The other, the enemy

Message from Gujarat elections: The Muslim is more alone than ever before.

Written by Abdul Khaliq | Published: December 27, 2017 12:19 am
 The Other, The Enemy According to the reigning electoral arithmetic, to woo the Muslim is to court disaster. (Photo: Reuters)

Prime Minister Narendra Modi in his victory speech justifiably pronounced that voters in the Gujarat election emphatically rejected the poison of caste. But he studiously skirted mention of the cancer of communal identity politics and religiosity that was masterfully deployed by the BJP and clumsily imitated by the Congress. While the BJP dragged the Muslim community into the electoral arc lights with loaded references to Aurangzeb and “Miyan” Ahmed Patel as a Pakistan-inspired Congress CM candidate, the Congress flaunted its “Hinduness” even as it concealed its dubious concern for Muslims. According to the reigning electoral arithmetic, to woo the Muslim is to court disaster. The Muslim is more alone than ever before.

The killing of Afrazul for being Muslim and the celebratory messages, donations and marches in support of the killer that followed are testament to a social consciousness that perceives the Muslim as the enemy, not just the “other”. A friend who knows Gujarat well, observed much before the election results that despite the enormous hardships caused by demonetisation, GST and spiralling prices, people still repose faith in the BJP as they believe that it is the only party that can deal effectively with the “Muslim menace”. Hate is the most powerful human emotion and also the most resilient. The spectres of Babri Masjid, 2002 and, dare I say, Muslim historical figures hang heavy over us. In today’s India, you cannot be any leader but only a Hindu leader to be acceptable.

A yogi who publicly announced that he will not stop till he turns India into a Hindu rashtra is now the UP chief minister. In his watch, state and religion have congealed into one. He sees no contradiction in using state funds for a Lord Ram statue or sanctioning a Rs one lakh subsidy for every pilgrim on the Kailash Mansarovar yatra even while opposing the Haj subsidy. Despite swearing allegiance to the Constitution, he has recently dismissed secularism as “the biggest lie told since Independence that has damaged the nation”. In his limited understanding, secularism is equated with minority appeasement (a cruel joke considering that, despite all the ministrations of successive governments, Muslims are at par with Dalits in almost every human development index).

Our claim to being a society fostering social and cultural heterogeneity is a sham. So is our long-cherished view of ourselves as embodying tolerance. We are in the grip of a predatory nationalism that is majoritarian in its sensibilities and brazenly anti-Muslim. A burgeoning club of anti-minority ultra-nationalists have become arbiters of what is socially acceptable and for them issues of justice and freedom are of no consequence. The gau rakshaks, the Hindu Yuva Vahini, the love jihad vigilante squads are their malevolent foot soldiers.

The good Samaritans on the Karavan-e-Mohabbat, a laudable joint initiative of about 50 organisations which recently traveled to the sites of lynchings across eight states to express solidarity with the victims were stunned by the implacable hatred and absence of compassion for the victims they witnessed. They have sorrowfully concluded that ours is a republic of hate.The most chilling finding of those who accompanied the Karavan was that, in almost all cases of lynching, the police had registered criminal cases against the victims and treated the accused leniently, not opposing their bail. The Rajasthan government recently issued directives to students and teachers of Jaipur to visit a “spiritual” fair to learn, inter alia, about love jihad and Christian conspiracies. The literature included a “love jihad rate card” listing the different sums a Muslim man stands to earn for converting girls from different regions. Even the Supreme Court has, time and again, shown an inclination to subordinate issues of justice to majoritarian aspirations in order “to satisfy the collective conscience of the nation”. The fight against terrorism is being systematically used to disrupt the lives of ordinary Muslims. A case in point is Hadiya’s sorry plight which has been precipitated by the justice system pandering to the bogey of love jihad terrorism, thereby stalling a young woman’s basic freedom to choose her religion and her mate.

The one indubitable take away from the Gujarat election is that the hope-inspiring sabka saath sabka vikas slogan has been emptied of all meaning. There is now no denying the truth in the recent observation of a professor and RSS ideologue that Hindutva is the nation’s preferred ideology as it is “compatible with the common wisdom of the Indian masses”. Although not officially proclaimed, the Hindu rashtra is already upon us. And to hell with the minorities.

The writer,a former civil servant, is secretary general of Lok Janshakti Party. Views are personal.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. Studious Z Al
    Dec 28, 2017 at 12:26 am
    Muslims are killing Muslims, Muslims are enemies of muslims. A social gattoes which get most tortured become a highest power in later time for example Jewish people.
    (1)(1)
    Reply
    1. Babu Indian
      Dec 27, 2017 at 11:57 pm
      Point to ponder : muslims have driven out Hindus from Pak/Bangla territory . In India muslims have grown to almost 20 percent by now . Muslim population is still growing at a faster rate than Hindus ( in fact middle class Hindu population will massively slow down due to the same cause as certain other populations like Europe, Japan ) . India is the last refuge of remaining Hindus . I predict ( as a educated person ) 30 years from now another civil wear will happen in India , and it will be tragic and brutal one . Only solution to avoid it is to totally bannnish islam from the lives of the INDIAN muslims in india and make them Hindu .
      (7)(8)
      Reply
      1. Studious Z Al
        Dec 28, 2017 at 12:25 am
        Muslims are killing Muslims, Muslims are enemies of muslims. A social gattoes which get most tortured become a highest power in later time for example Jewish people.
        (0)(0)
        Reply
      2. C
        CBA
        Dec 27, 2017 at 11:46 pm
        Mr. nonsense Abdul Khaliq, why India shall not be a Hindu Rastra. India-Pak was divided according to two nations theory. If Pakistan could be a Muslim could be Muslim country, what is the barrier for India to be Hindu Rastra. 23 percent Hindus in Pakistan at 1947 have been ousted/killed/converted by force to Islam but 6 percent Muslims in India in 1947 have been increased to 14.5 percent or may be more. Hindus must be tolerant but Muslims are traditionally intolerant to other religions. These should not happen in present India, Mr. cunning Abdul Khaliq.
        (9)(6)
        Reply
        1. Studious Z Al
          Dec 28, 2017 at 12:25 am
          Muslims are killing Muslims, Muslims are enemies of muslims. A social gattoes which get most tortured become a highest power in later time for example Jewish people.
          (0)(1)
          Reply
        2. Setty Pendakur
          Dec 27, 2017 at 10:35 pm
          The governments at all levels, have no business subsidizing, religious travel Religion should be personal and "state sponsored". The tragedy of India is that "every thing is caste based"...... from birth to death, schooling, jobs, promotions, encompassing all wealth..... long away to towards a totally merit based society. Yet, wonder of India is that it excels in many ways and in many places. Have a great year, every one...
          (3)(4)
          Reply
          1. Vikram At
            Dec 27, 2017 at 10:20 pm
            i dont like culling of humans, Rohingya way is more human approach, think 20 years from now is more appropriate time, when world will be free from oil producing power, all left overs should be forced or encouraged to migrate to saudi.
            (4)(5)
            Reply
            1. Studious Z Al
              Dec 28, 2017 at 12:26 am
              Muslims are killing Muslims, Muslims are enemies of muslims. A social gattoes which get most tortured become a highest power in later time for example Jewish people.
              (0)(1)
              Reply
            2. Load More Comments