Fifth Column: Bad times ahead?

Why does Modi remain a ‘fascist’ monster in the eyes of such a large, vocal group of Indians?

Written by Tavleen Singh | Published: May 28, 2017 1:59 am
narendra modi, modi, pm modi, bjp, hindutva, saffron groups india, modi regime, modi govt, modi policies, india news, indian express news Modi continues to be hated by Indian journalists of liberal persuasion, and liberals are articulate and convincing. (Source: PTI Photo)

So three years of Modi Raj and India is still India. Remember the prophecies of doom in our newspapers the day after that hot, white afternoon when Narendra Modi was sworn in as Prime Minister in the forecourt of Rashtrapati Bhavan on May 26, 2014? Remember the pontifications of political pundits who warned ominously that the ascent of the ‘fascist’ from Gujarat signalled the end of India? Remember Dr Manmohan Singh’s prophecy that Modi’s ascent to the job he then held would be a ‘disaster’? And how can anyone forget that Congress party campaign video in which Sonia Gandhi so dramatically announced that if Modi became Prime Minister, only ‘God can save India’.

Famous commentators remain even today who say, every chance they get, that there is an ‘undeclared Emergency’ in India and that goons have been given permission to take the law into their hands. Cow vigilantes roaming highways in search of Muslims and Dalits to hunt and kill help make the case that India has indeed slipped beyond the pale. But as a political commentator who remembers much worse times, I feel obliged this week to point out that there has been much less violence in the past three years than in ‘secular’ days of yore.

Nothing in the past three years compares with the violence that happened in the wake of Operation Blue Star. For more than a decade Punjab became a killing ground. Then, after Indira Gandhi’s assassination, Delhi’s streets were littered with the bodies of Sikhs, and apocalyptic visions once more rose. And, nothing that has happened in the past three years compares with the terrible communal violence that L K Advani’s rath yatra to Ayodhya left in its wake. So many Muslims were killed then that we lost count of the number of dead and the number of riots. So although the despicable, cowardly cow vigilantes remain unchecked, their barbarism (videotaped on cellphones) does not compare with that annual bloodletting that took the form of major communal riots in earlier times. Even in Kashmir, which is today Modi’s biggest political problem, there have been worse times. Much, much worse times.

So why does Modi remain a ‘fascist’ monster in the eyes of such a large, vocal group of Indians? Why do respectable foreign correspondents continue to repeat the lie that Gujarat in 2002 saw the worst communal violence in India since 1947? The simple answer is that Modi continues to be hated by Indian journalists of liberal persuasion, and liberals are articulate and convincing. It does not help that the Prime Minister has not held a single press conference in the past three years and it does not help that he chooses to stay so far away from the media that to actually get to meet him has become a privilege rather than the right that it should be.

Donald Trump despises the media but has given more press conferences and interviews in the past six months than Modi has in three years. This has damaged Modi more than it has the media. No amount of ‘good news’ on the Modi app and no amount of monologues on Mann ki Baat make up for the absence of real conversations with journalists, even those who hate him, and even those who ask difficult questions. What the Prime Minister seems not to have noticed is that his disdain for the media deprives him of vital feedback. It also deprives him of the chance to speak of his government’s achievements. So the successes of Swachh Bharat, and there have been many, remain unsung as does the speed with which rural roads are being built and other things that indicate real ‘parivartan’.

India remains India despite Modi, but there are signs of trouble ahead unless the Prime Minister finds his voice and discovers how important it is for him to lead more resolutely. Last week’s horrible jihadi attack in Manchester comes as a reminder that India with the second largest Muslim population in the world has been relatively free from jihadi terrorism in the past three years. But there are ominous signs that Muslim communities across the country are beginning to feel that cow vigilantism has the sanction of the Prime Minister personally. They perhaps never believed the slogan of ‘Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas’ but they believe it less every time Muslim cattle traders and dairy farmers are attacked and killed on our highways.

In a recent conversation with ordinary Muslims in a mosque in eastern Uttar Pradesh I heard a sensible, middle-aged man say, “Yes in the old days there used to be terrible communal riots. We remember them. But, what is happening now is more insidious. It is as if they want us to accept that in India our status is now of second-class citizens.” Only the Prime Minister can change this dangerous perception.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. D
    Dennis david
    Jun 5, 2017 at 12:26 am
    Mr Modi is interested in saving the cow's not the farmers. remember farmers can save the cows the cows cannot save the farmers
    1. S
      May 30, 2017 at 12:57 pm
      Well written.... although you do contradict yourself Ma'm . At the outset you claim that the doomsayers have been proved wrong. But as you build up the narrative, you acknowledge that things are bad.. very very bad ! Worse than ever before !
      1. S
        Sunny M
        May 30, 2017 at 6:29 am
        Another good try by Ms. Singh to convince Modi to talk to the media. She sounds like one of leaders in the fourth estate pack. A bit of threatening tone too ..with a ..."else watch out" While she has praised the PM too, as a journalist with immense wisdom she chose to forget that the very people that incited communal violence are today at the helm of affairs in this country. You don't need to be a rocket scientist to know why last 3 years haven't seen a violence. She unknowingly referred to the act of Mr. LK Advani which sums up the answer why no violence in 3 years ?? Another 2 years she will have more answers hopefully.
        1. J
          May 30, 2017 at 2:43 am
          Mr. Modi dos not want any Indian, Muslim or otherwise, to be a second cl citizen. However, similarly, neither does he want to see some citizens be more important than others, such as Politicians with their Red Blinking Lights and favored minorities such as Muslims. HIs method, India First, Appea t Never is merely the righting of the Ship of the State.
          1. R
            Ravi Diwan
            May 29, 2017 at 7:33 pm
            Real "Parivartan" is something visible to a common man in his /her life. Need not be sung.
            1. Load More Comments