Sadhvi hate speech: Cong says Jyoti’s ‘objectionable’ language had created tension, demands her expulsion from party

Opposition members demanded her resignation over her alleged communal remarks in an Delhi election rally.

By: Press Trust of India Written by Liz Mathew , Shubhajit Roy | New Delhi | Updated: December 3, 2014 12:52 pm
New Delhi: Union Minister of State Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti during winter session of Parliament in New Delhi on Tuesday. (Source: PTI) New Delhi: Union Minister of State Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti during winter session of Parliament in New Delhi on Tuesday. (Source: PTI)

With nowhere to hide after her ‘Ramzaadon-versus-haramzaadon’ remarks, the BJP on Tuesday forced Union Minister Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti to apologise in both Houses of Parliament but a combined Opposition demanded her resignation and registration of a case over her highly offensive remarks at a BJP public meeting in Delhi.

While Lok Sabha later settled for the apology, Rajya Sabha had to be adjourned for the day with the Opposition refusing to relent, insisting on action against the minister. Proceedings in both Houses got off to a stormy start. In Lok Sabha, Opposition members ran into the well of the House, shouting “the minister should resign… the minister should apologise”. Congress MPs including Jyotiraditya Scindia, K C Venugopal, Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury and TMC members Kalyan Banerjee and Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar were among the first to enter the well. They were joined by MPs of the Samajwadi Party, Left parties and Aam Aadmi Party.

Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi too rose from his seat and joined the protest. MPs waved copies of The Indian Express which reported Jyoti’s remarks — at a BJP public meeting in Delhi on Monday, the minister asked voters to choose between ‘Ramzadon’ (those born of Ram) and ‘haramzadon’ (illegitimately born). Even members of the treasury benches were seen reading the newspaper.

Congress leader Mallikarjun Kharge, whose adjournment notices on the issue were rejected by Speaker Sumitra Mahajan, said the “objectionable” language used by Jyoti had created tension at a time when communal riots had taken place. While rejecting the adjournment notices, the Speaker said the matter was “important but does not warrant interruption of proceedings”. Mahajan said members could raise the matter during Zero Hour but this did not satisfy Opposition MPs who also demanded an apology from the Prime Minister.

Proceedings had to be adjourned for 15 minutes. When Lok Sabha met again, Jyoti said: “My intention was not to hurt anyone. If my speech outside the House has hurt anyone, I express my deep regrets and accept…” In Rajya Sabha, she said: “If certain words spoken by me outside the House have hurt someone, I take back my words and offer regret. However, if the House feels so, I am also ready to seek an apology.” But Opposition elders did not accept her regret and Rajya Sabha could not transact any business in view of repeated adjournments.

In Rajya Sabha, she said: “If certain words spoken by me outside the House have hurt someone, I take back my words and offer regret. However, if the House feels so, I am also ready to seek an apology.” But Opposition elders did not accept her regret and Rajya Sabha could not transact any business in view of repeated adjournments.

Congress members Satyavrat Chaturvedi, Anand Sharma and Ashwini Kumar, along with SP’s Ramgopal Yadav, BSP’s Mayawati, Left’s Sitaram Yechury and TMC’s Derek O’ Brien, raised the issue. They asked for the minister’s resignation, registration of a case and an apology from the Prime Minister.

\Anand Sharma said the minister had taken an oath to uphold the Constitution, and if she had violated the Constitution by uttering such remarks, she should resign. Yechury said that an FIR should be filed and she should be sacked. He cited rulings of the Supreme Court and the Calcutta High Court to make the point that a mere apology would not do.

Yechury got support from TMC, Congress, SP, JD-U and Left parties. SP’s Ramgopal Yadav also asked for Jyoti’s resignation. JD(U)’s Sharad Yadav said she had confessed in the House, and a criminal case should be registered.
Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi tried to calm the Opposition, pointing out that Jyoti had already apologised and the matter should be allowed to rest in line with tradition. But the Opposition refused to relent as Deputy Chairman P J Kurien expressed his inability saying the remarks were made outside the House.

Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, who is also Leader of Rajya Sabha, said Jyoti’s remarks were “improper and unacceptable”. He, however, said the House cannot decide whether her action was criminal in nature. He said that should be left to agencies outside the House.

With no one paying heed to Kurien’s pleas for order in the House, proceedings were adjourned for 10 minutes — the fifth adjournment since morning. When similar scenes were witnessed after the House assembled again, proceedings were adjourned for the day.

Opposition parties made it clear that nothing short of the minister’s resignation would ensure that the House runs over the next few days.

Nine parties have come together to protest the remarks. “I do not see Rajya Sabha running this week. They are 60 and we are 150. The Prime Minister will need to come to the House… given the number of foreign tours he has done, he may need a visa to do so. And the minister will have to resign. At most Zero Hour and Question Hour can happen, but there cannot be any legislative business till the minister in question resigns,” TMC’s Derek O’ Brien said.

BJP sources claimed the Prime Minister had expressed disapproval over Jyoti’s remarks. At a meeting of the BJP parliamentary party, Narendra Modi asked party members to be cautious while making public comments.

Looking to counter the Opposition attack, Parliamentary Affairs Minister M Venkaiah Naidu said the matter was closed after Jyoti apologised. “Anybody who has elementary sense of parliamentary democracy in this country, past precedents and also conventions, the matter is closed… If somebody wants to take up the issue criminally, they are free to do so,” he said outside Parliament House.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: December 2, 2014 6:24 pm
  1. V
    vasoo kamulkar
    May 19, 2016 at 9:48 pm
    In which Madrasa were you studying Danial? Now, keep this lesson in mind. You aren't going to be corrected again and again. Adam (and Eve) were propelled over the sea of humanity some four to five thousand years after that Aaryan maharshee caled MANU. You are called a 'man' after Manu. The divine Aaryan language of Sanskrit gives the etymology of ''Man" as -MANU gt; Manawa gt;man. Once again, the term 'man' was derived much earlier from the Sanskrit word manawa. As usual, the post-Aaryan unsophisticated civilizations like the Arabs, in a haste to copy the Vedic mathematics and philosophy, had ignored semantics.
    Reply
    1. K
      Kt
      Dec 3, 2014 at 6:01 am
      what about the abuses Modi has faced in these years? What when MNS said that the minority have first right on resources? Congress and other parties should maintain the good ethics in parliament and contribute toward the growth of the country. India should not loose time on these non sense arguments.
      Reply
      1. K
        KarmaBicth
        Dec 3, 2014 at 9:18 am
        Adam and Eve were muslims? I think you meant the snake which came from your(devil's) clan.Your cult is not even in race to know tue God. Better start saying u follow the devil and we will believe every word written in ur book.
        Reply
        1. P
          Prahari
          Dec 3, 2014 at 7:57 am
          All these rubbish are being done by the GANGS of opposition to malign BJP
          Reply
          1. P
            Prahari
            Dec 3, 2014 at 7:51 am
            U stupid have done so may such mistakes in your tenure and not apologized for that, but at least this lady has asked for he same on the floor of the house.
            Reply
            1. P
              Prahari
              Dec 3, 2014 at 7:54 am
              What did u do when OWASI told to kill 75% Indian Hindus if they are freed form polices etc.for half an hour. U s do home works.
              Reply
              1. P
                Prahari
                Dec 3, 2014 at 7:59 am
                Why?????? did u ask for sacking WASI ????? Only because he is MUSLIM?????
                Reply
                1. P
                  Prahari
                  Dec 3, 2014 at 7:55 am
                  Yeh, so that in future u are not converted to Muslims.
                  Reply
                  1. H
                    HABERFIELD
                    Dec 2, 2014 at 8:04 pm
                    THIS LADY IS A "HARAMZADOON" HOW DO THEY GET FIRST ELECTED AND THEN A CABINET MINISTER. LOOKS LIKE R.S.S. HAS A BIG INFLUENCE INTO COMMUNAL MINDED APPOINTMENTS TO PROMOTE HINDUVATA. INDIA PROJECTS TO THE WORLD AS SECULAR BUT IN REALITY IT IS NOT
                    Reply
                    1. A
                      Abhijit
                      Dec 3, 2014 at 8:47 am
                      Forget it...coolguy has lost it ;-)
                      Reply
                      1. A
                        anil
                        Dec 3, 2014 at 11:58 am
                        Wow, come elections, communal tensions flare up from almost nowhere. Churches are being burnt, people get killed, looting arson everywhere. A Union Minister that too a Sadhvi uses 3rd rate criminal language against a religion. And Is this what they call it "Minimum Government and Maximum (NON) Governance". For selfish political gains human beings are being sacrificed, but they raise all for animal sacrifice
                        Reply
                        1. M
                          ma
                          Dec 3, 2014 at 5:05 am
                          did she say some such remark to the people?
                          Reply
                          1. C
                            ck
                            Dec 3, 2014 at 5:32 am
                            Cheap woman.... Shows the mentality of the BJP and RSS.
                            Reply
                            1. I
                              Ilangaiventhan Dhayanithi
                              Dec 4, 2014 at 7:31 am
                              Case must be registered against her and she escapes from it by being as a minister and not resigning from her post. This is cheating. She must first have the morality to fight justice by legal means. BJP must not say about morality if they commit mistake and point their finger on others mistakes.
                              Reply
                              1. I
                                Ilangaiventhan Dhayanithi
                                Dec 4, 2014 at 7:43 am
                                Your Cheap Atude as of your fore fathers were clearly visible from the profile name of yours. Its better you change your profile name as "Theva Adiyal Koothi". Because you people were responsible for creating a temples and making a section of people to serve the kings and pundi ts and not allowing others to enter into temple for several decades. I request Administrator to remove the profile as profile name is mean for a famale organ in tamil.
                                Reply
                                1. J
                                  JaiseKoTaisa
                                  Dec 3, 2014 at 6:22 am
                                  ohh really...first we need to bring down these rakshas in sadhvi's dress.modi started with sanyasi and just talking, no actual work.then yogianand somebody , started hate speech. then uma bharti in sadhvi's dress created nonsense...then maya kodani in sadhvi's dress, became ter**ist..now.. this lady rakshas...definitely india hindus can be only Asurs....modi must have been raavan in his previous birth...
                                  Reply
                                  1. J
                                    John
                                    Dec 2, 2014 at 2:24 pm
                                    What does this woman think? TOI says that she is new to parliment and not used to know how to speak. Then why we need such an illiterate in parliment of a great democracy? Remove her from office Mr.Modi Sir if you respect the nation more than this sic individual. She is inciting communal disharmony and we want you to act boldly. If you dont then you are letting us(The people of India) down. And by removing her you can send a warning signal to all those in power to shut their filthy mouth and work for the country's betterment. Waiting to see our PM in action. Thanks in advance Modi Sir!
                                    Reply
                                    1. J
                                      jerish solomon
                                      Dec 3, 2014 at 6:33 am
                                      I'll be sad to give my ration card if religious leaders and politicians come up with the plan that "India is only for Hindus " You guys are dividing every people by religion,I am upset by the way my country politician leads.So sad here ,a country which unitedly fought for the freedom now gets divided by words.Only people have to wake up and remove these evil roots with help of Lord Ram,Allah ,Buddha,Jesus ,Jehovah etc., Every religion only talks about love and peace,if that is true and be followed ,then all the spiritual leaders will be joining their hands to support every one in the world.All religious leaders have to join their hands to create a new safer India for our younger generation. Jai Hind
                                      Reply
                                      1. R
                                        Random
                                        Dec 3, 2014 at 12:33 pm
                                        Did anyone read today's The Indian Express' print edition? The lead headline on the front page says "And now an appallogy". I've been looking everywhere for meaning of the word 'appallogy'.Express team, please enlighten me what this word means. Or did you mean to write "apology"? It sure isn't a typo. What kind of people are making your pages these days?
                                        Reply
                                        1. D
                                          Danial
                                          Dec 4, 2014 at 7:20 am
                                          Guys, what a appaling comments from the indians in this forum. This lady is really a filthy mind and all her supporter should be behind bars .Everybody around the world belive that human race comes from Adam, but if they say in front of who doesn't belive in it are illegitimate thats where lies th fault , this the true color of BJP, they are hate monger. Our consution is secular, if u don't like it go to ....I worried for another parion if these bugger rule another few years. Not a good thing to happen.
                                          Reply
                                          1. D
                                            Danial
                                            Dec 4, 2014 at 7:11 am
                                            U r a big Kabir with little brain ..Everybody around the world belive that human race comes from Adam, but if I say in front of who doesn't belive in it are illegitimate thats where lies th fault , this the true color of BJP, they are hate monger. Our consution id secular, if u don't like it go to .
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments