The Karnataka model

The state offers an alternative trajectory based on growth, and closing of social, religious gaps.

Written by Christophe Jaffrelot , Kalaiyarasan A | Published: March 8, 2018 12:45 am
The Karnataka model Beyond reservations, Siddaramaiah has implemented a slew of welfare measures in Karnataka (in picture: chief minister Siddaramaiah)

In a recent speech at the Mahatma Gandhi Stadium, Bangalore, Chief Minister Siddaramaiah presented Karnataka as a better model state than Gujarat because of its capacity to attract investments (Rs 1.50 lakh crore per annum against Rs 40,000 crore). He also used today’s standard metrics of development by saying that Karnataka’s growth rate was above the national average (8.5 per cent against 7.1 per cent).

But there are other criteria of human development: Karnataka has contained social inequalities on at least one count, the closing gap between the OBCs, SCs and Muslims on one hand, and the dominant castes on the other hand — and in this domain it has been more effective than many states, including Gujarat.

According to the Indian Human Development Survey, in 2011-12, the annual per capita mean income of the OBCs represented 89 per cent of that of the dominant castes — Lingayats and Vokkaligas — in Karnataka. In Haryana, Gujarat and Maharashtra, it represented only 49, 50 and 78 per cent.

Interestingly, the relative affluence of the Karnataka OBCs — in 2011-12 they earned more than the Gujarat OBCs, Rs 26,264 as annual per capita mean income, against Rs 25,488 for the Gujarat OBCs — was not due to job reservation. Only 12 per cent of the Karnataka OBCs got salaried jobs, against 15 per cent for the Gujarat OBCs. Karnataka OBCs benefited more from another dimension of the positive discrimination programmes: Quotas in education.

Indeed, the percentage of graduates among the Karnataka OBCs is slightly above that of the dominant castes, 4.8 per cent against 4.6 per cent. Gujarat OBCs lag behind, with only 2.1 per cent of the state OBCs reaching the graduation level, almost five times less than the dominant castes.

In spite of atrocities, Dalits lag less behind dominant castes in Karnataka than in Gujarat in socio-economic terms. While they got 68 per cent of the annual per capita income of the dominant castes in Karnataka, they received only 54 per cent of it in Gujarat in 2011-12 (against 57 per cent in 2004-05).

Muslims also do well in Karnataka as compared to some other states. In 2011-12, the annual per capita mean income of the Muslims was 74 per cent of that of the Hindus in Karnataka while it was 31 per cent in Haryana, 62 per cent in Gujarat and 73 per cent in Maharashtra. The average Muslims earned Rs 20,473 in Karnataka while they earned only Rs 18,864 in Gujarat. That was partly due to the fact that a section of backward Muslims has been included in the reservation list. The percentage of graduates among Muslims was 2.8 per cent in Karnataka, while it was just 1.6 per cent in Gujarat in 2011-12. Today, Karnataka is also offering a range of scholarships to all the minority communities, which benefitted over 14 lakh students.

These contrasts between Karnataka and Gujarat reflect diverging public policies and political trajectories. In the late 1970s-early 1980s, Gujarat and Karnataka were among the pioneering states in terms of reservations. But Madhavsinh Solanki had to give up his policy in 1985 due to Patel-led demonstrations and no government revisited them, whereas Karnataka, with ups and downs, made the legacy it had inherited from Devraj Urs fructify.

While the Gujarat Congress let the KHAM coalition desintegrate, the Karnataka Congress rebuilt what is today known as AHINDA, a Kannada acronym for Minorities, Backwards and Dalits. Siddaramaiah, who is himself an OBC from the Kuruba (shepherd) caste, has committed to increase, if reelected, reservations beyond the 50 per cent cap the judiciary has imposed in every state except Tamil Nadu.

The court would prevent that, but this promise may strike a chord even beyond the Backwards and Dalits. Indeed, the creative manner in which Karnataka has dealt with reservations has resulted in the inclusion of segments of the dominant castes, mainly Vokkaligas, among the OBCs: Vokkaligas who have studied in a school in a rural area are eligible for the OBC quota.

Here again, Karnataka could offer a model to Gujarat, Maharashtra and Haryana, three states where dominant castes are asking for reservations because of the critical situation of their rural segments. While some Vokkaligas benefit from reservations, Lingayats are following another route by asking for recognition as a religious minority.

Beyond reservations, Siddaramaiah has implemented a slew of welfare measures. On August 16, 2017, Indira Canteens were launched to serve subsidised food to the lower sections in towns and cities, a scheme akin to Amma Canteens in Tamil Nadu. The canteens provide breakfast, lunch and dinner at subsidised rates and attract daily wage labourers, drivers, security guards, and others.

In 2017, the state introduced the Ksheera Bhagya scheme, which offers milk to 37.52 lakh children aged from 6 months to 6 years, 5 days a week. Eggs are distributed twice a week to 14.85 lakh children aged between 3 and 6 years in anganwadis. This scheme, besides improving child nutrition, has helped reduce the school dropout rate. The Mathru Poorna scheme, also introduced in 2017, offers nutritious hot cooked meals to pregnant women and lactating mothers.

In 2017, too, the Anna Bhagya scheme provided free rice through the Public Distribution System to people below the poverty line, a relief to the rural poor as the state was reeling under severe drought. In June 2017 President Pranab Mukherjee signed the Karnataka Transparency in Public Procurement (Amendment) Bill, 2016, which provides reservations for SC/ST contractors in government contracts up to Rs 50 lakh.

Whether the social dimension of the Congress’ programme will be sufficient to win the coming elections remains to be seen. Certainly, the party has sent positive signals to the relegated Dalit jatis by promising them sub-quotas within the SC category, but the new alliance formed by the JD(S) and BSP may well make inroads among the Congress’ Dalit vote bank.

The state’s tradition of shifting from one party to the other in each election may help the BJP, especially if the latter succeeds in communalising the campaign and taking the state by storm with Narendra Modi as the chief campaigner.

Whatever the results of the elections, Karnataka stands as an alternative model based not only on growth, but also on the closing of social and religious gaps, in contrast to the socio-economic, caste and communal polarisations which prevail in western and northern India. But Karnataka may exemplify here what is true of the South at large.

Jaffrelot is senior research fellow at CERI-Sciences Po/CNRS, Paris, professor of Indian Politics and Sociology at King’s India Institute, London. Kalaiyarasan A is faculty at Madras Institute of Development Studies, Chennai.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Christophe Jaffrelot
  • The lure of the populists

    Populists repudiate pluralism, for the people can only be one and they are the people. This explains their tendency to disqualify their rivals, and even…

  • The most Hindu of them all

    Religion was always recognised in India’s public sphere — but, unlike now, in the plural..

  • A war of labels

    Accounts of Dalit protests in Maharashtra are incomplete, need to be leavened by context and history...

  1. S
    Mar 10, 2018 at 12:27 am
    May be for Mr. Jaffrelot, broad day attempted murder of Lokayakutya, congress engineerd killings of likes of Gauri Lankesh and Kalburgi to blame political opponents or murders/killings and attacks of serving IAS/IPS officers, induced suicides and killings of dozens of Hindu nationalists or garbage pile on city streets is mark of efficient and good governance as long as congress is ruling party! Why foreigners are so interested in congress retaining power?
    1. G
      Mar 9, 2018 at 10:09 pm
      Data given by author is of 2011-12 and it says Karnataka fared better for OBCs, Dalit, and Muslims in welfare as well as income percentage in compare to dominant caste and Hindus, 2011-12 was 3rd or 4th year of BJP rule whereas Maharashtra was in 12th year of Congress NCP rule. Author is trying to mislead thinking readers forget history very soon
      1. K SHESHU
        Mar 9, 2018 at 9:51 pm
        ..... But the divisive firces have entered ....the Karnataka govt must canvass its achievements vigorously to win
        1. Vikram Gurjar
          Mar 9, 2018 at 10:25 pm
          Data given by author is of 2011-12 and it says Karnataka fared better for OBCs, Dalit, and Muslims in welfare as well as income percentage in compare to dominant caste and Hindus, 2011-12 was 3rd or 4th year of BJP rule whereas Maharashtra was in 12th year of Congress NCP rule. Author is trying to mislead thinking readers forget history very soon
        2. V
          Mar 9, 2018 at 2:14 pm
          Karnataka had been voted as number one Corrupt state in the country... this is easily hidden by the writer! Wonder what has happened to IE....
          1. Sadanand Adka
            Mar 9, 2018 at 8:54 pm
            This frenchman is a bootlicker of looteri mata.who allowed 12000 NGOs to come to India to propogate christianity.
          2. Anmol
            Mar 9, 2018 at 1:49 pm
            Siddaramaiah is the best Chief Minister in the entire country. I am sure, Siddhu will very soon realise vision of making Karnataka Hunger Free !! Siddaramaiah has the courage to Dream and Conviction to Succeed, very diffe from leaders who just know how to make Chanavi Jumla.
            1. Indian Singh
              Mar 9, 2018 at 4:12 pm
              Dwell on the AHINDA STRATEGY of Siddha too. ........... Anmol is most likely to be a MUSLIM ............ else a CHRISTIAN. ............... Both MUSLIMS and CHRISTIANS support Siddha because his strategy is to DEEPEN the DIVIDE AMONGST HINDUS and UNITE CHRISTIANS and MUSLIMS. 200 CRORE was allotted to CHRISTIANS and 11981 CRORE for MINORITIES in last BUDGET.
              1. P
                Mar 9, 2018 at 4:56 pm
                Stop being Paranoid about Lefts, and Muslims and Christians.
                1. Indian Singh
                  Mar 9, 2018 at 5:03 pm
                  STOP being PARANOID about HINDU UNITY.
              2. Load More Comments