The Phunsuk Factor
Will To Power

14 parties come together on stage to signal they are anti-Modi,sort of

The grouping also had many potential prime ministerial candidates and their own agendas.

A clutch of regional parties from across the country,most with a history of being fiercely anti-Congress,came together Wednesday saying they wanted to fight communalism,with their target being the BJP and its prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi.

Although none of them predicted a political realignment before the 2014 elections,the convention against communalism attended by 14 parties — including UPA constituent NCP — was silent on the Congress and the UPA government.

A brainchild of the Left,the convention was the first attempt to find a common slogan,unlike in 2009,when the Left parties had made a half-hearted attempt to build a third front. Between them,the 14 parties have 101 seats in the present Lok Sabha.

But the leaders consciously sought to dispel the notion of the grouping being an electoral front,knowing well that all of them have their options open and that many could switch sides.

Bihar CM Nitish Kumar,who has been attacked strongly by Modi and the BJP,said,“to defeat communalism,fascist mindset and terrorism,we should remain together to the extent possible and practical. I am saying to the extent possible because we all know one or two will disappear”.

Kumar linked communalism with terrorism,arguing that both thrive on each other.

“We are being asked whether a new front is being formed. It is not appropriate to speculate. As of today,there is nothing,” Kumar added.

The CPM’s Sitaram Yechury used an analogy from cricket and said,“There is nothing like a third front but this is a ‘doosra’ of Indian politics.”

The grouping also had many potential prime ministerial candidates and their own agendas.

The Left wanted to reassert its relevance at a time Mamata Banerjee has floated the idea of a federal front and reached out to Naveen Patnaik and Nitish Kumar. Mulayam Singh Yadav had to reaffirm his “secular credentials” after Muzaffarnagar while Nitish has to embrace Muslims – a key votebank of Lalu Prasad Yadav – after the split with the BJP.

However,none of the leaders barring CPM general secretary Prakash Karat targeted the Congress or the UPA government and issues such as price rise and corruption. Also,only Karat and the CPI’s A B Bardhan named Modi while attacking him while Kumar,Sharad Yadav and the BJD’s Baijayant Jay Panda targeted the Gujarat chief minister without naming him.

Karat and Bardhan slammed Modi for calling himself a Hindu nationalist.

“RSS is at the forefront of the communal ideology. It is the RSS which decided the BJP’s prime ministerial candidate. Narendra Modi says he is a Hindu nationalist. Can there be Hindu nationalists,Muslims nationalists,Sikh nationalists in this country? There can only be secular nationalists,” Karat said.

Although AIADMK chief Jayalalithaa sent her representative,her speech read by M Thambidurai,was silent on Modi,the BJP or the Sangh Parivar.

Jayalalithaa extolled the virtues of secularism and said communalism is rising.

She said the “Indian state is often seen to be acceding to the pressure of both minority demands at one time and to majority demands at another,which has fuelled the activities of various groups and encouraged them to engage in ‘one gunmanship’ in their search of loyalty to the issues being embraced by the majority and the minority groups.”

Kumar justified his party’s decision to part ways with the BJP. “The idea of India is unity and diversity. What Bharat are they talking about? What model of governance are they talking about? All want development. The question is whether it is the development of the corporates or the common man,” he said.

Mulayam said the SP had a track record of taking a stand against communalism since 1987.

“I was abused to the extent where it was said that either my father or mother is a Muslim,” he said. Referring to Muzaffarnagar,Yadav said the Ayodhya parikrama was an attempt to trigger communal violence and riots. “They were not successful,but they were successful in Muzaffarnagar,” he said.

The event marked the return of Mulayam to the Left-fold after a long association with the Congress. He had broken ranks with them in 2008 over the confidence vote on the India-US nuclear deal. On Wednesday,the trade-mark red caps of SP followers dotted seats all over Talkatora Stadium where the convention was held.

The BJD’s Panda too attacked Modi in a veiled fashion. He said there is an attempt to advance an argument that either you can have secularism or governance. “Those who have assembled here have all in their states delivered governance and upheld secularism. As the handling of the cyclone by the Odisha government has shown,secularism,governance,development and growth can all go hand in hand,” he said.

NCP general secretary D P Tripathi said there was nothing to be surprised about his presence at the convention. “That we are part of the government does not mean that we cannot be against communalism. We have always been opposing communalism. In fact,for the last ten years,NCP has been part of the Left front in Kerala,” he said.

Like Karat and Bardhan,Tripathi targeted the RSS for asking Hindus to have three children. “Those who are themselves not married are asking people to have more children. Most RSS pracharaks are unmarried,” he said.

A resolution adopted at the convention said “communal forces are once again seeking to raise communal issues and create communal tensions”.

“In the light of the forthcoming Lok Sabha elections,the communal campaign has been intensified. This has resulted in outbreak of communal incidents in various parts of the country. The riots in Muzaffarnagar are the most glaring example,” it said and resolved that it is necessary for secular and democratic forces to unitedly counter communal forces.

Do you like this story