A besieged life of the mind

Attacks on Nivedita Menon, Rajshree Ranawat show the decline of state universities, perversion of student politics

Written by Apoorvanand | Updated: February 10, 2017 12:10 am
Nivedita Menon, JNU professor Nivedita Menon, FIR against Nivedita Menon, Indian Army, anti-RSS, India news, Indian Express Nivedita Menon

The reports of attacks and a hate campaign in the form of agitations and police reports against academic Nivedita Menon of Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) and Rajshree Ranawat of the Jai Narain Vyas University (JNVU), Jodhpur, must concern us all. We cannot simply shrug it off when the university administration itself is filing criminal reports against academics for their “anti-national” remarks on its premises. FIRs have a life of their own and can have serious consequences. Books have been pulped, recalled from shelves, writers and artists have apologised for something they have not done, jobs have been lost. So, it is not amusing to learn that teachers are facing a “popular” agitation, bad press and possible arrests for their scholarly work, be this in a lecture at a seminar, an article or a book.

This attack is not an exception. A similar assault had taken place at the Mohanlal Sukhadia University, Udaipur, some time ago when the organisers and speakers of a seminar in the department of philosophy were targeted with criminal cases and a “popular” agitation. The case of the teachers in Haryana Central University, attacked for staging a play, is still fresh in our minds.

In these cases, nationalism is used as a weapon against knowledge and free enquiry. This article, however, is not an attempt to defend Nivedita Menon and Rajshree Ranawat or the English department at JNVU, which invited Menon to speak at a conference on “History Reconstructed Through Literature: Nation, Identity, Culture”, where she made allegedly “seditious” remarks questioning India’s claims over Kashmir.

Menon has since clarified, in great detail in a post on Kafila.online, that statements attributed to her are falsehoods and half-truths. She is not a coward, so she does not disown her remarks. But clearly, most of what is being blamed on her is not what she said but what the agitators imagined she had. This is an occasion to deliberate on the sad decline of state universities, the perversion of student politics and the irresponsible reporting by the Hindi
media, which borders on instigation and hate campaigns.

We know the sad story of the destruction of the once-outstanding Jodhpur and Jaipur Universities. They have been killed by starving them of funds and the non-appointment of faculty. Reduced to examination machines, they lack even the ambition of contributing to knowledge creation.

The divide between the state universities and central educational institutions, in terms of finances and knowledge, is huge and daunting. The sheer insensitivity of state governments and political parties towards the young is demonstrated in the way they treat and maintain universities. Vice chancellors are selected not for their ability
in academic leadership, but their loyalty to the government of the day. Departments are empty, libraries impoverished and laboratories non-functional.

In such a dismal scenario, conferences like the one Ranawat and her colleagues organised are audacious acts, pulled off in extremely adverse situations. They also serve as oases, a rare opportunity for students and faculty to be exposed to and interact with the best minds in the academic world. Such conferences provide an opportunity to the faculty and students to break free from mechanical, examination-driven classes. But it is clear that the university authorities are ready to sacrifice them at the very first provocation.

The quality of the corporate life of a university is something we need to think about. When unions of teachers and non-teaching staff members turn against their own colleagues, it gives a signal to other teachers that they cannot be adventurous and would be left alone to fight their battle. The behaviour of the ABVP, in such cases, has been
uniform. Instead of engaging intellectually with its ideological opponents, its members have indulged in threats, physical attacks, destruction of public property and public agitation. One expects student organisations to promote a culture of dialogue. It is disappointing to see some of them using their physical prowess and proximity to power to make their point.

The role of the Hindi media in the JNVU and other such cases has been dangerous. It does not engage in a balanced reporting of the facts. A team from the editors’ guild, which investigated Hindi media’s role in the Ram Janmabhoomi agitation, found that it has turned into a propaganda machine for Hindu right-wing politics. The reader and viewer solely dependent on Hindi media are not only malnourished, they are being fed intoxicants in the name of news and opinion.

The cultural life of what is known as the Hindi heartland is becoming dangerously narrow. This is definitely a loss for teachers, but more so for young minds. As socioloist Satish Deshpande argues, universities are the only spaces, in our otherwise highly segregated and hierarchical society, where the youth get a chance to participate in intellectual discourse in an egalitarian manner. This is an opportunity for them to experience a freedom which is unavailable in wider society. This applies especially to first-generation college and university goers.

To restrict or close down such spaces is to deprive them of their only source of intellectual and cultural nourishment. Here, they learn the art of dealing with differences and the art of persuasion. When a Rajshree Ranawat organises such a conference, or a Nivedita Menon speaks in it, they do not do so merely to exercise their right to free speech, but more out of their sense of responsibility towards the youth. They are being told that this is a soldierly duty, fraught with real risk, that they have been in the line of fire from the enemies of intellect, who, by being so, become enemies of equality, freedom and humanity.

The writer teaches at Delhi University

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: February 10, 2017 12:00 am
  1. R
    raj
    Feb 10, 2017 at 7:38 am
    I always wonder how talking of disintegrating India is an 'intellectual debate' and talking of integrating the country is 'communal' or 'too nationalistic'. These so-called intellectuals lecture from the comforts drawn from exchequer's money and are far removed from ground realities. Actually, they need to be more open minded.
    Reply
    1. A
      Anil
      Feb 10, 2017 at 11:26 am
      Free voice of those who want to disintegrate this country,at least u should not say like this. What treatment u have given to Kashmiri Pandits is well known.Jis Thalia mein khatey ho osi mein chaid karte ho.
      Reply
      1. K
        K SHESHU
        Feb 10, 2017 at 2:13 pm
        Education instutions are becoming marauding grounds of fascists parties and their affiliates
        Reply
        1. A
          Ajay G
          Feb 10, 2017 at 5:18 am
          No sooner places of academics are devoid of criticism and debate, they become houses of sycophancy and intolerance. lt;br/gt; lt;br/gt;Universities have inner strength to discard what is noy true and not worth it. Why then some Menon and Ranawat be made some celebrity !!! Possibly more people know about them now and may give them an ear.
          Reply
          1. A
            Ajay kranthi
            Feb 10, 2017 at 8:30 am
            Exactly..!!
            Reply
            1. L
              Lukman
              Feb 10, 2017 at 1:57 pm
              Prof Apoorvanand has never written about choking of non-leftist point of view from social science departments at universities. He has never written against the leftist student unions using physical abuse to block presentation of a non-left narrative in JNU, in Calcutta or elsewhere. The result is loss of credibility, when he writes about the episode of JNVU.
              Reply
              1. K
                Kris
                Feb 10, 2017 at 8:04 pm
                If anybody heard this woman speaks against India no self respecting Indian could aloow her to speak at any function. It is indeed surprising how JNU has produced so many antinationals as teachers at the tax payers' expense. If this woman or any anti nationals donning the role as teachers likes to work against the national interest, they should resign from JNU and should be ready to face public wrath wherever they do their activities. She is another Arunthati Roy and other communists who are known anti nationals.
                Reply
                1. G
                  Gaekwad
                  Feb 10, 2017 at 1:02 pm
                  Actually they became leaders (but certainly not of the world) because Americans believed that Trump will make America great again and Modiji could convince much of 39% Indians that they will have Rs 15 lacs in their account which he would retrieve from the corrupt Congress. He could neither prove Congress's corruption or deposit the promised Rs 15 lacs. Even Charles Ponzi became a billionaire, (being a billionaire epitomises success for bhakts), but eventually law did catch up wih him. Till Ponzi's fraud was discovered he was hailed by the people like you.
                  Reply
                  1. A
                    ansuman
                    Feb 10, 2017 at 11:49 pm
                    just wait 5 years and you will change too.
                    Reply
                    1. A
                      ansuman
                      Feb 10, 2017 at 10:40 am
                      wake up .
                      Reply
                      1. A
                        ansuman
                        Feb 10, 2017 at 10:45 am
                        why should we waste our time -with you traitors.
                        Reply
                        1. V
                          vijay
                          Feb 10, 2017 at 4:41 pm
                          We indians are a highly strung bunch of people who with very little tolerance to ideas that are at odds with their own. The very fact that we live in democracy gives us the right to speak our mind. If we transgress the laws of the land by doing so then the concerned branch of our democracy will put it right. There is no point in people taking a holier than though atude and hyperventilating about it.
                          Reply
                          1. B
                            Babu Gupta
                            Feb 10, 2017 at 12:53 pm
                            The anti national leftists are still hiding in places like termite and needs to be exterminated. JNU is one such place - where Afzal Guru is a hero ( a convicted terrorist involved in attack on India's Parliament). Nivedita Menon is part of JNU gang with sloganeering..Hindustan ke Tukde..Tukde.
                            Reply
                            1. B
                              bmniac
                              Feb 13, 2017 at 4:00 am
                              I am not a BJP person but these people are selective in their indignation.As teachers they tell the students what to think instead of opening their minds to study and analyse and arrive at what is true. I would like to see a good study of the demise of forests in Kerala Perpetrated by the Christians and isted by the secular Governments. Or an unbiased history of the Mappilla rebellion and the role of the Congress leaders!
                              Reply
                              1. B
                                bmniac
                                Feb 13, 2017 at 4:02 am
                                You write "socioloist Satish Deshpande" Pray what is that? Another slipshod teacher?
                                Reply
                                1. D
                                  Dr B
                                  Feb 10, 2017 at 6:08 am
                                  Right to speech is different thing and to talk against the integrity of country and to provokelt;br/gt;Kasmiri peoples to destabilize the states law and order situation is the anti national activity. Hence we have strong belief that Maximum professors of JUN belonging to English, History, social science departments are Anti nationals.
                                  Reply
                                  1. H
                                    hotwashabi
                                    Feb 10, 2017 at 12:31 pm
                                    Abeie Apoorvanand, left politics is not the only student politics and people like lt;br/gt;Nivedita Menon are cut off from reality. You guys should be happy that you got your employment based on your left party politics networking, so nororiously known in the DU and JNU otherwise you guys have no academic credentials.
                                    Reply
                                    1. M
                                      Mercury
                                      Feb 10, 2017 at 11:24 am
                                      And yes , 60 years of "right influenced cooperative" experiment of "Amul milk marketing federation" and "shree mahila griha udyog (lijjat)" has made a huge impact . Savvy ?
                                      Reply
                                      1. D
                                        DA
                                        Feb 10, 2017 at 5:26 am
                                        "The role of the Hindi media in the JNVU and other such cases has been dangerous. "lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Yeah right. That sounds like a clarion call to freedom of speech. Don't like what you hear in the media - muzzle it!lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Typical communist. Will contradict the headline of his article by the third paragraph. lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Mere bhai confused-aatma. Go teach whatever drivel you do to the IAS aspirants in your university. We have better things to do, and indeed even more sophisticated propaa.
                                        Reply
                                        1. D
                                          DA
                                          Feb 10, 2017 at 5:23 am
                                          The author has forgotten the purge of all academics that would not swear allegiance to the communist manifesto in the 60s and 70s. This is just desserts. lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Get off government payroll and then indulge in your propaa. My tax many does not pay for your upkeep so you could propagate your hateful agenda against Hindus.
                                          Reply
                                          1. H
                                            Haimeri Democracy
                                            Feb 10, 2017 at 9:32 am
                                            You can be "respectful". You ought to expect others to not reciprocate. That is our present culture of "Nationalism" and "Pride'.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments