MP House debates stray cows, BJP MLAs say a ‘problem’

The resolution, moved by veteran BJP MLA Shankarlal Tiwari, sought an end to the centuries-old practice of ‘era’, where farmers let loose their cows post-harvest to allow them to graze. The practice, members said, was adding to the number of stray cows.

Written by Milind Ghatwai | Bhopal | Updated: July 23, 2017 4:02 am

“Below Poverty Line (BPL) card holders get ration and other government facilities. Can’t we make a law to force every BPL card holder to rear at least one cow? If they don’t keep cows, they will not get BPL facilities.” This suggestion by BJP MLA Murlidhar Patidar came as members of the Madhya Pradesh Assembly, while discussing a ‘non-government resolution’, admitted that stray cows were raiding agricultural land and proving to be a menace to farmers.

The resolution, moved by veteran BJP MLA Shankarlal Tiwari, sought an end to the centuries-old practice of ‘era’, where farmers let loose their cows post-harvest to allow them to graze. The practice, members said, was adding to the number of stray cows.

While the debate occasionally veered towards cow protection and the supremacy of cow milk, gaumutra (urine) and gobar (dung), the focus was largely on the ill-effects of ‘era’ and the ways in which the problem of stray cows could be tackled. Lawmakers also admitted that monetary and commercial considerations, besides lack of fodder and encroachment on grazing land, were the main reasons why owners were abandoning their cows.

Patidar, whose constituency has the “country’s first cow sanctuary”, said, “The cow has lost the value it once enjoyed because people no longer see any monetary benefit in rearing cows.’’ Patidar, who made the suggestion on forcing BPL families to rear cows, said the sanctuary was yet to become functional but “so many cattle owners inquire about it that I get afraid. (Once it opens), 40, 000 to 50,000 cows will be released in it within 24 hours.’’ The sanctuary, spread over 472 hectares, claims to be able to hold 5,000 cows.

R D Prajapati, the BJP MLA from Chandla in Chhatarpur district, said he was afraid that if the menace of stray cows was not stopped, he would find it difficult to even enter his constituency. “My constituency has two problems: nilgai and stray cattle,” he said, while seeking a cow sanctuary in his constituency. “Let there be no development… just create one sanctuary and this will be the biggest service to farmers,’’ he said, adding “farmers run the risk of snake and scorpion bites but don’t leave their farms because they don’t want stray cows to damage their crops”.

MLA Divyaraj Singh, who represents Sirmour in the Assembly, suggested that cows should be tagged to establish their identity and that cows without owners should be given the status of “wild animals” and kept in enclosures in national parks or forest lands.

Veteran BJP MLA Shankarlal Tiwari, who moved the resolution and later withdrew it after being promised of a “permanent solution” by the animal husbandry minister, said the menace had assumed “alarming proportions”, affecting the very livelihood of farmers. “The government should come out with a law or rules to stop the practice of era,’’ he said, adding that animals that damage crops should be kept in kanji houses, with the government providing subsidy to run them.

Kanji houses are facilities where cattle are kept till owners reclaim them. Animal Husbandry Minister Antarsingh Aarya said a committee with representation from all political parties would be formed to find a permanent solution to the problem. Besides Aarya, the committee would have the agriculture minister and the cow protection board chief as members, he said.

Talking about the steps taken by the government, he said the cow sanctuary in Agar district was nearing completion and would be opened after the monsoons, followed by another sanctuary in Rewa. He said gaushalas and kanji houses for stray cattle were being set up at 107 places along the banks of the Narmada.

Senior BJP MLA Kedarnath Shukla said cattle rearing was “becoming very difficult due to the shortage of fodder and grazing land. Earlier, the practice of era lasted for a very short period; now it goes round the year.’’ Calling it “explosive information”, he said farmers pack their cattle into trucks and release them 10 or 20 km away, never to reclaim them.

Participating in the debate, Congress MLA from Pichhor, K P Singh, said the resolution was moved “not by the need for cow protection but by the difficulty cattle were posing to farmers”. He said, “The government that prided itself on welfare of farmers and protection of cows has been in power for 14 years, but has not been able to find any solution.’’

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. a
    annalyser2017
    Jul 23, 2017 at 9:11 pm
    What a strange at one time you said holy mother and other side you are saying the problem with them. presently it was a stray cows problem, that could be managed with the help of Government, or with some compensatory binding rules. But this is not all the problem, More problems will arise after few decade years when the strength will be increase bombastic and will then be the cause of shortage of food, water, disturbance of living/ growing and several unhuman problems. Presently because their slaughter, movements and exports are stoped, there fore become less beneficial and prices are decries. People will face several other problems later on.
    Reply
    1. S
      Srinivasan N. Iyer
      Jul 23, 2017 at 8:44 pm
      At last there is some sensible and mature discussion on the "cow" problem. One wishes thet also discussed how to stop the violence on this issue
      Reply
      1. P
        Parth Garg
        Jul 23, 2017 at 1:37 pm
        Strange that the BJP men on the one hand call cows as holy mother and on the other are calling cows as problem or a menace. Instead of burdening the already humiliated BPL people they should use their own sources to provide shelter to the stray cows. For information of the vigilantes a news from Kakinada (AP) 59 cows perished because they were left in the filth and rain and were diagnosed with pneumonia.
        Reply
        1. S
          Sagar
          Jul 23, 2017 at 1:02 pm
          The money collected daily in Hindu temples should be used for protecting and feeding cows, particularly the old and weak ones or those which have now immediate owners. Or the government should impose a 'cow tax' on all Hindus to facilitate this. Instead of just worshipping and forgetting their mother they should take responsibility even if it hurts the pocket.
          Reply
          1. R
            Rishi Raj
            Jul 23, 2017 at 12:57 pm
            The problem is real. Mr. Patidar should get credit for having admitted it and suggesting a solution. However, it wouldn't be fair or practical to burden BPL families with the upkeep of cows. BJP should allot each of its member with certain number of cows and bulls, according to their position in the party hierarchy, for maintenance. The party president should look after at least 1000 heads of cattle.
            Reply
            1. A
              Antony
              Jul 23, 2017 at 12:23 pm
              50 lakh cows are roaming around the streets of uttarpradesh eating garbage and plastic ,blocking roads andmakng every place stinking with cow dung! And BJP and RSS wants to create similar situation in every Indian state by forcing their cow laws using their gau rakshaks terrorists! Once the cow is unproductive the poor farmers who doesn't have even money to feed their own mothers will definitely send their gau mata to streets! Only option now is to force all bjp and RSS members to take take two street cows each to their homes to prevent India becoming a shi t filled with gober and stinking with mutra perfume !
              Reply
              1. S
                SAM
                Jul 23, 2017 at 12:20 pm
                This was bound to happen after the ban on cow slaughter. There was no reason for people to raise a hue and cry over the ban. It's understandable people's livelihood will suffer by the ban but the bigger problem: looking after cows past their prime. No government can feed or look after these animals as they are white elephants. In their exuberance to placate their voters BJP made tall promises which they find to their own predicament has become a Frankenstein. Now these fools want to force BPL card holders to rear cows!!! People who can't feed themselves must feed cows!!! Let the brahmins, banias and jains who proposed and backed this law feed them. They don't want even a bengali-hindu to live in their clean and sanctified societies as the bengali is a beef eater. Many laws enacted by BJP government will soon be only on paper and law enforcers will also hesitate to take action on people breaking them. It's only a matter of time.
                Reply
                1. B
                  Bharat
                  Jul 23, 2017 at 12:08 pm
                  Indians abroad, men and women will soon have to start using burkas. They are unable to face the other nationalities. They call us Indians "cows". It is so shameful !! They have left their home country for survival purpose and sending foreign currency to India which is of great help to our nation. Please bring back the glory that Indians had earlier. Please Please.
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments