Out of my mind: Faith in RS polls shattered

Normally Rajya Sabha elections are totally predictable, frankly boring. But we were treated to a cliffhanger.

Written by Meghnad Desai | Updated: August 13, 2017 12:28 am
gujarat rajya sabha elections, rajya sabha elections, gujarat, ahmed patel, congress, bjp, india, indian express news Senior Congress leader Ahmed Patel. (File photo)

Crisis? What crisis, existential or not? Ahmed Patel won. Normally Rajya Sabha elections are totally predictable, frankly boring. But we were treated to a cliffhanger. Every positive and negative aspect of Indian democracy was on display, making it the most watchable show in town. We had the wits of two Chanakyas — Ahmed Patel and Amit Shah — pitted against each other. Like Rocky IV, the senior man won. But, along the way, we saw the combination of extreme legality and obvious corruption of political morals. No party trusts its representatives, knowing that they have no commitments to the party above personal gain. Hence the forced isolation in Bengaluru. Two defectors wanted to convince the BJP that they could be trusted; that defeated the plan. There was also the procedural nitpicking where lawyers from both sides besieged the Election Commission. The denouement was fascinating. It seems that in a Rajya Sabha secret ballot, you have to show your ballot to your party whip but not anyone else. This means that not just the parties but the electoral system is based on mistrust of those voting. It is a shocking confession of the weak foundations on which the Rajya Sabha election system is based. A secret ballot is not secret. Who let that through? The Congress won, but I guess for the citizens watching, their faith in the electoral system for the Rajya Sabha suffered.

But while the BJP could not snatch one more seat than their due, they are now the single largest party in the Rajya Sabha. Thus far, the Congress had some clout in the Upper House. The government could not pass its prized land acquisition Bill despite repeated attempts. Now the balance may change. As the Rajya Sabha numbers change in a different rhythm than the Lok Sabha, if Modi were to deliver another majority as looks likely, the Congress will be in exile for a few years longer.

What many outside wish and as Jairam Ramesh expressed, the Congress ought really now to get around to looking at itself critically and ask what went wrong and how to put it right. It is difficult for a long-dominant party to face the reality of decline. But it is now or never. The Congress should not rely on cyclical comeback as happened in 1977, 1991 and 2004. Now there is a formidable party which has become hegemonic. Rather than repeat their entitlement to rule thanks to Gandhi-Nehru-Gandhi, the Congress ought to construct an alternative narrative which will appeal to the new generation.

It is hard to be hopeful that the Congress will revive itself. The conversion of a cadre-based party into a family fiefdom by Indira Gandhi emptied the party of anyone who can think outside the box and dare to point to the Emperor’s (or the Crown Prince’s) clothes. The last time it was an “outsider” from deep inside, Sonia Gandhi, who saved the party from terminal decline and delivered its comeback in 2004. You can’t step into the same stream twice. Maybe it is not a crisis but an opportunity. At 70, India can witness the passing of the baton from the Grand Old Party born in British times to a party born post-Independence. India has confidence in its democracy and is happy to renew it by a change of the hegemonic party.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. K
    K.Suresh
    Aug 14, 2017 at 1:40 pm
    Disloyalty to the party is a bad thing and certainly no party likes it. Foolishness on the part of its members is not a quality to the advantage of any party. But congress is glad two negatives made a positive coutesy two foolish and disloyal members of the party.
    Reply
    1. R
      Ramesh Nittoor
      Aug 14, 2017 at 12:10 am
      Crisis? What crisis, existential or not? ---- There were two crisis here and fortunately both will get resolved now. The corrupt machinations of the Hindutva face of BJP, Mr. Amit Shah has been exposed. That the legislatures were compelled to show Mr. Amit Shah their ballot papers, exposes him at personal level. Mr. Patel won this difficult round with no assistance from the dynasty. The rumored trip to visit Congress President prior to RS voting also did not materialize, nor were the dynastic duo present when EC negotiations were going on. The nature of the win is likely to have an impact on organizational structure of INC. Think Hindustaniyat won and Hindutva lost in this one of a kind Rajya Sabha election. BJP, if it dares to go with Hindutva agenda in 2019 is likely to be clearly exposed as a charalatan party, and even likely to lose the hustings.
      Reply
      1. A
        ak dev
        Aug 13, 2017 at 7:30 pm
        Ab PAPPU sa la kanha hai?
        Reply
        1. S
          School Bus
          Aug 13, 2017 at 6:42 pm
          It was a brilliant strategy by Amit Shah. He chose to fight on the enemy's land. There was no doubt of winning two seats for himself and Smriti. He fought for enemy's seat and gave a very good fight. Due to foolishness of those two congis Patel won, otherwise game was almost won by Amit Shah. Better luck next time. :)
          Reply
          1. A
            Alok
            Aug 13, 2017 at 5:11 pm
            An intelligent man who deflects the issue of bad morals in the whole dealings of horse trading and coercing of the voters by trying to find solutions for the G old Party. Great man with the gumption to think only NRI's have brains (courtesy brain drain) and resident Indians dumb. Mr Desai pl be unbaised if you really want Indian democracy to improve.
            Reply
            1. T
              TIHAEwale
              Aug 13, 2017 at 3:47 pm
              Indian Politics watching is a entertainment for the likes of Meghnad Desai sitting in England where rule of law is enforcable and Governance is there. it is a fact that Meghnad Desai is never going to settle down in India unless iNDIA once again becomes a colony of British
              Reply
              1. R
                Rajesh sahu
                Aug 13, 2017 at 9:03 pm
                Great. If he concerned so much about India. Why he is enjoying European life and commenting govt.
                Reply
                1. I
                  indian
                  Aug 14, 2017 at 8:50 am
                  Are outsiders barred from commenting on Indian politics ? An outside-in view often provides valuable inputs.
              2. A
                Ajit
                Aug 13, 2017 at 1:36 pm
                Good thing for congress is that AAP has imploded and Nitish has joined BJP. At the same time Rahul is lost cause. Any revival will only happened when Rahul renounces Congress.
                Reply
                1. A
                  ak dev
                  Aug 13, 2017 at 7:37 pm
                  Congress will not revive even if the ma-beta family leaves for Italy. The reason is their anti-Hindu character. Congress has to be dumped into grave yards.
                  Reply
                2. A
                  ak dev
                  Aug 13, 2017 at 6:39 am
                  Congress has an obsession with RSS. I have not come across even a single TV debate where Congress spokesperson has not abused RSS multiple times. Congees seem to derive extreme satisfaction by abusing and ridiculing RSS. While abusing RSS they end up abusing the Hindus on a minute to minute basis. Can any new narrative be effective if Congress has made RSS and Hindus its enemy? If reduced return is applied to anti-RSS stance of Congress, it doesn't gain Muslim votes but definitely looses Hindu votes. It's a suicidal but Congress can't find a reason to abandon it.
                  Reply
                  1. S
                    Shridhar Shettigar
                    Aug 13, 2017 at 11:58 am
                    You stupid don't equate RSS with Hindus for god's sake..
                    Reply
                    1. A
                      ak dev
                      Aug 13, 2017 at 7:33 pm
                      RSS represent Hindus. Not your cup of tea.
                  2. Load More Comments