Fifth column: Rahul’s speech hit home

When Smriti Irani went on national television to rage against the Congress vice-president for being a ‘failed dynast’ and to mock him for his ‘failed political career,’ I realized he must have said something that really hurt.

Written by Tavleen Singh | Updated: September 17, 2017 1:27 am
rahul gandhi rahul gandhi berkeley speech, rahul gandhi political career, narendra modi, smriti irani, shinzo abe, bullet train, india-japan ties, congress rule Congress Vice President, Rahul Gandhi at Institute of International Studies at UC Berkeley, California PTI Photo

Last week’s festivities in Ahmedabad to welcome the Prime Minister of Japan were so spectacular, it felt as if the bullet train was already here. Bunting and lights decorated the streets and dancers and musicians performed all along the route to the Sabarmati ashram. Shinzo Abe and Narendra Modi rode in an open jeep instead of in bullet-proof cars. This delighted the crowds who cheered the cavalcade on and told TV reporters that their admiration for Modi was undiminished and that, of course, the BJP was going to win Gujarat again.

So the future should seem filled with cloudless skies. Right? Why then have I begun to detect the first signs of vulnerability in the Modi government? In the past three years there has not been a single moment when the Prime Minister has seemed anything but invincible. He remained invincible when the Aam Aadmi Party won nearly every seat in the Delhi Assembly within months of the general election that gave Modi a full majority in the Lok Sabha.

He remained invincible when the midnight elimination of more than eighty per cent of our banknotes caused such disruption and misery that Opposition leaders launched a united assault. Chief ministers arrived in Delhi and held public meetings to declare that Modi had stolen the people’s money and given it to his rich friends. The people will punish him through the ballot box, they screamed from public podiums, and our usually reticent former prime minister stood up in the Rajya Sabha to make a speech in which he called demonetisation ‘a case of organized loot (and) legalized plunder.’ Then came the BJP’s magnificent victory in Uttar Pradesh and they slunk off defeated once more. Privately, Opposition leaders admitted that Modi was undefeatable for now. Privately, they blamed Rahul Gandhi for this and whispered about his failure to ‘mature’ as a leader.

So it is ironic that it should have been Rahul Gandhi who last week revealed wittingly or unwittingly that the Modi government’s real vulnerability is the economy. Personally, I would have paid no attention to Rahul’s speech in Berkeley had Modi’s Minister of Information & Broadcasting not reacted the way she did. When Smriti Irani went on national television to rage against the Congress vice-president for being a ‘failed dynast’ and to mock him for his ‘failed political career,’ I realized he must have said something that really hurt.

He said many things. He accused the Prime Minister of creating an atmosphere of ‘violence and hatred’ and mentioned the murder of ‘liberal journalists’ as if this were routine and new. Journalists have been killed in Congress times too and although cow vigilantes were not so visible, there have been terrible occasions of violence and hatred under Congress rule. Unsurprisingly, the first question at the end of Rahul’s Berkeley speech was about the pogroms against the Sikh community in 1984. So it was easy for BJP spokespersons to refute the ‘hatred and violence’ charge but not that easy to deny Rahul’s charges on the economy.

He said demonetisation had been done ‘unilaterally’ and at devastating cost to India, and that it had broken the back of many small- and medium-size businesses, and caused great agricultural distress. He pointed out that the economy was now growing very slowly and that the Modi government had failed to create the 30,000 jobs that India needs to create daily. This is all true.

It is also true, as Rahul Gandhi pointed out, that the economy needs to start growing at 8 per cent to create the jobs that young Indians desperately need. What the Congress party’s heir apparent did not mention was that it was under his Mummy’s government that the economy began to slow down. It picked up for a few months after Modi became Prime Minister, but since that midnight hour when our currency vanished, it has been hurting badly. Small businesses were just beginning to recover when along came GST and hit them once more with complicated rates and paperwork. Some of the rules have left even officials confused, so for the moment the economy remains tangled in reams of red tape. Big companies can hire experts to help them negotiate the regulatory maze. Small companies cannot so they are hurting more.

This is not good news for the Prime Minister because it was with the hope that he would bring prosperity, jobs and real change that the Indian people gave him the first full majority in thirty years. So are voters beginning to feel betrayed? It is clear from recent polls that Modi’s personal popularity remains intact. He is seen as an honest man trying to do the best he can for the country, but many others in his team are not seen this way. Only a dramatic economic upturn will make voters overlook some glaring flaws in his governance.

Follow Tavleen Singh on Twitter@ tavleen_singh

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Tavleen Singh
Tavleen Singh
  1. N
    Oct 16, 2017 at 8:17 pm
    1. A
      Sep 27, 2017 at 1:58 pm
      This Rahul koothy says that Gujrat has to be ruled by Gujrati only NOT BY OUTSIDER . wHAT HE THINKS OF SONIO? Real Indian or OUTSIDER? When he says non-gujrathi should not rule Gujrat, how can this family of Italians aspire for ruling India ? THEY ARE OUSIDERS AFTERALL.
      1. G
        Sep 22, 2017 at 11:14 am
        Congress must project Rahul a simple, honest, fine gentle man who is not part of dirty, goondas politics who is a better alternative to a talkative, over promising Modi. To some extent Congress was successful in making public believe that PM is not capable of walking the talk rather PM's loose talk hurt India s image abroad.PM would be foolish if he thinks all development took place in 3 years. Kudos to Congress for pulling India from a nadir to Niche in 70 years. It was not easy to rule extremely multi-dimensional diverse India in the state Britishers had left. I heard someone saying, a week is a lot in politics. Now, Congress has some agenda to fight election- unemployment, falling GDP and Intolerance. Besides, the present Govt instead of motivating youths to work hard for the betterment , it pushed them to fight for Gau Raksha The only job BJP created was to troll gentle people, bother intellectual, secular minded folks. Mind you- Modi is not invincible!
        1. A
          Sep 27, 2017 at 2:00 pm
        2. T
          Sep 19, 2017 at 12:39 am
          "Only a dramatic economic upturn will make voters overlook some glaring flaws in his governanc" The last line says it all .... its all about the money . ..
          1. T
            Sep 19, 2017 at 12:27 am
            What he said about arrogance of congress since 2012 brought them down is absolutely correct . But the present government has been arrogent from the day 1 they came to power . And this arrogance will surely bring them down to . Rahul gandhi is already showing signs of improvement and even if he doesnt win in 2019 its gonna be tough for present arrogant government to win with clear majority .
            1. Load More Comments