Express investigation part-II: My loudspeaker versus your loudspeaker

That’s the spark in more than a quarter of the estimated 400 communal incidents since May 16 in 12 bypoll areas in UP.

Written by Appu Esthose Suresh | Saharanpur/ Bijnor/ Moradabad | Updated: August 9, 2014 9:20 am
A temple and a mosque in Nehtaur, Bijnor, each with its own loudspeaker. There was a communal incident in the town on July 23. (Source: Express Photo by Oinam Anand) A temple and a mosque in Nehtaur, Bijnor, each with its own loudspeaker. There was a communal incident in the town on July 23. (Source: Express Photo by Oinam Anand)

Mitron aaj to tumhare mandiron se speaker utar rahe hain, ek na huye to kal yeh tumhare ghar main ghuske tumhari izzat utarenge. Isliye bolta hoon, apni taakat dikha do. To sab milte hain, shaam 6 baje Bageshwar mandir. (Friends, today, they are removing speakers from your temples; if you do not unite, tomorrow they will enter your homes and humiliate you. This is why I say, demonstrate your strength. So let us meet at 6 pm at the Bageshwar temple.)

— Message sent out on WhatsApp, allegedly by Vijay Kumar Mittal, head of the Bageshwar temple committee in Saharanpur.

loudspeaker4_475

On July 23, four days before riots broke out between Sikhs and Muslims in Saharanpur city, nearly 2,500 Hindus answered the message, gathering quickly at Kothwai Nagar, 5 km outside the city. On the previous night (July 22), loudspeakers at the temple had blared Shiv Katha, disturbing scores of Muslims at their night-time Ramzan namaaz. Some 300 Muslim families live in the Hindu-dominated area, and an argument broke out between the two communities on Behat Road before the police were called in. The night passed peacefully, but the next morning, the WhatsApp message went out.

On the same day, in Nehtaur in adjoining Bijnor district, two Muslim men attacked a Hindu pandit called Rajesh Singh Saini with a knife. Saini’s temple is in the predominantly Muslim neighbourhood of Holiyan, and residents of the area had objected to the volume of the temple’s loudspeaker. The local police shrugged off the attack as the result of personal enmity between Saini and someone called Salim. But a full week after the incident, The Indian Express observed five armed policemen still patrolling the area.

In the 10 weeks after May 16, when the new government took over in Delhi, police in Uttar Pradesh recorded 605 incidents of “communal” nature, two-thirds of them in and around 12 assembly constituencies headed to bypolls. In this communal tinderbox, the humble loudspeaker emerged as a potent catalyst for tensions.

Traditionally used for propaganda, provocation and posturing, the loudspeaker was transformed into an effective instrument of polarisation. Police records of over 600 communal incidents during this period scrutinised by The Indian Express show some 120 of them were triggered by the use of loudspeakers at places of worship — the largest contributor, alongside construction activities involving masjids, madrasas and kabristans, to tensions.

Ten incidents occurred in Muzaffarnagar; nine each in the districts of Bijnor, Meerut and Moradabad. Loudspeakers triggered eight incidents each in Amroha and Saharanpur; seven each in Sambal and Bareilly; and six in Shamli. Five incidents each were witnessed in Baghpat, Rampur, Bahraich and Balrampur.

loudspeaker

The incidents spiked sharply after June 16, when \Hindu mobs poured out on the streets of Kant, Moradabad, after a newly installed loudspeaker at a Dalit temple was removed.

Between May 16 and June 16, only 17 incidents were recorded — all but one of which were in the western UP districts of Muzaffarnagar, Shamli, Amroha, Sambhal and Moradabad. After June 16, however, and especially after Ramzan began on June 30, there was a spurt in communal incidents, which also spread rapidly eastward.

In nearly all of these 120 cases, a familiar pattern was seen: temple loudspeakers competed with loudspeakers of the azaan; and a new and aggressive Hindu insistence on the right to use loudspeakers triggered Muslim reaction.

loudspeaker3_475

OUTSIDERS, RUMOUR, DENIAL

Vijay Kumar Mittal of Saharanpur’s Bageshwar temple committee — also an activist of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad — denied having sent the WhatsApp message that, besides exhorting Hindus to “unite”, contained several offensive references to Muslims. Police are yet to establish where the message originated.

Eyewitness accounts of Muslims, corroborated by police officials, suggest that the majority among the 2,500-strong Hindu mob that gathered at the temple were outsiders. Said a Muslim man in Saharanpur who identified himself as Nazir, “We have never had such problems in the past. If it (the loudspeaker) was loud, we would request that the volume be turned down, and the pujari would oblige. But this Ramzan, it was impossible to conduct our prayers.

loudspeaker2_475

“We informed administration officials because we did not want conflict. But an agitating mob showed up the next day. There were very few locals in that mob. I don’t know what would have happened had the administration not intervened.”

Nazir was among members of the community who gathered for afternoon prayers not far from Bageshwar temple amid curfew in Saharanpur.

Kapil Mishra, a member of the Bageshwar temple committee, said, “The loudspeaker will remain where it is, and the Shiv Katha will continue. The temple uses loudspeakers only occasionally. What about the masjid? Their radio (loudspeaker) blares throughout the year. Have we ever objected?”

Assembled inside the temple, Mishra and other members of the temple committee described an alleged attack by Muslims on a priest. “Muslims attacked the pandit of the Shankaracharya temple and injured him. This is what is happening to us wherever the Mohammedans are in a position of strength,” they said.

However, the local police station has no record of any such attack. About the July 23 incident, Kothwai Nagar police have recorded in the station registry that following rumours of a loudspeaker being removed in Bageshwar temple, both communities had gathered on the main road, but the district administration had settled the matter and urged both sides to maintain peace.

loudspeaker5_475

At Muzaffarnagar, Balraj Singh, the Bajrang Dal’s regional coordinator for western UP, told The Indian Express: “Why do Muslims object to mandirs using loudspeakers? They don’t want Hindus to express themselves. They want to subjugate us. We are being denied the right that they enjoy. That is why they are making an issue out of mandirs using loudspeakers.”

Balraj Singh said he had just returned from clamped-down Saharanpur.

POLITICIANS’ OPPORTUNITY

At 7 pm on July 23, barely half an hour after the knifing of priest Rajesh Singh Saini in Nehtaur, Bijnor, Karan Singh Saini, the BJP’s Nehtaur in-charge, arrived at the local police station along with 200 others. Gathering the crowd had been easy, he said, because everyone knew pressing charges against Muslims would be difficult.

“The news spread to nearby areas, and we decided to meet at the police station. We knew it would be difficult to press charges against a Muslim because the Samajwadi Party government patronises Muslims,” Karan Singh Saini said.

Soon afterward, a “Muslim” delegation led by the SP’s local unit in-charge arrived at the police station, seeking an “amicable” compromise. Police, however, charged both groups, much to the dismay of the Hindu population in the area. The station registry recorded that the incident involved two individuals of the Hindu and Muslim community, both of whom were under the influence of alcohol, and that an FIR had been registered.

Later, standing in the one-room home where Rajesh Saini is recovering from his injuries, a neighbour said, “The SP government patronises them (Muslims). We are the victims, but get charged.”

Everyone in the room agreed, and several people recounted incidents of attacks on priests during Ramzan. The Indian Express could not confirm any of these incidents. The police have no record of such attacks.

(All Photos by Oinam Anand)

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. A
    aslam
    Aug 6, 2014 at 12:45 pm
    two to three minutes azaan does not bother anybody else.Altogether 10 to 15 minutes per day is not a disturbance by any meane on brothers we are indians and good indians
    Reply
    1. S
      S.Gonesh
      Aug 6, 2014 at 7:15 am
      India must put a ban on the noise of the muslim mosques. This religionis not a religion. It is HIMSA preachers and belongs to arab-desert cultur.Hindustan need a clean and quiet envireonment and not a lot of noisefrom this brutal religion.
      Reply
      1. D
        Debol Mukherjee
        Aug 6, 2014 at 6:36 am
        Stop using loudspeaker from all the religious place immediately.
        Reply
        1. D
          Deepak T
          Aug 6, 2014 at 12:56 pm
          I had once felt that calling for azaan is good thing as it reminds one to remember one's respective GOD. However, it should be not so often in a day and definitely not at 5 am in the morning. It disturbs the sleep which is important for ones health.I have old parents and they get disturbed by morning azaan. As it is old people do not get sleep with loads of anxiety and other health issues. this one can definitely be avoided.I do not see why people of Islamic belief do not see this and bring every issue to a point of discord resulting in acrimony in society.
          Reply
          1. G
            Gautam
            Aug 9, 2014 at 11:53 am
            The correspondent seems to be a Kerala atheist. Because he is not reporting on the prejudice of UP police and SP government against Hindus and in favour of Muslims in such incidents.
            Reply
            1. O
              OpinionatedOrator
              Aug 8, 2014 at 10:25 am
              Apply the loud speaker situation to temples to
              Reply
              1. O
                OpinionatedOrator
                Aug 8, 2014 at 10:26 am
                As a Hindu I echo your sentiments. Not just Muslims, even Hindus should keep Religion to themselves instead of rubbing it on others
                Reply
                1. O
                  OpinionatedOrator
                  Aug 8, 2014 at 10:24 am
                  I agree with your point. But, please also add temple speakers to that list. In the small town I stay, all the three temples nearby fire up devotional songs eraly morning at 5.30 to 6. Its not a case of compeion either as there are no masjids nearby at all.Why should my sleep be disturbed when others want to pray/please God
                  Reply
                  1. O
                    OpinionatedOrator
                    Aug 8, 2014 at 10:28 am
                    Now I know why there are communal clashes in this country. It's because of narrow minded people like you
                    Reply
                    1. O
                      OpinionatedOrator
                      Aug 8, 2014 at 10:25 am
                      The same applies to other communities as well, not just one community
                      Reply
                      1. J
                        jai
                        Aug 7, 2014 at 9:26 am
                        Jinnah's government worked for the benefit of the country they ruled. SP is just a greedy family using communities to fulfil their lust for power.
                        Reply
                        1. S
                          Sankara Menon
                          Aug 9, 2014 at 9:32 am
                          The author is a Christian never forget that
                          Reply
                          1. S
                            Sankara Menon
                            Aug 9, 2014 at 9:35 am
                            The author says "and a new and aggressive Hindu insistence on the right to use loudspeakers triggered Muslim reaction." Thereby meaning it is a right that only Muslim has. Afterall the author is also a kitabi like them. And an aggressive conversion maniac kitabi group at that
                            Reply
                            1. V
                              Veer Bhallal
                              Aug 8, 2014 at 2:28 pm
                              article totally biased against Hindus, for media crooks, Muslims do no wrong
                              Reply
                              1. K
                                kvjayan
                                Aug 9, 2014 at 1:43 pm
                                Pseudo-secularism is the bread and butter of the Angrezi media and they thrive on it and without which they will perish.
                                Reply
                                1. M
                                  Mohan
                                  Aug 6, 2014 at 12:37 pm
                                  Ban all loudspeakers from all temples and mosques.Let us see if it stops #MeerutGangRape like incidents.
                                  Reply
                                  1. N
                                    naresh
                                    Aug 6, 2014 at 11:36 am
                                    In those countries where Islam is in minority there are no loudspeakers for any reminders for prayers so why in India?
                                    Reply
                                    1. A
                                      amarjeet sharma
                                      Aug 6, 2014 at 6:35 am
                                      This your correspondent is fanatic and prejudice towards Hindus. He has a dirty mind set. He has linked all the events of clashes withe change of Government at Centre. He is blind towards the of the working of the SP Government in UP which is solely working for the Muslims and against the Hindus.
                                      Reply
                                      1. P
                                        proxyowl
                                        Aug 6, 2014 at 5:41 am
                                        With friends like (and other irresponsible elements), Modi needs no enemies. If India develops and gets somewhere good, that is when the status of hindus (and all others ) will be established. Instead of seeing that, these irresponsible elements seem to think that they have been granted the license to indulge in petty hate games. Go Indian Express, help India ward off the communal virus by vigilant reporting. Nobody needs this situation, absolutely nobody
                                        Reply
                                        1. R
                                          Rajiv Pande
                                          Aug 7, 2014 at 7:43 pm
                                          Ban loudspeakers, ban appeasment
                                          Reply
                                          1. P
                                            Prakash Vinayak
                                            Aug 6, 2014 at 7:41 am
                                            Please remove forcibly all the loudspeakers from all the places of worship from all over India ( including J & K ). This is applicable to all the religions.That is the only way of solving this problem. There has to be ban on use of loud speakers from religious places and religion related schools.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments