MSU diary with sadhus as inventors brings disrepute to India: Ex-student, Nobel Laureate

According to Ramakrishnan, who won the Nobel Prize for Chemistry in 2009, such depictions bring “disrepute” to the university and the country.

Written by Aditi Raja , RITESH GOHIL | Vadodara | Updated: March 24, 2017 9:16 am
msu, msu diary, Vadodara’s Maharaja Sayajirao University,Venkatraman Ramakrishnan, msu diary with sadhus, inventors, india news, latest news Venkatraman Ramakrishnan

Nobel Laureate Venkatraman Ramakrishnan, an alumnus of Vadodara’s Maharaja Sayajirao University (MSU), has urged its administration to consider reprinting its diary and planner, which credited sages from ancient India for their “contribution to science” — from “developing nuclear technology” to “discovering rockets and aeroplanes”. According to Ramakrishnan, who won the Nobel Prize for Chemistry in 2009, such depictions bring “disrepute” to the university and the country.

The Indian Express had reported on March 9 that the MSU’s annual diary and planner for this year, which was released recently, hailed nine Indian sages for work ranging from “discovering rockets and aeroplanes” to pioneering cosmetic surgery.

In an email sent Thursday to The Indian Express, Ramakrishnan wrote: “India has produced many great discoveries in the past. The most striking example is the invention of zero and the positional number system, which transformed arithmetic and mathematics in general. There were also many great discoveries made in the 20th century by people like (C V) Raman, S N Bose, J C Bose and (Meghnad) Saha. In fact, the Science Museum in London is planning a special exhibition on Indian contributions to science and mathematics in connection with the 70th anniversary of Indian independence.”

On the university’s move, he wrote: “Instead of giving prominence to these real contributions, it is disappointing that the university chose to print an official diary that ascribes to figures from religious scriptures discoveries that belong to modern science, such as nuclear technology, airplanes and cosmetic surgery. The people who did this may think they are being patriotic, but in fact they are bringing disrepute to the university and to India generally. I urge the university to renounce these features in the official diary and consider reprinting the diary.”

Ramakrishnan was responding to a request seeking comment from this newspaper. The request was sent after Professor A C Sharma, dean, Faculty of Science, MSU, told the university senate during an ongoing debate on the diary that he had received an email from Ramakrishnan on the issue.

As The Indian Express reported, the diary hails Sushrut as the “father of cosmetic surgery”; Acharya Kanad as the one who “developed nuclear technology”; Kapil Muni as the “father of cosmology”; Maharshi Bhardwaj as the one who “discovered rockets and aeroplanes”; Charak Rishi as the “father of medicine”; and, Garga Muni, as the “scientist of stars”. The sages share space with eminent scientists like J C Bose, Vikram Sarabhai and C V Raman.

With the issue being raised at a senate meeting Thursday — the diary was not on the agenda — Prof Sharma told the gathering: “We know that this university has great alumni and many people who are associated with us. All of them don’t agree with our activity. Nobel Laureate Venkatraman Ramakrishnan has made a comment in this regard.”

Sharma, quoting Ramakrishnan, said, “Though I fully agree with all those who have sentiments for our history but before making anything public, we should have concrete evidence and whatever we are writing should be scientifically proven facts.”

During the debate, professors of the Faculty of Science contested the claims of senate member Jigar Inamdar, who referred to the Constitution to defend the representation of sages in the diary.

Inamdar produced pages from a reproduction of the Constitution, which depicted illustrations from Ramayana and Mahabharata, asked why an issue was being made about attributing the scientific inventions to sages.

“The Congress party has been objecting to the presence of sages in our diary saying that we are insulting the sages and our Constitution. But on Page 6 of the Constitution, we have a picture depicting the Ramayana and on Page 18, a picture of Mahabharat. So what is wrong with paying a tribute to the sages through the diary?” he asked.

Inamdar holds various positions in the university, including honorary executive director of the Institute of Leadership and Governance; Gujarat government-nominated syndicate member; elected senate member from the donor’s constituency, and, regional director of Indian Council for Cultural Relations (ICCR).

When contacted, Inamdar told The Indian Express that he did not agree with Ramakrishnan’s suggestion. “I personally respect Venki (as Ramakrishnan is popularly known). But just because he is a Nobel Laureate, whatever he says does not become true. He has the right to object. It is my right to say that the MSU diary should have these details about the sages, and it is his right to object to it. But just because he is a Nobel Laureate, we cannot accept whatever he says as truth,” he said.

“It is India’s misfortune that the British introduced the education system in India through (Thomas Babington) Macaulay. They destroyed our existing education system and kept the Western culture in mind. They taught the wrong history to all of us for all these years. Our Hansa Mehta library (in MSU) has several books related to astronomy that prove Indian scientific research. I am proud to be a BJP member and an RSS worker as the party is working hard to bring to light the actual Indian culture. The Congress regime has only pushed forward the Western education agenda.”

According to Inamdar, the debate should only be about whether the sages had been able to prove their research or not. “Who can prove that these Indian researches were not proven in their own time. I staunchly believe that Lord Ram travelled in the Pushpak Viman. There were no Wright brothers at that time. But the Pushpak Viman existed. We need to prove this now.”

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. G
    Mar 26, 2017 at 3:44 pm
    “It is India’s misfortune that the British introduced the education system in India through (Thomas Babington) Macaulay. They destro our existing education system and kept the Western culture in mind." Mr. Inamdar if British had not given us modern education system, we would have been basking only in our religious education today. Agreed that British rule was bad for us, but modern education system in the country is something we need to thank brits for. Will you send your kids to a Gurukul or monastery to take cultural education, instead of top-notch English medium schools, colleges and often foreign universities? Hypocrites..!
    1. M
      Mar 24, 2017 at 3:59 am
      Life's not about air planes, submarines.... there's more to it than what you and me know. What we know is nothing compared to what we don't know.
      1. U
        Mar 24, 2017 at 6:18 am
        The jihadi express again tries it's level best to defame and discredit Hindus.
        1. J
          Mar 24, 2017 at 6:33 am
          Yes we all know that there is more to life than utility and all scientific enquiry is not about utility, also there are boundaries and limits to science, but this exercise to re imagine our past dishonestly is not fooling anyone. It actually shows how little you really value the real achievements of our culture. Both Philosophers and scientists acknowledge that what we know is very little, but they don't go around fabricating whatever they please dishonestly because of that. And if you really believed that philosophical statement which you are trying to hide behind then you wouldn't need to call someone a British stooge to challenge their arguments.
          1. V
            Mar 24, 2017 at 5:08 am
            Till 17 century indians thought earth was flat and sun revolved around earth took some westerner to educate us that earth is round.. indians used to live in caves took some westerner to teach us how to build cities and towns and forts on top of mountains ... indians didnt had any luterature took some westerner to teach us how to read and write lt;br/gt;Ayurveda was cave dwellers eating leaves and roots
            1. Load More Comments