Kerala: Suspended four months for hug, Class XII student stands up to fight

After Kerala High Court setback, Class XII boy says will move division bench; girl says depressed, humiliated by school authorities.

Written by Shaju Philip | Thiruvananthapuram | Updated: December 20, 2017 12:31 pm
Suspended 4 months for hug, student stands up to fight Affects morality of school: St Thomas Central School principal Sebastian Joseph.

“I WILL fight to get back my right to education and privacy. I have lost both these rights.”

Suspended from class since August for hugging another student in public and posting photos with her on his Instagram account, this Class XII student of a reputed private school in Thiruvananthapuram says he will not give up fighting for his rights. Not even after the Kerala High Court ruled in favour of the school last week.

With his family standing firmly behind him, the 16-year-old says, “Now, I will move an appeal in the division bench of the High Court.”

The girl, who was suspended along with him, and her family have opted to stay away from the spotlight, fearing that her younger sister, who is studying in Class II in the school, would be targeted. “I have been depressed… I am yet to recover from the mental trauma inflicted upon me by the school,” says the 15-year-old in Class XI.

Also Read | Kerala High Court upholds suspension of Class XII boy, girl for hugging in public

On August 21, St Thomas Central School, run by the Mar Thoma Church Educational Society, suspended the two students for their “public display” of affection during a youth festival on campus that day. Following an appeal by the boy, the Kerala State Commission for Protection of Child Rights asked the school to take back the students. The school approached the High Court, which on December 12 stayed the panel’s decision, while observing that “the issue hampers the reputation of the school”.

“The school authorities are spreading malice against me… I was allowed to write the semester exam, but kept away from other students. I was forced to sit in the library for the exam and not even allowed to board the school bus,’’ says the boy.

His father, an automobile engineer, alleges that a representative of the school management described his son as a “breeding bull”. “Why can’t my son go out with his girlfriend? The girl or her parents don’t have any complaint. What worries the management is that we questioned the punishment in the child rights panel and obtained a favourable order,’’ he says.

“The controversy should have ended after both the students tendered an apology immediately after the incident,” says the father.

Describing the incident that led to the suspension, the boy says, “After the festival, the girl, who had taken part in a recitation competition, came down the stairs, and I hugged her in a congratulatory mood for about five seconds,’’ he says.

On the photos posted on Instagram, the boy says, “Both of us used to go out with the consent of our parents. Once, we took a few photographs of us sitting together. Why should the school interfere in such personal issues? I have kept these photos private. To defend their side, the school took those photos to court. It amounts to hacking of my account and violates my right to privacy.’’

School principal Sebastian T Joseph says that “everyone has to accept” the court verdict.

[jwplayer 90kUMlrB-xe0BVfqu]

“The hug was a prolonged one. No parent would like to see his or her daughter being hugged in public. The issue affects the morality and discipline of the school. Parents entrust the school with the responsibility of their children. Hence, we have to act accordingly. There was no complaint from any quarter over the incident,’’ he says.

“The boy himself attracted trouble by moving the child rights panel over the decision of the management,” says Joseph.

The Mar Thoma Church Educational Society is an arm of the Mar Thoma Church, which represents a prominent non-Catholic community in Kerala. The school doesn’t have a Parents Teachers Association. The mission statement on its official website states: “The promoters of the Society which runs the three schools and its current leadership are motivated by abiding Christian values of universal love and brotherhood, charity, respect and regard for fellow human beings and selfless sacrifice to all. We seek to inculcate these values in our students without intruding in any way into the personal beliefs or religion of our student community.”

“The school authorities insulted me… After the hug and the Instagram photos, they tried to depict me as an indecent girl. They tried to depict my family in poor light. I want to appear for the Class XI exams, at any cost. And next year, I want to study in a school where I can lead a peaceful life,’’ she says.

“It’s a pity that parents of other students are keeping silent to maintain the reputation of the school. But several alumni, who had faced such harassment in school, have come out in our support,’’ she says.

The boy, meanwhile, is facing a new challenge. The High Court had urged the school to take a “balanced view”, considering that the boy has to appear for the Class XII exam in March. But the school is not so sure. Says the principal, “If he wants to write the final exam, he has to get a clearance from the CBSE for his attendance shortfall.’’

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. Rayz Victor
    Dec 23, 2017 at 4:14 pm
    Excerpt from the Court Judgement "The summary of the fact discussion made above would make it clear that, the incident that took place in the school in respect of the 2nd respondent and the girl student on 21.07.2017 is admitted by the 2nd respondent. So also, the postings of the photographs of the 2nd respondent and the girl student in the Instagram in compromising positions are also admitted by the 2nd respondent. Copies of the screen shots taken from the Instagram were produced before me during the course of arguments. However, I do not intend to make the photographs part of this proceedings, since it will tarnish the re tion of the 2nd respondent as well as the girl student. However, I find that various photographs were posted in the Instagram in various compromising positions and if it had the effect of publicity, the issue definitely hampers the re tion of the school.
    (0)(0)
    Reply
    1. M
      Murthy Bharath
      Dec 23, 2017 at 12:59 pm
      I appreciate the Prin l for standing firm on his ground. If it was a Hindu School, then we could see called left liberals, Sicluarists, Lytheians Delhi and press udes would have made hue and cry about Moral policing............. As it was a Christian School according to them it is not newsworthy.
      (0)(0)
      Reply
      1. Asim Syed
        Dec 22, 2017 at 12:22 pm
        School Authorities made it horrible for the kids. But I am more concerned about the news that NO other school in the area is ready to take the boy in their school. What happened to all these schools. Are all of them run by the Religious Fanatics? Is there not a single school run by people who believe in Humanity ? We are really living in dark ages.
        (1)(0)
        Reply
        1. E
          Eve Fernandez
          Dec 22, 2017 at 2:07 pm
          Children go to school to learn. Not hug.
          (0)(9)
          Reply
          1. Lino Jakobsen
            Dec 22, 2017 at 5:04 pm
            Top politicians can hug each other before a running camera. Why can't school kids. What kind of a sick school system do you want? One that forbids people being friendly to each other? What purpose should that serve? Tell us that, please.
            (0)(0)
        2. Alias Paul
          Dec 21, 2017 at 1:37 pm
          What is the matter if a boy hugs his opposite sex,its natural,schools in kerala are trying built a discrimination in between students,the principle itself proclaimed that it was a congratulating hug,the hug can lead upto 10 sec ,u filthy guys are saying is a sexual assult or something,its the way you giys see the children,everyone have rights,and every citizen have the right to quesgion it,these cbse school are single piece of , try grow up a litlle in your standard
          (7)(1)
          Reply
          1. E
            Eve Fernandez
            Dec 22, 2017 at 2:08 pm
            Boys can hug boys (with out any ulterior intention). Why hug girl?
            (0)(5)
            Reply
          2. Leopold Kanappilly
            Dec 21, 2017 at 1:27 pm
            .................... THE SCHOOL PRIN L SEBASTIAN JOSEPH A 'OLD-SCHOOL' HAS TO GROW UP TO 21st CENTURY PRIN L OR GO...GO...GO..
            (6)(1)
            Reply
            1. Leopold Kanappilly
              Dec 21, 2017 at 1:29 pm
              Prin l
              (0)(2)
              Reply
            2. Load More Comments