Kashmir: By banning our newspaper, government is only looking for scapegoats

'Kashmir Reader’, a small English daily published from Srinagar, was asked to stop publication on the evening of Sunday, October 2.

Written by Mir Hilal | Updated: October 5, 2016 1:01 pm
kashmir reader ban, kashmir reader, kashmir reader ban protest, kashmir journalists, kashmir reader online, j&k kashmir reader, kashmir reader banned, j&k news, kashmir news, india news The newspaper has been accused of “publishing content that can incite acts of violence” and “disturb public tranquility”.

‘Kashmir Reader’, a small English daily published from Srinagar, was asked to stop publication on the evening of Sunday, October 2. The government order announcing the ban was dated September 30. We are yet to find out why the police delivered a copy of the order three days later. The newspaper has been accused of “publishing content that can incite acts of violence” and “disturb public tranquility”. The government information department later issued a statement that said the order had been issued a week after the Kashmir Reader was served a notice to explain its “position on a series of items published disturbing public tranquility and notwithstanding the principles of rules governing the subject (sic)”. No such notice was served to us.

The most interesting bit of information in the information department’s statement is attributed to district magistrate Farooq Ahmed Lone. “The decision was taken after a series of reports from various agencies and credible inputs providing sufficient ground for the decision taken,” he said.

Since when did the perusal of a newspaper’s content become the job of unnamable “agencies”? What does “credible inputs providing sufficient ground for the decision” mean? Every government institution in the thick of the raging uprising, especially police, army, CRPF and the civil administration, has its own PR cell. Reporters regularly talk to them for information and comments. We have not received a single complaint from the information department on any report/article so far. What then made the government act on the reports of “various agencies”?

Any item the government deems a threat “to public tranquility” could be rebutted even before the reporter sits down to write the copy. The other side has all the time to explain its position. And if for any reason the other side has not been addressed, the newspaper is obliged to issue clarifications/corrections, and even apologise if needed, later. This is exactly what we have been doing.

The ban, therefore, points to a bigger malaise, which is the recklessness of state authorities in times of crises. A few days into the raging uprising, the government announced a ban on publication of all newspapers for three days on the phone to a group of editors, who had met a day after police seized newspapers at printing presses. In the wake of international outrage, it then denied having enforced a ban and requested newspaper owners to resume publication. No one was held responsible for such a perfunctory decision.

Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti casually remarked at the peak of the uprising: “Had those children gone to buy toffee?”. She had been told by the security agencies that the protesters had been shot dead when they tried to overrun police stations and army camps, a theory that has largely gone unquestioned. It became one of the most widely circulated — and condemned — of her statements. Did her remark incite violence or the media’s faithful reportage of her comments?

As many as 90 people have been killed, more than 10,000 injured, about 700, mostly students have been partially or fully blinded. About 7,000 people have been arrested and many booked under the Public Safety Act, including the human rights activist Khurram Parvez.

The forces have reportedly damaged hundreds of transformers supplying electricity to people in scores of villages and towns (IE, September 12, 2016). Houses have been ransacked and the elderly beaten up. Is this cataclysmic situation the creation of a small newspaper?

After blaming the uprising on Pakistan, militant outfits, activists of rival pro-India parties, Hurriyat, mosques, human rights activists, the government has now turned to the media. On October 4, Kashmir’s largest circulated newspaper, Greater Kashmir, wrote on its front page : “The ban on Kashmir Reader newspaper was least expected after the state government backed off from its recent attempt to muzzle the local press following the widespread condemnation from across the world. But as another similar bid reveals, the government is none the wiser for it and in no mood to give up. This time though only one paper has been banned, it hardly detracts from the troubling larger import of the move.”

Rather than looking for scapegoats, the government needs to rethink its media policy. Its massive bureaucracy needs to become more responsive to the media in difficult times. At the height of the unrest, upto 70 incidents would occur in a single day. A small newspaper like ours can cover only a few of these. Journalistic ethics demand that we talk to the other side, the government, for its version of the events. Are the officials concerned available to respond the queries of 10 reporters? Ask any Kashmiri local journalist and he would frown. Has the government reinforced its PR machinery, or geared up its existing one, to widen its media outreach? No.

The police department usually summarises the day’s incidents in a paragraph. A typical police press release, after declaring the day by and large peaceful, would squeeze a line like this at the end: “57 miscreants have been arrested.” Reporters hardly find any official available for an elaboration on such a large number of arrests.

The media has shortcomings. But instead of imposing bans, the government can help itself, the people and the media by fostering an atmosphere where careless wielding of power does not fetter professionalism.

The writer is editor of ‘Kashmir Reader’

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. J
    Jayakumar
    Oct 5, 2016 at 2:09 pm
    The press in Kashmir are paid by the separatists. They don't try to give a true picture and only blame the forces which are trying to save JK from stan take over.
    Reply
    1. R
      Rajat
      Oct 5, 2016 at 1:34 pm
      Tell this author that in this era of twitter and facebook, readers all over India have seen videos of 'innocent' stone throwers beating up security personnel. Don't paint one sided story. I feel for innocent Kashmiris, they are our brothers, but there are many vile people too who don't want to peace or to be part of India. And their grievance is that they want to be part of islamic stan and not Secular India.
      Reply
      1. K
        K SHESHU
        Oct 5, 2016 at 2:26 pm
        Another nail in the freedom of expression
        Reply
        1. S
          Shafiq
          Oct 5, 2016 at 12:12 pm
          Yes the largest democracy of the world that really suits you
          Reply
          1. A
            Ari Basu
            Oct 5, 2016 at 6:21 am
            David - you seem unaware about a lot of things. First of all, you have commented on a post by someone named 'S.P. Chakravarty'. I don't know how you arrived at Sunni from this - Chakravarty is a common Hindu (Brahmin) surname usually from Bengal or am . Secondly, a lot of people all over the country are dissatisfied with the Government. Currently, I am dissatisfied about the condition of the roads in Bombay - and I have loudly told anyone who will listen that I feel the Government is not doing the job it is supposed to. This is dissent - and it is a right that everyone in a democracy enjoys. Sometimes the dissatisfaction gets to a boiling point and leads to violence on the streets. The Shiv Sena and MNS in Bombay or Trinamool and CPI(M) in Calcutta have all resorted to violence on the streets to express their dissatisfaction with some Government action or decision. This has nothing to do with any political party or religion. We need to ask ourselves whether the grouse is genuine and whether the Government should be trying to address the problem - or should it try to shut down dissent by use of force and unjust laws. BTW, most of the laws that the Government currently uses to gag dissent were written by the British and designed to suppress Indian Nationalists and the freedom movement. So does that make the Indian Government Anti-National?? Of course violence is not a good solution to voice one's grievances and no religion sanctions violence. Unfortunately, we have a neighbour who finds the dissatisfaction of people a fertile ground to cause trouble. Simplistically, if the Government focuses on development and economic upliftment of the people of Kashmir, the people would not be dissatisfied and the unrest would vanish.
            Reply
            1. D
              Diwakar
              Oct 7, 2016 at 4:36 pm
              Kashmir reader is a known Hurriyat Propaa tool ,daily you can see more than half- of its article attributed to hurriyat camps or sourced from stani newspapers ..,lt;br/gt;this should have been banned long back ,I dnt know why Govt. took so long to decide !! better late than never just read past 2 months of this newspaper and you'll know how much lt;br/gt;negative vibes on front pages it disseminate ,lt;br/gt;It has even written J and K states as Indian occupied Kashmir (IOK) or Indian -held Kashmir (IHK) which is the same language as is used by stani newspapers .lt;br/gt;Just see the below link lt;br/gt;
              Reply
              1. D
                Diwakar
                Oct 7, 2016 at 3:23 pm
                nmvhj.
                Reply
                1. D
                  Diwakar
                  Oct 8, 2016 at 8:21 am
                  It has even written J and K states as Indian occupied Kashmir (IOK) or Indian -held Kashmir (IHK) which is the same language as is used by stani newspapers .lt;br/gt;Just see the below link lt;br/gt;
                  Reply
                  1. D
                    Diwakar
                    Oct 8, 2016 at 8:20 am
                    This was a long overdue ,in most of the Tweets on Hurriyats page /Twitter you'll see link referring of Kashmir reader Many ppl belive is overground propaa tool of Anti-india Hurriyat camp ...Apart from mis-representing writing indian kashmir as India -Held Kashmir ,which is same language as Used by stani newspapers :lt;br/gt;It never mention If Hurriyat activists commits crime : Like when TeH (tehreeke Hurriyat camps burnt down many Auto rickshaws for defying their hartal call ..this poor driver's only source of living was Autos driving he was helplessly crying at geelani's activists for burning Autos ...it never demonised hurriyat ,,but always demonised Mehbooba Mufti Govt . its editorial /violence wielded news headlines : It even level led false bribery allegation Mehbooba Mufti without any evedence ..that she paid 10 lakh to a person to speak against hurriyats
                    Reply
                    1. D
                      Diwakar
                      Oct 8, 2016 at 8:22 am
                      kashmirreaderdotcom/2016/09/07/the-inhumanity-and-heartbreak-in-india-held-kashmir-must-be-halted-malala/
                      Reply
                      1. D
                        Diwakar
                        Oct 8, 2016 at 8:21 am
                        Reply
                        1. J
                          Jaideep Gupta
                          Oct 5, 2016 at 1:00 pm
                          Thanks to Indian Government to stop publishing a anti-national paper 'Kashmir Reader'.
                          Reply
                          1. J
                            Jaideep Gupta
                            Oct 5, 2016 at 1:05 pm
                            There is no Hindu terrorism as such. Have you ever heard a single hindu organisation killed any innocent person. Rather they help the government to built a strong India. Where as see Taliban, Al Quida. How they destroy stan.
                            Reply
                            1. J
                              Jaydip
                              Oct 5, 2016 at 4:10 pm
                              M0r0n, its because Kashmir is ours and Somalia is a foreign land! Because we have zillions of people like you, we, that is India, can never dream to become a truly developed country. Love your country but always question your government! Country and government is not same.
                              Reply
                              1. C
                                Chandru
                                Oct 5, 2016 at 8:00 pm
                                As many as 90 people have been killed, more than 10,000 injured, about 700, mostly students have been partially or fully blinded.lt;br/gt;Mr Hilallt;br/gt;You are also giving half truths- refer abovelt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Did you mention that the students got injured/killed while pelting stones at the police!?lt;br/gt;I am not saying that the Policemen are angels - but you are in the same group- half truths!lt;br/gt;But you are Secular!
                                Reply
                                1. E
                                  err
                                  Oct 5, 2016 at 4:15 am
                                  All anti nationals and islamic jihadists talk about freedom of expression and human wrights when they are cornered ,when they are in power or when they become majority ,they will kill all the minorities, look at what they did to Kashmiri Pandits and sikhs in kashmir?? they killed and driven them out, no Hindu is left in Kashmir
                                  Reply
                                  1. C
                                    Chacha Jee
                                    Oct 5, 2016 at 8:00 pm
                                    I agree with author. The problem is mosques and qurin. They go to mosques which teach them qurin which teaches them killing women with stone, they go to big mosque for hajj , there are told to stone. Here they go to mosque and come out stonig security forces who are not supposed to retaliate. Muslims think when there is retaliation by non muslim then it is violation of their qurin. Modi should actively persuade muslim to move to their beloved stan.
                                    Reply
                                    1. C
                                      Chacha Jee
                                      Oct 5, 2016 at 8:11 pm
                                      Try throwing stone to a police offer in USA..They will arrange their meeting with Allah right away.These Muslims say they are stanis then when indian are holding them. Just like actors. all stani s should be sent to stan. The problem is in 4 districts of Kashmir where Muslims are in majority. Unless these Muslims are roundrd up and marched to stan in full glare of Cameras, nothing will change or more stans will be made out of india. Daily Hindus refugees come from stan then why not muslim refugees from India to stan. stan will change only when it sees muslim camps in stan. Give azadi as burma did, putin in Chechnya. Solviana offered to muslims. Drastic steps needed.. india biggest mistake of keeping muslim here aftet 1947 for vote bank politics. HI DIED FOR STAN
                                      Reply
                                      1. K
                                        KP
                                        Oct 5, 2016 at 6:57 am
                                        Mir is justifying inciting violence by news papers and hailing terrorists as usual since the violence and unrest in Kashmir is sponsored based on religion read Islam without applying mind every individual faithful contributes his bit towards jehad yes thus is reality how can news papers remain second to any body it is the secret behind their business Mir is pained vomiting killings but is deaf and dumd to admit who is behind killings Geelani is an out sider and not of Kashmir origin Kasir has in past too been exploited by these imported so called Islami scholars who preached and practised only violence killings loot and arson
                                        Reply
                                        1. K
                                          KP
                                          Oct 5, 2016 at 7:10 am
                                          don't be Kashmir specialist sitting in AC rooms this is undue and overflow of tax payers money pumped in from decades used for getting arms besides encouraged loot and continuous arson they don't need any development don't u understand they r destroying schools Hospitals and existing infrastructure simple use tanks and bulldozers like Russia to finish trouble mongers for ever
                                          Reply
                                          1. K
                                            KP
                                            Oct 5, 2016 at 7:17 am
                                            nation has suffered too much due to the secular curse what we need is a proud Hindu Rashtr Hindu is not communal India is secular because of Hindu majority this curse was introduced by faithful Muslim dynasty of Nehrus
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments