Like a bee gathers honey

GST will reset the basic rules of taxation. It is an illustration of PM Modi’s transformative reforms. Modi is on a transformative agenda, the fruits of which will be borne by this nation in a few years’ time. He is setting India’s basics right with a futuristic vision.

Written by Ram Madhav | Updated: July 4, 2017 8:28 pm
gst, narendra modi, gst impact, goods and services tax, modi economic reform, indian express news The PM has quoted Chanakya in his speech of June 30. What Chanakya said, and what Bhishma was supposed to have told Yudhishthira in Shanti Parva, explaining Raj Dharma, was that a government should collect taxes in the manner a honeybee collects honey from the flowers. (Illustration: C R Sasikumar)

Behind every successful man there is a woman, thus goes a saying. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has made a Modified version of it by almost saying that “behind every corrupt person there is a financial advisor”.

“These thieves, robbers and companies went to some economic doctor for sure. Shouldn’t they have identified such (tax evaders) people? Shouldn’t such people within your community, who helped evaders, be identified and moved to the sidelines?” the prime minister was reported to have confronted the community of chartered accountants during his address to the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India a few days ago.

Post demonetisation, there were murmurs that some unscrupulous elements in the accountant fraternity were making a quick buck by helping get the illegal wealth of many legalised. Nobody had the guts to talk about it openly. But the prime minister minced no words.

He called upon the chartered accountants to shoulder the responsibility for bringing in economic transparency and discipline. In fact, his entire address demonstrated his courage and determination to take on the economic offenders, however big and mighty they may be. His address has stirred the conscience of every right thinking Indian. One chief minister sent me a message after listening to the PM’s address that summed up the sentiments appropriately: “I really liked our PM’s speech delivered at chartered accountants day. Proud to be a citizen under his leadership”.

If there is one significant difference that needs to be highlighted about the three years of this government, it is this courage and boldness. Therein lies the difference between reform and transformation. Reform is a halfhearted attempt at tinkering with the existing system by timid leaders to alleviate the intensity and magnitude of the malice. But bold leaders do not talk about alleviation, about trying “to make the problem less severe”.

Their vision, and mission, is to annihilate, to completely root out the problem. That is called transformation. For the first time, we have heard a prime minister talking about not just “poverty alleviation” but the complete eradication of poverty. India is already called a “middle income” economy. Modi’s agenda is to ensure that nobody in the country shall be poor. Similarly, he called for eradication of homelessness by the year 2022. These are very courageous and ambitious targets. But that is Modi’s way.

The prime minister has introduced us to a transformative era in our politics. A transformative agenda is not easy, and many a time, it is not popular. Take the case of demonetisation. To take on the warlords of the parallel economy through one late evening action involved huge political, if not personal, risks. Similarly, to go after the hoarders of black money, many of whom will probably be proxies for politicians, and taking the battle right up to Switzerland, required massive courage and determination.

But then, it has become the hallmark of the Modi regime in the last three years. Modi is on a transformative agenda, the fruits of which will be borne by this nation in a few years’ time. He is setting India’s basics right with a futuristic vision. As he himself indicated at the launch of the GST at midnight on June 30, the country might need to take its time to adjust to the new reality. His reference to spectacles with new numbers is advice to countrymen to try and adjust to the new agenda rather than curse it.

The Goods and Services Tax falls in this category of bold and transformative reforms. Countrymen are used to governments’ economic agendas that yield them something or the other. But certain transformative agendas need not necessarily “give” them something. They are meant to set new basics in place. The GST is one such agenda whose objective is to transform the basics of our tax regime.

The PM has quoted Chanakya in his speech of June 30. What Chanakya said, and what Bhishma was supposed to have told Yudhishthira in Shanti Parva, explaining Raj Dharma, was that a government should collect taxes in the manner a honeybee collects honey from the flowers. In fact, Chanakya declared that a kingdom whose kings are greedy is not worth living in. But that has been our experience in all these decades. Multiple and complex tax regimes have plagued our system.

The prime minister has rightly quoted Albert Einstein who said “The hardest thing in the world to understand is income tax”. Not just he, many have talked about the ills of tax regimes. American humorist and columnist Will Rogers had once famously commented that: “The difference between death and taxes is, death doesn’t get worse every time Congress meets”.

The GST is one reform that is expected to put an end to this tax terror. As the PM himself described it, it is a simple tax regime. The finance ministry has captured it aptly in the slogan “One Nation One Tax”. It is designed in a manner that it would be a win-win regime for all stakeholders, including investors, businessmen and consumers.

It called for a celebration for more than one reason. Firstly, to have one tax structure for the entire country calls for celebration. Also to be celebrated is the fact that our purchase orders entail only one fixed tax now, instead of the multiple taxes we used to end up paying. It is unfortunate that some parties in the Opposition have chosen to not participate in the event marking its launch.

But it is not just about celebration. It is about entering into a new system. We are more used to tinkering than a comprehensive systemic transformation. The Goods and Services Tax regime should be seen as another bold midnight decision of PM Modi’s government aimed at grassroots transformation. No transformation is painless. But the fruit of these agendas shall be sweet.

The writer is national general secretary, BJP, and director, India Foundation

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. R
    rishi
    Jul 5, 2017 at 2:37 am
    Articles like this one by Mr. Madhav do great justice to the transformatory process of our economic systems triggered by a nationalism-driven honesty in NDA-Govt.'s policies.....the transformations of this nature were long due but little thought of in the lost 65yrs or so when the nation moved at a snails's pace in colonial-congress' s wilful misrule while many other countries moved forward in leaps and bounds.
    Reply
    1. R
      rishi
      Jul 5, 2017 at 2:29 am
      this is where the core difference in policy: BJP seeks to to enrich the Govt. which in turn leads to greater public-spending triggering a chain of economic growth processes......contrast this to a shamelesss congress "always" sought to enrich itself....all policies were designed to encourage people, individuals to business houses, public-sector en ies to private corporates..... to resort to illegitimate gratification of enforcement agencies for "easy life of easy money" culturally....and thus it became a norm that to survive in India , you have to be willing to get corrupt by actually not be willing to either pay taxes nor meet compliances and govt. regulation".....the illegal gratification was naturally shared by everyone from the peon to the president all of whom perpetrated the "(corruption)chalta hai" culture that was leading an entire Nation to "dishonesty and corruption in their everyday lives"....one Modi could transform so much....I vision a billion modis on the rise now.
      Reply
      1. K
        Kabir
        Jul 5, 2017 at 1:05 am
        Now this person with a fake name now faking to be tax expert too?
        Reply
        1. S
          sunny
          Jul 4, 2017 at 8:45 pm
          Management quality of BJP leaders are superb, they were dead against GST when they sit in opposition now------
          Reply
          1. K
            Kuldeep Saxena
            Jul 4, 2017 at 8:10 pm
            It is a nice article by Mr. Madhav yes we do understand and appreciate the step of demonetization and now the second one implementing GST. but the basic teething problems still prevail. It is very clear that when we opt for a new system there are practical problem and at times we had been magnifying them more than the actual problem as we are not familiar with the system and norms. Definitely we need to educate both consumers, manufactures, traders and our CA's to work on little faster as we need to ensure the exploitation. There has been few commodities like Petrol, Hard Drinks and few more in addition to some more commodities which definitely needs to work on. Another thing is that since lack of Knowledge there may be exploitation by the business communities. Let us see and watch.
            Reply
            1. S
              Sheshu
              Jul 4, 2017 at 7:51 pm
              It is a tool to implemet political oppirtunism
              Reply
              1. B
                Bill Fotsch
                Jul 4, 2017 at 7:30 pm
                Best wishes to Mr. Modi for rooting out tax corruption in India by challenging accountants and ins uting a new, simplified tax structure. The corrupt vested interests will surely challenge him. Should he succeed, I hope Mr. Modi would spend some time advising US lawmakers and voters on how to do the same in the US. There is a reason politicians in the US are very wealthy, and it's not public service.
                Reply
                1. B
                  Barb Dewyre
                  Jul 4, 2017 at 7:25 pm
                  Bootlicker, instead of talking in cliches, tell us how much money was deposited in the demonetization exercise? How much of it was black money? How much did the public withdraw subsequently? Nitin Ghadkari said that about 150 countries in the world had implemented GST. Amit Shah said that there were more lynchings in the UPA regime. Modi said that this was the first time India had conducted surgical strikes which the then army chief contradicted. How many lies will you feed the nation? By repeating the same lies over and over again they do not become truths! And the only persons believing them are you yourselves.
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments