Out of my mind: Tyrants and heroes

Indira Gandhi was also a hero who became a villain when, for the one and only time in the history of independent India, she established a constitutional dictatorship.

Written by Meghnad Desai | Published: November 26, 2017 2:03 am
Indira Gandhi, Robert Mugabe, Emergency, Congress, Jan Sangh, BJP Indira Gandhi

Last Sunday, as India remembered Indira Gandhi on her birth centenary, there was high drama being played on TV screens from Harare, where Robert Mugabe was fighting a battle not to resign after 37 years of elected dictatorship. The people of Zimbabwe are well educated and well aware of how much they owe to Mugabe. He had started as a hero, who fought for his country’s independence and won. But then over time he went from bad to worse. The economy collapsed due to too much government interference and corruption. Even so, while wishing him to go, people of Zimbabwe did not want to force him to leave.

Unlike in many other coups, the Army did not kill him and take over power. Everyone behaved impeccably, in proper constitutional fashion. He did finally resign when the parliament threatened to impeach him. It was a peaceful transfer of power.

Indira Gandhi was also a hero who became a villain when, for the one and only time in the history of independent India, she established a constitutional dictatorship. The old colonial apparatus of repression had been left intact by the Congress Raj. So she could legally declare an Internal Emergency (as there was already an External Emergency in force). She did it for the sake of avoiding a small inconvenience — prohibition from voting in Lok Sabha while the Supreme Court heard her appeal in an election case against her.

For that small inconvenience, she jailed the Opposition politicians arbitrarily, suppressed free press and put fundamental rights in jeopardy. She let her son Sanjay, though unelected, act in the most arbitrary manner to carry out a widespread attack on Muslim men by forced sterilisation. (She pretended not to know what he was doing.) She dishonoured the Constitution by changing the Preamble in a Parliament that had lasted beyond its legitimate date, adding the words ‘secular’ and ‘socialist’ which the Founders, including her father and B R Ambedkar among others, did not think merited inclusion.

By some chance, perhaps due to bad advice from sycophants or sheer arrogance, she called an election and lost. India was lucky she did not perpetuate herself in power. Her opponents failed to hold her to account. Once she returned to power in 1980, all was forgotten. History was rewritten and she is celebrated as someone who, rather than being India’s only Fascist Dictator, upheld Jawaharlal Nehru’s Idea of India as a tolerant, liberal democracy.

She did however do one constructive thing. Thanks to the Emergency, the Jan Sangh politicians had to suffer imprisonment. Until then, they had to bear the taunts that their party had not fought during the colonial days or gone to prison as Congress leaders had. Indira Gandhi now gave them that badge of honour. They too had gone to jail fighting for freedom from an oppressive ruler.

The rest is history. The Jan Sangh became the BJP. It rose steadily from the 1980s onwards. The seeds sown in the Emergency sprouted and by 1989 the Congress lost its hegemonic status. India could now experiment with other centres of power. Through the muddle and strife of the next 25 years, the BJP came through as the alternative answer to the Congress. Give Indira credit for the success of the BJP.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Meghnad Desai
Meghnad Desai
  1. Jag Mohan Manchanda
    Nov 27, 2017 at 1:15 pm
    Emergency was declared partly because Indira Gandhi was not sure whether the apex court would grant her relief after Allahabad High Court declared her election null and void. In the meantime, J.P. Narayan had galvanized the masses and Jan Sangh jumped on to the bandwagon of Janata patty , which captured power at Center. However, the new front broke up when Jan Sangh refused to snap its relationship with RSS and rechristened itself as BJP.. The rise of BJP has had a lot to do with scams that broke out during UPA-II and the feeling that Congress indulged in minority-appea t. With only three years spent in power, it may be too early to predict how BJP would fare on the national front. The public reactions at present are mixed. PM Modi enjoys popular support but the economic policies pursued by his govt has led to job-losses and price rise. Interest rates have fallen but growth rate remains steady. The gap between intent and delivery seems to be widening rather than bridging.
    1. A
      akbar khan
      Nov 27, 2017 at 3:53 am
      Just read Bishen Tandon's two-volume diary of his first-hand experience as Joint Secretary in the Prime Minister's Secretariat in the years spanning the Emergency. That will open people's eyes to what sort of "leadet" IG was, and the damage done to India by her and the evil gang she was the presiding deity of.
      1. B
        Nov 26, 2017 at 5:27 pm
        During FAKEndranath's tenure, every day is a day of emergency. a morphed photo uploaded can send a 19 yr old to jail 15 yr old junaid khan gets lynched to death cow vigilantes have taken over the roads...
        1. G
          Giri Gowda
          Nov 26, 2017 at 6:13 pm
          its actually losing your Black Money Power :-)))
          1. B
            Nov 26, 2017 at 6:34 pm
            cant say much for you if you do not recognize the signs of fascism
        2. D
          D Prakash
          Nov 26, 2017 at 4:23 pm
          Indira Gandhi lived and died for India, and she thought she knew better than any other Indian what was good and best for India . Most of the citizens at that time thought so till she put in emergency and started the pampering of her son. In the eyes of all those who have read the cons ution amendment during emergency , she fell from high pedestal to a lowly pedestal. Now comparing PM Narendra Modi to PM Indira Gandhi is not only fallacious , it lacks facts. Most citizens of India think and regard PM Modi as one of the best prime ministers India had , nay, the best prime minister India has seen yet.
          1. B
            Nov 26, 2017 at 5:28 pm
            Most citizens of India? have you taken the opinion poll of 133 cr indians? pl share the polls then
          2. P
            Parth Garg
            Nov 26, 2017 at 2:57 pm
            The subtle hint is taken.
            1. S
              Nov 26, 2017 at 6:17 pm
              After all, History repeats itself in one form or the other !
            2. Load More Comments