Owning a friendship

Sushma Swaraj’s Israel visit took place against the backdrop of the Indian Ocean’s growing significance for bilateral security.

Written by Martin Sherman | Updated: January 22, 2016 12:07 am
India's Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj speaks during the 70th session of the United Nations General Assembly. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig) India’s Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj speaks during the 70th session of the United Nations General Assembly. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

As 2015 drew to an end, reports appeared in the Indian and Israeli press of an event of potentially far-reaching strategic importance, which went largely unmentioned in the mainstream media in the West.

The reports referred to the successful testing of the “Barak-8” long-range surface-to-air missile somewhere in the Indian Ocean, from the Indian navy’s stealth destroyer, INS Kolkata. The Barak-8 (“Lightening” in Hebrew), brimming with cutting-edge technology, is the product of a joint Indo-Israeli development endeavour. It reflects precisely the culmination of a process envisaged in a policy-paper this writer had co-authored with the late M.L. Sondhi as far back as 1998, when Indo-Israeli relations were still in their infancy.

The study — one of the very first to identify the ascendancy of India as a strategic power, and the potentially profound significance of this for Israel — recognised both the necessity of and the mutual benefits entailed in joint-Indo-Israeli development initiatives. And it designated the naval sphere to be of particular promise: “…sea power could become a factor of increasing significance. Israel’s long-term strategic need to strengthen its navy… corresponds well with India’s desire to extend its maritime capabilities”.

The successful Barak-8 test constitutes a ringing endorsement of that prognoses and also a fitting precursor to the just-concluded visit of India’s External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj to Israel. The visit, on the heels of one by President Pranab Mukherjee last October, and ahead of a speculated visit by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, signifies that India no longer feels the need to keep its burgeoning ties with Israel discreetly low-profile.

Commonly cited constraints that reportedly inhibited more demonstrative warmth between the two countries were: One, the wish to avoid angering India’s large Muslim minority; and two, concern for the considerable expatriate Indian community working in the Arab Gulf states.

However, of late, it appears that the “dampening” effect of these factors has waned. For, in what seems to be a discernible change in its voting pattern in international institutions, India has refrained from voting against Israel in various UN bodies, as it did in the past, preferring to abstain from anti-Israel resolutions.

Since the establishment of diplomatic relations, almost a quarter-century ago, the bilateral relationship has grown steadily, irrespective of which party has been in power. But while it’s true that it was a Congress government, led by then-PM P.V. Narasimha Rao, that initiated the normalisation between the two countries, there has always been a perceptible sense of greater warmth in the relationship under BJP governments.

This enhanced ambience of Indo-Israeli amitié is certainly the case with the Modi government. Indeed, the appointment of the unabashedly pro-Israel Swaraj as foreign minister, who, when in opposition, served as chairperson of the Indo-Israel Parliamentary Friendship Group (2006-09) and reportedly sees former Israeli premier Golda Meir as a role model, certainly seems to symbolise the desire for enhanced ties between the two countries.

Strengthening bilateral ties entails potentially huge benefits for both parties. Trade has grown more than 20-fold since formal diplomatic ties were established — from a meagre $200 million to almost $5 billion today.

For Israel, an uptick in its relations with India couldn’t have come at a more fortuitous time — especially given the chilly winds blowing its way from the European Union, with talk of punitive economic measures evermore prevalent. The recent European decision to label Israeli merchandise produced beyond the pre-1967 frontiers has made Israeli concerns all the more tangible.

In contrast to Europe’s dark past of animosity towards the Jews, India’s history has virtually no record of any significant anti-Semitism. This, together with the burgeoning Indian middle class with its increasing purchasing power and the fact that India will soon be the world’s third-largest economy, makes it a lucrative target for Israeli business, not only in its own right but as a strategic alternative to the EU, should further restrictions on Israeli products be imposed by Brussels.

The prospect of enhanced trade with the East in general and India in particular clearly enhances the importance of the Indian Ocean theatre for Israel as a commercial maritime route. Accordingly, cooperation and coordination with the Indian navy is likely to become an increasingly important factor in ensuring the secure passage of cargo in both directions.

But for Israel, commerce is not the only reason for the increased importance of the Indian Ocean. Indeed, given the spectre of a resurgent Iran unencumbered by international sanctions and its coffers replenished by the nuclear deal, the waters of the Indian Ocean have assumed critical significance for Israel’s security, as reflected by its recently expanded and modernised submarine fleet.

The potential for mutually beneficial collaboration between India and Israel spans virtually the entire spectrum of human endeavour — from national security on land, sea and air, through cutting-edge civilian technology in medicine, food production and communications, to cultural exchanges, enhancement of water management and rural development. But beyond that, there appears to be a special affinity between the two peoples that transcends cordial government-to-government relations. The visit of the top diplomat of the world’s largest democracy, Sushma Swaraj, to the world’s most beleaguered one, was built on this foundation.

The writer, a former advisor to the Israeli government, is founder and executive director of the Israel Institute for Strategic Studies

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. S
    SS
    Jan 20, 2016 at 12:27 am
    Buy technology and CLAIM IT WAS JOINTLY DEVELOPED. Brahmin incompetents will do anything.
    Reply
    1. K
      K SHESHU
      Jan 20, 2016 at 6:46 am
      The bilateral agreements should stress peace and security between nations. The trade and commerce has increased over the years. Israel has benefited from its friendship with India.
      Reply
      1. R
        Rajesh
        Jan 20, 2016 at 10:30 am
        Both the points on India's relations are invalid. CONgi jihadi supporters obviously bend over backwards for the Mullah vote, but BJP has no such constraints. More importantly who cares what these Mullahs think? Polls show that 60-70% of Indians have a positive view of Israel. What a minority of terrorist lovers thinks is irrelevant. As for the Arab countries, people need to forget this foolish notion that they can do anything. Countries like Saudi have long introduced a policy to employ more Saudis and less foreigners (including Indians). The policy has been a complete failure quite simply because madra educated pigs are incompetent and incapable of doing the jobs that foreigners do. That's why they hire foreigners. And let's not ignore the near slave like manner they treat Indians, particularly maids and labourers. Also, many Mullah countries such as Jordan and Egypt themselves have relations with Israel, so why should they make a fuss over India. High time Indians realize that we are a major country. Over time as our economy grows even more, we will gain even more clout in the world. Once you become so big that you cant be ignore, like the Americans or the Chinese, other countries have to tolerate you whether they like it or not. Another thing is that for Sunni Arabs, our relations with Shia Iran are even more annoying than with Israel. Finally, why should have to avoid relations with Israel, when the Arabs are best friends with stan ?
        Reply
        1. R
          Rajesh
          Jan 20, 2016 at 10:31 am
          Buy garbage weapons and take kickbacks. Corrupt Nehru family bootlickers will do anything.
          Reply
          1. M
            Mehdi Patel
            Jan 21, 2016 at 1:44 pm
            israel caused us to lose 3 billion in oil investment when they broke up sudan into two..if u look at israel long term strategy..they want to break up iraq syria nigeria..are u sure india will have good relations with africa if we continue to support israel..we are behind sweden brazil south africa when it comes to pressuring israel to end the occupation...we are losing our decades worth of sacrifice nurturing a foreign policy consistent with international justice..are we an imperial nation??
            Reply
            1. M
              Mehdi Patel
              Jan 21, 2016 at 1:40 pm
              so we flush our moral comp in the toilet for isreali "friendship?" PM benjamin disraeli looted inida the east india company was managed by london jews who demanded their own east india company on palestine...supporting israel is the same as saying all the wealth the brits tole from india is ok...at a time where more and more carbbean and african nations are demanding reperations...the brits and israelis arent even willing to give us back the kohinur...we have indians starving to death today because of london finaciers looting of india...
              Reply
              1. M
                Mehdi Patel
                Jan 21, 2016 at 1:48 pm
                so we flush our moral comp in the toilet for isreali "friendship?" PM benjamin disraeli looted inida the east india company was managed by london jews who demanded their own east india company on palestine...supporting israel is the same as saying all the wealth the brits tole from india is ok...at a time where more and more carbbean and african nations are demanding reperations...the brits and israelis arent even willing to give us back the kohinur...we have indians starving to death today because of london finaciers looting of india... NATO is recolonizing africa...will india join the imperial actions or defend africa from the NATO looting?? stick with the BRICS foreing policy..dia needs africa more than israel and NATO plans...we have cheap pharmaceuticals africa needs ...the us does not want us in africa...
                Reply
                1. G
                  guestfromindia
                  Jan 20, 2016 at 5:51 am
                  Not to mention the Jewish tribe sheltered in India. India is the original boat as described in the Matsya avatar (Noah's ark in other faiths).
                  Reply
                  1. V
                    VMK
                    Jan 20, 2016 at 11:17 am
                    It would be useful for India, if Isreal helped in establishing an IIT like university in India. Isreal is particularly good at adapting weapons of previous generation to nearly their modern versions by some refurbishments etc. Isreal has a potion which likes to visit India and has no negative atude towards Hinduism, so Jewish professors are happy to train indians quite enthusiastically.
                    Reply
                    1. P
                      Prakash Iyer
                      Jan 23, 2016 at 11:28 am
                      Our relations should be based on contemporary realities. Can we determine mine our relations with Iran based on Nadir Shah or our relations with Afghanistan base on Ahmed Shah Abdali?
                      Reply
                      1. K
                        kulaputra kulaputra
                        Jan 20, 2016 at 1:01 am
                        The non Brahmins neither bought nor developed from anyone not giving a bribe. Go drink their stuff
                        Reply
                        1. K
                          kulaputra kulaputra
                          Jan 20, 2016 at 1:02 am
                          this is wonderful news. This is TINA driven but nonetheless a wonderful beginning.
                          Reply
                          1. R
                            rohitchandavarker
                            Jan 20, 2016 at 7:57 am
                            The hesitancy of public proclamation of deep Indo-Israeli cooperation of the past has given way to openness and closer interactions. The long history of pro-Palestine position by India has given way to realpolitik. The strategic importance of Israel for India cannot be understated. The rapidly shifting geo-politics of the region necessitates a flexible realignment of positions keeping in mind common areas of concerns. Israel has been a trenchant critic of Iran and the feeling's mutual. Upon the JCPOA implementation, Israel has been extremely wary of the outcome of the freedom given to Iran. Iranian support to Hezbollah and Hamas might increase in the days to come, is the common fear in Israel. However, a bigger problem awaits Tehran, Saudi Arabia. In the short to medium term, Iran is less likely to be focus on Lebanon and more on the jostling for primacy within the Arab world against Saudi Arabia. The proxy wars between the two in Syria, Yemen and Iraq along with the common goal of eliminating ISIS will be taking centrestage. Given this scenario, the Middle East seems to be in crisis with a plethora of vested interests pushing their respective agendas. India and Israel find common ground on terrorism and counter terrorism, regional security and defence of its borders. Hence, it is mutually beneficial for the two countries to work in close cooperation to mitigate risks. India has always had warm historical and cultural links with Iran. Given the regional dynamics, India might have a role to play in smoothening relations with Israel and Iran. India's neighbourhood is home to terror, instability and inimical forces. Israeli technology know how would greatly benefit India. In addition to the successful missile programme, India can enhance its counter terrorism expertise from Israeli experience. Elbit Systems is a world leader in border surveillance and its help in securing India's borders would benefit India. The naval component is seldom publicised yet notable strides have been taken in the recent past. India seeks to maintain safety and security in the Indian Ocean while engaging in robust anti-piracy operations. To this end, India and israel can coordinate their navies for closer cooperation to secure IOR commons.
                            Reply
                            1. C
                              Charles
                              Jan 20, 2016 at 11:10 am
                              If you don't know anything please stop writing rubbish and make a fool of yourself.
                              Reply
                              1. C
                                Charles
                                Jan 20, 2016 at 11:08 am
                                UPA even forgot the late PVN PM of India. Hope to hear that the present NDA will take care and honor him. Long live the India - Israel friendship for the mutual benefit of people from both countries.
                                Reply
                                1. S
                                  sdas
                                  Jan 20, 2016 at 2:06 am
                                  Amazingly, the UPA Govt. did not have the courage to publicise the Israeli help but the NDA have done the right thing - and the Armed Forces of India are better served today.
                                  Reply
                                  1. Load More Comments