• Associate Sponsor

The WhatsApp conundrum

Its encryption protects the privacy of users but prevents action against those using it to spread fake news, rumours and communal tension

Written by Asad Rehman | Published: February 5, 2018 12:48 am
The WhatsApp conundrum The problem of fake news and misinformation being spread via WhatsApp is not exclusive to India. It has become a trend across the globe.

The recent violence in Uttar Pradesh’s Kasganj displayed, once again, the threat WhatsApp can pose in such fragile times. After the death of a youth, Chandan Gupta, in the violence, rumours were spread claiming the death of another person — Rahul Upadhyay. These rumours were circulated on Twitter, Facebook and WhatsApp groups, among other social media platforms. Some publications even carried the “news” of Upadhyay’s death, which added to the the communal tension. Upadhyay later clarified to the media that the rumours of his death were greatly exaggerated, and were being used by people spreading hate and paranoia on social media.

The situation is distressing because there is no apparent solution or even a proper diagnosis of the problem WhatsApp poses for law enforcement agencies, and society at large. The issue of checking “fake news” and misinformation on WhatsApp has never become part of popular discourse. Unlike Facebook or Google, the messaging service did not play a role in allegedly “influencing” the US elections and is not as popular in the West. The challenge it poses, however, is far more complex.

WhatsApp works in a way that is fundamentally different from Facebook and Twitter. In the latter, it is comparatively easier to check fake news and prevent the spread of misinformation.

Posts on Facebook can be viewed by the friends of a user, whereas WhatsApp (the app is owned by Facebook) messages are encrypted end-to-end — a feature that is great from the perspective of privacy of users. Facebook newsfeeds are regulated by algorithms, which can be tweaked by the social media platform. WhatsApp’s rationale for its security is a viable one: The encryption helps messages, photos, videos, voice messages, documents, status updates etc from falling into the wrong hands and can be controlled by users. There is no way to turn off the end-to-end encryption.

I don’t think anyone would disagree with WhatsApp’s claims. And privacy, of course, is an increasingly salient concern for many of us. But for those who care about what’s happening beyond their private lives, the encryption presents a conundrum.

WhatsApp’s end-to-end encryption ensures only you and the person or group you’re communicating with can read and see what is sent, and nobody in between — interestingly even WhatsApp does not have access to the media and messages. When a message leaves a person’s phone, it is assigned a cryptographic lock, and only the person receiving the message has the key to this lock. These keys change with every single message that is sent.

In India, however, WhatsApp’s reach is what makes it dangerous at times. According to Satista, a leading statistics company, the number of monthly active WhatsApp users in India in February 2017 was 200 million — exponentially greater from August 2013, when it was just 20 million. The messaging application is being used more and more by rural and older populations, who are often new to the internet and less tech-savvy. With the prices of smartphones and mobile data falling rapidly, the number of WhatsApp users in the country will only grow.

The problem of fake news and misinformation being spread via WhatsApp is not exclusive to India. It has become a trend across the globe. Media organisations and fact-checkers face a problem every time they get a message on WhatsApp with something that is potential news. As passionate journalists, we always get excited by information that can make a news story. The problem with what we receive on WhatsApp is that often we cannot confirm the source of the message. Many messages are shared on groups, where you you might not have the contact of the person who has shared the the message saved on your phone.

A colleague recently received a message which said that the recent stoning on a school bus ferrying children was carried out by five Muslim men at a time when the anti-Padmaavat protests were in full swing. The message on WhatsApp had named all the five “accused” and was spread widely on WhatsApp and later on Facebook and Twitter. It was used to spread anti-Muslim hysteria and several people shared that message to make political gains.

What can be done? The spread of fake news through WhasApp is something we might not be able to control directly, and its encryption does protect the privacy of its users. This puts the responsibility of stopping this spread of misinformation on citizens and the media. People need to be told that messages on WhatsApp can be dangerous and false information can be spread by people looking to create trouble.

Most users do not understand the intricacies of technology. For them, the message needs to be repeated to drive the point home. Public figures and authorities need to stop sharing messages they receive on WhatsApp and the messaging app should issue disclaimers stating that messages can be false.

asad.rehman@expressindia.com

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Asad Rehman
  1. G
    guest
    Feb 5, 2018 at 8:35 pm
    tell me a single message that can match that pedophiles terror manual in its hate content,.
    (0)(0)
    Reply
    1. Seshubabu Kilambi
      Feb 5, 2018 at 7:18 pm
      There is a need to monitor misuse and abuse of technology specially relating to social media
      (0)(0)
      Reply
      1. Masa Kola
        Feb 5, 2018 at 4:10 pm
        Actually solution for Fake News is simple. The existing media should be unbiased and need notgive their' Faltu' opinion as news. Reporters should go ong people and not just in TV Studio.
        (2)(0)
        Reply
        1. Ghajabiram Sriramulu
          Feb 5, 2018 at 4:35 pm
          Same opinion! If mainstream media editors, journalists drop their biased views in spaces, coverage, wordings and headlines fake news or propaganda could be reduced. More than the news which is shown, the news which is not reported, highlighted or suppressed is the reason for false propaganda in social media. Journalists should be impartial, carry no ideological orientation and have commitment to Truth and Justice irrespective or minority or majority
          (1)(0)
          Reply
        2. M
          Maneesh
          Feb 5, 2018 at 2:23 pm
          This is utter nonsense. Encryption is a must in today's world of lurking cyber criminals. Going by the author's logic, even bank logins should be unencrypted for the fear of money laundering, terror financing and havala racketeering
          (2)(1)
          Reply
          1. D
            Dennis
            Feb 5, 2018 at 12:20 pm
            Dear Mr. Asad, there is gross misuse of Watsapp in Kashmir by means of which youths are instigated against Indians and the Indian government, why no mention of it?
            (4)(1)
            Reply
            1. Load More Comments