A chief minister’s own goal

By brokering a face-saver for MNS, Devendra Fadnavis has shown himself as a CM afraid of a bully

Written by Julio Ribeiro | Published:October 27, 2016 1:38 am
adhm row, ae dil hai mushkil, mns, devendra fadnavis, ae dil hai mushkil producers, maharashtra, maharashtra chief minister, army welfare fun contribution, karan johar raj thackeray, bollywood, india news, indian express news Devendra Fadnavis

I am shocked by the decision of Maharashtra’s young chief minister, Devendra Fadnavis, to broker a face-saver for the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS). Unless the BJP in Maharashtra has decided to boost the dwindling clout of the MNS to counterbalance the threats doled out at regular intervals by its alliance partner, the Shiv Sena, I see no justification for letting Raj Thackeray off the hook. The police had taken the studied decision to clip Thackeray’s wings by detaining his main lieutenants.

If more of these shakha pramukhs had been put away till Karan Johar’s film was released by month’s end, Raj Thackeray’s ability to disrupt the release would have been effectively thwarted.

I remember the 1984 communal riots in Mumbai. The army had been called out but the killings and arson continued till a political decision was taken to detain the 51 shakha pramukhs on whom the then Sena chief relied for muscle power. One evening, I, as the then commissioner of police, summoned my senior inspectors and gave them a list of local Shiv Sena troublemakers who needed to be put away. The inspectors were told that if any laxity was noticed, the hammer would fall on the heads of the defaulters. Except for one shakha pramukh from Vikhroli, who belonged to Nepal and had a long criminal record, the 50 others were safely in police custody by early next morning. Bal Thackeray was on his knees pleading with the then chief minister, Vasantdada Patil, to release his henchmen.

We did not touch the sena pramukh. His cabal, led by Manohar Joshi, were also not touched. They were the white collar gentry who were not mentally conditioned to incite or lead the lumpen element that is essentially required to pillage and burn. If any of them, particularly Bal Thackeray, had been arrested, the shakha pramukhs with their ability to work the crowds would have gone on the rampage. The main persons employed to organise political violence were the ones we needed to put out of mischief. And that worked. Peace descended on the streets of the city.

Mumbai’s present police chief, Dattatray Padsalgikar, was obviously working on these lines. But it was suddenly announced that the chief minister himself had brokered peace for the producer with Raj Thackeray. I do not know why he had to do that because Karan Johar certainly knew what was required of him to come to an understanding with the MNS. The chief minister represents state power and it is his mandate to maintain the state’s authority. He should have backed the police chief as Vasantdada Patil backed me in 1984. He had an excellent chance to call Raj Thackeray’s bluff, but for reasons best known to him, he capitulated. I suspect political chicanery of the type that does his party no credit. Besides, it diminishes the authority of the state.

It is but natural for the common man to believe that he is living in a soft state where the rule of law is being routinely sent for a toss. Raj Thackeray has been indulging in criminal activities of the worst kind, like burning toll booths and threatening to stone the offices of those who do not comply with his diktats. Recently, the Supreme Court by an order limited the height of the Gokulashtami human pyramids to comply with safety standards but both the Thackeray cousins openly announced that they would not follow the Supreme Court orders and then proceeded to flout them. If they were aggrieved by what the Supreme Court decided, they could have gone back to the court in revision but to announce and then implement their resolve to defy the orders of the court is a clear affront to the rule of law.

If this trend continues, I am afraid that respect for law will evaporate even more rapidly in the days ahead. Business leaders will think twice before investing in a country that is unable to uphold the law. Our aspirations to become a lead player on the global scene would vanish in smoke. Our political leaders should seriously think about the consequences of permitting political adventurers like Raj Thackeray to gain mileage in this unbecoming manner.

In this entire episode, there are two individuals I feel for. One is the young chief minister himself. He had a bright political future ahead of him. He is personally honest and he takes decisions. But to take a decision that shows him in a poor light as a man who is afraid of a bully is, to my mind, suicidal.

The other person I am sorry for is Shaina N.C., the BJP’s spokesperson. To me, personally, she is part of the extended police family. Her grandfather was the longest serving police commissioner of Bombay (as it was then called), who raised the toast at my wedding. Poor Shaina! She was asked to state the party’s line about the chief minister’s deal with Raj Thackeray and she had to say that the deal was cut to uphold the rule of law when the truth was exactly the opposite. Left to herself, I know Shaina would not have endorsed such a preposterous stand.

The writer, a retired IPS officer, was Mumbai police commissioner, DGP Gujarat and DGP Punjab

