The dying light of freedom

The verdict is the deepest challenge to the idea of India since Jinnah’s two-nation theory.

Written by Mani Shankar Aiyar | Published:May 17, 2014 5:08 am

Darkness descends. The idea of India gutters. The light that lit our freedom struggle and so defined the nature of our nationhood is going out. We are at a moment of history that can only be compared to Lahore, March 23, 1940, when Jinnah persuaded one section of our society to accept that India was comprised of two nations because nationhood had to be founded in religious identity. Thus was conceived a Muslim Pakistan. But Gandhiji resisted India cloning that example with a Hindu India. For that, he had to pay with his life at the instance of the very forces that are today most avidly celebrating Narendra Modi’s victory.

The campaign has shown the incoming prime minister insisting that for any Hindu, India is his rightful home, thus equating India with Hindudom and reducing to sufferance those who regard India as their home but not Hinduism as their religion. My closest Muslim friend, viewing the imminent catastrophe, asks, “Was it for this that our parents decided to remain in India?”

I have reassured her that even if over a third of Indians voted for the BJP, nearly two-thirds did not. This is a low moment for us, but if Indian secularism is not a Nehruvian whim but the consequence of that secularism, that plurality, that inclusivism being woven into the warp and woof of our millennial civilisation, then this is not a moment of defeat but a moment of challenge.

We have to be on our utmost guard to spot the new government awaiting its Godhra opportunity. Godhra was to Modi what Marinus van der Lubbe’s attempt to set fire to the Reichstag was to Hitler. It gave them the occasion to ride a wave of public anguish to accomplish the deepest purpose of their political lives. We have been forewarned, therefore, we must be forearmed. This is not a moment for armchair secularism. The issue is not a philosophical or polemical one. It is a red alert to be vigilant and activist. We must convert Modi’s Reichstag moment, when it comes, into our Belchi moment. In the Congress, the Sadbhavana Sena died with its first and only chairman, Sunil Dutt.

That needs to be revived and converted into a rapid action force that reaches the spot the minute news comes in of a communal flare-up. Moreover, the sena must concert with other secular forces, irrespective of differences. India’s secular nationhood is too fundamentally important to be left hostage to other considerations.

There are two other fronts on which vigilance is called for. One is development. The so-called Gujarat model blazed the path to unashamed crony capitalism. That is why those thousands of crores of rupees of doubtful provenance poured into the coffers of Modi’s campaign, just as Krupp and Thyssen funded every step of the march of the corporal from the Beer Hall Putsch to the German Chancery. Hitler repaid them with the biggest bonanza ever. Modi waits to confer similar bounty on his benefactors.

Even as the nation’s secular majority must concert its efforts to preserve the quintessence of our nationhood, so must the forces of equity, social justice and human development concert their efforts to keep the country from being gifted to robber barons. The Congress may be in reduced numbers in Parliament but along with others not on the treasury benches, the voices of fair play for the aam aadmi will not be lacking in number. The socialist Lilliputians might yet tie down big business Gullivers and their political cohorts.

That brings me to the next, and related, imperative. Parliamentary institutions have been severely mauled in the BJP’s clambering to power. The last Lok Sabha was rendered by their antics the most non-functional ever. The Rajya Sabha followed suit — and often led the way. The incoming opposition, of which the Congress constitutes the largest single fraction, must unchain the speaker and chairman and insist that both Houses function in accordance with the rules and regulations of the House, its propriety and precedents, with dignity and decorum. Happily the saffron shouting brigade is on the treasury benches.

Hence the opposition can ensure that democracy is restored to its throne. The priority of the largest opposition party must be to restore Parliament as the nation’s highest forum for debate, not demonstration. And it is in Parliament that we can best thwart every effort of the incoming government to move towards its nefarious ulterior agenda.

On the external front, the first duty of every parliamentarian in this centenary year of the start of World War I must be to read all he or she can on the vainglorious strutting of jingoistic leaders that led those the Cambridge historian of the war, Christopher Clark, has called “The Sleepwalkers” blundering into a slaughter they never intended nor wished, a slaughter that began in 1914 and, with but a short interregnum, ended only in 1945, after nearly 50 million people had lost their lives. Shrill and narrow nationalism, as Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore warned, are the worst enemies of peace and humanism.

Yet, those two qualities are precisely the stock-in-trade of the party now coming to power. There is no Atal Bihari Vajpayee — surely the last Nehruvian — to rein in the chauvinism of what passes for “patriotism” in that party. The ideological extremists have taken over and will seize every chance to convert external events into the grand opportunity for flag-waving and mindless brinkmanship. Catastrophe worse than the two World Wars awaits this subcontinent, if those fortunate enough to not be on the treasury benches fail to be ever-vigilant and ready to risk immediate popularity for the larger cause. We have our work cut out for us. Let us put our shoulders to the wheel.

The writer is a Rajya Sabha MP  from the Congress

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. V
    Vatsyayan Vatsyayan
    May 17, 2016 at 11:41 am
    Mani Shankar is an eternal stupid.
    1. T
      May 17, 2014 at 3:38 am
      The author only willfully forgets that Hitler's coming to power in both Jan and March 1933 was on the basis of large coalitions, not a selective mandate. You sir have an utter contempt for democratic majority principle, and whilst an adhominem is not warranted to expose your blatant lack of political integrity (something evident in your ability to disregard 1/3rd) - do remember that you have LOST by 4 lack votes.^Some humility and introspection please.
      1. A
        May 18, 2014 at 3:34 pm
        Does Mani Shankar Aiyer even read what he writes?!.. These are very very serious charges which have been put on the newly elected BJP. Isn't the show of the Congress in this election enough? Isn't it enough that in the Lok Sabha, the Congress cannot be a opposition party as they are not even considered as a party anymore and are considered as a group in the Lok Sabha. This itself shows the sheer desperation of the congress party (Read: congress group)... and the sheer frustration that whatever they tried, it was just not possible to stop the Juggernaut of Modi. Also, the fact that most congress candidates have lost by margins of 100,000 votes and that many of them even forfeited their deposits shows how badly they fared. This gives no right to Aiyer to make these baseless allegations that a 'was is upon India and that we have to brace for the worse' !
        1. E
          May 20, 2014 at 5:39 am
          Well written sir
          1. S
            May 19, 2014 at 6:39 am
            The ilk of Mani and his cronies have been shown their place by people of India. People like Mani think that India still follows 'jhagirdhar' system where masters tell servants what to do. They feel power and government are their birth-right and none can claim access to it. The fact is Mani and his Congress cronies have been swept by Modi wave so much that most of his MP's and sitting Cong cabinet ministers have lost by more than 1L votes. Mani himself lost his deposit and stood 4th on Mayiladuthurai..... lets ignore this hi-sycophant. He has no relevance now.
            1. k
              May 19, 2014 at 10:07 am
              Waste of time....
              1. I
                May 17, 2014 at 2:10 am
                Darkness truly descends -- not on India but on the corrupt and sycophantic politics of India. Shudder to think that these are the people who were holding power for the majority of India's independence. Get a life and have humility in accepting the election verdict!
                1. B
                  May 17, 2014 at 11:34 am
                  Mr.Aiyar, your party and govt almost ran the country to ground. Did you ever talk about it? Explain Vadra, innumerable scams, jobless growth, Aadhar farce before you p your judgement on hope. Explain why a small business needs to wait 3 months to get registered and how all your party MPs looted the tax payer money. Also, explain the retrospective taxes that would have driven business out of our country which had to be reversed by the SC. You guys were the beneficiaries of a system that promoted sycophancy and rewarded it with loot at the cost of country and countrymen. Now is the time for change. We, the people, have made our choice - you guys had your chance, did nothing and now have to go home and let the country advance. We know to be the check and balance, you've lost our trust, now go back gracefully, grateful that you had a chance to serve. Don't pollute the electrons - they are probably the only ones not part of your scams !
                  1. K
                    May 19, 2014 at 6:53 am
                    congress group is frustrated to the core and has gone out of mind. Mani Shankar, you are trying to ignite communal hatred among the minorities by making such baseless and serious allegations, don't forget already case has been filed against Rahul hi for his 22,000 remark. Mani Shankar, you have been chucked out of the LS by people of India. Please spend time only with your family and save the nation.
                    1. N
                      Naresh Mathur
                      May 19, 2014 at 9:42 am
                      Just two things Mani; 1. Crony capitalism is well defined by 2G and coal allotments - Navin Jindal personifies the crony captalsim of UPA-2. and 2. The "pepper spray" MP on that date alongwith his so callled "attackers" belonged to your party and not wjhat you call "shouting saffron brigade". I know for hard core "ideologist"(anti-people to my mind) it is difficult to respect people's verdict!
                      1. M
                        May 18, 2014 at 10:00 am
                        What a sore loser... I wonder if its his sense of "enlement to rule"or his complete inability to hold up a mirror and see his own failings that's causing this handwringing...sad.You don't become the leader of a nation because you were appointed the Vice President of a party. You become one because people choose to follow you!!
                        1. M
                          Meetesh Kumar
                          May 18, 2014 at 2:16 pm
                          You are nothing but a sore loser and a sycophant. First win a embly or lok sabha election then talk.
                          1. S
                            Sambhav Singh
                            May 18, 2014 at 11:51 am
                            Very very sad Mr. Aiyer, I expected better from an intellectual like you, by no means is narendra modi absolutely innocent as far as Godhra is concerned and yes, there is need for constant vigilance to ensure the new government does not violate any principles upon which this country was founded, but then that is true for any government, not just for this one, for 10 years Sir we gave you clear mandate to run this country but you and your fellow party members shamelessly ran this country to ground, if today Narendra Modi is in power than the fault lies upon you too, the list of failures of UPA are far too many for me to recant here but let hits be noted, as far as Congress is concerned, the public anger has not gone away, there is more to come dear sir, keep a vigil for that too
                            1. S
                              Sharat Chandra
                              May 26, 2014 at 7:55 am
                              Read this extraordinary from Mani Shankar Aiyar. This is what we voted out, thank God!
                              1. S
                                May 30, 2014 at 10:16 am
                                This man is mentally sick and not fit for being in public life. A very frustrated congressi dog.
                                1. Load More Comments