• Associate Sponsor

Seedbeds of radicalism

Religion-based education in Pakistan has made universities a fertile ground for extremists.

Written by Khaled Ahmed | Published: September 23, 2017 12:15 am
pakistan education, pakistan higher education, pakistan extremists, religious education, pakistan, indian express news Education has produced terrorism. It sounds shocking but it is true: The kind of religion-based education given in Pakistan.

Pakistan is in the grip of terrorism unleashed by university-educated youth who kill in the name of Islam. A Karachi gang that was recently nabbed was found to have connected with university-level teachers and their students who were on the take from the Islamic State under the banner of Ansarul Sharia (friends of the Islamic way). The gang is busted and even the police, specially targeted by them “for publicity”, were traumatised when told who they were. In the photographs that appeared on TV, they look divine with their facial hair styled like the Old Testament prophets. If you met them on the street you would go down on your knee and kiss their hand.

According to the Sindh police’s counter-terrorism department, of the 500 prisoners it had studied, 64 held master’s degrees and another 70 had bachelor’s degrees, proving that their indoctrination came from the country’s own textbooks. A girl from a well-to-do family devoted to Islamism in Hyderabad had actually run away to Syria to be trained as a suicide-bomber but was caught in time before she could kill fellow Muslims in Pakistan.

Education has produced terrorism. It sounds shocking but it is true: The kind of religion-based education given in Pakistan. Such influence doesn’t end even after students join engineering and medical university. Universities turn out nuclear scientists who claim they can make electricity for the whole of Pakistan from a single djin. The textbooks don’t let go of nationalism which in Pakistan is India-centric and is useful among Pakistanis for judging each other too because judgemental is what you become instead of being inquisitive.

Finally, you end up doing nothing to India but doing a lot of harm to fellow-Pakistanis. India can pay an Islamist in Pakistan to kill fellow-Pakistanis. Particularly vulnerable are liberal Muslims who tend to defend the minorities, just as liberal Hindus don’t like it when Hindutva street power goes after Muslims for handling slaughtered cows.

But are Muslims anywhere else better-off? Surveys tell us that the entire Islamic world is abysmal when it comes to education: It is either the idea of jihad — constant warfare — or rivalry within the religion which makes normal education redundant. Teaching Islam: Textbooks and Religion in the Middle East; Edited by Eleanor Abdella Doumato and Gregory Starrett (Viva Books, 2008) makes the point quite clear.

In 1947, Muslim leaders were British-Raj-educated but led populations who had received much of their religious instruction in the mosque and madrasa. In 1949, they agreed to plan a constitution based on the Quran and the Sunna, in other words, the Quran and the Hadith, known only to the cleric. This is the point where the Muslim leader in Pakistan abdicated his right to draft a modern constitution. The rest of the Muslim world went through the same kind of pattern: People lived according to the worldview of the mosque while “modern” dictators ruled them by decree postponing the pledge of Quran and Sunna. Just as Pakistan thought of democracy in 1947 and pledged Quran and Sunna, the Arab Spring agitation against “modern” dictatorship too thought of Quran and Sunna — the banner in Egypt’s Freedom Square said “na’am lil-sharia” (yes to sharia) — and when elections were held and the Islamic party won, it turned out that the new rulers were interested only in religious law which they thought was pure democracy.

The leave-it-to-the-masses approach adopted by the founding fathers of Pakistan allowed the religious parties who didn’t win elections to retire to the seats of learning. Non-clerical parties fought and won elections by paying lip-service to Islam. They ignored the fact that religious parties were steadily winning college and university union elections and thus dominated the campuses. The “modern” rulers went to the United Nations and signed the Universal Declaration of Human Rights thinking all rights mentioned in the charter must be Islamic because how could Islam be opposed to human rights? It took half a century, and rule by an Islamist general in Pakistan, to realise that Pakistan had signed a charter allowing the right to change religion which Islam punishes with death.

