Discover, invent in India

A country that aspires to become an economic superpower must first become a science & technology superpower.

Written by David J. Gross | Published:January 15, 2016 12:01 am
India, US, China, FDI, Financial Times, FT Report The lack of necessary funds for investment in science guarantees failure; but money alone will not produce the desired results.

I love India! I love its people, its culture, and its vitality. I have many dear friends and colleagues and so have visited regularly over the last three decades. For years, I have felt that India, with its long tradition of excellent science, great scientists and scientific institutions, and rich cultural history that respects learning and excellence, has the potential to become a scientific power.

Many ingredients for greatness already exist. First, India possesses an immense pool of talented young minds. Many have been attracted abroad, where they have made enormous contributions to science and technology. This overseas community has strong ties to the country of its origin and is an important national resource that could greatly assist in the development of India. Given appropriate opportunities, many would return. Second, the Indian economy is booming, now reaching levels of growth second to none but China.

How can this potential be unleashed? I have worked with colleagues to aid this mission. For the last decade, I have chaired the International Advisory Committee formed to advise the new International Centre for Theoretical Sciences (ICTS), a branch of the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research in Bangalore, founded by my good friend Spenta Wadia. The ICTS, modelled on the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics in Santa Barbara that I led for 15 years, has as its goal to foster excellence in the basic sciences through its programmes, generating interactions and cross-fertilisation between disciplines, and acting as a node for scientific information and values. In June, we inaugurated the campus of the ICTS and welcomed its new director, my ex-student Rajesh Gopakumar.

My experience with the birth of the ICTS strengthened my optimism regarding India’s prospects, but also taught me much about the enormous difficulties in creating excellence in India and the perils of Indian bureaucracy. Last week, I attended the Indian Science Congress, where I had hoped to meet with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, express some of my concerns and recommendations regarding the state of basic science in India. As this meeting did not transpire, I welcome the opportunity to present these here.

Prime Minister Modi challenged his nation to “Make in India”. But in order to “Make in India” and compete with better or cheaper goods from abroad, one must first “Invent in India”; and in order to “Invent in India” one cannot just rely on the underlying science done elsewhere, one must “Discover in India”. I suggest the strategy: Discover, invent, and make in India.

A country that aspires to become an economic superpower must first become a science and technology superpower. China has learnt this lesson well and is on its way to becoming a world leader, both in technology and in basic science. Realising this aspiration requires investment. Despite repeated promises, the percentage of India’s GDP devoted to research and development has remained for 15 years at a paltry 0.9 per cent — minuscule in comparison with developed countries: The US figure is 2.7 per cent, South Korea spends 4.4 per cent. In the last 15 years, Chinese investment in technology, higher education and the basic sciences has doubled. China now spends 2.1 per cent, and this percentage is rapidly increasing.

Without investment, there is no return. In the US, companies spend much on research and development of their products, but have realised that they cannot make truly new products without long-term investments in basic science that are best supported by the government. The recipients of the recently created wealth in technological se ctors of the Indian economy should give back to their country to support excellence in the basic sciences. The lack of necessary funds for investment in science guarantees failure; but money alone will not produce the desired results. Were the R&D budget (relative to the GDP) to double, and were the GDP to double as well over the next decade, the resulting quadrupling of funds will only achieve its goals if there is fundamental reform in the structure of India’s higher education and research institutions.

Indian science is burdened with an inflexible, irrational and outdated bureaucracy. India imposes irrational bureaucratic regulations, such as severe restrictions on travel for young Indian scientists and for foreign collaborators, as well as forced retirement at a relatively early age for excellent, and sorely needed, scientific leaders. The only rationale I can see for such a cumbersome and harmful bureaucracy (applying the same rules to the post office and to centres of scientific research) is the inability of the government to make informed judgements of quality.

This highly politicised system must be radically reformed and modified. Elsewhere, planning for science is largely protected from day-to-day politics. Funding flows to independent agencies (such as the National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, and the European Research Council), independent of ministries and politicians, where scientists have much input to shape long-term plans for growth and development. Peer review is the norm. This is especially important in the basic sciences, which require long-term and stable funding.

The government and the bureaucracy alone cannot remedy the existing state of affairs. The scientific and educational community must step up. Scientists and educators must demand changes and they must help in shaping these changes. Leading Indian scientists should engage in public discourse, participate in the necessary review and planning processes, create new institutions of research and education, and help raise the level of existing centres. India does not lack brilliant young people who can create the science of the future, but they need to be given appropriate opportunities, visibility and engaged in decision-making. India has three national academies of science, but they play little role in either advising the government or representing the scientific community. The US benefits immensely from the advice it receives from the National Research Council, which produces over 400 reports a year for its departments. The Indian government also needs increased scientific input to address the many urgent problems of India.

Reforming governmental institutions is not simple, and allocating scarce resources for long-term payoffs is difficult. But both are necessary if India is to develop the science and technology necessary for its economic development and to take its rightful place among the scientific leaders of the world.

The writer, a Nobel prize winner in physics, is Chancellor’s Chair Professor of Theoretical Physics, Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of California, Santa Barbara.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. N
    Nanjundaswamy
    Jan 15, 2016 at 3:23 am
    Science congress became a Congress of brahmin monkeys. After that these people are paid to write about India's scientific development. Nan karma!!!
    Reply
    1. I
      Idea
      Jan 15, 2016 at 12:08 am
      M manufacture engineers, convert them to highly paid desk clerks. India will be a scientific, technological super power. Very simple! And don't forget to appoint only incompetent brahmins as head of all scientific insutions. They had already made India a STOOPER power.
      Reply
      1. A
        Amazing.fact
        Jan 15, 2016 at 10:51 am
        Nobody will contribute to country run by brahmin buggers who appoint only incompetent lickspittle brahmins as head of all scientific insutions to ert their fucious superiority. Once appointed as head of an insution, they would just do what his brahmin buggers ask him to do, nothing else.
        Reply
        1. M
          MyTake
          Jan 15, 2016 at 7:16 pm
          Problem is w generation of Indians has grown up literally hating knowledge, science and logic. To a considerable number it equates with communal agenda! During Anna's anti-corruption drive one vote bank community leader in Delhi publicly said they should not support anti-corruption drive because it will help the communal forces! See the the logic of Nehruvian generation? Where one can go in science and technology with this logic?
          Reply
          1. V
            Vuukle
            Jan 15, 2016 at 3:54 am
            R u fckd in your brain
            Reply
            1. K
              K SHESHU
              Jan 15, 2016 at 8:10 am
              For development of scientific temper, financial support to students as well as infrastructure is needed. Many insutions in India are without proper lab facilities. Moreover, thanks to US and its corporate stragedy, many students are trying for management courses including engineering graduates -the policy followed by India too. The country can become a 'scientific' power only when the students problems as well as infrastructural problems are addressed.
              Reply
              1. B
                Brahmin.bhatks
                Jan 15, 2016 at 3:20 am
                As xyz said, we invented quantum mechanics and in fact we are the quantum state. We can be both 1 and 0 at the same time. We are the most flexible object in the world. See we even bent over our back to our arch enemy Pak. And we are called brahmin bhakts. Now a days the real God is nothing for us and we already stopped pooja for all of them. Our real God now is Shri Shri Shri His highness his holiness Narendra Modi-ji-ji. We are doing pooja daily to him and that God will turn India upside down( Kashmir struggle will be spread till Tamil Nadu) and we will declare the most advanced country in the world. Like we cooked up our GDO from 4.5% one week to 5.4% the next week to 6.5% the third week to 7.9% now we have enough technology to cook up research papers.
                Reply
                1. A
                  Ashutosh Singh
                  Jul 18, 2016 at 9:21 am
                  for the times they are a changin!
                  Reply
                  1. R
                    Rajesh
                    Jan 15, 2016 at 6:56 am
                    Isnt it obvious? He has had an irrational hatred of Modi since 2002, and in 2014, he went completely of the edge. Consider him to be those mental cases standing on the side of the road talking to themselves, and just ignore him.
                    Reply
                    1. K
                      Kaliyug
                      Jan 15, 2016 at 5:51 pm
                      It is as honest as it gets, the only thing missing is the lack of education in the political sector. India is not ready for democracy, otherwise people like Mulayam, Mamta and Laloo cannot be elected and the country expected to reach the corridors of excellence in science and engineering, India and Indians will have to forego this caste based politics and religion based politics that keeps every party dragging a dead horse to stay in power, this SC and ST quota system should be abolished immediately, there should be avenues available for training people in skills that suits them best, stealing seats of education from the best and giving it to the least motivated is not good developmental model..
                      Reply
                      1. D
                        Dipti
                        Jan 15, 2016 at 5:22 am
                        This 0.9 percent of GDP for SandT in India. Hope the writer is aware that most of it is for paying the ries of the huge sarkari scientist establishment --CSIR, DST, etc. These scientist-bureaucrats are mostly third-rater jobbers with no questioning spirit beyond looking askance at the next Pay Commission award. I say sack them all and then rehire only those willing to produce results within a time frame. Else, continue paying ries till the last one retires.
                        Reply
                        1. D
                          Dr. Sonali
                          Jan 15, 2016 at 9:48 am
                          Let each IIT and IIM become autonomous creative universities.
                          Reply
                          1. D
                            Dr. Sonali
                            Jan 15, 2016 at 9:45 am
                            Please identify one IIT or IIIT and suggest ways to make it into a world cl technology and management university.
                            Reply
                            1. D
                              DURAI
                              Jan 15, 2016 at 2:31 am
                              A very sincere, well written and thought provoking article. Spot on!!! hope the authorities concerned will take heed!
                              Reply
                              1. P
                                Priya Singh
                                Jan 15, 2016 at 8:38 am
                                Every opinion towards the growth is better and best so we should focus on improvement of Science and Technology. Every time in any topic people bring the politics and see their self interest rather to National interest.
                                Reply
                                1. I
                                  iftiindian
                                  Jan 15, 2016 at 5:51 am
                                  Sir,no need to become science and technology super power because according to Ram deva and Sri Sri Maharaj Narendra damodar Modi Indi was super power in ancient time in the field of science and technology including medical science. Sir you know even before the plastic invention Siva performed plastic surgery of his son ganasha beheaded by himself and that too an elephant's head. Isn't it wonder sir? Even today's science and technology is unable to do that. Sir not only this in the field of aeronautics,during the period of Ramayana,Ravana use fighter jets and airbus without fuel. As far as present days science and technology concerned,Ramdev and some chaddian scientist have invented the Omni power of cow dung and cow Mutra. If you suffer from influenza to cancer apply cow dung and Mutra it will charismatically cure the disease similarly during war cow dung automatically change into hydrogen bomb and cow mutra changes into fuel. Sir I am unable to write the w properties of these omni power scientific invention. Sir for the time this is enough to understand that having great scientist like Ramdev and his Chela Modi under Chaddian patrons,India doesn't need to go away from cow dung and cow Mutra. Thank you.
                                  Reply
                                  1. N
                                    nerd
                                    Jan 15, 2016 at 2:41 pm
                                    The foreigner in question is a Nobel Prize Winner for heavens sake. He could have allocated 15 mins at least. Coining slogans like "Make in India" and "Startup India" is the easy part. As the author says unless you research and invent in India you cannot Make in India. China is firmly entrenched as the Factory of the World and I do not see that changing any time soon. The best bet for us would to come up with disruptive technologies invented by us that would change the market place. But that said this government is reducing funding for basic research which does not bode well for the future at all.
                                    Reply
                                    1. K
                                      K N
                                      Jan 15, 2016 at 4:27 am
                                      Can we expect such a positive in depth write up from an Indian author ?
                                      Reply
                                      1. A
                                        anandap
                                        Jan 15, 2016 at 7:10 am
                                        At least our science experts of India read JD Barnal's "science n in history" to understand how importance science and technology in society to uplift the poor people. Mythological mysteries may always impact people to follow supersious practices. However it is the primary responsibility of society and government to pursue and spread scientific tempo among the people. PM Modi's advisors may look this article as an eye opener.
                                        Reply
                                        1. M
                                          MS
                                          Jan 15, 2016 at 4:34 pm
                                          Reforms; actually Sir this is a very heavy word for our country. Very well articulated Sir.
                                          Reply
                                          1. M
                                            M.L.Gupta
                                            Jan 15, 2016 at 5:39 pm
                                            Thanks Mr Gross for an honest, frank and fair piece of advice to our leadership. It is hoped that it reaches the PM, without someone disposing it of as a mere grievance, as is the case with original ideas sent to the PM most enthusiastically when he invited them under "Interact with the PM" on his website. Ideas are valuable ets and can prove turning points in history.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments