Army officer major Gogoi, who tied youth to jeep gets award; Paresh Rawal says do this to Arundhati Roy

The award, a senior officer said, was given “for sustained efforts on counter-insurgency”.

Written by Praveen Swami , Liz Mathew | New Delhi | Updated: May 23, 2017 6:28 am
jammu and kashmir, J&K, Kashmir human shield, Human shield, man tied to jeep. officer awarded, Paresh rawal, BJP MP Paresh Rawal, Arundhati roy, writer arundhati roy, india news, indian express news BJP MP Paresh Rawal and writer Arundhati Roy

Major Nitin Leetul Gogoi, who is alleged to have ordered a Kashmiri man to be tied to a jeep bonnet on April 9 to deter stone-pelters from targeting his troops and election staff, has been awarded a commendation certificate by Army chief General Bipin Rawat, military sources in New Delhi said. The award, a senior officer said, was given “for sustained efforts on counter-insurgency”.

Confirmation of the award to the officer came hours after BJP MP and actor Paresh Rawal tweeted that author Arundhati Roy should be tied to an Army jeep instead of a stone-pelter, a reference to the Kashmir incident.

“Instead of tying stone pelter on the army jeep tie Arundhati Roy!” Rawal tweeted, taking a swipe at the author while ostensibly reacting to reports by Pakistani websites which claimed she had made remarks against the Indian Army on a recent visit to Srinagar — sources said she has not been there in many years.

Speaking to The Indian Express, Rawal said: “I know it is harsh. I meant it to be harsh. That’s why I got the desired effect — it has called the attention of the nation to what she (Roy) has been saying and a debate will start now.”

Sources, meanwhile, said the decision to award the Chief of Army’s Staff Commendation Card to Major Gogoi was made after a court of inquiry hearing his case exonerated him, saying his actions were justified by circumstances. The findings of the court of inquiry are expected to be made public in days, sources said, but the documents and testimony used to arrive at the conclusions were unlikely to be released.

A separate criminal investigation by the J&K Police remains ongoing, though the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act bars it from prosecuting military personnel without the consent of the Union Government.

“The officer deserves it,” Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh said in a tweet, welcoming the decision to give Major Gogoi the commendation, a point he had made in a piece in The Indian Express last week.

According to the Army’s website, the Chief of Army Staff’s Commendation Card is given for “individual acts of gallantry or distinguished service or devotion to duty performed either in operation or non-operational areas which are not of a sufficiently high order to qualify for a higher gallantry award or for which the higher award is inappropriate”. It states that the card is given for “a specific act of bravery or distinguished service or special service”.

However, Army sources declined to comment on the specific act for which Major Gogoi was being given his commendation.

Though Major Gogoi has had the support of much of the Army’s mid-level officers, as well as a large swathe of retired personnel, the Army’s decision has disturbed some retired personnel, who say it may set a bad precedent.

Key to their concerns are worries that young officers may read the commendation as a go-ahead to resort to disproportionate force, or violate counter-insurgency protocols designed to avoid inflaming crisis situations.

“Even if one accepts the argument that Major Gogoi was faced with an extraordinary situation,” former Northern Army commander Lt General H S Panag told The Indian Express, “the fact is that there are protocols in place to handle it. Hostage-taking and human shields are not among them. What can I say — the Army must have taken this into account.”

Meanwhile, the BJP distanced itself from its MP’s remark on Roy. Union Minister Smriti Irani, reacting to Rawal’s tweet, said: “Nowhere will we, in any way, support any violent message by anybody, against any individual of the country.”

Irani, who was addressing a party press conference, however, added that she had not seen his tweet and any answer she has given will not be fully “correct and knowledgeable”.

Attacking Roy, Rawal said: “She is an armchair critic. She sits in AC rooms and writes against the Army. If she has the freedom of expression, why can I not have the freedom to express what I want to say?”

“When she is condemning the Army, demoralising Army and criticising the Kashmir policy, she is humiliating the country. Well, you can criticise the Prime Minister, the ruling party and the government. But when it is on the Army, she should understand that it is not alone. The entire country is behind the Army.”

“No one is going to tie Arundhati Roy to the jeep. Army is not going to punish her. But with my tweet, I got the desired result,” he said.

His tweet drew condemnation from many users on the social media platform with some accusing him of inciting violence.

Congress general secretary Digvijaya Singh hit out at the BJP, asking, “Why not (tie) the person who stitched PDP-BJP alliance?”

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. N
    Navneet Bakshi
    May 23, 2017 at 8:03 pm
    Also tie-up Barkha Dutt and Sagarike Ghose along with her to give her a company.
    Reply
    1. A
      Anuradha Kalhan
      May 23, 2017 at 7:38 pm
      The Army did what it is trained to do perhaps. In the absence of bullet proof vehicles and gear it is in a horrible, desperate corner surrounded by people who hate them. Pushed by government that wnats to score political points .Army is not supposed to be used against our own people. But whats with Mr Paresh Rawal? What is he trained to do besides acting? If our army doesn't have the equipment or training to deal with internal strife why not tie Mr Rawal and other messengers of peace in the BJP. we can build an entire human shield across the valley with these saints insie the RSS& BJP .
      Reply
      1. N
        Nissar Ahmed Naik
        May 23, 2017 at 6:47 pm
        "If we want the land of Kashmir but if we do not love the people of Kashmir then we are imperialists." -Dada Dharmadhikari, a great hian.
        Reply
        1. C
          Chinmay
          May 23, 2017 at 9:16 pm
          Just like AZADI gang in kashmir wanted land of kashmir but not kashmiri hindus.
          Reply
          1. O
            Obama
            May 24, 2017 at 4:07 pm
            To tying a stone pelter to a car and letting him go unhurt and avoiding bloodshed in the process is an act of disowning Kashmiris. According to you it would have been better if the soldiers had to fire on the people or get stoned to death by them!!!
            Reply
          2. D
            dinesh yadav
            May 23, 2017 at 6:45 pm
            Deputy Prime Minister Vallabhbhai Patel said at a public meeting in Bombay on October 30, 1948: “Some people consider that a Muslim majority area must necessarily belong to stan. They wonder why we are in Kashmir. The answer is plain and simple. We are in Kashmir because the people of Kashmir want us to be there. The moment we realize that the people of Kashmir do not want us to be there, we shall not be there even for a minute… We shall not let the Kashmir down” (The Hindustan Times, October 31, 1948).
            Reply
            1. N
              Nissar Ahmed Naik
              May 23, 2017 at 7:01 pm
              We all want Kashmir to be part of India. But we must show our love to the people of Kashmir in order to do that.. Today UK is alowing the people of Scotland to say if they want to be part of UK. Can we allow the Kashmiris a similar opportunity?
              Reply
              1. H
                hussain
                May 23, 2017 at 8:30 pm
                kashmir men are there to show love to their women why you want to forcibly love them - how if i come in your house and forcibly love your mother will you allow
              2. A
                autonomous
                May 25, 2017 at 9:11 am
                PATEL vision is annexing entire J&K with iron fist from pak. Are you from fools paradise pak) ?Its not a piece of cake to give a land to another country that belongs to one country.RUSSIA how vast it is ! though it annexed crimea once belonged to them so here is no point for debate,Do you gone through how much "I n d i a n s" died in kashmir?? kashmiri radicalised mobs can choose their living either in in dia nor pak nor saudi but they can't ask for the land that belongs to I N D I A ."Ap pe as em e nt "will not bring I N D I A anything I N D I A is secular, best eg for "ap pe ase me nt "is U.K T E R R O R attack.
                Reply
              3. A
                autonomous
                May 23, 2017 at 5:14 pm
                There are some countries in the world who preach human rights,minorities rights ,press freedom ... to the world but they will not follow it best eg: "U.S , PAK , SAUDI.But only INDIA really values & practises its democracy rightly so only those seperatist ,anti nationals are roaming freely.If any army men of u.s have been under attack by radicalised violent people in U.S ,CIA will make sure of those people involved get punished that even their generation will never forget.
                Reply
                1. S
                  sanjay R
                  May 23, 2017 at 4:08 pm
                  All Indian should notice that see the stand of most Mulla's here and their mind set and tweets, their are standing with whom .... .....
                  Reply
                  1. S
                    sanjay R
                    May 23, 2017 at 3:49 pm
                    I totally agree with what Paresh Rawal said .......... First I salute Major Gogoi and we are extending our prayer to u and ur family..... crush the anti nationals elements without any hesitation and live as a proud India ........
                    Reply
                    1. R
                      Ramesh Nittoor
                      May 23, 2017 at 4:23 pm
                      It is this binary construct which is a losing strategy for India, and Mr. Rawal calls it a success ! To insure success we need to expose his stupidity . For India to win both left and right flank polity be able to play their part, not be at loggerheads.
                      Reply
                      1. N
                        Nissar Ahmed Naik
                        May 23, 2017 at 8:44 pm
                        It is people like Paresh Rawal who are vigourously alianating the Kashmiri people. Their tweets and comments proclaim to the Kashmiri people, "We hate you , we hate you, we hate you!" As to the episode of tying a man to the Jeep, it does not matter what the truth is, the the armed forces people can't be prosecuted aand the truth can't be found out.
                    2. D
                      Dominic Emmanuel
                      May 23, 2017 at 3:48 pm
                      A cheap Bollywood comedian can think and speak only this far. One needs to be educated to understand Arundhati, Medha Patkar, John Dayal and other human right activists. The BJP and the Sangh Parivar must be fee proud of this shameful comment as others are rejoicing the lynching of the four in Jharkhand, or of churches being vandalized and cows being treated with biscuits by Yogi. What a wonderful image of India?
                      Reply
                      1. D
                        DILIP
                        May 23, 2017 at 4:01 pm
                        It is so sad that your anglicised subservient parents forgot to teach you roper manners, that you speak through your mouth and squirt from your bung h0le and not vice versa.
                        Reply
                        1. S
                          Sammeer
                          May 23, 2017 at 4:25 pm
                          RSS trained dog......Dilip is quick to respond. Dude how much they pay u to b this alert on IE. U must b from IT cell of BJP. Dude do u hv any vacancy I m eager to join your IT cell. U too are a cheap brat ftom Abvp like Paresh joker.
                          1. D
                            DILIP
                            May 23, 2017 at 6:55 pm
                            We all know that Sammeer is an illegitimate son of a WH 00 R E, whose illegitimate baap used a burst condom and a small drip unfortunately at the wrong h00 le manufactured a carrot size drip like him, full of sh11t and pig pi $$.
                        2. Load More Comments