• Associate Sponsor

Utkal Express derailment: ‘Block ka time nahin hai, gaadiyan bahut hain’

Audio clip shows request to stop rail traffic for maintenance work was denied

Written by Avishek G Dastidar , Mallica Joshi | Updated: August 22, 2017 8:52 am
Utkal express, utkal express accident, utkal train derailment, kalinga utkal express accident, rail traffic, Khatauli station, indian railways, railway accident Workers repairing the rail track after the Puri-Haridwar Utkal Express train derailed in Khatauli near Muzaffarnagar, on Sunday. PTI Photo

“Sir, (Kalinga Utkal Express) Meerut city se nikal rahi hai.”
“De dein, Sir, 15 minute ka inko (block)?”
“Nahin nahin, block ka time hi nahin hai… gaadiyan bahut hain.”

An audio clip of a purported conversation between Khatauli station master Prakash Singh and a section controller for Northern Railway in Delhi — which reportedly took place minutes before the Kalinga Utkal Express derailed at Khatauli on Saturday, killing 22 people — indicates that the ground staff had asked for rail traffic to be “blocked” for carrying out maintenance work, but the request was denied.

Shailesh Kumar Pathak, Commissioner of Railway Safety (CRS), also confirmed that the Permanent Way Inspector (PWI), who is responsible for track maintenance, had asked for a 20-minute “block” — a temporary stoppage of all trains — to replace a damaged section of the track on Saturday.

Sources said Pathak has obtained the PWI’s written request submitted to the Khatauli station master.

While Railways officials said they were trying to verify the authenticity of the audio clip, sources said the Khatauli station staff have identified one of the voices as the station master.

In another purported conversation, the two officials can be heard discussing the PWI’s request for a “block” .

Sir, yeh PWI 20 minute ka block maangte hain (the PWI is asking for a 20-minute block),” says a man, purportedly station master Prakash Singh.

Ye kaunsa block hai (Which block is this)?” asks another man, purportedly a section controller for Northern Railway in Delhi.

“Main line, loop line sab bandh ho jayengi. Main keh raha hoon gaadiyon ka group hai, kaise mil jayega block (Main line, loop line, everything will close. I have said there is a group of trains, how will we get a block),” says Singh.

The request for a “block” is again shot down in a subsequent conversation.

“Sir, (Kalinga Utkal Express) Meerut city se nikal rahi hai (Kalinga Utkal Express is leaving Meerut city),” says the section controller.

“De dein, Sir, 15 minute ka inko (block) (Should we give a 15-minute block)?” asks the station master.

Nahin Nahin, block ka time hi nahin hai bhai sahib, gaadiyan bahut hain (no, there is no time for a block, there are many trains),” the controller replies.

The PWI, Pradeep Kumar, who was among the four officials suspended on Monday, could not be contacted.

Khatauli Station Supervisor Rajendra Singh, who said on Sunday that the station staff had no information about any ongoing work on the tracks, refused to speak to the media on Monday.

“Lives have been lost only because of a human failure. Work was started on the track without permission. If the PWI’s request for a block is refused, he doesn’t have the authority to cut the track without informing the station master,” said Commissioner of Railway Safety Pathak, who visited the spot on Monday.

Confirming that the PWI had asked for a 20-minute block, Pathak said: “The request was placed at 5.10 pm but it was refused as it was a busy time. It is the job of a PWI to make sure the track can take the train’s load. If he thought this was not the case and a block was still denied, he should have followed the standard operating procedure. Red flags should have been placed at a distance of 1,200 m and 600 m from the spot and crackers should have been placed on the tracks to alert the driver and stop the train. This was not done.”

Pointing to the audio clips and the PWI’s written request, a source close to the CRS said that “the primary responsibility will fall not just on the track maintenance people but also on the operations control staff who denied the request”.

Sources said the crack in the “glued joint” of the track was meant to be repaired for some time now. The track maintenance team had arranged a generator, rail welding machine and other equipment, and had sent the written request. “It has been found that as per official log data, signal was failing frequently because of the faulty joint and the PWI was trying to do a ‘forced block’,” said the official. “Yes, he should have raised the red flag and stopped traffic… But the people who denied the block are also responsible.”

The last train that passed Khatauli safely on Saturday was a passenger train which left the station at 4.46 pm.

According to sources, a crack had been noticed in the track at the accident site — 300 metres from the railway station — on June 12, when a resident of the area flagged down a train by waving a red shirt.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. S
    Aug 22, 2017 at 4:11 pm
    Railways have been used during qualition era politics of UPA as political tool rather than mass transportation network which deserves to be run as such without political interference. A separate Railway budget had given Rail mantri an undeclared status of a great maharaja. Only after Modi became PM the Railway Department has been brought down from this high pedestal. But this change at the top has not sunk in down the line and railways at the ground level run as recklessly as in the past. Inspit of so many major accidents during the last one year the staff at the lower level have not been sensitised towards safety of passengers. How could trains be allowed to travel on a track which had cracked joints? There has been utter negligence on the part of the lower management because they lack basic operational knowledge and sense of responsibility. Only fools blame political leadership for such things. There had been virtually no investment in railways for last 30 years.
    1. Damodar Biswal
      Aug 22, 2017 at 3:48 pm
      Suspending or transferring some officials will not help.All these people should be tried for criminal negligence of duty.
      1. Garry Garry
        Aug 22, 2017 at 3:14 pm
        Where are Twitter Raja Modi and Hero Suresh Prabhu?
        1. R
          Aug 22, 2017 at 2:41 pm
          China has 4 rail universities. They have 60 of bullet trains of the world .we are planning to upgrade British era railways . Prabhu was supposed to deliver but he is like all others .
          1. Satindra Paul Singh
            Aug 22, 2017 at 2:28 pm
            Very very hopeless procedures.No body is taking responsibility.A ic railway management system from the colonial times.No medernisation and fatal flaws in the system.Politician and bureaucrats nexus to the detriment of the public.More than 100 people died and authorities are lying as usual that 23 died.
            1. Load More Comments