Fifth Column: Murmurs of trouble

In his digital dreams Mr Modi sees a billion Indians becoming enthusiastic participants in a cashless economy in the near future.

Written by Tavleen Singh | Published:December 11, 2016 12:02 am
demonetisation, pm modi, modi, demonetisation protest, demonetisation opposition, digital transaction modi, modi cashless economy, modi online banking, modi news, demonetisation protests, demonetisation effects, pm modi demonetisation, india news People standing in an ATM to withdraw cash. (Source: Reuters File Photo)

A month has gone by since the Prime Minister rendered more than eighty per cent of our currency useless and so far, millions of the poorest of our citizens have waited patiently in long queues to collect their rationed money. Many have waited hours and days without food and water only to find when they got to the top of the queue that the bank had run out of money. The lives of our neediest citizens have been disrupted unimaginably and many small businesses have simply died. Despite this, the riots predicted by learned judges of the Supreme Court have not happened.

Last week, I heard the first murmurs of protest. I was in Goa and as usual, got talking to my taxi driver. He was a BJP supporter and said he hoped that the BJP would win again in elections due next year. Then he said he was no longer sure of this. When I asked him why, he said people were really suffering because of having to waste whole days queuing up instead of working. “In my case, when I finally got to the top of the queue, they gave me one note of Rs 2,000 and they may just as well have not because I cannot cash it anywhere. Why are there not enough Rs 500 notes? What is the point of us having to suffer like this when trucks filled with new notes are being caught by the police?” The day before this conversation, Goa police had impounded a truck filled with more than Rs 1 crore in new currency.

Watch what else is making news

Similar seizures have been made in other parts of the country, causing people to believe that they are the only ones who are paying the price for Narendra Modi’s grand scheme to purify the Indian economy. He has used religious words like ‘yagna’ to defend his decision but appears not to have noticed that it is not corrupt officials and businessmen who are being purified by fire but ordinary people who have never earned enough to pay taxes, leave alone stash away black money.

What is done cannot now be undone but perhaps those who advised the Prime Minister to do what he did failed to anticipate the consequences. Did they tell him for instance that Internet services in India were not world standard and so online banking could be tricky? In his digital dreams Mr Modi sees a billion Indians becoming enthusiastic participants in a cashless economy in the near future. But if he understood our creaky banking system better, he would have seen the flaws in these dreams. From different parts of the country, I heard terrible stories last week of very poor people putting their meagre savings into bank accounts only to see the money vanish. The standard response of bank officials is, “Sorry, there was a mistake.”

It is the Prime Minister’s good fortune that the Opposition parties foolishly decided to waste a whole session of Parliament with silly protests, black bands and infantile slogans. At the end of this carnival, Rahul Gandhi announced flamboyantly that if he was allowed to speak in Parliament, his words would cause an earthquake. Such a shame that it was his party that made Parliament non-functional. Had the Opposition parties combined to question the government in both Houses, they would have played a more useful role.

As someone who speaks as a layman and not an economist, I have to admit that I am unable to see how the Prime Minister or the Indian economy has benefited. When this question has been put to Mr Modi or his ministers, the standard operating response has been that there will be “long-term gain” from this short-term pain. The Prime Minister himself in recent public meetings has urged people to understand that a cashless economy will be less vulnerable to corrupt practices and this is why he did what he did.

The problem is that when almost every day now we hear of trucks filled with new currency being apprehended in cities across the country, this claim is hard to believe. If stories of these cash-filled trucks were not already damaging the Prime Minister’s ambitious project enough, the suicide note of Janardhana Reddy’s driver became the black icing on the cake. If there is any truth in the charge that Reddy laundered crores of old notes to marry his daughter off in royal style, then it indicates that black money and black methods to conceal it will be hard to erase. It does not help that this mining billionaire from Bellary was once a celebrated supporter of the BJP and a protégé of Sushma Swaraj. The truth is that decades of bad policies and corrupt taxmen have made Indians very wily when it comes to black money. This is why whatever happens, the real criminals will remain uncaught.

Follow Tavleen Singh on Twitter @ tavleen_singh

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. H
    Hemant Kumar
    Dec 11, 2016 at 4:08 am
    She is not able to understand, as e payments increase, there would be less currency notes required to be printed and available notes could be diverted to areas where there is severe cash crunch and people are not able to switch to e payments. In such a fluid situation, everything cannot be planned to the minutest detail. Hail Mr. Modi for showing the light in the darkness.
    Reply
    1. O
      Onkar Singh
      Dec 11, 2016 at 10:15 am
      Tavleen is a journalist who keeps her options open,till the other day she was a Modi bhakts,today when she's speaking about the people's hardships it's not a stinging one to rattle the powers that be.Today, you just want to be seen standing with the people,but how sensitive you are to the problem of the poor is not reflected in your article!!
      Reply
      1. B
        Barb Dewyre
        Dec 11, 2016 at 1:12 pm
        "Our ground intelligence......" presupposes that you and your kin have any and secondly who in the BJP gives a toss, in your foul mouthed words. You are just a wart on Modi's posterior. And yes, Indians are not stupid as they will prove in the forthcoming state elections, but there are some, like you, who are genetically morons.
        Reply
        1. B
          Barb Dewyre
          Dec 11, 2016 at 1:53 pm
          And I rammed your mom with it!
          Reply
          1. B
            Barb Dewyre
            Dec 11, 2016 at 1:17 pm
            And you are Modi's !
            Reply
            1. B
              Barb Dewyre
              Dec 11, 2016 at 3:24 pm
              Keep scratching each other's. That's all you LGTB's can do. Truly a pastime of people who don't know whether they made it into this world from the front or the rear
              Reply
              1. B
                Barb Dewyre
                Dec 11, 2016 at 1:05 pm
                Running a country is not about rolling the dice. It is about making educated choices, something you and your chaiwallah do not have the brains to do.
                Reply
                1. A
                  Albert Colaco
                  Dec 11, 2016 at 5:50 pm
                  Truck loads of new currency are being seized all over the country, while our poor in mullions queus up and wait for hours inline for their own cash and finally if they are fortunate, get just a fraction of their requirements (4k instead of promised 24k)! Bers: printing of new Rs.,2000 notes in lieu of Rs.1000 and demonetising of Rs.500 notes without arranging for their early replacement Stupid indeed! The ultra rich are smiling, it's the poor who are weeping because they are bearing the brunt of demonetisation!
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments