After the meteoric rise

... must come sustained groundwork. But AAP is stuck in an excess of rhetoric, contradictions

Written by Suhas Palshikar | Published:April 20, 2017 12:07 am
aap. aam aadmi party, aap support, aap mcd elections, kejriwal, arvind kejriwal, aap delhi, delhi aap, mcd elections aap, delhi news, india news, indian express news, latest news The purge effected by Arvind Kejriwal pushed away many small popular agitation groups willing to participate in the new experiment of party politics. (Express Photo by Amit Mehra)

Two years after its massive electoral victory, the Aam Aadmi Party is facing a critical test this week when Delhi votes for municipal elections. Given its huge majority in the assembly, even if it manages to win with a slender margin, that would appear tame and, certainly, failure to win a majority would pose new problems for the party beleaguered by the recent setback in a Delhi by-poll and a lacklustre showing in Punjab and Goa. But beyond the routine electoral ups and downs, why do we need to take the AAP’s fortunes in the coming municipal elections seriously?

The party emerged from the anti-corruption agitation of 2011. However, corruption cannot become an issue for sustained mobilisation or for running a party. So, as an “anti-corruption” party, the AAP had a flawed formation. Yet, the AAP deserves to be looked at seriously because the party did not address any particular social section, nor did it rely on regional sentiment. In this sense, it was an important experiment — it was a party without the trappings of being a caste or regionalist party. It also aimed at being an all-India party, rather than confining itself to one state. So, the AAP could rupture both the neat dichotomy of parties into all-India and state-based parties and the monotony of bipolarity regulated by the “all-India” players.

The only other party that came to close to achieving this was the BSP. Its social constituency of Dalits and its ambition to build bridges with “bahujans” qualified the party to become at least a “multi-state” party when it began to spread to Delhi, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and so on. But the decision to focus on Uttar Pradesh and the inability to broadbase the party’s following even to the larger Dalit community have reduced it to only a state-level player in UP. Today, the party system in India has arrived at a turning point: The so-called all-India left parties have ceased to be truly pan-Indian. At most, they are relevant in only a few states. And the Congress, which boasts of being an all-India party with a long history, is on the verge of losing its all-India character.

Entering the party political arena and crossing the threshold of relevance has never been easy in India’s democratic politics. The success stories are often confined to “caste parties” or regionalist parties. That is why we often have scores of parties desperately wanting to “make it” in politics, but they remain like the unnoticed “extras” in a star-studded Bollywood set-up. The real show is carried on by the handful of parties who have already crossed the threshold.

Even after the 1990s, when the Lok Sabha began to have more than 30 parties represented in the House and coalition governments had more than 10 parties sharing power, not many parties had the capacity to rupture the nature of political competition at the all-India level in the real sense. Their role and fame depended on the contingencies of hung legislatures, rather than real popular support and the ability to mobilise the masses. Besides, no party since the advent of the BSP has even nursed the ambition seriously to expand beyond one state or beyond one social section.

Given that the Congress and the BJP together often poll not more than 50 to 55 per cent votes, a large segment of voters would be available for mobilisation. Further assuming that there is no such thing as a parochial voter who wants only to vote for a regionalist or a caste party, this segment should be the natural constituency for any new entrant. One could say that, theoretically, this was the assumption behind the formation of the AAP, particularly in the context of the Congress vacating space and the expectation that a new political entrant could likely take over that space. Its Delhi victories — both the truncated victory of 2013 and the decisive one in 2015 — signified that this could become a real possibility. How did the AAP live up to this possibility?

The AAP slipped up on two key fronts. Almost as if it were a legatee of the Socialist or Janata Dal politics, the party got involved in bitter internal bickering and a personality cult. The purge effected by Arvind Kejriwal pushed away many small popular agitation groups willing to participate in the new experiment of party politics. The novelty of the AAP was not so much in its naïve anti-corruption rhetoric, it lay in the attraction it held for mass movements which were now willing to engage with party politics. It lost on that front.