With the passage of time, and the movement of the population from the village to the city and its elevation to the middle class, what was marginal in the shape of religious parties started becoming mainstream. Pakistan accelerated the process by opting for deniable jihad, in the process empowering the madrasa and its “mufti” leaders. The politicians delayed the process of rolling back democracy through religion by adopting Islamic rhetoric and stuffing the constitution with Islamic injunctions. They started saying Al-Hamdu-Lillah and Masha-Allah and allowed street power to trickle away to the non-state actors.

Last year, when the killer of governor Punjab was hanged, the clerical show of strength was frightening: The clerics held the killer had murdered a blasphemer and was therefore a saint for whom they built a mausoleum overnight. Today, university campuses are middle class; so is the army. And education is helping them look for the enemy within rather than without, within the Muslim community and within the Islamic world, as Pakistan goes on killing the Shia Muslims of Quetta after the Afghans have finished with them.

The writer is consulting editor, ‘Newsweek Pakistan’

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Khaled Ahmed
  1. Lurene Gisee
    Sep 26, 2017 at 10:33 am
    Terrorism's architecture has changed in the last decade. Tactics differ from territory to territory and level of fanaticism. It's not G pa's terror.
    (0)(0)
    Reply
    1. S
      Sarah
      Sep 26, 2017 at 6:54 am
      Europe was also ruled by religion, where the Church was in control of the population - and the education of the population. In the middle ages. And it is exactly the reason why we had the Age of Enlightenment and why for far too many centuries, Europe was infested with supers ion and fear, the people downtrodden and kept in the dark, in ignorance. The Age of Enlightenment paved the way for modern Western civilization. The Muslims can hate the West all they like for all I care - but there's a reason why we have the best standards of living ever seen in human history so far. We are advanced. And ironically the Muslims just LOVE to benefit from our modern world, whilst hissing hatred and jealousy for it. Pakistan is a failed state. Like every Islamic nation today, it is a corrupt and primitive place. Religion is the cause. Let them rot with it, if that's what they want so badly. Pakistan offers nothing good to the world.
      (2)(0)
      Reply
      1. S
        Shafted mohammed
        Sep 25, 2017 at 3:20 pm
        Pakistan the land of the pure has become Papistan that land of sinners. They are offering jihadi course in universities as they had bad luck to be born in pakistan that after death for jihad they would get better life and be born in some civilized country in Europe.
        (0)(0)
        Reply
        1. P
          papa imran
          Sep 26, 2017 at 1:22 pm
          s if only i could find a way to behad you
          (0)(0)
          Reply
        2. A
          anil
          Sep 25, 2017 at 3:20 pm
          India should start planning for post implosion of pakistan. All these extremists with AK 47 in hands will be free to roam all around the world but will choose India like Rohingyas have chosen India and there will be mad men/ women like Bhushan and Grover who will support these.
          (1)(0)
          Reply
          1. S
            Sarah
            Sep 26, 2017 at 6:59 am
            Well said, Anil. When Pakistan does implode- and we all know it will - there are 200 million Pakistanis who will be flooding your borders. That's a disastrous notion. India is doing SO WELL - to have to absorb those rabid crowds of Pakistanis will cause nothing but strife for India. India will have to make some brutal and cruel choices in order to maintain its upward trajectory in the world, taking in horde's of Pakistanis will do nothing but drag India back down.
            (0)(0)
            Reply
            1. P
              papa imran
              Sep 26, 2017 at 1:28 pm
              stop talking through your as- about well said anil ss he is an extremist hind and just as bad
              (0)(0)
          2. D
            D Prakash
            Sep 25, 2017 at 3:18 pm
            India's polity has to internalize that Islamic education system has a fault line as explained in this article too. It has ingrained stream of teaching of Islamic theology too. India needs to take a bold decision to do away with Madrassas and even Convents and Gurukuls too. There should be one education system devoid of religious theology or theologies.Government aids to Madrassas / Convents / Gurukuls are against the article 25 of the Cons ution too. Let us be ruthlessly secular in our thinking and practice.
            (3)(0)
            Reply
            1. Load More Comments