• Associate Sponsor

Out of my mind: Tanks on the lawn

PM Modi came to power promising inclusive development and a major plank of his promise was social harmony.

Written by Meghnad Desai | Published: December 28, 2014 12:00 am


During the post-War years, trade unions were very powerful in Britain. They could dictate policy to governments, especially Labour governments. It was during the Sixties when Harold Wilson was PM that he famously said to a trade union leader, “Get your tanks off my front lawn”. His desperation was due to the fact that his sensible anti-inflation policy was being undermined by the unions.

Wilson’s heartfelt plea reflected the dilemma of a party leader faced with a militant rank and file he was unable to control. But the arrogance of the trade unions, which were friends of the Labour Party, finally led to multiple defeats for the party and the unions once Margaret Thatcher took them on.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi must share Wilson’s desperation. He came to power promising inclusive development and a major plank of his promise was social harmony. But his “friends” have other ideas. They care not a whit about “sabka vikas”, let alone “sabka saath”. Swachh Bharat is irrelevant to them. “Make in India” for them means making all minorities in India Hindu. They are in a hurry to complete their agenda. So “make mayhem while the lotus rules” seems to be their message to the PM.

With friends like these, Modi will not need enemies. Indeed, the Opposition has had an early Christmas. It has disrupted Parliament again and again.

It is one thing for the PM to keep his Cabinet in line by instilling awe for his authority. It is his backbenchers who pose problems. It was his charisma and Amit Shah’s electoral genius that got most of them a seat in the Lok Sabha. They’ve never had such a platform before. They were peddling their agenda, but no one was paying any attention. Now they can cause disruption in Parliament.

All political parties have a problem with their ideological fringes. These people work hard for the party to realise its core agenda. The leaders know that to get a majority, the ideological fringe has to be kept quiet since it does not command acceptance. A political party needs to win power and retain power to accomplish the changes it feels will improve the conditions of the voters and their families. This requires a constant renewal of trust and building of consensus by accomplishing concrete tasks which make a difference. This is a long-term game; a marathon, not a sprint.

But the ideologues do not care about practical matters. They have stars in their eyes. They are in a hurry. Bijli, sadak, shiksha, makaan can wait. Religious conversion of minorities to Hinduism and prevention of reverse conversion are urgent for them. Infrastructure or bullet trains can wait; the Ram Mandir must get priority. “Sabka saath” is out of the question; getting rid of the Muslims is what they have been dreaming for years.

The BJP has a complex problem. It has just won a convincing majority in May. In state elections, it continues to consolidate its dominance. It can become the hegemonic party of government like the Congress used to be if it can discipline its troops to keep their eyes on this big chance. But the BJP is not its own master. As in any Hindu joint family, it may be the breadwinner but that does not mean it can lay down the law. The elders and the distant relations hanging around want to have their own way. The Parivar is the problem. It has a cultural agenda which it wants to take to the streets. The surprise is not in its agenda but in its impatience, not to say its total lack of respect for the law.

Narendra Modi wants 10 years to realise his dream for India. There is no Opposition as of now that can do more than rushing to the well in Parliament. As he wins state after state, he will advance his control over the Rajya Sabha. Yet in the results for Jammu and Kashmir, the BJP has missed the top spot by three seats. Could it be that the Sadhvi cost the party those seats by speaking during the election? Any more of this and the Rajya Sabha majority may remain a dream.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Meghnad Desai
Meghnad Desai
  • Out of my mind: A smart State

    The fraud allegedly committed by Nirav Modi on the Punjab National Bank brings me back to what I have been arguing for the last several…

  • Out of my mind: Where is AAP?

    But there is a bigger question here. Why is it difficult in India, even after 70 years of democracy, to build non-dynastic grassroots parties which…

  • Out of my mind: The Padmavati debacle

    Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh may be lost, but that is a problem for Vasundhara Raje and Shivraj Singh Chouhan. Modi has to secure the trust…

  1. R
    Jan 2, 2015 at 12:56 pm
    Anti conversion movement is only the stiffening of the spine of the caste system. Nothing else.
    1. Sundeep Mallya
      Jan 2, 2015 at 5:38 am
      That is 30% too much, don't you think?
      1. P
        Pitambar Sharma
        Dec 28, 2014 at 3:32 pm
        The opposition is magnifying many times the natural voices of a small group within the BJP that is seeking to balance the terrible wrongs of the past, especially the Congi government. Lord Desai, unfortunately, has joined the fringe media and the opposition in making it sound like the BJP is starting a war to eliminate the minorities while all they are asking is the same rights that the minorities had for a long time but they did not -- a right to protect and promote their religion. What is wrong with it? The development agenda continues. One goal is not at the cost of the other.
        1. A
          A Rajaraman
          Dec 28, 2014 at 3:07 am
          Sir, is Sri N D Modi lislistening to sane advice.
          1. A
            Dec 28, 2014 at 5:49 am
            Den why not ban on religoois conversions..nd why not a word about conversion by musljms and christians...just yestersau saw a prgmme where zakir naik openly converted a few hibdus ro islam ...openly on tv...isnt that provocative..0
            1. Load More Comments