Once that true novelty was lost, the party’s ability to focus on mobilisation got adversely affected. Since then, the AAP has attempted to project itself as a possible node around which a new anti-BJP politics can shape. Ever since it won Delhi two years ago, the AAP has attempted to position itself as a giant killer and as the chief Modi-baiter party — mostly through press statements and social media posts. Kejriwal also sought to establish linkages with the JD(U) in Bihar and the TMC in West Bengal.

More importantly, in the last two years, the AAP has not attempted even in a single state to engage in sustained mobilisations on any issue. Even in Punjab, where the party created quite a hype, it sought to rely mainly on creating impressions and depended on high rhetoric, losing the opportunity to shape new grounds for struggles. Instead of engaging in any sustained mobilisation anywhere in the country on any issue of common interest, and instead of serious party-building almost anywhere, the party’s leadership sought to entrench itself in the usual intrigues of apex coalitions.

Meteoric rise is not unknown in politics, but politics is more about sustained groundwork. Whether in Punjab or Goa or some time earlier in Gujarat, the AAP sought to parachute itself through the temptingly easy route of tantalising drama. It ignored sustained and silent mobilisation. Following its tame showing in Punjab — though it polled 23 per cent votes there — and its failure to dent Goa’s politics, with its six per cent vote, the AAP is sitting on two key contradictions. One is the contradiction between its Delhi-centric politics and its multi-state ambitions.

The other is the contradiction between its original emergence through popular mobilisation and subsequent inability to engage in meaningful mobilisations over substantial issues. This leads to a politics of contradiction and rhetoric. A loss or win in Delhi would not save the party from the contradictions it has created for itself. Whether it spreads or remains a Delhi party, its hollowness would remain a stumbling block in its evolution.

The writer taught political science at Savitribai Phule Pune University and is currently chief editor of ‘Studies in Indian Politics’

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. Y
    Yogesh
    Apr 21, 2017 at 5:47 am
    They just haven't delivered anything meaningful in Delhi so far and most election promises have been damp squibs - most voters now feel very foolish to admit that they actually voted for AAP
    Reply
    1. S
      shashank
      Apr 20, 2017 at 8:35 pm
      AAP is also a pseudo secular cult. They supported JNU kind of incidents w heartly. They signed pe ion for Yakub memon. The list is long and it is bound to grow.Hence pepole of Delhi will give them appropriate lesson. Hope some burden on Indian politics will be lighten on 23rd.
      Reply
      1. A
        An average
        Apr 20, 2017 at 4:54 pm
        My dog was barking using high pitch I shouted don't act like Kejriwal! He was shocked and pleaded instantly, ok kejriwal also has long tounge but please dont abuse me by calling Kejriwal, I am more reliable more honest more dedicated and do more hard work and do sacrifice for you mankind! Koi shaque? Any doubt?
        Reply
        1. A
          Ajay G
          Apr 20, 2017 at 4:36 pm
          A lot is still expected from Arvind Kejriwal. His gov't in Nee Delhi is doing good within the given cir stances. A few independent deptt with a hostile MCD and LG. His allegation on EVM has brought him disrepute, though. If he wants to build his political party, AAP must divorce the gov't of New Delhi.
          Reply
          1. T
            Tarun kumar Talukdar
            Apr 20, 2017 at 4:32 pm
            From d starting i know it very soon ppls realized what kind of cheater fm Annaji lokpal agitation.He was full his life very eagger to take chance of opportunity without hardwork. In Delhi ppls give him chance nd all selfish within a night they took on their head nd start making fool to Nation. Media, journalist, corporate even foreign Indian also start contribution. Than greedy Kejri start another cheating game. Now he jumped fm Delhi to all over India. Fm CM to going to jumped PM. Everyday he start blame game on Modiji. Ppls become a mad what is going on? No job in Delhi only Modi Modi so he got d result in Punjab nd Goa. Again after loosing he try to start fool to Delhi that he will consentrate on Delhi. I think Delhi ppls not a so stupid again they will vote him. He is lost his full faith nd his stupid, corrupt, proudy team. Good bye AAP.
            Reply
            1. A
              An average
              Apr 20, 2017 at 4:24 pm
              Mr. Kejriwal wants to be PM more than Rahul hi forevermore till he dies and even after him his entire Family must rule this country as the Congress did and even nowadays wants. So this bania is endlessly greedy and even can send Anna Hazare jail the first thing he will do. Any doubt? Koi shaque?
              Reply
              1. D
                Dash
                Apr 20, 2017 at 2:17 pm
                People are angry with Kejrilal's corruption,mjsgovernance,theatrucs,misgovernance & blamegame. His incompetence is costing us dearly. There is zero infra development. Slums & illegal colonies are proliferating. Delhi is deterirorating. MCD polls will ve a hard slap on kejrilal's face. We will show our anger on 23rd April.
                Reply
                1. P
                  P.C.Kulkarni
                  Apr 20, 2017 at 9:59 pm
                  AAP has done excellent work in education and healthcare fields.Off course bhakts like you have nothing to do with education so you can neither understand nor appreciate
                  Reply
                2. S
                  Shivakumar
                  Apr 20, 2017 at 1:20 pm
                  AK is more nationalistic leader than the so called nationalistic leaders.BJP is winning only because of vote polarisation. attack 20 and get support from 80 . AK never uses religion as a tool to get votes. He is straight forward.He is gr root leader like any common man. He has achieved much more than any other party or any other leaders in the last 3 years. It has slow pace but one day or other people will understand the truth.
                  Reply
                  1. C
                    cat eye
                    Apr 21, 2017 at 3:45 am
                    Good analysis, Chinna Thambi Chivakuma. Attack the poor 1 Brahmins in your state of Tamilnadu, then 99 Dravidians fall to choose a populist A party or D party. Then you the endless unsolvable issues such as Hindi-Hegemony, Sanskrit-imposition blah blah ; you win the election.
                    Reply
                    1. S
                      Sankara Subramanian
                      Apr 21, 2017 at 5:52 am
                      Great 😊😊
                  2. P
                    Pradeep Phadke
                    Apr 20, 2017 at 11:43 am
                    The biggest problem with AAP is it's 67/70 win in Delhi.WE have seen Delhi CMs working reasonably well with own or opposition Govts at the center. But, AK refused to honour the protocol and made it in to an ego issue. As a result AAP leadership spent time only in fighting with Central Govt or LG leaving them no time to focus on the state governance and even party building activities. AK's approach is always "I am right, every one else is wrong". "I am clean everyone else is corrupt". AK's sole job,it appears,was to counter Modi and say opposite of what he says. That opposition for the sake of opposition to a national leader with 70 approval ratings is bound to backfire.
                    Reply
                    1. A
                      Albedo
                      Apr 20, 2017 at 11:39 am
                      The main enemy of AAP is Kejriwal and his more than life-size ego. You can't build parties by shouting or releasing adverti ts. Again his ego is coming in the way of good governance. Finding fault with others is a weapon used by many left-wing politicians all over the world (Venezuela is an example) but has failed. Cheers
                      Reply
                      1. K
                        Kachru
                        Apr 20, 2017 at 10:51 am
                        AAP is still looked upon by people to form an alternate opposition. It is still in formation. AAP Party & it's Gov't in New Delhi ought to be different. Educated people understand well the game of Other corrupt piliticians.
                        Reply
                        1. T
                          TIHAEwale
                          Apr 20, 2017 at 10:50 am
                          Akela Arvind should lose MCD polls so that Arvind we concentrate on the job on hand for the next 33 months. Now regarding fighting corruption we have how dishonest Akela Arvind when he blames LG for leaking to media about Delhi Govt recommending to LG for approval of Rs 3.5 crores payment to Ram Jhootmalani and dinner bill to ITDC for Rs 13,000/- per plate for 800 guests
                          Reply
                          1. N
                            Ninad
                            Apr 20, 2017 at 10:19 am
                            Can't we evaluate their work in health and education sectors?
                            Reply
                            1. K
                              Kachru
                              Apr 20, 2017 at 10:55 am
                              New Delhi gov't controls only 4 sectors ; Water, Electricity, Education & Health. MCD does not see elected people eye to eye.
                              Reply
                              1. J
                                Jaganath Yadav
                                Apr 20, 2017 at 11:51 pm
                                There is more to governance. AAP came to power on anti-corruption plank, then indulged in corruption. AAP deserves to be dumped
                                Reply
                              2. M
                                mklburg
                                Apr 20, 2017 at 8:18 am
                                FROM SWACHH BHARAT, YOGA DAY, BETI BACHO, JANDHAN, OROP. SURGICAL STRIKE, DEMONETISATION.....TO LAL BATTI MODIJI ROCKS! NEVER BEFORE ANYTHING EVEN CLOSE TO THIS HAPPENED IN THE HISTORY OFINDEPENDANT INDIA, JAI HIND!
                                Reply
                                1. P
                                  P.C.Kulkarni
                                  Apr 20, 2017 at 9:11 am
                                  Only 2 lakh jobs created in place of promised 2 crore jobs
                                  Reply
                                  1. A
                                    Aman Sharma
                                    Apr 21, 2017 at 7:39 am
                                    Bengali leftists and CON gress took in 2 crore Bangladeshis. Ask them to go back and you will have more jobs.
                                2. A
                                  Asif Noorani
                                  Apr 20, 2017 at 8:17 am
                                  Our AAP friends are being a delusional in hiding behind the "23 vote on first attempt in Punjab/3-4 years while others took much longer" smokescreen. Conditions today are totally different from what they used to be. AAP was born on and for modern television which never existed in the current form in earlier years. When the Congress and BJP were building themselves up through their ground work, there was no Internet and no mobile phone . Most importantly, there was no one Anna whose movement was to be hijacked for political purposes. All said and done, AAP was simply a flash in the pan. Easy come, easy go.
                                  Reply
                                  1. N
                                    Niladrinath Mohanty
                                    Apr 20, 2017 at 8:01 am
                                    Perhaps AAP could have done better but for the loose tongue of Arvind Kejriwal.
                                    Reply
                                    1. A
                                      Anil
                                      Apr 20, 2017 at 7:04 am
                                      AK CM by morning PM by night and this time Delhi will kick him out
                                      Reply
                                      1. P
                                        P.C.Kulkarni
                                        Apr 20, 2017 at 9:08 am
                                        You are wandering in fool's paradise. No doubt job of AAP is tough because star players against them are LGs itching to demolish AAP at the behest of BJP
                                        Reply
                                      2. P
                                        Pramod
                                        Apr 20, 2017 at 6:30 am
                                        The fundamental fault about AAP is that it is a one-man party. It caters to political ambition of one single individual and all its resources are emplo to build personality cult of one man. Suppose tomorrow, for any reason, this individual is removed from the political scene, the AAP would collapse like a house of cards.
                                        Reply
                                        1. J
                                          John
                                          Apr 20, 2017 at 6:06 am
                                          This PAAP party is haram. The mobilization that author is talking about was the result of Anna's (another fraud self-styled hian) movement.
                                          Reply
                                          1. V
                                            Vijay
                                            Apr 20, 2017 at 5:09 am
                                            This article is biased. 3 to 4 year old new party winning 23 of vote share in another state itself is an achievement. That to without big corporate company funding. Yes it won 20 seats . Still much better than g old party which was restricted to only 3 seats ? Be ured by the end of this year AAP will be National party. Keep writing negative things until then..
                                            Reply
                                            1. V
                                              vish
                                              Apr 20, 2017 at 2:26 am
                                              The author should understand it is the wrong leader and wrong values that are responsible for the failure of this party.Once upon a time he was considered as Model and a case for study in Management School and now a case study in negative sense .Which means people can go wrong and can be fooled easily ,may be some people some time and some people more time and some all the time but not all the people all the time .
                                              Reply
                                              1. Load More Comments