The big bypoll shift: Non-Yadav OBCs who voted BJP do a rethink

The defeats in Gorakhpur, Phulpur and Araria are a stinging blow to BJP because it’s in power in both these states. Both the winning Samajwadi Party candidates Praveen Nishad (Gorakhpur) and Nagendra Pratap Patel (Phulpur) hail from non-Yadav OBC communities.

Written by Ravish Tiwari | New Delhi | Updated: March 15, 2018 8:42 am
The big bypoll shift: Non-Yadav OBCs who voted BJP do a rethink Yogi Adityanath in Lucknow. (Source: Express Photo by Vishal Srivastav)

Bypoll defeats in all the three Lok Sabha seats in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar have the potential to set alarm bells ringing within the ruling BJP-led NDA which had won 104 of its 338 seats from these two states in 2014. In particular, the BJP alone had swept these states winning 93 of its 282 seats — one-third of its total tally in 2014 Lok Sabha elections from these two states. The defeats in Gorakhpur, Phulpur and Araria are a stinging blow to the party because it’s in power in both these states.

Read | Accept Gorakhpur, Phulpur verdict but SP-BSP alliance will stall progress: Yogi Adityanath

What unites these results is a trend that runs counter to the social combine that the BJP had so successfully stitched in these two key Hindi heartland states: the coalition of non-Yadav communities.

The entrenchment of Samajwadi Party and the RJD was seen as reflecting the Yadav community’s dominance in Mandal politics in the Hindi heartland (Uttar Pradesh and Bihar). The political mobilisation of non-Yadav OBC communities was seen as a viable attempt to counter them. The BJP’s success in 2017 UP elections was largely attributed to this — it fielded over a third of its candidates from non-Yadav OBC communities.

And in Bihar, where the party suffered a drubbing at the hand of Nitish-Lalu alliance in the 2015 Assembly elections, the BJP reached out to the non-Yadav community by forging an alliance with Nitish Kumar’s JD(U) in 2017.

However, this social alliance seems to have come unstuck during the bypolls to these three seats.

Both the winning Samajwadi Party candidates Praveen Nishad (Gorakhpur) and Nagendra Pratap Patel (Phulpur) hail from non-Yadav OBC communities.

Yogi Adityanath, Uttar Pradesh, Bharatiya Janata Party, UP bypoll results, 2019 Lok sabha elections, BJP vote, OBC votes to BJP, Non-yadavs, Akhilesh yadav, samajwadi party, indian express news Samajwadi Party National President Akhilesh Yadav going back after meeting BSP Supremo Mayawati at her house in Lucknow on Wednesday. (Express photo)

The fact that SP’s Kurmi (a peasant caste) candidate won against BJP’s Kurmi candidate in Phulpur, which is considered an OBC-dominant seat, is a significant development signalling Kurmis’ preference for the SP candidate rather than the BJP’s even though both were from the same social group.

Read | Samajwadi Party-BSP knocks out BJP in Yogi’s Gorakhpur, Akhilesh says results ‘beginning of a grand win in 2019’

Likewise, the SP winner from Gorakhpur hails from Nishad (boatman/fisherman) community. This community spread widely across the riverine regions of the state was believed to have lent its weight behind the BJP during the 2017 Assembly elections.

But this time, the community seems to have gone with the SP’s candidate from the community ignoring the charm and appeal of saffron clad Hindutva icon and Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.

The BSP’s Dalit support base, clearly, has also played a key role in the SP’s victory in Gorakhpur and Phulpur. That BSP once used to be an umbrella for Dalits and non-Yadav OBCs also helped SP candidates.

Also energising the Opposition is its hope that if these non-Yadav OBCs can defeat the BJP in the high-profile constituencies of Chief Minister (Gorakhpur) and Deputy Chief Minister (Phulpur), they may inflict larger damage in the Lok Sabha constituencies of “ordinary MPs.”

Even in Bihar, the alliance with JD(U), which was expected to bring the non-Yadav OBC community’s support to the BJP, does not seem to have worked as RJD candidate Sarfaraz Alam defeated BJP’s Pradeep Kumar Singh who hails from non-Yadav OBC Nishad community.

The results of Gorakhpur, Phulpur and Araria suggest that the BJP’s non-Yadav OBC support base may require more cementing when rival parties are ready to play the same game of fielding non-Yadav candidates.

Not only Yogi Adityanath’s all-encompassing Hindutva appeal seems to have frayed in Gorakhpur but Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Maurya didn’t consolidate his base either.

The results may not suggest that that non-Yadav OBCs have begun looking for options beyond the BJP but they have sent a reminder that the BJP cannot take them for granted.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. Laurent Bern
    Mar 15, 2018 at 2:38 pm
    Do you want to your organ? We are here to help you with good cash to do anything you wish, 1 2 Cr Contact us if you are interested in donating your organ. Contact (servicecenter249 ) Number 918496850589 or call 918867434096
    1. יִםךטאַרןמןאט
      Mar 15, 2018 at 1:26 pm
      गोरखधंदा करोगे तो गोरखपुर हारो गे
      1. P
        Propoganda before 2019
        Mar 15, 2018 at 12:39 pm
        Congress agenda is to divide BJP vote base. Patel Andolan was to diveide loyal patel who voted for BJP that didn't worked as expected. 14 innocent patels died because of greed of congress to come to power. NEXT step is dalit andolan, Kisan Andolamn. As 2019 election approaced There will be blood, violence, castist violence, agitation, corruption sponsored by congress.
        1. R
          Raj Kumar
          Mar 15, 2018 at 12:00 pm
          Ideology though does impact the Indian minds but the community self-interest remains a pragmatic reality. In India today we have two political ideologies, one represented by the BJP and the other by the Communists. There is no other ideology in the Indian political space. People vote for the communities and there is always an alliance which shapes and re-shapes to convenience. BJP's victory in 2014 cannot be solely an ideological victory but also a smart strategy of caste politics. An example is Haryana where BJP represented the non-Jatt backward communities. Traditionally the Jatt ruled the state with almost 25 percent population where as the backward castes individually numbered less. But the BJP successfully s ched the backward castes to change the political equation. Similar strategy in Maharashtra and UP. It is therefore important to understand that in the coming years a new alliance may potentially change the political equation. The ideology is a time pass of the social media.
          1. Ravishankar Balasubramanian
            Mar 15, 2018 at 1:40 pm
            All politics is unfortunately caste based politics and not policy based. Parties should debate what is your policy and plan VS mine. Unfortunately every politician is involved in polarizing voters. More so the BJP
          2. Mast Malang
            Mar 15, 2018 at 11:41 am
            Sab Ka Saath, Sab Ka Vikas is a failed jumla hence people are deserting BJP.
            1. Load More Comments