Maharashtra govt triggers fresh controversy, says madrasas without formal subjects are not schools

Madrasas which do not teach primary subjects such as English, Maths and Science would be considered as "non-schools" and children studying in them as "out of school" students, Maharashtra government today said.

By: Express News Service | Mumbai | Updated: July 3, 2015 12:26 pm
Madrasas, Madrasas to be derecognised, Madrasas de-recognised, maharashtra madrasa, Madrasas BJP, BJP Madrasas, Madrasas news, maharashtra madrasas news, Madrasas de-recognised, maharashtra madrasas, Madrasas de-recognised in maharashtra, maharashtra, out of school, non school, Madrasas, religious school “Madrasas are giving students education on religion and not giving them formal education. Our constitution says every child has the right to take formal education, which madrasas do not provide,” State Minorities Affairs Minister Eknath Khadse said.

Triggering a fresh controversy, Maharashtra is set to declare at least one lakh students in the state as “out of school” children, with the BJP-led government announcing that madrasas that do not offer mathematics, science and social studies will not be recognised as formal schools.

The decision was conveyed in a letter written by the state’s minority affairs department to the school education department, which is conducting a day-long survey on July 4 to determine the number of “out of school” children in the state.

Share This Article
Related Article

With the move sparking fierce criticism from Muslim organisations and Opposition parties, Education Minister Vinod Tawde clarified that “students of madrasas that follow a proper academic curriculum” will not be counted as “out of school”.

Maharashtra’s Secretary (school education) Nand Kumar said Vedic schools teaching only Vedas would also be classified as non-schools.

Tawde added that the state government’s intention was to encourage regular academic subjects such as science, mathematics, social sciences and languages in madrasas, even while they continue to impart religion-based education.

Principal Secretary (minority affairs) Jayshree Mukherjee said that the state was not de-recognising madrasas but only trying to identify those that do not provide access to regular education alongside religious studies.

“A substantial number of madrasas do not provide regular education to students. Our purpose is to first find out the number of students without access to regular education. We will take remedial measures after analysing the numbers,” Mukherjee said.

However, Congress MLA from South Mumbai Amin Patel said it was “ridiculous” that the state government pays madrasas up to Rs 5 lakh each for various upgradation measures, and for teachers’ salaries, and then proposes to term their students as being “out of school”.

“Not only are there many madrasa students who go on to do professional courses, but as many as 536 madrasas received money from the government in 2014-15. Some received Rs 2 lakh, some got Rs 2.5 lakh, others more from the minority affairs department. How can the government now deem these madrasas’ children as out-of-school kids?” Patel asked.

According to the state’s minority affairs department, there are 1,889 registered madrasas across Maharashtra.

Under the Dr Zakir Hussain Madrasa Modernisation Scheme, launched by the previous Congress-NCP government in 2013, any madrasa that wishes to build infrastructure such as a laboratory or library or hostel can seek funds from the government. Assistance can also be sought for teachers’ salaries.

The scheme allows a maximum of Rs 2 lakh for infrastructure, Rs 3 lakh for salaries and Rs 50,000 for purchase of books, a total of Rs 5.5 lakh annually.

In 2014-15, 536 madrasas availed funds through this programme — the government has set aside Rs 20 crore for 2015-16.

While officials say the funds come with a rider that madrasas must offer maths, science and social studies, the government has not monitored compliance with this condition.

Ainul Attar, joint secretary, minority affairs department, said, “Last year was the first full year of the scheme. This year onwards, we are evolving a tighter monitoring mechanism with the help of collectors and the school education department.”

Madrasas in Maharashtra have their own certification, their students finishing as Maulvi, Alim or Fazil, various levels of accomplishment in Islamic studies.

Apart from religious texts, several students also appear for state board matriculation exams privately. There has been a long-standing demand that the state recognise certification provided by madrasas.

“How can they call our students out of school? Are they all illiterates? Madrasas have provided basic education in areas where the state cannot reach. We do not want government help,” said Maulana Mahmood Dariyabadi of the All India Ulema Council.

Maulana Mustaqeem Azmi of the Jamiat ul Ulema said that they would ask the state to scrap the order.

Congress MLA Patel as well as AIMIM MLA from Byculla Waris Pathan said they too would ask the government to rethink the decision.

Tawde, meanwhile, said the government merely wants to ensure that students from all communities get mainstream education through subjects such as science and mathematics.

“The intelligence level of people criticising the move to teach children additional subjects needs to seriously be questioned. I have to abide by the Right to Education legislation passed by Parliament, and I want all children in my state to be educated as per the national curriculum,” said Tawde, who was recently fending off allegations of his own degree being from a derecognised university.

Dilip Kamble, Minister of State for Minority Affairs, who kicked off the controversy on Wednesday when he said in Kolhapur that children from madrasas would be deemed out of school, said the issue was unnecessarily being given a political hue and that the government’s intention is not to discriminate against any particular community.

“Not just madrasas, but children studying in educational institutions of gurudwaras and churches that do not offer mainstream subjects will also be deemed as being out of school,” Kamble told The Indian Express.


For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    Jul 3, 2015 at 10:54 am
    Why pressues always like to link controversy to Muslim and hindus.... such a pig these medias are.... When it clearly state that any insution providing only religious education and not any formal will be considered out 9f school.... “Not just madrasas, but children studying in educational insutions of gurudwaras and churches that do not offer mainstream subjects will also be deemed as being out of school,” #pressute shame. And what's wrong in it...
  2. K
    Jul 3, 2015 at 7:17 am
    When will you muzzies start opening your mind? Get out of that sickular, rotten, hypocritical mind. It is not too late to start seeing the real picture.
    1. K
      Jul 3, 2015 at 7:18 am
      You are a STUPID, do you realize that?
      1. G
        Ghulam Muhammed
        Jul 2, 2015 at 7:22 pm
        Consutional freedom of religion means no state role in the affairs of religion, including its teaching, promotion, and other allied activities. BJP rule is deliberately going against the spirit as well as of the letter of Consutional law, in trying to impose Hindu religion and religious culture on all people of this multi-cultural, multi-ethnic, multi-religious land. The use of 'de-recognition' of Madarsa students as not enrolled in any school system, is a very sinister move to enforce Madarsa students to compulsorily abjure their religious education and force them at some stage to enroll 'mainstream' school system, which is rapidly being Saffronised without any approval by the 69 percent of the voters of this democratic nation that have not voted for BJP and its coalition partners. This move will be strongly resisted by all religious groups that may include caste groups that do not fully subscribe to Brahmin religious mainstreaming.
      2. K
        Kabir Bilal
        Jul 2, 2015 at 7:39 pm
        Our only aim behind doing this is to ensure that every child of the minority community gets a chance and learn to come into mainstream, getting good paying jobs and have a prosperous future, Khadse said. In my opinion, if it is the real goal behind this move then I must say that its a HOLY MOVE and should not be controversial....... State shoud interefare if children from any community are being deprived of mainstream... .. In order to ensure everyone's prosperous future. I would like to add here one more thing that I am a madrasa guy and i got my formal education in madrasa itself in West Bengal... Learnt math, science, geography, history and English along with religious books. Either madrasas should know the fact that formal education is the right of every child and look into the syllabus or the state must interefare.
        1. P
          Jul 3, 2015 at 1:02 pm
          1. The article is biased. 2. It is correct that Madarasas which do not teach Maths, Social Sciences and Science in schools should be de-recognized. We do not want students coming out with believing that the World is flat, was built in 6 days and is only 6000 years old. 3, When students are taught dogma only and have no access to other valid forms of knowledge, they cannot become well adjusted or employable citizens. Those opposing these reforms are the same people who cry out that Muslims are not being emplo. Then they conveniently forget that their education levels have been curtailed to the teaching of dogma. 4. There is one thing that truly surprised me in the Government order. Why is English being promoted. India must have a policy of promoting local languages, Sanskrit and later on, one international language. We cannot continue with a colonized British mindset.
          1. R
            Jul 3, 2015 at 2:14 pm
            Y does this article say it is controversial decisions. Indian governments gave 60 years for our Muslim brothers to come out of their mindset, and adapt to new education system. It is true that Madrasas do not teach more than basic knowledge. If the Muslim community has to grow and prosper, they have to adapt new education means. Media talks of bringing up all communities, when government takes some decisions media starts calling controversies and blah blah. What is the purpose of this bias article? Is media doing any good for any community or just trying to malign the image of majorities? non congress govts? Media is among the worst bias media of all.
            1. S
              Jul 2, 2015 at 4:23 pm
              Hatredness? Which Madrasa did you get your education from?
              1. Load More Comments