The Politics Of Victimhood

The demands of the agitating Marathas are not reasonable.

Written by Anand Teltumbde | Published:October 10, 2016 12:04 am
maratha, maratha agitation, maratha protest, maratha quota agitation, maratha demands, maratha employment, maharashta, maharashtra agitation, maratha rape, kopardi rape, caste atrocities, muk morcha, silent agitation, dalit, caste agitation, sharad pawar, victimhood, maratha victimhood, indian express opinion Maratha rally.(Representational PTI photo)

The form and content of the Maratha agitation sparked off by the rape and murder of a 14-year old school girl in Kopardi village in Ahmednagar district of Maharashtra, notorious for its record of caste atrocities, has stunned observers. The form of muk morcha (silent rally) adopted by the protesters is novel and puzzling since the community is not known for such patience, individually or collectively. The content is confusing since all the culprits were arrested within a week of the crime and the chief minister himself promised that they would be hanged to death. The original demand — justice to the victim — has been overshadowed by the plea to introduce reservations for the Maratha community and repeal of the SC and the ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.

The call for capital punishment to the culprits of the Kopardi incident — they belong to a Dalit caste — was supported by all, including the Dalits. But the protests took a distinct caste turn after it was raised in the state assembly by NCP leaders, Radhakrishna Vikhe-Patil and Ajit Pawar. A massive muk morcha on August 1 demanded reservations for Marathas and the repeal of the SC and the ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. NCP bigwigs including party supremo Sharad Pawar supported the morcha. A spate of similar morchas, over 40 so far, have since taken place all over Maharashtra. Some of the NCP leaders have accepted that they provided logistic support to the rallies. These morchas have no face or clear leadership. The spokespersons are like school girls. Established politicians have been scrupulously kept out.

The Marathas, who account for a third of electorate, are divided into three classes. The top layer is made of the wealthy Marathas who control the cooperative sector, run businesses, and hold political power. They are called gadhivarcha (fort-dwelling) Marathas. The NCP is their party. The second layer comprises rich landlords, who control small cooperatives and institutions of local self government. They are described as wadyavarcha (mansion-dwelling) Marathas. They support the Congress and the BJP. The third section, the vadivarcha (the commoner) Marathas, is facing the brunt of the mounting agrarian crisis. They support parties like the Shiv Sena, MNS and other such lumpen outfits. None of these parties could inspire the Marathas masses in such large numbers and incur the electoral risk of identifying openly with the demands raised by the agitators. However, each party imagines that it could partake of the gains of this mobilisation.

The demand for Maratha reservation is not a new one. Similar demands have been raised by the Gujjars, Jats, and Patidars, their counterparts in other states. The Marathas are the kunabis (tillers) of Maharashtra, but would not identify themselves as so when the kunabis were classed as OBC by the Mandal Commission. Instead, the Marathas have claimed kshatriya-hood for themselves.

History apart, are these demands feasible? The political class, including Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, who appears to be the target of the NCP, has supported the claims, notwithstanding the failure of earlier attempts to secure them. The Maratha community, which has complete dominance over the politics and economics of the state, can never establish through constitutional means that it is socially and educationally backward and establish the claim for OBC reservation. If the political class manages the inclusion through fraudulent means, the existing OBCs are likely to oppose it and the courts will stall it. The second demand — the claim to repeal the SC and the ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act has now changed to modification of the act — is directed against the Dalits. The basis of the demand that convictions are few — the rate of conviction is as low as six per cent — only indicates the dominance of the dominant castes over the state apparatus, which works to ensure that cases booked under the act fail at every node of the justice delivery system. Moreover, it is a national act and cannot be tinkered under false pretexts.

Though both the demands are unlikely to be fulfilled, the consciousness of victimhood among the Marathas achieved by the morchas is going to serve the interests of the political parties. The Maratha youth must realise that their own leaders have been responsible for their current plight. The current mobilisations are unlikely to alleviate their misery.

Teltumbde is author of ‘Mahad: The Making of the First Dalit Revolt’

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    Ajitdada
    Oct 10, 2016 at 8:54 pm
    The castiest atude of so called Maratha stems from their social status and control power till now. There was no cast as "Maratha", This is an acronym given by outsiders to All the people who live in Maharashtra region since Muslim invasions of Maharashtra region. The falll of Devgiri Yadava is a game changer. The 4 main communities at that time ( Kunabi(tiller), Shepherds, Mali, Vanjari) have started wielding control of Maharashtra region. The prominent among them started forming their leagues and joined Adilshahi. Especially few families Kunbi and Shepherds rose to power and had intermarriages. A new type of community became predominant. Shivaji born to such a family and he was from a Kunbi clan (shudra) where as Shepherds umed themselves a Kashtriya status. It became an a hardest job for Shivaji to declare himself as Kashtriya king at the time of his coronation. Shivaji's gson established a Peshwa and this changed the fate of Maratha empire. Peshwa was expansionist and he kept many established families away from the power and gave chances to Kunbi and Shepherd commander. Today the Kunbi cast is changing their ideny to show they are Kashtriya hence they started putting their cast a "Maratha" rather than Kunbi-Shudra. As per Supreme court "Maratha" is not a cast based on the histroic facts. The so called Kunbis wish to abolish the "Kunbi" ideny and create reservation as "Maratha" which means their social status will be elevated as well as reservation will continue. This is the most communal agenda ever pla in India before. Before 1947 there were just 5% in Maharashtra who claimed in Mahrashtra as "Maratha" even they had marriages between Kunbi clan which was 95%, but today hardly 10% claim themslves as "Kunbi" and 90% claim as "Maratha". Due to power transition in Maharashtra so called "Martha" today are feared that local and other powers will go to "Shephered" , "Mali" and "Vanjari" casts. In fact Shepherds in Mahrashtra are 2nd in potion after Kunbi and now well connected. This social reality is upsetting the "Martha, Kunbi". In short, if "Maratha" is accepted as a cast then our national anthem need to be rephrased by dropping "Maratha" to make it more secular.
    Reply
    1. K
      Kumarpushp
      Oct 10, 2016 at 9:58 pm
      120 million Dalits should join with 120 million Muslims to demolish egos of Maratha what mahar did to Peshwas who were put in place for ever .
      Reply
      1. P
        Pmp
        Oct 10, 2016 at 7:23 am
        All the shenanigans of the Morchas,including the latest riots in Nahik,is handiwork of the party highlighted by the author, and It's corrupt and amoral Supremo.such riots are planned with precision to foment unrest,be it the Kopardi crime or the failure of local services in Mumbra/ Mumbai.These people have enjo privileges for decades and now to ask for reservations,when the power is lost through electoral process is not only pathetic but opportunistic.
        Reply
      2. R
        Rajat
        Oct 10, 2016 at 2:02 pm
        The same analysis appeared in the newspapers a few days ago. The writer has just reproduced it, verbatim, in some sentences. And then typical to his writing brushes aside the concerns of the poor among the upper castes as 'irrelevant'
        Reply
        1. S
          Saurabh
          Oct 10, 2016 at 4:12 pm
          Homework is done by Mumbai HC and Supreme Court, and they have rejected ur all demands.
          Reply
          1. S
            Saurabh
            Oct 10, 2016 at 6:59 pm
            Me and my family have Indian as ideny. U have crossed ur limit by dragging my parents. But I won't cross because there should be difference between good and evil. This is what ur people's mentality. U needlessly brought my parents, I'll reply you by meeting personally.
            Reply
            1. S
              Saurabh
              Oct 10, 2016 at 7:18 pm
              Will give you answer very soon at place and time of my choice. You think you can comment anything anonymously.
              Reply
              1. S
                Saurabh
                Oct 10, 2016 at 5:10 am
                Marathas can't get reservations, they also know it better. This muka morcha was just a show of power.
                Reply
                1. Load More Comments