Dear Digital Indian

The onus is on you, the reader, today — more than ever before — to proactively make choices on what you are reading.

Written by Anant Goenka | Updated: April 12, 2017 9:12 am
FICCI, Digital Indian, Digital Bharat, Digital India, Smart cities, Makes in India, Digital India, Anant Goenka, Express column, Indian Express Representational Image.

Five years ago, we looked westwards, and complained about India’s abysmal digital infrastructure. Two years ago, we were in this room at FICCI’s inaugural “Digital Bharat” seminar, and looked with wide-eyed wonder at the macro-level opportunity of the government’s Digital India, Make in India and Smart Cities programmes. And while we clapped, if we put our hands to our hearts, through the applause we could hear nervous scepticism.

Because when any government in the world announces a programme, it is generally met with scepticism.

Today, however, we can all sit back and appreciate the progress we have made. Every state is competing with the other to build a smarter city. And whether you are at Momentum Jharkhand, Sunrise Andhra or Progressive Punjab — each state is rolling out the red carpet for technology entrepreneurs.

Certainly, citizens have seen a lot of benefits too. Today, from the booking of train tickets to LPG cylinders, all are online. The income tax department reminds you of your due date via email and your city’s traffic police suggests roads to avoid on their Facebook page. We lead, not just in internet usage, but in innovation too. India has the world’s most vibrant and sophisticated payments infrastructure in the world. We even have an entire technology stack which leverages the power of the web for developmental purposes.

Safe to say, then, that digital India is a reality. But events like this are a good opportunity for us to pause, just for a few moments, and think not just about what digital India is, but who the digital Indian is.

And here’s where, being true to my profession, I am going to be a little cynical and dampen the mood by calling for some caution.

The reality is that the 800 million Indians under the age of 35 have never seen the world more polarised. Spin the globe and place your finger on a country of your choice. Vietnam, Philippines, Turkey, France, USA, UK and maybe, controversially, even India. Not in a long time has public discourse been so contentious. Political arguments often end in abusive fights and there’s no seeing any other points of view.

One of the primary reasons this is so is because we don’t know how to navigate the internet’s fast-paced and wide-laned information highways. And, as editors, we don’t have the ability to be the traffic wardens we once were.

Today if you read a piece that supports Donald Trump’s worldview on climate change, for instance, an editor’s instinct is to suggest your next piece be one critical of it. Just to give you both sides of the story. An algorithm, however, recognises that you are more likely to read another one that supports the same perspective, and it keeps feeding you content that seems to agree with your worldview. So no one meets in the middle, we just get pulled to both sides.

The onus, therefore, is on you, the reader, today — more than ever before — to proactively make choices on what you are reading. The Express Group is India’s second largest digital news media company. Since the majority of our readers consume our news through intermediary platforms, we can no longer tell you what you should and shouldn’t read, we can only write the truth. But we can’t tell you which truth you must consume. That’s a choice you have to make. Our newspaper, a medium that’s still growing in India today, is a complete diet because Venkaiah Naidu and Tavleen Singh write for it, so do P. Chidambaram and Christophe Jaffrelot.

Two years ago, we were here and we celebrated the fact that anyone can publish news and find an audience online, concluding therefore that the internet is truly the most democratic medium.

I am going to amend that a little to say that the internet is potentially the world’s most democratic medium, but it’s up to the user to use it wisely. To broaden your horizons, to question and expand your worldview, and to be empathetic to those who look at the world differently. Don’t trust another human, or worse, an algorithm, to do that for you.

The reality is that a lot of this digital terrain is best travelled on the backs of four horses: Google, Amazon, Facebook and Apple. So the concentration of power is unprecedented.

It’s up to the government to ensure it is being utilised appropriately. And as internet users, it is up to us to maximise the power of the medium.

Ask yourself: When is the last time you looked at a social medium that wasn’t owned or controlled by Facebook? Watched a video that wasn’t on YouTube? Clicked on a link that wasn’t on Google’s first page of results.

We must expand our horizons and there’s never been a better time to do it. Never before has the world produced and consumed more journalism than it does today. And people are far more informed. Strike a conversation with a teenager and you’d realise just how much smarter they are than you were at their age.

I welcome FICCI’s initiative to study the presence of local Indian languages online. As the publisher of India’s largest Marathi language site, we see how the immense power of India resides in its languages. We talk of broadband penetration in rural India, but the purpose is defeated if there isn’t much content in the language that the consumer is comfortable in. We have recently launched and we are excited to launch another language site later this month.

As Barack Obama said in his farewell speech, democracy is only as strong as each one of us is. The internet, too, is only as democratic as we want it to be.

Post-script: The fact that the British invented cricket never stopped India from reforming it. Why, then, aren’t we more proactive in reforming the internet? I am glad to hear the honourable minister pushing Indian representation on the board of ICANN (internet policymaker). The world’s largest democracy is also one of the world’s largest consumers of the internet. If it truly wants to be a democratic medium, we must be represented in its administration as we are in its growth.

The writer is Executive Director, The Indian Express Group. Adapted from his address at FICCI and Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology’s India Internet Conference, New Delhi on April 5

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: April 12, 2017 12:15 am
  1. A
    aman gupta
    Apr 13, 2017 at 1:51 am
    thank you goenka sir for addressing us the citizen or more precisely the youth of india. I almost follow the newspaper daily via some medium or the other and read other newspapers too. editorials addressing us are very rare and we are truely grateful that today you address us. your advice will very helpful to us and i hope my search for unbiased material of news will always end here only.
    1. P
      Apr 12, 2017 at 10:40 pm
      This is a marvellous set of words written..I must say that each of the word is worth stolen and quoting for me who had been trying to establish Internet Maturity around in education. Thanks for writing . The speech must have been rich experience for each one who attended the event. Hope the video is available.
      1. J
        Apr 12, 2017 at 8:28 pm
        Mr. Goenka, Thank you for the advice. Many of us - a majority of the middle cl , I would ume, whatever the TV ratings show - have already made our choices and chosen our options. Let me enlighten you. We don't watch mainstream English television news anymore, since we think they are heavily biased and packed with leftist-activists who have only one agenda: to shout, to disrupt, to raise a ruckus, and shame India and Indians. Whatever the television ratings say, we are comfortable with the view that these so-called "news" channels are only entertainment, ma , channels. We don't purchase print media anymore - in our household and those of our extended family and friends, no newspaper boy flings a subscribed copy any longer. Instead, we consume media online, for free, from any source that catches our fancy. Speaking for myself, I find IE painfully difficult to read with columns increasingly written by people with twisted minds. We prefer to vote with our wallets.
        1. G
          Apr 12, 2017 at 6:19 pm
          Notice how proudly he quotes that fact that Venkiah Naidu and Tavleen Singh write for it, when it fact it is merely a token presence. Indeed, the paper is full of extreme left wing propa a which rises to a crescendo every time there is an election. Even the news articles themselves are farcical and openly biased. The great Goenka would be ashamed at the destruction of this once great paper.
          1. V
            V. Ramaswami
            Apr 12, 2017 at 4:46 pm
            Contrary to po r belief, print media is to a large extent also controlled by a few large players worsened by the incest in the industry seen in the control of verticals of review and distribution channels with no oversight or control. For all type of information, the consumer needs to protect oneself by not being an echo chamber taking in only what one likes.
            1. P
              Apr 12, 2017 at 4:28 pm
              The similar thing was here-> : business2buddha /2014/06/14/served-by-biases/ surprisingly the image used in that article is from Indian Express
              1. V
                Venkatraman Shenoy
                Apr 12, 2017 at 4:08 pm
                A lot of hot air, because as owner of Indian Express, he can afford to out it out for the internet readers to read it, in a manner of 'take it or leave it. Chidambaram is a fraud and Jeffrelot is anti-Hindu and IE is their preferred platform to spew venom against the government and Hindus.
                1. D
                  deendayal lulla
                  Apr 12, 2017 at 1:58 pm
                  Sir,why cannot we have our own social networking sites,on the lines of Facebook,and a search engine like Google. We are an information technology superpower. When China has its own social networking site - Weibo,and a search engine Baidu,what about us? We also need more freedom on internet.
                  1. P
                    Parth Garg
                    Apr 12, 2017 at 10:46 am
                    Readers in fact are last on the priority list of newspapers. The list tops a. management b. government and c. advertisers. in that order. Readers are only figures to prove the worth of a newspaper before these three.
                    1. G
                      Apr 12, 2017 at 9:26 am
                      Seems like the liberal paper has changed the comment setting where one can no more like or dislike the comments. Too scared of losing legitimacy I guess. Their sister concern TheAntiHindu doesn't even let you comment on articles. Such liberals they are.
                      1. A
                        Ajay Tyagi
                        Apr 12, 2017 at 12:19 pm
                        Righto Bro!!!
                      2. G
                        Apr 12, 2017 at 9:24 am
                        Lol. Seems like a make belief article. It is time IE give up the pretense of publishing truth and name itself as Islamic Express. One odd minister and half-hearted writers from right-of-centre writing in your paper doesn't change the facts that you are a space for anti-Hindu and so called left-liberals to spew venom. But then again. It is a post-truth world as they say. So keep publishing the "truth".
                        1. H
                          Apr 12, 2017 at 8:16 am
                          When the muslims unite ,you call it 'consolidation', when non-muslims unite you call it 'polarization'. Shame to pressitutes.
                          1. R
                            Ritun bailung
                            Apr 12, 2017 at 8:31 am
                            first, you write your good name then your concern will be considered.
                            1. A
                              Ajay Tyagi
                              Apr 12, 2017 at 12:21 pm
                              See the comment instead of fixating with name
                          2. S
                            S.K. Express
                            Apr 12, 2017 at 1:41 am
                            Dear Mr. Goenka, Hope you will read my comments. I find it hard to accept your claim of publishing the truth. I had a lot of respect for IE and fondly remember how Mr. R.N. Goenka fought the political bigwigs including the Ghandy family. Unfortunately, this newspaper now publishes irresponsible, divisive articles that are full of lies especially targeting Hindus and Hinduism. Check out the intent of the articles from Liz Matthew, Seema Chisti, Harsh Mandar etc. Is the goal of this newspaper to divide India into pieces? Even the Kashmir coverage is biased against the Indian army and India in general, with your editors "purposely" supporting the stani agenda (not necessarily a humanitarian agenda). Is the goal of the IE to help create and recruit jihadis in Kashmir and elsewhere? Just read what your IE is publishing and judge for yourself. I use a pseudoname and email address so that people focus on my comments and not know my iden y or how I can be reached. Sincerely,
                            1. Load More Comments