Badaun gangrape case: In new turn, DGP says one of the girls may not have been raped

Admitting laxity on part of the local police, the DGP said a lot of evidence could have been collected immediately.

By: Press Trust of India Written by Pritha Chatterjee , RAMENDRA SINGH | New Delhi | Updated: June 8, 2014 8:14 am
DGP said that the post mortem report stated the victims died due to hanging, but examination by the experts revealed they were hanged after they were killed. (Picture Source: AP) DGP said that the post mortem report stated the victims died due to hanging, but examination by the experts revealed they were hanged after they were killed. (Source: AP)

Contradicting the post mortem findings in the alleged rape and murder of two cousins who were found hanging from a mango tree at Katra Sadatganj village in Badaun district last week, Uttar Pradesh DGP A L Banerjee said on Saturday that “one of the girls may not have been raped” and “there is a possibility that the case is not how it appears”.

“There is a need to conduct narco analysis and lie detector tests of all those involved in the case. There is a possibility that the accused could be innocent, we have to still conduct more enquires. From our investigations so far, we are suspecting there could be a different motive to the murders, and the crime is of a different nature. I will not use the term honour killing now before I can prove it,” said Banerjee, adding that the girls’ family members as well as the witnesses would be subjected to the tests.

“The girls were strangulated before death. From our investigations and the information available with us so far, it appears that one of the girls may not have been raped,” he said.

The post mortem reports accessed by The Indian Express had said the deaths were caused by “asphyxia due to ante mortem hanging”, meaning that the girls were alive when they were hanged. The reports also said the “perineal findings were suggestive of rape” for both girls, quoting specific genital injuries.

Dr Rajeev Gupta, who headed the panel of doctors who conducted the post mortems, declined to comment.

Banerjee said call detail records (CDRs) and forensic evidence collected from the spot had revealed “new angles” to the case. He said \four empty bottles of beer and a piece of cotton wool with blood on it was recovered from near the spot. The DGP said the people whose CDRs are being analysed include the girls’ relatives and witnesses.

He said there was a possibility that in the case of one victim, who was an only child, a plot to seize the family property could be a motive. “I am not talking about the rape here, but the murder,” he said.

Meanwhile, both the Badaun SSP Atul Saxena and officiating District Magistrate Udairaj have been suspended. On Saturday, a forensic team from Lucknow and Bareilly visited the spot where the girls were found and the house of the accused.

“We always knew the police was biased… They are trying to frame our family to save the accused who are all Yadavs. We will leave the village and go to Delhi to fight for justice,” said the father of one of the victims.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. A
    Arkota
    Jun 8, 2014 at 3:15 am
    Is he a DGP or spokes person for the accused? It his duty to investigate and put together the facts. Instead he is wool gathering and surmising his own theories and spoiling the public mind. He is like a TV channel for the accused and the govt.
    Reply
    1. P
      Paddy Singh
      Jun 8, 2014 at 8:02 am
      Yes, but NaMO, as you call him has not said a word on the rape, questioned the UP government or even ordered an enquiry. And the less said the better about the Poona murder. He is for the `senas that will now rule the country, he is from the senas that will create chaos in the country and he is no better than any run of the mill politician.
      Reply
      1. S
        Subhash
        Jun 7, 2014 at 10:17 pm
        Won't wonder, if the final report eventually turn the killings as suicide and let the accused go scot free!
        Reply
        1. S
          sharma
          Jun 8, 2014 at 6:03 am
          Let's not politicise or sensationalise the issue. It is nowt a one day headline. UP and Bihar needs development and modernisation. Let ius all work and strengthen NaMo's hand. One news paper of repute refuses to accept any comment with hindu muslim minorities etc in the article. This is stupid as it proves nobody in the newspaper is reading my comment and it is under auto screen.
          Reply
          1. B
            bhagawan
            Jun 8, 2014 at 1:25 am
            She had been murdered by hanging from a tree and so what does it matter if she had not been raped? The culprits who committed the atrocity of killing this girl (with or without a rape) deserve the extreme penalty of death by hanging just like their victim.
            Reply
            1. C
              Citizen
              Jun 7, 2014 at 3:12 pm
              It is unfortunate that investigation agencies in spite of modern scientific methods available they failed to gather the crucial crime scene evidence properly and protect the same of its custody till it reaches the justice system shows the laxity of the entire force. It is immaterial whether they are raped or killed before or after a crime was committed by some criminals and it is the duty of law enforcement to bring them to justice but the statements of the top cop seems to mislead the public in this regard. Jaihind
              Reply
              1. Load More Comments