Zero sum game is up

As its friends befriend India, Pakistan’s ruling elites must come to terms with new regional, global realities

Written by Husain Haqqani | Updated: January 27, 2017 1:37 pm
modi, pm modi, narendra modi, modi uae, uae prince, india uae prince, uae pakistan india, india uae, india news, Prime Minister Narendra Modi,shakes hand with Abu Dhabi’s Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan after signing of agreements between the two countries in New Delhi on Wednesday. (Source: PTI Photo)

The United Arab Emirates, historically close to all South Asian countries, is the latest among many traditional friends trying to make Pakistan aware of the futility of its zero sum competition with India. UAE Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan was the chief guest at India’s Republic Day parade on January 26 and a contingent of UAE soldiers led this year’s parade. From the UAE’s perspective, the gesture acknowledged economic, political and security realities. With $60 billion in bilateral trade in 2015, the UAE is India’s third largest trading partner, after the United States and China. It is also the 10th largest foreign investor in India with over $8 billion in investments. Indian companies have invested around $55 billion in the UAE and annual remittances from the 2.6 million-strong Indian diaspora amount to $8 billion.

WATCH VIDEO | R-Day parade: India displays military might, cultural diversity

Pakistan’s ruling elite, especially its all-powerful military, tends to see other nations as close to India or as friends of Pakistan. The Pakistani narrative often ignores economics and sees international relations in binary terms, emphasising religion and ideology. Some Pakistani commentators have already started taking potshots at “fellow Muslims” embracing “Hindu India” at the expense of Pakistan. Ironically, UAE is not the first Gulf Arab Muslim country affirming friendship with India as chief guest at India’s Republic Day parade. Former Saudi King Abdullah was the chief guest at the 2006 parade and proudly declared India his “second home.”

For its part, the UAE has maintained close ties with both India and Pakistan historically even while providing critical support to Pakistan at crucial times. The largest Indian and Pakistani diaspora in the Gulf are in the UAE and they send much valued remittances to both countries. The communities often also get along quite well, benefiting from their shared cultures. Pakistan’s effort to build an iron curtain with India breaks down in the UAE as it does elsewhere around the world. Given the geographic proximity and easy access to both countries, Indians and Pakistanis often interact in Dubai, in addition to breaking trade and travel barriers.

Also read | Why UAE Crown Prince is a very special Republic Day guest

WATCH VIDEO |Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Witnesses Republic Day Parade, India’s Military Might On Display

Since becoming independent in 1971, the UAE has shown tremendous sensitivity to Pakistani concerns in the security realm even while expanding trade and economic ties with India. During the 1970s, Pakistan concluded a military protocol with the UAE and other Gulf countries, which enabled Pakistani officers to train and serve in the armed forces and police of these countries. The UAE’s founder, Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan, made it his country’s policy to assist Pakistan’s economy by hiring Pakistani labour in addition to giving direct aid. Between 1971 and 2015, the UAE was the destination country for 32.9 per cent of Pakistani migrant workers. As of 2016, according to World Bank data, the 1.2 million strong Pakistani diaspora in the UAE sends remittances worth $4.36 billion annually to Pakistan.

Moreover, the UAE has periodically offered balance-of-payments support in addition to investment in specific projects to help Pakistan get through times of economic difficulty, such as the years immediately after Pakistan’s loss of Bangladesh and at other interludes of political turmoil. Bilateral aid, which started with the setting up of the Abu Dhabi Fund for Development (ADFD) in 1974, over the years has made the UAE the second largest Arab donor to Pakistan while Pakistan has been the largest ADFD aid recipient in Asia. Still, the UAE’s affection for Pakistan’s people cannot alter two harsh facts that make India more important for most countries than Pakistan. First, the difference of size between the two South Asian neighbours. Compared to $60 billion in bilateral trade between the UAE and India, its volume of trade with Pakistan stood at only $7 billion in 2015. Although the UAE is the fourth major foreign investor in Pakistan, the cumulative value of those investments stands at $20 billion, much less than the UAE’s investment relationship with India.

WATCH VIDEO | PM Modi, Defence Minister Welcome Republic Day Chief Guest Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed Bin Zayed

The second, more significant, reality that is undermining Pakistan’s ability to remain the UAE’s first friend in South Asia is its policy of tolerance for jihadi terrorism. The UAE has taken the lead in confronting the violent Islamist narrative espoused by various jihadi groups while Pakistan remains hesitant to give up support for violent groups that it sees as instruments of regional influence. The January 11 attack by Pakistan-backed Afghan Taliban belonging to the Haqqani Network at the governor’s house in Kandahar resulted in the death of five UAE diplomatic staff and the wounding of its ambassador to Kabul, Juma Mohammed Abdullah Al Kaabi. Such incidents demonstrate how the UAE and Pakistan might be moving in opposite directions. Pakistan’s national narrative paints India as a permanent enemy and Pakistanis tend to expect their friends, whether in the greater Muslim world or the West, to view India through Pakistan’s eyes. As the UAE crown prince stands alongside Prime Minister Narendra Modi on the dais and UAE troops march alongside India’s soldiers in Delhi on India’s Republic Day, Pakistan must review its narrative and policies. If all of Pakistan’s friends are befriending India, perhaps it is time to give up the mantra of “permanent enemy” and come to terms with new regional and global realities.

The writer, director for South and Central Asia at the Hudson Institute in Washington DC, was Pakistan’s ambassador to the US from 2008-11

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. S
    Sridhar Sridhar
    Jan 29, 2017 at 4:13 am
    CPEC is Colonization of stan to Enrich China. Much has been written by stani intellectuals like Han Nissar about CPEC and need not be reiterated here.lt;br/gt;Most stanis think through their butt without using brain cells. There are no "Iron brothers" in this day and age. China did not help stan in 1971 when it lost its East wing nor during Kargil war. It helps stan when it suits China. lt;br/gt;China's help of stan also has to do with India leaning towards USA of late. China's economy has seen its peak and is on the decline now. India is outpacing China. China may not be able to push in the kind of money it promised as loan for CPEC.lt;br/gt;stan is in bad shape. Its external debt is above 70 billion dollars. Typically, when it exceeds 100 billion, IMF, WB come knocking and tell you to do X,Y, Z or else. This would include among other things pulling back its nuclear ets on which stan spends a lot of money, allowing international agencies to literally run the nation.lt;br/gt;So, stan's choice is to either fall in China'slap or Western lap. I think s have chosen former course already. Only time will tell if this is a good choice or bad. Looking at what some African nations have gone through vis-a-vis China, it is a terrible choice.
    Reply
    1. S
      Sridhar Sridhar
      Jan 29, 2017 at 4:15 am
      Haqqani is an intellectual while you are the "kutta" barking at a tree!
      Reply
      1. I
        India
        Jan 27, 2017 at 8:51 am
        This can never be written by so called secular journalist of India
        Reply
        1. M
          Mmr
          Jan 28, 2017 at 12:53 am
          stan has lost several opportunities to mend ties but I don't see any opportunity coming it's way soon. Army establishes the narrative for stan. Army is an enterprise taking 40%of its GDP and 30% goes to service the debt. It is economics stupid. Until and unless the army is discredited like (1971 war) Army is going watch its interest. Even the bloggers with liberal views and anti establishment (army) views have disappeared. This is stan for you. Like General Patton said "don't disturb your enemy when he is making mistake" let them carry on.
          Reply
          1. M
            Mugdha
            Jan 27, 2017 at 2:32 am
            stan a proxy,frontline state a sort of Compulsion,whose reality first known to India acknowledged by USA and Eu after 9/11, then by west Asia and now it's turn for China and Russia.But,knowing it's reality will not do unless it being nurtured to reinforce narrow national interest.
            Reply
            1. M
              MyTake
              Jan 27, 2017 at 11:25 pm
              Main problem is stan has not been able to decide up until now whether it is Indian or Arabian in origin. It is now looking for its ancenstors in China, just in case and out of hate for Indians!lt;br/gt;A country that does not know its origin, why should it bother to exist! What good it can do which does not even know what is its ideny? Hijacking Islam for "survival" is not good enough reason to "filllt;br/gt;Up" the missing links in genetic (source) make up!
              Reply
              1. M
                MyTake
                Jan 27, 2017 at 11:36 pm
                There are lots and lots of places of importance linked with Vedic past and its heritage in current stan. By developing these places and by providing security it could easily attract millions of tourist and peace in exchange of what its Taliban brothers are "giving" (which is deaths, destructions and insecurity of life)!lt;br/gt;But has anyone heard of a stani leader's who knows how to apply his/her mind in a dignified way? All they know is put one against the other and extract ransom money for survival, playing conveniencing/inconveniencing game in an alternating/oscillating manner!! This method has percolated down even to gr roots, hence, the w of its existence has become nothing but a cancer!
                Reply
                1. M
                  MyTake
                  Jan 27, 2017 at 12:22 am
                  stan = Islam infiltrated by Satan!lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;If you don't believe it find out what Satan's duty is and compare this with stan does in real life!
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments