Crisis of cashlessness

Demonetisation is hurting rural India, drying up wages, household supplies and food

Written by Harsh Mander | Published:December 24, 2016 12:48 am
demonetisation, demonetisation deaths, old currency notes, black money, atm queues, atm, banks, bank queues, corruption, pm modi announcement, modi, pm modi, india news, latest news, indian express Long queues outside banks and ATMs have become a common sight following PM Narendra Modi’s announcement to demonetise Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 notes. (Express Photo: Praveen Khanna)

The overnight withdrawal of most of the country’s currency has beaten down casual workers, street vendors, slum dwellers and homeless people in India’s cities with a brutal hand. But the brunt of this body blow is even more dire on rural landless workers, small farmers and artisans in India’s vast countryside, as I learnt travelling in rural Odisha. For people for whom life, at the best of times, is one of bare, precarious survival, the aftershocks are monumental, an unfolding tragedy whose scale we have barely begun to comprehend.

Ironically, the direct impact of the cash crunch was least visible among the most impoverished tribal communities. “We have rarely ever seen Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 notes,” tribal residents of village Gundrubari in Nayagarh district told me. “We never had much cash to start with.” They all had bank accounts. But when I asked them if they had any money in these accounts, they replied with laughter. No one sells paddy or employs labour. Their weekly grocery purchases are for less than Rs 100. Their small holdings barely sustain them for a couple of months in a good year. They live on wild roots and tubers across seasons.

Only some widows and old people spoke of mounting panic because their sons who had migrated were unable to send home any money. One was a construction worker in Kerala; his company had offered him wages in old notes. He refused. Another, an electrician in Hyderabad, returned home because his employer said he had no cash to pay him.

But the moment we moved to mixed caste villages, the story was different. Padmacharan Parida, a middle farmer with seven acres of farmland in Haripur village in Nayagarh, had employed 34 workers to harvest his paddy; he owed them Rs 12,600 in wages. He took a long bus ride to his bank to withdraw this. He was turned away twice. The third time, the bank gave him Rs 3,000. His workers squatted all day outside his home, demanding payment.

He then went to the grain traders to seek an advance, even though he knew they paid much less than the official minimum support price. But they said they too had no money this year. Finally, in desperation, he borrowed the cash from a local moneylender at even higher interest rates than usual, and thus paid off his workers.

But now, he had no money to thresh his paddy, piled up at his fields. Heavy rains were expected in the next few days. If that happened before threshing, he’d lose his entire crop. For the last three years, the monsoons had failed. He had expected to make up some of his losses this year with its good rainfall. “But Modi devata turned out to be even more cruel than Indra devata (the rain god),” he remarked ruefully.

Another small farmer in village Sankhamuda said he too couldn’t withdraw money from his account to pay workers. He went to the bank four times; he was finally given a Rs 2,000 note. He couldn’t use this to pay his workers — no one had change. Maya, who heads a self-help group of women making incense sticks, spoke of even greater distress. The middleman who buys their incense says he has no money to purchase because the trader to whom he sells is out of cash. Their stocks are piling up, their small machines are now idle.

The women instead spend their day trying in vain to get vegetables and groceries on credit. Even moneyed people refuse them loans. The informal economy of the village, running on small loans given on trust, has suddenly collapsed. There is also no wage work for women, even at distress wages. Employers have no money.

A small grocery store owner in Chakormal village, Sonepur, explained why he could not help the women. “I have no cash to buy my stocks. I went to the bank to draw Rs 20,000. After repeated visits, they gave me Rs 4,000. I don’t know how I will even be able to run my shop.”

We asked people about the government’s goal of a cashless economy. “We are already cashless,” scoffed some. One woman said she’d never put all her money in a bank. “When someone falls sick, will I go stand in line at a bank or go to hospital?” she asked indignantly.

As in times of drought, people are learning to eat less. Most households have stopped buying vegetables. Cow owners said they were unable to sell milk as people had no currency. People in many villages spoke of gravely ill people at home who couldn’t be taken to hospital, lacking money.

Across Sonepur and Bolangir, landless workers and small farmers take an advance from labour contractors of around Rs 15,000 to Rs 20,000 in November each year. In return, they work until June the following year in semi-bondage at brick kilns and construction sites across the country. Life in the kilns and building sites is wretched and gruelling, with 18-hour work days at times. But this was how they’d survived for generations.

However, this year, it is already December and the labour contractors haven’t come to employ them. They have no currency to pay advances. And there is no wage work in the fields either as farmers have no money to pay them.

“How will you survive then?” I asked. “We will just die,” they replied. And then, inexplicably, they laughed.

 

The author is a human rights worker and writer

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    Abhinav Gour
    Dec 24, 2016 at 3:09 am
    I wish, the long queue photo too was from a village, if any. Why put up a local Delhi photo?
    Reply
    1. P
      Prashant
      Dec 24, 2016 at 8:39 am
      I also live in jehanabad(one of v few town which get most backward district fund from government of india,,in Bihar),,,,,here queues r small,,,banks are giving 4 thousand at a time,,,life is little difficult but not as much as u wrote above,,,,,,,,, though expectations r v high from Modi,,,,,,let's c what happens after 30
      Reply
      1. H
        Hemant Kumar
        Dec 24, 2016 at 11:03 am
        Everybody knew except this writer that there would be difficulties. He is a well known present govt baitor. They receive funds from foreigners to spread disharmony, disaffection and to create post truth environment in which manufactured prejudiced perception matter and truth is given a burial. They betray even the people in whose name they receive funds. They work with the zeal of missionaries giving a blind eye to the long term interest of the nation and it's people. They work as lawyers to fan fire of emotive issues rather than giving material help to the distressed. A great of disunity is being created thanks to their NGOs' dirty tricks.
        Reply
        1. A
          Ash
          Dec 24, 2016 at 2:59 pm
          Gods going to come down and put everything right in 6 days left.No doubt BJPWill hold a successful rally.I have personally felt the pain because I couldn't withdraw from my account till now.
          Reply
          1. A
            Ash
            Dec 24, 2016 at 2:53 pm
            Why don't you get out of your AC office and travel like this guy did.Take the rounds of ATMs in Delhi.If this wasn't happening everywhere I might have believed the misinfo peddaled by this govt.
            Reply
            1. A
              Ash
              Dec 28, 2016 at 6:49 pm
              Anyone trying to show the true picture is blasted as a Congress stooge or in the pay of foreign powers.This action has hurt and impacted every Indian.Do u really think that u can sing a luullaby and tell people it's nothing,there is no pain.They are not stupid.
              Reply
              1. A
                Aql
                Dec 26, 2016 at 11:50 am
                If you are a PM Mr. Modi, do some effort and stand in the line for full day so you will know the suffering of old and poor people. Bhashan dena an he per line me lagna mushkil he.
                Reply
                1. B
                  Bhogendra Thakur
                  Dec 27, 2016 at 3:09 pm
                  The man already had blood on his hands. The fresh blood may not make much difference to him but history will not forgive him.
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments