• Associate Sponsor

Out of my mind: An unparliamentary democracy

Parliament has been turned into a general purpose complaint akhada.

Written by Meghnad Desai | Published: December 20, 2015 12:35 am
india Pakistan relationship, Shinzo Abe, paris climate talk, Parliament GST bill, RSS, ISIS, iecolumnist, Meghnad Desai, indian express A view of the Rajya Sabha uring winter session 2015 in New Delhi. (PTI Photo)

India has a remarkable electoral democracy, which, with its 800 million voters, is an envy of the world. The executive is functioning well; note the amazing breakthrough in the India-Pakistan negotiations. India did well at Paris and Shinzo Abe was generous with the deals. The judiciary is active across the board on green issues and social issues, holding the powerful to account as in the National Herald case.

The problem is with the legislature. The Winter Session has proved to be worse than the Monsoon Session. There are daily disruptions. Parliament during the day has come to resemble the TV news channels at night. Not much work seems to be done and the GST Bill looks like it may miss another deadline.

This is bad but not news. In the Budget Session in 2010, the Lok Sabha functioned only for two-thirds of its time and the Rajya Sabha three-quarters. That was much better than the Winter Session of 2013 where the wastage rate was 94% for the Lok Sabha and 81% for the Rajya Sabha.

But the anger and the bitterness are the most disturbing aspects of the present scene. Indeed there is an escalation of language and imagery which is remarkable. Even outside Parliament, the language has reached hyperbolic proportion. Thus the alumni of St Stephen’s, no doubt the cream of the liberal, tolerant elite, have accused the principal of being like ISIS. Professor Irfan Habib also used ISIS as an analogy for the RSS. ISIS kills and beheads people, abducts, enslaves and subjects women to appalling violence, and has been killing their fellow Muslims with impunity. How does one lightly use such a label to describe what can be a difference of opinion, even of ideology? Then the Chief Minister of Delhi calls the Prime Minister a psychopath. Why such language?

In the parliamentary arena, the week before the Winter Session seemed promising. The Prime Minister had tea with Sonia and Rahul Gandhi. The Finance Minister was consulting the Opposition about GST. But as soon as the session opened, one thing after another with little relevance to the business at hand has provided the excuse for rushing to the well. The breaking news of previous night is used to break up Parliament.

The root cause is unparliamentary behaviour. In my 24 years as a British parliamentarian, I have never once seen members shouting, leaving their place, rushing to the Speaker (we have no well) let alone waving banners. Members enter and leave the chamber bowing towards the throne. They shout in the House of Commons but the Speaker can always scold the members into submission. They enter and leave bowing to the Speaker.

This contrasts with the weak position of the presiding officers in the two houses. Why do MPs disobey the presiding officers and thereby humiliate them? The whips of the many parties have become cheerleaders in the disruption and not constraining elements as they should be. In this they have the approval of their leaders who aspire one day to be in power themselves, no doubt to face the same music. Then they will blame the Opposition and the cycle will resume.

Parliament has been turned into a general purpose complaint akhada. This prevents it from being a forum for serious debate. India deserves better.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Meghnad Desai
Meghnad Desai
  • Out of my mind: Where is AAP?

    But there is a bigger question here. Why is it difficult in India, even after 70 years of democracy, to build non-dynastic grassroots parties which…

  • Out of my mind: The Padmavati debacle

    Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh may be lost, but that is a problem for Vasundhara Raje and Shivraj Singh Chouhan. Modi has to secure the trust…

  • Out Of My Mind: All together now

    Given our federal structure, the idea of holding elections simultaneously in the 29 states plus the Centre is impossible as of now. Some Constitutional amendments…

  1. K
    Dec 20, 2015 at 10:56 am
    Parliament has been used (and abused) not just as an 'Akhada' but a 'Yudh bhoomi' as well with members at blows with each other, specially during the congress rule at the time of Telengana voting in which an honourable threw pepper spray. The most consutional body witnessed the most unconsutional method of functioning. .!
    1. M
      Dec 20, 2015 at 12:13 am
      Modi has cleverly left the pit behind, as he does a world beating job of selling India. Perhaps, in time the parliamentarians will feel embaraced into submission. I can not understand why a loosing side has so little shame as to disrespect the electorate, perhaps they still have not got over the poll results or perhaps they keep hearng voices telling them feel they and they alone were 'born to rule'
      1. H
        Dec 20, 2015 at 1:50 pm
        This is a complete failure of democracy as is practised in India. There is only 1 solution which is long term. Enforce minimum education qualification for becoming an MP and before they can complete as an MP and they should attend a college/training center for 1 - 2 years on various aspects of parliamentary democracy etc and p an exam. Otherwise you can see Lallu Prasad becoming the PM in the near future.
        1. Anil Tandale
          Dec 20, 2015 at 3:57 am
          Congress government argued in Bommai case before the Supreme Court that there is no concept called 'Consutional Morality', but only numerical majority, and whatever the majority says is morally correct. The Rajya Sabha rules need to be redrawn so as to ensure that its members do not insult the majority in the Lok Sabha.
          1. S
            Dec 20, 2015 at 3:56 am
            It is shame to see the behavior of some congress parliamentarians in debates. Unsubstantiated accusations and pure hooliganism. Congress lost shamefully but it has not accepted it so far . Ruling India was supposed to be the birth right of hi family and now it is like a fish out of water. If this is their condition in less than two years , there is still 3 years to go how will they survive. When one says there are more than 30-35 % criminals in our parliament one can see that. One really wonders did we inherit democracy or Nehru hi empire.
            1. Load More Comments