But will a nodal ministry at the Centre solve all issues in a federal structure such as ours?
In its determination to politically destroy Indira Gandhi, the party succeeded in hastening her return to power.
Rajasthan government’s decision to ‘target’ free medicines and diagnostics is contrary to the recommended role of government in healthcare
Leading a protest movement that has been messy, inchoate and inconclusive, the 61-year-old is seen as having disastrously overreached.
Ishant Sharma’s selection,Gautam Gambhir’s non-inclusion are two questionable decisions made by selectors.
When good people do unexpected things,you search for reasons why they could be right before condemning their choices. And it was with that objective that I sat down to look at the Test team to South Africa. A selection committee that has done a wonderful job so far has picked a side that I hope perplexes more people than just me.
For a start,seventeen players for two Tests? Ideally,you look at the different skills you need in the playing eleven and pick an option for each should there be a last minute injury. Unless the pitches South Africa offer India are going to be drastically different,and that has as much chance as India giving them a Durban lookalike at home,you would play two openers,four other batsmen,a wicket keeper,a spinner and three seamers. So,on the outside you need sixteen players. But I suspect the selectors have broken down those categories and found themselves in a dilemma over the choice of spinners. Hence this unusual selection.
In South Africa,you are unlikely to play both Zaheer Khan and Bhuvaneshwar Kumar; you cant have two swing bowlers largely on the friendly side of 130 kmph. That means two quicker bowlers,most likely Mohd Shami and Umesh Yadav. And Ishant Sharma as cover for one of them. That is five bowlers already. Ravichandran Ashwin picks himself and Pragyan Ojha cant be dropped immediately after figures of 10-89. But then there is this theory that you could play five bowlers in South Africa. Neither of the five seamers bats and Ojha doesnt either,so the only way to do that is to pick Ravindra Jadeja and hope that he fits in with Dhoni and Ashwin in some permutation at numbers 6,7 and 8. So that base had to be covered. That is eight bowlers already.
Given Dhonis workload,it is fair to pick a second wicket keeper,and Wriddhiman Saha has done well enough to get that spot. So,with ten players ostensibly needed,it leaves little room for reserve batsmen. That is where this selection becomes a little difficult to fathom.
When India travel overseas,the most important aspect is the new ball; bowling it and facing it. India have picked two openers,neither of whom has really been tested overseas. It is fair to assume that Murali Vijay and Shikhar Dhawan will get both Tests,but if one of them breaks a finger,for example,who opens the batting for India? On the assumption that Ajinkya Rahane will finally get an extended run in the middle order (the selectors have made it clear that is where they seem him batting),and Ambati Rayudu is the back up batsman there,a hole materialises at the top of the order.
I suspect because this is a short tour,Cheteshwar Pujara is the fall-back option,and while that is not wrong in itself,it has to be an emergency option not part of a plan. People like to play in their positions and will have earned the right to do so. Rahul Dravid didnt enjoy opening the continued…