Time for reflection, fellow doctors

The medical sector needs to think about why it is seen in poor light — by patients and government.

Written by Vikram Patel | Published:June 10, 2017 12:04 am
Indian Medical Association, medical sector, IMA, IMA protest, IMA doctor protest, IMA strike, indian express news, opinion The IMA is absolutely right in demanding action to stop violence against physicians. (Representational image)

Members of the Indian Medical Association (IMA), the nation’s largest professional society of medical practitioners, marched in New Delhi earlier this week to signal their protest on a range of issues concerning the profession. Every state branch was instructed to mobilise at least 1 per cent of its membership, including medical students, and every doctor in India was exhorted to participate in a “pen down” strike (implying that no prescriptions would be signed) while the “satyagraha” walk was in progress. Symbolically, the programme began at Raj Ghat; it was estimated that about 10,000 doctors took to the streets.

The IMA president justified this national action on account of the “injustices” meted out to the medical profession, exemplified by increasing instances of violence against physicians, the growing number of cases of criminal prosecution against physicians, the imposition of bills to regulate hospitals and nursing homes, and the “trampling” of the prescription rights of doctors consequent to the government’s diktat to use generic medication. He has been quoted to say that “there is absolutely no end to the injustice being heaped upon the medical fraternity and this noble profession”.

The IMA is absolutely right in demanding action to stop violence against physicians. This violence is consistent with the growing trend of vigilantism in India, leading bigots to murder those who are perceived to be eating beef, or the lynching of suspected thieves, substituting the due process of the law with criminal acts.

I do hope, however, that this national action also offers an opportunity for my fellow physicians to reflect on the reasons why there is rising anger, both in the community and amongst policymakers, which leads to the kinds of actions the profession is concerned about. If indeed we are a noble profession, why do our patients increasingly despise us to the extent that they beat us up? Why does the government implement policies, including disbanding the Medical Council of India, which has been denounced by the courts for its failure to regulate medical education and practice, which seemingly reduce the dignity and autonomy of the profession? Why are cases of malpractice and negligence on the rise? Surely these are symptoms of a serious trust deficit between the profession and the people of this country.

Most people, including most physicians, know exactly what I am referring to by the trust deficit. More than a decade ago, Transparency International published a report based on a survey of 5,000 Indians, which identified corruption in the health service as having the most impact on the people of this country, second only to the police. Shockingly, the report observed that “the key actors leading to corruption in this sector across zones are allegedly doctors followed closely by hospital staff”. Kickbacks for unnecessary clinical tests or referrals,
an irrational use of medical procedures for commercial gain, illegal payments from corporations in return for prescribing their over-priced products, and bribes for obtaining health care services are everyday examples, but this corruption now extends to even more disturbing instances of criminal acts, such as collusion with sex-determination and the illegal organ trade.

While enriching a few, these practices have had profound economic consequences, in particular for the poor. Unsurprisingly, while healthcare in most countries is viewed as a key strategy to enable people to rise out of poverty, healthcare in India is the leading cause of impoverishment.

And, to a large extent, the medical profession remained a mute spectator to this denigration of medicine’s basic values, reinforcing beliefs that the profession only responds collectively for its own interests.

My fellow physicians, I believe, that if we really wish to regain our reputation as the noble profession and be trusted by our people, we will need to radically re-imagine our way of practicing medicine, to become genuine guardians of the health of Indians. We will need to play an active role in addressing the shameful observation that India has, for a country with its economic and health resources, the worst health indicators in the world.

To do this, we will need to restate our commitment to evidence-based medicine, which champions the use of affordable and effective treatments through a universal health care system. We will need to actively cooperate with the government as it implements its progressive National Health Policy, and become an indispensable partner of the movement that is so urgently needed to repair our broken health care system. We should be advocating for and celebrating efforts to reduce health care costs. We should stand in solidarity with our people to hold the government and the private sector accountable when they fall short of their responsibilities.

When the government insists on our using generic medicines, instead of viewing this as an intrusion into the privileged relationship we enjoy with our patients, we should demand action to assure the quality of these medicines and ensure that the cheapest generic drugs are sold by chemists — we should welcome the government’s initiatives to strengthen the oversight of medical education and our own clinical practice, for we have miserably failed to do so ourselves.

And, most of all, let us stop serving the interests of our corporate masters, from the hospital chains which have commodified the most sacred aspects of our profession and our humanity, to the pharmaceutical and biomedical device industries, to which we have sold our souls for trinkets of gold.

So, as my fellow physicians reflect on the reasons why some of us marched through the capital, I hope we will also take a moment to question why the medical profession has plunged from being the guardian of people’s health to demanding protection from the people.

The writer is a professor at Harvard Medical School and at the Public Health Foundation of India

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    A Banerjee
    Aug 15, 2017 at 12:59 pm
    A newspaper today carried on its front page a news item -"Pvt practice rampant in BRD:sacked doc". A search in the net shows that this has been blacked out. Whatever be the background to this blacking out, there is no doubt that the long pervading massive corruption at all levels in state for decades still reigns supreme and no dent has been made by the Yogi govt in this regard. To be frank, Yogi and Siddarthnath Singh (following his g father, the great Lal Bahadur Shastri) should have resigned.
    Reply
    1. R
      Rajesh kashyap shimla
      Jun 11, 2017 at 9:26 am
      The solution to all the questions is Health information system. We should have strong health information where anyone or every one knows that what has been prescribed by whom and when. It should be mandatory to register all the patients through this system. Unfortunately government is delaying it unnecessarily. We should press upon the union government to bring the bill to have HIMS.
      Reply
      1. A
        asad alam
        Jun 10, 2017 at 11:22 pm
        raise the ry of intern to at least 30000.and that of junior residents to at least 120000 otherwise no one will be left in public sector.believe me
        Reply
        1. D
          Dr. Neeraj Sood
          Jun 10, 2017 at 10:37 pm
          You have the benefit of an observer who has seen both sides of the coin.It sickens me no end that incentives and commissions are rampant even now after the Demobilisation and G.P.s consider it their birth-right to demand consideration for referrals spear headed by all the RMPS masquandering as doctors. In every nook & corner are self styled Doctors whose basic degree can range from electro Homeopathy Unani Reiki Ayurveda or any number of pathies which are practiced with impunity and nearly all prescribe Allopathic medicines without being Qualified to do so Then there are chemists on every street who have bought pharmacy diploma from someone and hung in their shops and nut only sell medicines but prescribe these without any legal authority to do so. You have aptly described the malady but have stopped short of readily implementable measures to overcome all the corruption & malpractice. Your Suggestions invited I will prescribe some in next mail
          Reply
          1. M
            M. C.
            Jun 10, 2017 at 10:15 pm
            It is also true. "Child has to CRY, to get the mother's MILK" Thus this Aandolan for the Govt.
            Reply
            1. M
              M. C.
              Jun 10, 2017 at 10:07 pm
              I feel if there is some corruption in medical fraternity, it should not be there at all. But at the same time I would like to say, the most important reasons for it r :- 1.There is over all acute shortage of medical personal/ doctors( I mean the well qualified. hard working & the honest doctors) 2. Doctors r not getting the optimal returns even for their hard & sinceare work & r not able maintain their reasonable standard, for which they have worked hard & have sacrificed their w life. 3.if u consider that the doctors r the guardian of public , then public should also consider,doctors as their guardians & should give proper respects to them & take their guidance & advises with due respect & with full faith. As Dr's r always treating their patients to the best of their ability & the aim is always to cure the patient as far as possible.when a dr prescribe, the medicine/ treatment, he/she always prey to God by writing first letter as prayer, (RX i.e. Thou take the Pt &cure him.
              Reply
              1. A
                asad alam
                Jun 10, 2017 at 8:24 pm
                Mr patel earns a ry of 16789000 rupees per year at harvard.and he dictates indian doctors to not commercialize this or that.I want to ask him why he left india if he wanted to serve the country.an intern in india gets 15000 rupees per month.what kind of humanity is this if not an outright exploitation.Big businessmen and Mafia can commercialize everything.The government begs them to create jobs.But a doctor after 10 years of rigorous study and spending lakhs should not take his due fees.Wow mr.harvard. Why don't u ask the government to raise the ry of medical professors in india to your ry level.Be honest.
                Reply
                1. P
                  Pat
                  Jun 11, 2017 at 9:39 pm
                  FYI, Dr. Patel was born in U.K. And was educated there. You need to get your facts in order. Comparing incomes across countries does not make a case for corruption among Indian doctors.
                  Reply
                  1. P
                    Pat
                    Jun 11, 2017 at 9:51 pm
                    Sorry, he was born in India. My error.
                    Reply
                  2. T
                    Tellitasitis
                    Jun 10, 2017 at 7:18 pm
                    Thank you Dr Vikram Patel for an honest essment of the state of healthcare in India, and asking the medical profession to look inward before blaming others.
                    Reply
                    1. Load More Comments