Myth and reality

Art and culture are going through a right-wing phase, though Hindu art forms have never been targeted in India.

Written by T M Krishna | Published:June 9, 2016 12:40 am
narendra modi government, two years of modi government, Religious violence, indian culture, hindutva, muslims in india, minorities in india, muslim culture, right wing, culture in india, muslim exploitation, exploitation of muslims in india, anti modi, increase of hinduism, hindu in india, conversion,  Hindutva politics, congress, education system in  india, indian express column Hindus have been quite happily celebrating every festival with pomp, in fact the sizes of pandals during Ganpati utsav or Durga puja have only increased over the past decade.

As one who is thought of as belonging to the “world of culture”, I would say that the first two years of the Narendra Modi government have been the most disturbing times that I can recall. It has been a period when the political context has forced me to ask difficult questions of what this nation really is as a cultural identity. An ideational collapse has occurred and you can see it even these paragraphs. I find I have used the word culture to describe what is essentially religious.

Would I have done this some years ago? I would not have. This too is a remarkable achievement by the present dispensation. It is not that Prime Minister Narendra Modi has stood up at the ramparts of the Red Fort and made a proclamation to the effect that India that is Bharat has one culture, in body, mind and soul, and it’s name is Hindutva. He has not done that. In fact he has, both in India and abroad, spoken of “sabka saath”, but his colleagues and political partners have blatantly espoused Hindutva. And he has not contradicted them.

Hindus have been told by Hindutva’s spokespersons that for the last 60 plus years, this country has victimised and marginalised them. We have reached a point where this manifest untruth now carries the ring of historical truth. Hindus have been quite happily celebrating every festival with pomp, in fact the sizes of pandals during Ganpati utsav or Durga puja have only increased, the number of young people who visit temples has clearly been on the rise over the past decade or more and, let us not forget the proliferation of sadhus and gurus that dot our topography. If anything the Hindu, is far from being sunk or mass converted. But the fear of such a happening has been implanted in every Hindu mind.

Religious violence is not a creation of this government. The Congress can never atone enough for 1984. But there is a shift in the way society has taken to this new Hindutva political craftsmanship and that is for me the most worrisome trend. Today, violence of the religious/cultural kind is not just a tool of party politics and their attached lumpen outfits, today it is owned and worn on the sleeve with aplomb.

It is said with barely concealed anger if a Hindu celebrates his religion, he is accused of being right-wing but a Muslim is never asked that question. Let us think about this, seriously. In this world’s context, can we ever make this statement and actually believe it is true? If there is any community that has been globally vilified, it is the people of the Islamic faith, yet we are convinced that they have greater acceptance than the middle and upper class Hindu. There is enough data to prove that Muslims and Dalits are the most backward communities in this nation. There is no doubt that parties in and out of power including the Congress and many Muslim leaders wearing various political hats have only exploited the average Muslim voter, but should this make “us” insensitive to “their” real conditions? Worse is to think that Muslims are receiving benefits at Hindus’ cost. This idea in itself entrenches an underlying cultural thought — that this is a Hindu land and that Muslims are guests. Not to forget the allied belief that Muslims are terrorists or possible terrorists, unless Hindu thought has touched them, and just in case you did not know, Sufism is quintessentially Hindu!

Another invented truism being spread around is that the education system has made people anti-Hindu and pro-religious minorities. Even more laughable is the assertion that leftist academicians with the connivance of western socialist scholars have wiped out Hindu goodness and achievements from our history. If we were to visit the innumerable religious studies, art and language departments around this country, we will find more PhDs that are seeped in Hindu religiosity than of the other kind. But from what the naysayers claim, India by now should have become a mini-Soviet Union, but we are not, and thank goodness for that.

For all the Hindu pride that is demanded of us, the last few years have witnessed a strong misogynist (let us remember that this is not just a male attitude) and pro-upper caste/class articulation of India. There is clearly a cultural strategy to linearise Hindu sanskriti and within it engulf all that has in the past and present questioned its organisation. In the eulogisation of Hindu history I also smell a strong whiff of appropriation combined with the establishment of a certain idea of the Hindu — one that emanates from the middle classes. There has been no attempt to address issues of gender, multiple genders or caste. If anything there is a suppression of such discourses. Suppression today is not enforced via a dictatorial ban, it is mobilised using fear.

The world of the arts, especially the classical and wannabe classical community (nobody cares about the rest) has heralded this government, for they believe that they are the true representatives of Bharatiya sanskriti. All of sudden many Hindutvas have emerged out of closet. There is clearly a streamlining of what is artistically Indian, where religious Hindu inclined art forms are being pushed forward. Art and culture are going through a right-wing phase, even though at no point in India’s independent history were the Hindu art forms targeted. Hasn’t Bharatanatyam always been the “number one” symbol of Indian antiquity?

We should not allow people to subsume culture into religious belief systems. But I now wonder whether the larger society really cares to engage with this thought. Sociologists, activists and cultural liberals vouch for India’s syncretic identity providing us many living examples of wonderful people. But do these small pockets matter anymore? If anything they are being used to certify the real Indian – the one who accepts the Hindu as that mythic being.

As I end this piece, I feel another achievement of this government, at least in me — cultural pessimism.

The writer is a renowned Carnatic vocalist and author of ‘A Southern Music: The Karnatik Story’

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. H
    Hemant Kumar
    Jun 9, 2016 at 1:53 pm
    The leftist intellectuals/ atheists hyped their views against chanting of Bharat Mata ki jai, against nationalism, against beef ban, against intolerance, against Dadri lynching, supporting award wapsi etc. This shows their anti Hindu mindset.
    Reply
    1. I
      indian
      Jun 9, 2016 at 3:26 pm
      Actually the Arran invasion theory is still in question.
      Reply
      1. I
        indian
        Jun 9, 2016 at 3:25 pm
        Earlier, these so called artists freely denigrated Hinduism (MF hussein painting Durga nude is okay according to them, but a Hindu painting something blasphemous in Islam isnt). The only difference now is that they cannot denigrate it. And they are complaining
        Reply
        1. A
          Ashok
          Jun 9, 2016 at 5:40 am
          Writer is not mentioning inconvenient truth about how Hindu culture has been run down by pseudo secularists and left historian. He does not mention about Auragjeb and Tipu who murdered and demolished lacs of temples Hindus and still these liberals callers them secularists. This is hypocracy of the worst order.
          Reply
          1. S
            Sanatana Moorthy
            Jun 9, 2016 at 1:13 pm
            The writer often displays his arrogance, when he talk about his music and now, he is acting very cheap, silly and petty to prove that he is a leftist, pro-minority and above all, anti-hindutva to receive applause from pseudo secular and anti-national groups.lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;It is dirty trick pla by every other, self-styled "progressive" minded members of english speaking media.
            Reply
            1. S
              Skanda
              Jun 9, 2016 at 12:59 pm
              Fear and more fear. Of Hindu expressions of ideny. The writer is such a sorry apologist for the Left's hegemony over Indian historiography in school textbooks as well as university curricula. India must be the only country on earth with a major civilizational past that is not understood by its young generation. As the Dalai Lama recently said, youngsters know nothing of Indian thought and philosophy. Raised in Christian schooling systems that uphold the Macaulayan ethos and brainwashed in the universities on Left academic antipathy towards the sacred dimensions of Hindusim, contemporary Indian youth are thoroughly alienated from their heritage. Hindutva is just a symptom of this deep discontinuity the charge for which lays at the doors of the congress and the left ruled academia in India that has controlled India's meta narrative
              Reply
              1. K
                K SHESHU
                Jun 9, 2016 at 12:09 pm
                No religion should be attributed to art and culture. The ' swaras' of each and every musical song -- bhajans, ghazal, quires , namaz,etc. -- have the same melody anywhere...
                Reply
                1. A
                  Achal
                  Jun 9, 2016 at 12:56 am
                  Very biased and irrational article. Nothing has been substantiated!
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments