Fifth column: Sonia’s loving message

So fascinated was I by Sonia’s Bharatiyata appeal that I watched it more than once in Hindi and in English and longer I watched, the more I saw a case for slander.

Written by Tavleen Singh | Updated: April 21, 2014 9:18 am

Halfway through this endless election if it were not clear that Narendra Modi leads the race, he may have seriously considered suing Sonia Gandhi for her recent TV appeal. In her first direct address to the nation in a decade of being India’s de facto prime minister, she accused Modi of trying to break the country. She said, in so many words, that the choice before voters in this election was between “Bharatiyata” and a “vision clouded with hatred and falsehoods… that will drive India to ruination”.

So fascinated was I by Shrimati Sonia’s Bharatiyata appeal that I watched it more than once in Hindi and in English and the longer I watched, the more I saw a case for slander. It reminded me of Rajiv Gandhi’s speeches during the 1984 election campaign when he accused the opposition parties of treason because of their alliance with the Akali Dal. In those long ago times, the Election Commission was feeble and there was no Code of Conduct; so he got away with it, but it surprises me that nobody in the Bharatiya Janata Party has complained yet about their prime ministerial candidate being charged with trying to destroy India. What has Modi said so far that can be construed as spreading hatred?

His campaign has talked about taking India in a new economic direction with “minimum government, maximum governance”. He has talked about making India a rich and prosperous country by creating jobs for the youth and investing in education and healthcare. On the Hindu-Muslim front, he has urged both Hindus and Muslims to fight poverty and not each other. So whoever wrote Madame’s appeal can be taken to court for spreading falsehoods.

As someone who is very keen on Bharatiyata, I consider it my duty as a Bharatiya to point out that the Congress party has caused more damage to it since 1947 than almost anyone else. In the name of socialism, magnificent palaces, forts and ancient temples have been allowed to decay. Soniaji, please take a boat ride on the Ganga when you go to campaign against Modi and you will see the ruins of our oldest city. And while you are about it, notice what has happened to our most sacred river.

If ‘socialist’ values have caused the neglect of old monuments and museums, ‘secular’ values have made it impossible for Indian children to learn about their own country in state schools. What they are taught about India’s ancient civilisation would fit on a postage stamp. So they usually leave school imbued with more awe of McDonalds and Hollywood than any aspect of their own heritage.

Two other things in Soniaji’s appeal caught my attention. She said Congress had respect for democratic institutions (they do not), without noticing that she has personally diminished the prime minister’s office to dwarf size. Sanjay Baru’s excellent new book confirms this, but in dusty villages and shabby small towns during this election campaign, I have met ordinary, semi-literate Indians who complain that the prime minister has not been allowed to be a leader.

They use mean words to describe the good doctor’s status. So Soniaji, you have some nerve when you talk about respecting “the institutions of democracy”. And, even more of a nerve when you say that you believe that power “should not be the preserve of a select few”.

Have you not noticed that the Congress Party under your leadership has been reduced to a family firm? Have you not noticed that nearly all your younger MPs are in the Lok Sabha because they had a Mummy or Daddy who bequeathed them a parliamentary constituency as if it were just a family estate? Have you not noticed that the main reason why your son is Managing Director today of the family firm is because he is your son? So where are those with whom you believe you have shared power?

India’s tragedy is that it is today a country in which too much political power is in the hands of too few people and it is because of this that voters are looking for change this time. It is the reason why a new political party could get where it has in so short a time and it could be the reason why Narendra Modi could soon become India’s prime minister.

Ordinary Indians are so impatient for change that the word I have come to identify this election most with is parivartan. I have heard it so often on my travels that it rings constantly in my ears. When I ask people why they want to vote for Modi they nearly always say that it is because they want India to become a developed country and they think he can make this happen. So where did you hear this talk of hatred?

Follow Tavleen Singh on Twitter @ tavleen_singh

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: April 20, 2014 12:08 am
  1. B
    binnysingh
    Jul 13, 2014 at 4:11 pm
    We were in Jalgaon few weeks ago. It was such a sorry sight with people sitting on the side walk with dabba's. No toilets. What about the ladies how do they manage? Where do they go? This is what we get after 65 years of independence and Congress rule. Just the basic necessities are not available for these folks.
    Reply
    1. P
      Prue88
      Apr 30, 2014 at 5:32 am
      I have read the book by Sanjaya Baru and I am happy and thankful that he defended Dr. Manmohan Singh and exposed hi Parivar. He is right in saying that PM is the leader of the country, does not matter what party he/she belongs to. But he is only mam who defended Dr. Singh. But I am not setting my heart or mind on Modi. He is equally corrupt and racist. I cannot understand why Tavleen Singh does not get that.
      Reply
      1. A
        Ajithkumar Ajithkumar
        Apr 21, 2014 at 10:45 am
        You hit the nail on its head.. Tavleen singh is the best columnist at the moment, not because she supports modi, but because of the issues she rises.. The education system should be changed.. we need a system, which teaches our kid about our heritage our achievements.. India for the most part of written history has been the pinnacle of architecture, technology, medicine, science and philosophy.. people all around the world traveled to India to learn stuff.. Today the western world is teaching us lifestyle and hygiene.. just think about Mohenjadaro which was 2500 years old with underground drainage and well built structures with everyone giving due importance for hygiene. We just have a single paragraph about the greatest kings of the world like Raja Raja Chola or Rajendra chola.. we don't have any mention about the cholas victory over malaysia, indonesia, combodia and so on.. The world's largest temple Angorwat was built by a chola empire and we read this from books written by French authors and not through our text books.. these psuedo intellectuals, left liberals and socialists categorically destro our culture and our education system..Thanks to Tavleen for raising these issues..
        Reply
        1. S
          Sharman
          Apr 30, 2014 at 10:30 pm
          Sonia has made mockery of the democratic system. It is the time she should be shown door for ever.
          Reply
          1. B
            Bhawani
            Apr 21, 2014 at 3:30 am
            Tavleen Singh at its best, as always!!
            Reply
            1. C
              Chaithra NB
              Apr 20, 2014 at 5:07 pm
              Nice article, exposed optimistic and pessimistic politics (Personalities)
              Reply
              1. L
                Lakshmi Chatti
                Apr 21, 2014 at 10:36 am
                The article is thought provoking.This article provided me with immense satisfaction and pleasure.
                Reply
                1. K
                  kvl
                  Apr 21, 2014 at 6:07 am
                  Madam, your article prompted me to write this.Day- in and day out our secular leaders are accusing ,insulting Modi. He stood unfazed ,enduring this onslaught. that is his generosity.now sonia blaming Modi that he divides the nation whereas Congress unites. forgetting that she is the main lady to divide Andhrapradesh which is otherwise a prosperous state.A fear psychosis created by repeating always about 2002 riots at this election time and even foreign countries papers also repeating the same news. but not disclosing what led to the riots.That means Hindus are also not safe in their own country.To safe guard their country is most important for any Nation.Also so much conversions are taking place (invisible).worrisome to Nationlists. British tried and now this is continuing silently.hope at least my comment will find place in IE, thanking you
                  Reply
                  1. M
                    Mahen
                    Apr 21, 2014 at 10:51 am
                    truth and facts
                    Reply
                    1. P
                      Pradip Bhattacharya
                      Apr 20, 2014 at 3:16 pm
                      Tavleen Singhji, my hats off to you for writing truth so candidly.
                      Reply
                      1. M
                        Malathi Kasturirangan
                        Apr 29, 2014 at 9:16 am
                        YOU HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD.
                        Reply
                        1. S
                          Saira
                          Apr 22, 2014 at 6:50 am
                          LoL - oh you were serious. Modi wants India to be a developed country - what precisely consutes development for Modi, pray?
                          Reply
                          1. R
                            Ravi Kirran
                            Apr 20, 2014 at 2:03 am
                            Well said. Nicely written article, must read.
                            Reply
                            1. S
                              Sunder Ram
                              Apr 20, 2014 at 2:41 am
                              Nice article.
                              Reply
                              1. V
                                vikas
                                Apr 20, 2014 at 1:40 am
                                I liked this article very much. I like to be generally optimistic but sometimes country's situation takes toll on me and pessimism takes over. It makes very sad to see in our large country every area of life is limited to some names - politics - 5-6 families across india with the FAM at top, economy - 2-3 families around, education - IIT/IIM/AIIMS..we can start and finish rest of story in less than ten lines..Please politicians don't play with voter's Bhartiyata..are all virtues prepared only for us so that you can occupying the devil space ? When despite hiding all your finances the poll affidavits still show crores, we realize why poverty line could not move upwards from 33/- a day...Try Bhartiyata..please
                                Reply
                                1. Load More Comments