• Associate Sponsor

Lakes of fire

The froth spewing from them in Bengaluru is a symptom of a pervasive urban problem — the discharge of untreated sewage into water bodies.

Written by Isher Judge Ahluwalia , Almitra Patel | Published: August 30, 2017 12:52 am
Water pollution, Bellandur lake, Bengaluru lake, Bengaluru lake pollution, bangalore lake According to the CPCB, 75 per cent of the measured pollution in our rivers from point sources is from municipal sewage and 25 per cent is from industrial effluents. (Illustration: C R Sasikumar)

Bellandur lake in Bengaluru has been much in the news in recent months for the surge of foam and froth from the polluted lake, and the rise of smoke and flames from the area surrounding it. Barely two weeks ago, in the midst of the city’s heaviest rains in a century, the stinking froth and foam (a mix of chemicals and untreated sewage) rose as high as 10 to 12 feet from Bellandur and spread onto the streets, endangering traffic and entering shops and homes across the road, causing huge inconvenience to those living in the area. Only a few months earlier, in February, the area was engulfed in smoke as garbage strewn around the lake was set ablaze.

In May 2015, the Bellandur lake itself was on fire, creating enormous fear and anxiety in the minds of the people living in the area. The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) submitted a report to the Union Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, highlighting the sustained inflow of untreated sewage and industrial effluents as the principal forces behind the phenomena of froth and fire. Subsequently, an expert committee set up by the state government submitted its report on rejuvenation of the lake in October 2016.

How long would it take to get down to action? It is hard to believe that this is happening to the largest lake in the Silicon Valley of India, which has been known for its hundreds of lakes originally built in the 16th century by damming the natural valley systems. The National Green Tribunal turned its attention to the problems of the Bellandur lake in February, and expressed extreme dissatisfaction on the unhealthy condition of the lake in its successive hearings. The tribunal has issued a number of directions emphasising the need for removal of silt from the lake, treatment of municipal sewage which is going into the water body, closure of polluting industries, ban on dumping of municipal solid waste around the lake, penalty on apartment buildings in the area which are sending untreated sewage to the lake and an environmental fine of Rs 5 lakh on anyone found dumping waste in and around the lake. Most recently, the NGT has asked all departments of the government to work together to prepare an Action Plan by September 7 for cleaning up the lake.

Bellandur is only one example, although a major one, of what we are doing to most of our lakes, streams and rivers in urban India. Out of 480 million litres per day (MLD) of wastewater discharged to the lake, only 308 MLD is treated. According to the CPCB, 75 per cent of the measured pollution in our rivers from point sources is from municipal sewage and 25 per cent is from industrial effluents.

Indian cities and towns have abused their surface water bodies. Sewerage networks are supposed to ensure that sewage or wastewater is conveyed to a sewage treatment plant, treated and then discharged into water bodies. Bengaluru has 6,800 km of sewerage line and 14 sewage treatment plants. The capacity for sewage treatment in Bengaluru in 2015-16 was 51 per cent but actual sewage treatment was only 37 per cent of the sewage generated. This is still higher than the 30 per cent average for all Indian cities and towns.

Since the “unofficial” groundwater that is used by city residents from private bore-wells is not included in the definition of water consumed by the city, wastewater or sewage (estimated as 80 per cent of the water consumed in the city) is typically under-estimated. The situation with respect to sewage treatment is therefore worse than it appears for all cities.

As the untreated wastewater or sewage finds its way to local waterbodies, it feeds the growth of water-weeds, which blankets surface water. Aquatic vegetation is an orphan waste, not yet covered by the rules under the Environment Protection Act 1986. Apparently, the huge roots of water hyacinth absorb impurities and can lock up pollutants in the water. But when this profuse aquatic vegetation dies, it sinks to the bottom and decays. The microbes feeding on the rotting organic matter consume all the oxygen in the water, disturbing the ecology for the survival of fish life. When such organic matter naturally breaks down, it releases fatty acids that float to the surface. These act as natural surfactants, which allow minute bubbles to form which often persist for a long time. This is how foam is formed and turns into froth.

Surfactants are clearly a cause of foam formation. That is why detergent companies deliberately use surfactants to create foams that lift off dirt and have a feel-good factor for detergent users. The problem arises when these surfactants are not biodegradable and do not break down after their purpose is served.

In the late 1950s and the 1960s in the United States, lakes, rivers, and sewage treatment plants experienced foam formation, caused by synthetic laundry detergents that were highly resistant to chemical breakdown. Now, by law, the lathering agent of all detergents on the market must be biodegradable. They therefore quickly lose their ability to cause foaming and are unable to produce long-lasting foam. We need similar regulations in India, that is, the surfactants in detergents must be biodegradable.

It is the phosphorus in detergents entering wastewater which hugely promotes the growth of water plants. Phosphorus is useful for agriculture, but it is directly responsible for choking our surface waters with aquatic vegetation. It is also indirectly responsible for forming huge rafts of foam which get stabilised by rotting vegetation on the lake bottom.

The problem was first identified when Lake Erie, on the US-Canada border, turned green and its aquatic life began dying for want of oxygen, as dying plants sank to the bottom and rotted, consuming dissolved oxygen from the water. This is called eutrophication. Both countries rapidly responded with an international treaty in 1970 which, has since 1973, limited the phosphorus content in their detergents to a maximum of 2.2 per cent. The European Union followed suit.

India has no mandatory rules limiting phosphorus content in detergents and laundry bars, even as demand for detergents has grown at the rate of 10-11 per cent per annum between 2005 and 2010, and is likely to have been faster in the subsequent years because of rapid urbanisation. The phosphorus content in the detergents in India is much higher than 2.2 per cent. It is extremely important that a lower limit closer to the global norm is placed on phosphorus content and its labelling becomes mandatory for all detergents in the Indian market so that caring citizens can make eco-friendly purchasing choices.

In the recent crisis on the frothing and flaring in and around the Bellandur lake, far too much of press attention was placed on fire-fighting with bio-culture and/or water sprinklers and not enough on the factors that have brought us to this pass. There are no short-cuts to protecting our catchments for freshwater. Waste management is critical — solid waste (garbage), liquid waste (sewage), and acquatic waste. Additional challenges are posed by encroachment, which diminishes catchments for freshwater. Urban planning in India must ensure that wetlands which are natural recharge zones are typically not disturbed. Also, natural drains which provide a safe exit to storm-water including flood-water and also recharge ground water, should be protected from encroachment.

Ahluwalia is chairperson, ICRIER, Delhi, and former chairperson of the high-powered expert committee on urban infrastructure and services. Patel is member, Supreme Court committee on solid waste management

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Isher Judge Ahluwalia
  1. C
    Aug 30, 2017 at 8:26 pm
    How is that this article never mentions the word "methane" anywhere? Are the readers that dumb?
    1. V
      Aug 30, 2017 at 5:45 pm
      What about converting this so called pollution into useful product for the country. is anyone interested
      1. A
        Aug 30, 2017 at 4:42 pm
        The author has hit the nail on Bangloreans' head. Calcutta took nearly 100 years to decay. Mumbai just over 50 years. Banglore is dying in just 25 years. The British developed Banglore as a cantonment. Luckily, for nearly 45 years since independence, politicians in Karnataka played a complementary role for Bangalore and kept the city centric model alive. The longer than expected rural centric government at the centre and a similar too late one in Karnataka during the last 22 years is playing havoc with the City's infrastructure. The peasant lords have minted millions by using Bangalore as a chess board but still they are not satisfied. Somebody said that India has got its own right for a self rule. We have to read between the lines. That 'somebody' might be eyeing what, if our cities continue to wither under peasants terrorism ?. Is it our knowledge manpower. Which is the next city for the peasants' target ?. It seems, the fate of IT and Bangalore is entwined.
        1. A
          Aug 30, 2017 at 1:57 pm
          The article is to be quite apprecaited for bringing to public attention such an important issue. Let it be an eye opener to our regulators and planners. Political will is a must and social education. All our public utility system need quick attention better later than never. The rivers and water bodoes needs to be protected at any cost other we will be doomed - they will be silient killers. We should follow the Western civility than other things! All industries should be regulated and ensured to be latest in technology.
          1. Satindra Paul Singh
            Aug 30, 2017 at 1:17 pm
            This proves that in India administration is not working for the public interest but for its own.It clearly shows that our democratic ins utions are rotton.Civic bodies are den of corruption and busy in filling their own pockets.There is overlapping power system and lack of full autonomy,transparency and accountability.Elections have become a farce and tamasha.All over India there is centralisation of power.Govt. are not transparent and confidentiality,secrecy and rampant corruption is the norm.Town planning is controlled by the CMs or PM.Politicians are doing diservice to the nation which came in to existence just 70 years back.How long it can linger on this way or on ICU is visible.Black and criminal money is consumed in elections.Under the present circumstances there is no hope for the betterment of the system.
            1. G
              Aug 30, 2017 at 5:17 pm
              This kind of victim based thinking is at the core of Indian's problems. We are part of the problem and not just at the receiving end. Trash, pollution and sewage are problems that we cause and can fix. When we start to blame "corruption", "centralization", "black money", "administration" we give up the power to fix it because it is out of our control. If corruption were to disappear tomorrow, our streets and waters will not become clean miraculously. Indeed, there are many countries where corruption, centralization and elections were not a problem and they still suffered from pollution. We need a little perspective to see our own role in the problems instead of tilting at the windmills.
            2. Load More Comments