Sinking Valley

New Delhi’s strategy of containment by force has failed, there is a deepening death wish in Kashmir

Written by Pratap Bhanu Mehta | Published:April 15, 2017 12:15 am
Kashmir, Kashmir man army jeep, man tied to jeep, Kashmir violence, Kashmir clashes, stone pelting, Kashmir nationalism, nationalism, Valley violence, Express column, Indian Express Kashmiri protester throws rocks at Indian security forces in Chadoora town, about 25 kilometers south of Srinagar, Tuesday, March 28, 2017. (AP Photo/Dar Yasin, File)

It is an unmistakable sign of the corrosion of Indian democracy that an odd combination of illusions and nauseating bravado is being spun in Delhi around the grim political situation in Kashmir. Every element of Indian policy in Kashmir lies in tatters. And yet, instead of asking forthright questions, our denial goes deeper. Kashmir now seems to be going from a deep and violent conflict to a state where there seems to be a death wish all around: Security forces with no means to restore order other than by inflicting death, Indian nationalism now more interested in showing machismo than solving real problems, increasingly radicalised militancy with almost a touch of apocalyptic disregard for life, foreign powers fishing in troubled waters, scores of young men and children even, who are making a statement that courting death seems a better option than what they regard as suffocating oppression. They are all feeding off each other.

The roots of the Kashmir problem are deep, and the point should not be to gloat at one government’s failure. The deep gulf between what the Indian state wants and what Kashmiris in the Valley want has always been unbridgeable. But over the last decade and a half, beginning with Vajpayee, there was an attempt to create at least some kind of modus vivendi that had three elements: Containing insurgency, relying on local political forces and elections to at least create partial modes of incorporation, and reaching out under some nebulous appeal to “insaniyat” or humanity. What has transpired in the last few months has made it clear that every shred of Indian policy is now ineffective even to produce a modicum of a modus vivendi in Kashmir. Whatever our counter-insurgency, or counter-militancy policy is, it is backfiring profoundly: Kashmir is more in the grip of militancy and radicalisation than at any point in the last 15 years.

Whatever our hope that some modicum of local democratic process can create a sense of participation has been belied by the single-digit turnout in the Srinagar by-polls: A stinging rebuke to faith in Indian democracy. Admittedly, the fear of violence and threats by militants contributed to this stunning debacle. Let us for a moment assume that it is just the threat of violence that kept people away. But isn’t that supposed to be the point? Why, after three years of this government’s strategy, are we less able to protect Kashmiri voters? What does that say of our counter-insurgency strategy?

It’s a fool’s errand to think that coercion alone will win India Kashmir. But more deeply worrying is the fact that the legitimacy of almost all conventional political actors on whom we have relied, from the PDP to the National Conference, is dipping rather than increasing. Their hold was always very tenuous. But it should be obvious now that they are not even remotely plausible instruments of placating Kashmiris. What other political interlocution will there be? And there is no space left for a dialogue outside of the realm of politics, a dialogue that can address the almost unbearable suffering this conflict has produced. We have regressed to a new and, even by Kashmir’s standards, a frightening low, in Kashmir, pure and simple.

But the disquieting thing is that no one in Delhi wants to face this truth squarely. The Indian emperor has no clothes. I am trying to imagine what the headlines would have been on Kashmir five years ago. This column was often critical of Manmohan Singh. But on Kashmir and Pakistan, he was wise, and it is a pity that we frittered away a slender historical opportunity to make progress on Kashmir. Yet, I can imagine, if the current catastrophe we are seeing in Kashmir had occurred under the UPA, Manmohan Singh would have been roasted and held to account. But we dare not say the truth that, for the moment, Kashmir has been lost on Modi’s watch.

The point is not to apportion blame. Maybe there is an overdetermined futility about Kashmir. But we are doing ourselves a disservice by engaging in a politics of diversion. More than militant propaganda, the way we talk about Kashmir does more harm to India’s cause in Kashmir which desperately requires breaking the cycle of othering and humiliation that has marked this conflict. It creates difficulty even when groups in the Valley do this. But it is inexcusable when those more distant wage their bravado wars of revenge to perpetuate this cycle, as if we were not talking about fellow citizens. We do this by making territory efface all considerations of the people: The militants did this by forcing out Pandits; but we risk doing the same by not recognising the core issue is not holding territory, it is giving people confidence in the Indian project.

Second, we are gullible enough to buy diversionary tactics. At the height of this unfolding catastrophe, what was most of Delhi discussing: Were some stone pelters paid to throw stones? The faux outrage at what might be true of some stone pelters completely obscured the larger question of why our Kashmir strategy is a failure, pushing us to new lows. Our discourse on Kashmir is enough to convince anyone that if the Indian state needs this much propaganda and diversion to convince people in Delhi not to ask hard questions, it must surely mean that it has lost the plot. Even our jawans will be better served if, instead of fantasies of revenge, we asked hard questions about why we have put them in this situation in the first place. But treating a serious situation as a farce does not do our credibility any good.

The quality of Indian democracy may not be sufficient to enable an opening in Kashmir. But surely it is a necessary condition. It is difficult to shake off the sense that as Indian politics continues on its pathway of jeopardising individual liberty, and finding proxies for targeting minorities, whatever toehold Indian democracy hopes to have in Kashmir will erode even further.

There is a long and arduous summer ahead. The international environment is turning against India: China is more aggressive; our obsessive desire to get aligned with the American military industrial complex will not yield dividends on Pakistan. In short, Pakistan’s strategic space has increased, not decreased. But we are looking at a situation where our strategy of containment by force has failed, our political instruments are hollow, and there is a deepening death wish in the state. Kashmir is looking at an abyss. Who lost the plot this time around?

The writer is President, CPR Delhi and Contributing Editor, ‘The Indian Express’

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. R
    Apr 17, 2017 at 12:04 am
    We Indians need to start using our IQ in Kashmir for a change. Who is causing the problem there for India? It is the Hurriyat Conference and the stone pelter mobs. Hurriyat Conference provides political cover. The stone pelters are organized at local levels with masterminds behind them supplying stones and money. The propa a is done by rabble rousers and clergy who use Islamist propa a. Funding comes from stan and locally. There is masterful use of social media like Facebook and Whatsapp. First of all, ban Hurriyat Conference under sedition law. Exile all leaders, all operatives, each and every one of them out of Kashmir permanently to some remote location in South India with no phone access. Cut off all social media permanently in Kashmir. Thirdly reach out to the clergy and offer them large sums of money to switch sides to India. Fourthly offer a 100 jobs program to all kashmiri muslim males above 15 years of age. Protect the borders with twice the forces. Problem Solved!!
    1. A
      Arshad Andrabi
      Apr 16, 2017 at 8:36 pm
      Kashmir dispute is new Delhi's own creation.Nehru went to UN,promised plebiscite to his friend Sheikh abdullah,later deposed him for jail,eroded autonomy granted to state, itz the duty of new Delhi to address the genuine sentiments of kashmiris.
      1. V
        Apr 16, 2017 at 2:34 pm
        The only good thing I can find in this Opinion section is the use of good vocabulary.Rest i think editor has a lot of antipathy towards India and that too comes under democracy :P
        1. F
          Apr 16, 2017 at 1:17 pm
          All the bigots spitting vitriol senselessly here have zero clue about the genesis of the kashmir problem...but their vitriol is full of confidence.Idia is doomed.
          1. S
            Apr 16, 2017 at 11:07 am
            Can't understand what writer want to say ,he is in his own confused enough what to tell in this letter , may be he is one of few Manmohan Follower !
            1. A
              Apr 16, 2017 at 10:24 am
              It's an article which has no direction of giving information and remains meaningless. It has been penned down without looking at the right of India over Kashmir and trauma suffered by our forces also. Writer should be thankful that due to our democratic set up he has been able to write up such meaningless meme at large. Had not been our forces that disciplined the writer must have been enjoying kahwa with his fellow ones in or heaven. Nobody has got the right to tarnish social, democratic set up of union of India. the writer Instead should incessantly thank god that he has been born in India and taken care by one of the most disciplined and valorous armed forces, rather lamenting on issue created by suck ups like himself. May God give him brains and balls to digest the truth. Kashmir was, is and shall always be ours. Jai Hind.
              1. G
                Gururaj Narayan
                Apr 16, 2017 at 9:39 am
                The article is full of lament, with hardly any useful suggestion . How is this writer any better than the shortsighted leaders in New Delhi?
                1. N
                  Apr 16, 2017 at 8:56 am
                  These opinions are just like other opinions dispensed while sitting in a cosy chair and enjoying warmth of your home/office. While the problem has been posed and that too half heartedly, finding solutions has been left to Political cl es, that too knowing fully well that our Politicians appear to have failed since 1948. In the present, the tiff between GoI and China about land route to Middle East can not be ignored. With dueling of current situation who stands to gain the most needs to be understood. Are we talking of 'Azzadi' to w J&K, authors needs to spell out! In my opinion, we have seeing this for more than half century, political solution to K problem does not exist and all Governments have been shy of implementing the only solution which could work.
                  1. A
                    Apr 16, 2017 at 8:23 am
                    The problems have been compounded by politicians who represent the region, and by others who are only interested to create an illusion that they are oppressed. In fact it is other way around. There are many videos showing people beating and har ing security forces who are unable to much, for fear of everyone trying to blame, even going to the extent of criminal cases. You can't expect to control wide spread violence with restrained efforts.
                    1. A
                      Apr 16, 2017 at 7:17 am
                      Is islamic terrorism not the root cause of Kashmir issue? Indian Govt's policy is? These pressti will not help real Indian cause ever.
                      1. S
                        Apr 16, 2017 at 7:04 am
                        The seeds of present situation as brought by the writer were planted during the gloomy period of previous government(UPA).None of the political forces in Kashmir are interested in finding a solution for their people. We have lost out on at least three generations,its for the people of valley to decide their fate themselves. Blaming the uniformed forces is the easiest way to add fuel to the burning point, you got be one amongst them to understand their role. Being in media you get an opportunity to put across things directly, it's more advisable to bring out actual facts on ground ,the ultimate goal of every player involved should be to bring peace and not add fuel to burning situation. Create awareness in the younger generation what they are missing out.
                        1. B
                          Bushan Lal Koul
                          Apr 16, 2017 at 7:03 am
                          The write-up of B.P.Mehta is timely & needs giving a Thought to by the sleeping Mandarins in North & South BLOCK--& PMO's office. The W country needs to address IT -------Fast Enough.???
                          1. R
                            Apr 16, 2017 at 5:01 am
                            The one and the only solution for keeping Kashmir with us to remove the special status given to it and leave for the President of India to govern it thereby making politicians there toothless.
                            1. S
                              Apr 16, 2017 at 2:25 am
                              There was never any containment, rss is trying to win elections by stoking Kashmir as a crusade against Muslims.
                              1. M
                                Murali Inala
                                Apr 16, 2017 at 5:46 am
                                But RSS is not there in other parts of world, where ever wars are going on. What about your ISIS.
                              2. S
                                Apr 16, 2017 at 1:49 am
                                The writer criticized the government for not being successful in so many words but otherwise has not offered any insights of what, why or how. In effect, he simply repeated 'you failed' to the government some number of times - but has not pointed to anything possibly done wrong. Neither has he covered what could be behind the militants' hostile position. It only confirms that about Kashmir , noone knows including the militants what the issues are and as far India is concerned, they would be ed if they did anything, ed if they did not again without undrestanding
                                1. A
                                  Ashok Suri
                                  Apr 16, 2017 at 12:53 am
                                  The author is not aware of how Kashmiris are made to behave by the gullible politicians and militants leaders ; environment is artificially created to suit their objectives and journalists like Mehta fall into the trap. Live there to understand & don't sit in your comfi environment to pen down the unreal.
                                  1. D
                                    Apr 16, 2017 at 1:20 am
                                    Nope, he ain't gullible. As a matter of fact, people like Mehta make their living out of treachery and propa a against the nation. Period.
                                  2. H
                                    Apr 16, 2017 at 12:30 am
                                    Modi has no strategy for Kashmir. He simply is fire fighting, while playing to the Hindutva gallery. As usual, Indian interests suffer deeply to benefit Modi's electoral politics..
                                    1. A
                                      Ashok Suri
                                      Apr 16, 2017 at 12:56 am
                                      Have you lived in Kashmir Or Do you have slightest idea as to how it feels to have left your home of many years?? Problem is not of local Kashmiri but external elements. Kashmiris are peaceful by nature & external elements are out there to create disturbances.
                                    2. R
                                      Apr 15, 2017 at 11:45 pm
                                      "दरबारी पत्रकार " like PBM can stoop to unimaginable level to get their daila quota of "Old Monk"..
                                      1. B
                                        Apr 15, 2017 at 11:01 pm
                                        generally this seems to be a congress take as is evident from tenor of letter .what is required is strategy of punjab i believe things will become better
                                        1. H
                                          hemanta acharya
                                          Apr 15, 2017 at 10:25 pm
                                          It's a success.militancy is localised now.cant u see this dumb head.
                                          1. Y
                                            Apr 15, 2017 at 9:48 pm
                                            The strategy you are commenting on appears to be an imagination that flourishes in your head. Data does not support any strategy in play. The system seems to be just taking care of each event in its momentariness.
                                            1. Load More Comments