nation will duly recognize this hopelt;br/gt; surely in right time. Thanks sir for a good unbiased article once again.
                            Reply
                            1. V
                              Vishnu pratap
                              Mar 11, 2017 at 11:28 pm
                              Great Article sir, at times of challenges. The fact is that demonitization is clearly a ber in the eyes of the educated. But in the eyes of the uneducated common people and the PM its a great manoevre. Let us see who has taken the eyes out of the ball. The ball is in the air till 2019. Are we getting under it and in rightly positioning is the question? Sure you are perfectly in position. Truth will triumph but not at godspeed. Even this big win does not ensure anything to BJP if opposition shows courage, generosity and maturity, which fortunately they are now forced too. BJP will have more space for more mistakes which unfortunately is not good for them. Thanks for an unbiased great article.
                              Reply
                              1. V
                                Viswanath
                                Mar 12, 2017 at 5:22 am
                                Chiddu continue to hang on to his failed narratives while his own son seemed to have learnt a lesson or two from the failed attempt in 2014.
                                Reply
                                1. K
                                  K SHESHU
                                  Mar 12, 2017 at 2:04 pm
                                  Congress past mistakes haunt the party in future
                                  Reply
                                  1. Z
                                    zizek
                                    Mar 12, 2017 at 3:32 am
                                    " I had hoped that the BJP would pause, take stock, pull back and steer the country on the path of development. The BJP government did not..."lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;See who is talking! The man belonging to a party where he bows down to that kid of a a man Rahul hi and Her Majesty, Sonia hi. Have you taken stock yet? Look at yourself before pointing fingers at others.
                                    Reply
                                    1. Z
                                      zizek
                                      Mar 12, 2017 at 3:34 am
                                      "Dalits, religious minorities, young girls...live in fear, in different degrees of course, but nonetheless fear..."lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;So, those who are not living in fear are not Dalits, religious minorities, young girls etc. Thanks for making that discovery, Mr PC(olumbus).lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;"I cling to the hope that the BJP government will pause, take stock, pull back and steer the country on the path of good governance and development for all the people..."lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;I cling to the hope that Congress will pause, take stock, pull back and unseat the mommy-kiddo from the Gaddi and would try to come up with that beautiful thing called DEMOCRACY within the party. How about that, huh?
                                      Reply
                                      1. Z
                                        zizek
                                        Mar 12, 2017 at 3:27 am
                                        And what a veritably nonsensical article, sir! This article is what is wrong with the intellectuals -- this article, which shows a complete lack of capacity by the author to practice what he is preaching to others: that is, to sit back and take stock of the reasons as to why people are embracing Modi and rejecting others.lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Let me just rebut some of his 'arguments':lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;"Mr Rahul hi’s decision to name Mr Amarinder Singh as the candidate for chief minister..."lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;How low can you stoop PC as to not credit the man (Capt. Amarinder) who got your party victory and instead to praise RaGa to have selected him for the Chief Ministerial candidate?lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;"Long divided and exploited on caste lines, with religious animosity just under the surface, the BJP tried to ‘Hinduise’ the castes and set them apart from the non-Hindu sections of the people... . The BJP’s messaging found its target, the master communicator was at his best, and the results have proved that the BJP’s strategists were right."lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Okay, so everyone who voted for BJP voted out of religious sentiments and not for anything to do with development! And further, they are all fools who got so tricked by Modi. How patronising!
                                        Reply
                                        1. V
                                          Vikrant
                                          Mar 12, 2017 at 5:52 am
                                          I would request the so called seculars and the intellectuals to continue with this hate Modi message. Their pride of being power for so long that they now consider themselves defacto rulers and repository of all wisdom. They still want to continue with tbeir caste based and religion based that had made them loot the country and share with the spill overs in media who then kept parroting the message to public. Those days are gone and till they realise this Modi cannot be dislodged. Modi can only be defeated by a person who can deliver more than him and the yuvrajs and shehzadas cannot do that
                                          Reply
                                          1. S
                                            Surya
                                            Mar 12, 2017 at 5:03 am
                                            Winning elections and implementing core agenda of RSS is aim of Modi. Do not expect him to pause, take stock, pull back and steer the country on the path of good governance and development for all the people.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments