Officially Outlawing Love

The Sehwan killing by IS only reaffirmed what Pakistan formally believes in.

Written by Khaled Ahmed | Published:March 4, 2017 12:10 am
pakistan, pakistan army, pakistan terrorism, terror attacks pakistan, pakistan war against terror, pakistan offensive against terror, pakistan policy on terror, pakistan terror state, sehwan terror attack, indian express The attack on Lal Shahbaz Qalandar, the saint of love, took place after a judge had outlawed love.

After the Pakistani killers of the Islamic State (IS) slew 88 devotees and wounded hundreds at the “Shia” mausoleum of Lal Shahbaz Qalandar at Sehwan Sharif in Sindh recently, people thought it was an act of satanic cruelty. But IS knew Sehwan as “Shia” and that the saint buried there was renamed Usman to avoid being found out. The saint is revered by Muslims, Hindus, Ismailis and other branches of Islam; all dance together to the Qalandar’s mesmerising songs. Did the IS take itself out of the pale of Islam with this act?

No: It reaffirmed what Pakistan officially believes in. Javed Ahmad Ghamdi, a scholar and a member of the highest advisory body, the Council of Islamic Ideology, till religious parties got him to quit and flee the country, said the killers of Pakistanis were clones of their victims and a part of the diseased Muslim global nation. He laid out four characteristics of Muslims in the world, which make them behave as they do.

Watch What Else Is Making News

The first is, wherever in the world there is “kufr” (non-belief) and apostasy, it has to be quelled through defeat at the hands of Muslims. The second is, all states must become Islamic and Muslims should strive to convert them to Islam. The third is, the modern nation state is unlawful under Islam and should be ruled by a caliph instead. And the fourth is, Muslims should have one global state ruled by a single caliph, not many states calling themselves Muslim.

Ghamdi said Muslims killed at Sehwan actually learned the above lessons at madrassas, residential “free” schools where boys are sent at the age of five because their families are too poor to look after them. After passing from the madrasas, most men become prayer-leading custodians of mosques or join the education department as teachers, instructing curriculums not very different from the madrassa doctrine.

This year, a judge of the Islamabad High Court declared Valentine’s Day as being against Islam: The word “love” put him off, as it had the madrasas, and Pakistanis couldn’t walk around in public with their red “love” balloons. Where hate speech is rampant despite a new law against it, love can’t be allowed expression. According to the Daily Insaf, some time ago, the Multan Intermediate Board exam was disrupted when examinees discovered one question in the Urdu paper said: “Write the blessings of love” (mohabbat ki barkatain). The students said they were not trained to write on the subject and considered it obscene: The mystics must have turned in their graves. The attack on Lal Shahbaz Qalandar, the saint of love, took place after a judge had outlawed love.

Pakistan is evolving from, according to Tilak Devasher in his easily-the-best book on Pakistan, Courting the Abyss, Jinnah’s lack of clarity on what the state would be. On August 11, 1947, Jinnah said: “You may belong to any religion or caste or creed; that has nothing to do with the business of the state.” But on December 14-15, he told the Muslim League: “Let it be clear Pakistan is going to be a Muslim state based on Islamic ideals.” On January 25, 1948, he declared that Pakistan’s Constitution would be based on Islamic law (sharia) “to make Pakistan a truly great Islamic State”.

The climax of what Jinnah innocently founded has come today because the Blasphemy Law can’t be reformed as the madrassas are too strong and backed by terrorists who could be the state’s “strategic assets”. The most touching incident was reported last year from Hujra Shah Muqeem, a village south of Lahore, where a boy, mishearing a cleric’s question, “Who among you doesn’t believe in the teachings of the Holy Prophet? Raise your hand!”, raised his hand and was publicly condemned as a blasphemer. The boy cut off his hand and presented it to the cleric.

The crucial question facing Pakistan is — what to do with the jihadi organisations that suit Pakistan’s geo-strategy, but have been condemned by the UN as terrorists? Ex-army chief General Pervez Musharraf embarrassed the state further by appearing on Dunya TV on February 18, claiming Hafiz Saeed’s Jamaat-ud-Dawa was a “strategic asset” because “he didn’t kill in Pakistan”, but was helping the uprising in Kashmir.

Musharraf didn’t care much for Jaish-e-Muhammad though; he called it “terrorist” in his book. He probably recalled how Jaish had conspired to kill him; what piqued him perhaps was how Ahmad Saeed Sheikh, under death sentence in Hyderabad jail, somehow phoned President Musharraf from his cell, threatening him for calling off jihad with India.

The writer is consulting editor, ‘Newsweek Pakistan’

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. P
    Mar 4, 2017 at 11:10 am
    Islam is terror religion, not relegion of peace....pls stop talking of human rights of terrorist
    1. A
      Mar 4, 2017 at 1:18 pm
      A tree is known by the fruit it bears; parents are known by the children they rear.
      1. A
        Mar 4, 2017 at 1:16 pm
        stan has lost its soul to an evil ideology.
        1. A
          ak dev
          Mar 4, 2017 at 10:14 am
          Muslims have the least chances of winning religious wars either with Hindus or Christians. The only effective tool available to them is terrorism. With Trump in USA, it should now be possible to fight Islamic Terrorism directly.
          1. A
            a khan
            Mar 4, 2017 at 11:43 pm
            Mr. Khaled Ahmed, your pen under the burden of Indian Express cash is unable to write anything;br/gt;Only fools can believe in your words. lt;br/gt;Valentine day was abandoned in stan to avoid the immorality that's strong example was unfortunately witnessed in India when women were molested and threatened collectively. lt;br/gt;stani people are loving people without losing moral human and social values. lt;br/gt;Second, maddra propaa is also for ignorant only. lt;br/gt;Mostly maddra in stan have been equipped with computer technology , English and sciences long ago. lt;br/gt;Grow up and come out of your ignorance and capitalist journalism that is just to flare hatred and mastery of;br/gt;lt;br/gt;From stan
            1. M
              Mar 4, 2017 at 3:29 am
              No Indian journalist, of whatever background, nor any Indian "Intellectual", would have written this. Nothing illustrates the depth of cruel theology than the act of the little boy of Hujra Shah Muqueem, "The boy cut off his hand and presented it to the cleric" lt;br/gt;World fears, rightly so, this theology and belief system, except the Media and most politicians here in India.
              1. R
                Mar 4, 2017 at 11:23 am
                Islam by its very nature is the most intolerant of all the religions. There are many verses of Kuraan which prescribes violence on non-Muslims. They have destro the Indian culture so much so that brothers fight each other in the name of;br/gt;And the most pathetic thing is fanatic Muslims praise the very invaders which attacked and forcefully converted their ancestors. If we want to live in harmony and peace then Muslims(and Christians also) would to have to shun the practice of converting other faith's people to;br/gt;We should take lessons from middle East which is witnessing extreme and pure version of Islamic resurgence resulting in killings of many innocent lives who themselves are;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Bottom line is : religious fanaticism in any religion is bad for the progress of humanity and therefore we should give primacy to rational and humane thinking over religious dogmas.
                1. C
                  Mar 4, 2017 at 8:08 am
                  Thank God that the author is a Muslim and stani!lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;If an Indian writer - even he is God- writes this reportlt;br/gt;He would be torn to pieces for communilasm and this newspaper would have been burnt!lt;br/gt;Didi would call for. Bengal bandh on Monday !lt;br/gt;Congress spokesperson - any one of those- would have seen BJP plot and would call for the head of Modilt;br/gt;At least 10 -Scholars - would have returned their awards !lt;br/gt;Kashmir would burn - it is burning anyway!lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Ahmad bhai - a big thank you and bigger thank you that you are not an Indian otherwise our secular brigade would have lynched you!
                  1. Load More Comments