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. S
    Sampat
    Oct 27, 2016 at 11:00 am
    He risked his life during insurgency in Punjab. During his one of morning walks, in fact he was indiscriminately fired upon.
    Reply
    1. S
      Sirius
      Oct 27, 2016 at 3:41 pm
      Kaun se madrase se taleem pai hai ?
      Reply
      1. J
        Javed
        Oct 28, 2016 at 9:42 pm
        How come this IPS officer thinks he knows all never took the Christian church mafia? We all know how the church is a mafia who molest kids. How come Ribero could not find a single case of church molestatiolns. Is it because he was part of it?
        Reply
        1. J
          Javed
          Oct 27, 2016 at 1:56 pm
          This guy Ribero lost all respect when he proved that he is a Christian fundamentalist first and Indian second. He thinks now he is a super man god's gift and so elite. Come on man you never took on your church padre priests who molest kids not you commented on Teresa who loved to give pain to suck to die and molested kids in Kolkotta.
          Reply
          1. R
            Rajat
            Oct 27, 2016 at 12:37 pm
            With the brokered truce, the people can visit the multiplexes without any fear. Had there been no truce, the Government may have ured people of safety but many would have sta away fearing violence. This is a better outcome. lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;The writer has reached a senile age. He is not in a right frame of mind. He should retire his mind also.
            Reply
            1. R
              Ram
              Oct 27, 2016 at 8:16 pm
              Now Bhakt will cry cry and cry
              Reply
              1. S
                SubbuI
                Oct 27, 2016 at 5:09 am
                RESPECTED REBEIRIO SIR. VERY APT OBSERVATIONS .FADNAVIS AS YOU POINTED OUT "YOUNG" CHIEF MINISTER.SIR MAY BE BY COMPARITIVE AGE AND LOOKS HE MAY BE YOUNG. BUT, MY PERSONEL OPENION IS HE IS VERY OVER AMBITIOUS AND MORE GREEDY FOR HIS AGE. ME,MY SELF. MINE AND I ARE THE MOST FAVORITE WORDINGS IN HIS ATUDE AND DEEDES.ALONHG WITH THE ARROGANT LADY SMIRITI IRANI. YOUNG FADNAVIS IS OVER AMBITIOUS AND LOOKS AT TOP DELHI SLOT.AND PLANNING FROM NOW ONLYAlt;br/gt;FADNAVIS NOT ONLY GAVE IN TO MNS. HE IS THE AUTHOR OF FULL STORY FROM IST TO LAST PAGE.HE IS THE MOST CUNNING AND CALCULATIVE WHICH ARE EVIDENT FROM THE WAY HE SILENCED HIS NO2 AND MUNDAY LADY.lt;br/gt;AS FOR AS SHINA N.C IS CONCERNED SHE IS A DOUBLE TALKER WITH NO CLEAR VIEWS NOT ONLY IN THIS EXTORTION TAMASHA BUT ALSO ANY THING CONCERNING NATIONAL ISSUES
                Reply
                1. V
                  Vanamali
                  Oct 27, 2016 at 6:55 am
                  Ok, we all know you are part of the same fake "secular" "liberal" "intellectual" brigade that constantly advises that government must hold dialogue with Stone pelting Kashmir terrorists and with terrorist state stan.
                  Reply
                  1. K
                    K SHESHU
                    Oct 27, 2016 at 2:08 pm
                    The fascists have grown to such an extent that the w government and industry us being engulfed
                    Reply
                    1. A
                      Anuj
                      Oct 27, 2016 at 12:20 pm
                      He was simply doing his duty for which he was paid from public exchequer. He acted no different than a constable posted on a check-post.
                      Reply
                      1. A
                        Anuj
                        Oct 27, 2016 at 12:09 pm
                        You are trying to supress freedom of speech.
                        Reply
                        1. V
                          Vidhu
                          Oct 27, 2016 at 2:47 pm
                          Why did you need to comment with an umed name?
                          Reply
                          1. V
                            Vidhu
                            Oct 27, 2016 at 9:51 am
                            A timid surrender to disruptive forces. Politics touching a new Low. Extremism gaining an upper hand. State must have been tough with MNS goons.
                            Reply
                            1. A
                              Ajay G
                              Oct 27, 2016 at 9:45 am
                              Like Rajiv hi changed the course of history by opportunistic approach on Shah Bano case, BJP has written the rules for Freedom of Expression for future of India. A very bad precedent.
                              Reply
                              1. A
                                Ajay G
                                Oct 27, 2016 at 9:42 am
                                These political decisions have always given our democracy a jolt.
                                Reply
                                1. A
                                  Apurva Singh
                                  Oct 27, 2016 at 4:39 pm
                                  Julio you have no credibility left so get lost
                                  Reply
                                  1. O
                                    Orion
                                    Oct 28, 2016 at 1:13 pm
                                    Politics of the right is tricky in best of times; when two young politicians want to eat the cream so easily by this Diwali, people see through it... (at least Nitish Kumar is trying out something - he may fail but come out a winner in that process!). Experiment something! If perception is everything in politics, Dashing (Mr. Thackrey - will even do violence for the country) and the Dynamic (Mr. Phadnavis - will anyhow maintain peace for the country) both came out poorly. lt;br/gt;The problem statement is simple: how do you apply pressure on the neighboring country to supplement the pressure of the Indian Govt so that the world stops thinking that it is another round of family feud across the fence. Both of you have trivialized it beyond cognition!
                                    Reply
                                    1. A
                                      Austine Vause
                                      Oct 27, 2016 at 1:31 pm
                                      Indeed, it was an excellent chance to call Raj Thackeray's bluff. Mumbai remains under terror of MNS. Nagpur bosses did not oblige Fadnavis !!!!
                                      Reply
                                      1. A
                                        Austine Vause
                                        Oct 27, 2016 at 1:23 pm
                                        Julio Ribera has been upright and fair in this beautifully written article. It was an excellent chance to call Raj Thackeray's bluff like Modi has called stan's nuclear threat a bluff. Political chicanery !!!!!
                                        Reply
                                        1. A
                                          Ankur Gupta
                                          Oct 27, 2016 at 1:18 pm
                                          Ribeiro has acknowledged the uprightness and decision making qualities of Fadnavis. Kudos for that. Fadnavis is young and may have been tempted to conclude it amicably. It does not mean his stance will remain same in similar situation in future. He may need to take a stand against party bosses and his mentors in Napper.
                                          Reply
                                          1. B
                                            Barb Dewyre
                                            Oct 27, 2016 at 12:52 pm
                                            It is an established fact that those who promote the agenda of the terrorists ultimately get run over by them. It is only a question of time before MNS bites BJP. What kind of a message has Fadnavis sent to India: We cannot handel this neighbourhood goonda so you can imagine what we are doing in JandK?
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments