J&K govt data shows: Firing across LoC has limited impact, fails to deter Pakistan

Incidents of firing across the LoC have risen steadily since 2012, when 79 were registered, to 236 in 2013, 226 in 2014, and 279 in 2015, according to data gathered by the J&K government.

Written by Praveen Swami | New Delhi | Updated: July 3, 2017 11:51 am
loc, line of control firing, ceasefire violation, ceasefire violations, india news 124 exchanges of fire in 6 months, 113 along LoC, Jammu border: Data

FIRING ACROSS the Line of Control (LoC) has escalated dramatically since India’s strikes on jihadist training camps in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir in September, classified data obtained by The Indian Express has revealed. The data suggests that the policy of “massive retaliation” for cross-border firing set in place in 2014 is failing to deter the Pakistan Army from harrying Indian counter-infiltration defences on the LoC.

The data, compiled by the J&K government, shows that there have been 124 exchanges of fire from January to June 21, 2017 — all but 11 along the LoC and international border in the Jammu sector, under the control of the Nagrota-based XVI Corps.

In contrast, there were only five exchanges of fire in the same period of 2016, before India’s cross-LoC strikes sparked a wave of assaults using mortar and machine guns, as well as ambushes targeting Indian patrols by so-called Pakistani Border Action Teams, or special forces units mixed with irregulars. Localised but lethal skirmishes now form the core of a grim war of attrition on the border in Jammu — a region with near-zero jihadist infiltration — as soldiers fight to avenge past attacks, or establish tactical advantage for their posts and patrol routes in anticipation of future ones.

The latest fighting, sparked by the June 23 ambush which claimed the lives of two soldiers, is reported to be continuing intermittently, with shelling at the end of the month claiming the life of Naseem Akhter, a Poonch resident, and Abdul Wahab, living across the LoC in Nakyal. Kashmir, guarded by the XV Corps, is seeing the LoC regularly probed by jihadist infiltrators, the raison d’etre for aggressive retaliation — but here, there is little fighting between the two armies.

Incidents of firing across the LoC have risen steadily since 2012, when 79 were registered, to 236 in 2013, 226 in 2014, and 279 in 2015, according to data gathered by the J&K government. The first six months of 2016 were quiet, but overall numbers rose sharply to 227 after the strikes.

The J&K government’s data, based on direct observation by intelligence units, reflects significant fire exchanges which may pose a risk to civilians, rather than all violations of the ceasefire India and Pakistan entered into in 2013, which include relatively minor incidents.

Lok Sabha replies provided by the government show that those incidents have also escalated, from 347 in 2013, to 583 in 2014, 405 in 2015 and 449 in 2016 — again showing that India’s more muscular posture has so far failed to deter the Pakistan Army.

“The enemy has realised that times have changed and their old habits will not be tolerated… People know my intentions,” Prime Minister Narendra Modi had, following the first cross-border clashes of his tenure. The government had authorised forces to use disproportionate force against Pakistani military fire, and declined to engage in dialogue while the fighting continued — a break with past patterns.

Major-General Ashok Narula, the Indian Army’s chief spokesperson, said in May that “punitive fire assaults across the Line of Control are being undertaken by the Indian army”. He released a video that showed Indian artillery destroying temporary bunkers on a tree-covered mountain, shot, military sources said, on May 9, a week after the beheading of two Indian soldiers by a Border Action Team.

In 2003, when India and Pakistan agreed on their unwritten ceasefire, 2,045 exchanges of fire were recorded, which claimed the lives of 59 Indian troops and 40 civilians.

“I believe these fire-exchanges are serving absolutely no demonstrable strategic purpose. Their only purpose is to fuel a certain nationalist posturing in both India and Pakistan,” said Ajai Sahni, director, Institute of Conflict Management in New Delhi.

The data shows six Indian soldiers have been killed in the fire exchanges so far this year, and 12 injured, while 10 were killed and 56 injured in 2016.

“It is unimportant if more Pakistanis were killed or Indians. The loss of a single Indian soldier’s life without a strategic aim is a criminal waste,” said Sahni.

The firing across the LoC, interestingly, comes at a time of relatively low infiltration. Even though the Indian Army has reported multiple infiltration attempts along the LoC in Kashmir this summer, Home Minister Rajnath Singh announced that infiltration in January-June 2017 has been 45 per cent lower than in the same period of 2016.

“Largely, the firing on the Line of Control is taking place because both sides have become locked in a tit-for-tat cycle of retaliation, with neither willing to back off,” said a senior military official.

For the Pakistan Army, continuing to hit back is of critical importance in the wake of last year’s cross-LoC strikes, to demonstrate that it is willing to willing to risk escalation despite the weakness of its military position.

Estimated to deploy some 200,000-225,000 troops along the LoC, the Indian Army’s XV and XVI Corps have overwhelming numerical superiority against Pakistan.

Pakistan’s X Corps, made up of the 23 Infantry Division, 12 Infantry Division, 19 Infantry Division and Force Command Gilgit-Baltistan, only has some 100,000-125,000 troops, experts believe.

General Asim Bajwa, Pakistan’s Army chief, who came to office soon after the cross-LoC strikes, placed Kashmir high on his agenda, amid fears in his command that India could react to a future terrorist strike with a larger-scale attack in the Neelam valley.

The Pakistan Army chief, in visits to the Haji Pir sector in April, the Kel sector in March, and the shelling-hit Bhimber sector in December and February, is believed to have ordered commanders to harry Indian defences, rather than back down in the face of artillery assault.

Indian commanders, in turn, fearing that further escalation could hamper their counter-infiltration posture and render maintenance of the LoC fence difficult, have resisted the temptation to deploy heavier-calibre artillery.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. G
    Jul 5, 2017 at 4:43 pm
    Six month ago my boyfriend told me it was over between us and he was avoiding me, each time i call his phone he will say he know i love him and he love me too but he just can not continue the relationship because he has find someone else. I did all i could to make him come back but nothing happened until i came across Doctor Okumu and seek his help. I did all that Doctor Okumu as me to do and he assured me that my boyfriend will call me and beg for forgiveness within 12 to 16 hours and everything happened just as he said, he also told me i will win a lottery which also happened. I am filled with joy and realize that Doctor Okumu is like a God on earth so i made a vow to my self that i will let the world know about this.Do you need any help then contact Doctor Okumu today for help via email: doctorokumuspelltemple or via : : doctorazuaworldofpowerfulspell.webs or via whatsapp 1-631-800-5540..
    1. A
      Jul 3, 2017 at 6:28 pm
      Nostradamus once said that a man from Gujarat will come and win China. Lets prepare for all out war, World is with those who wants to fight for their cause, for their genuine reasons. One who cowers down for genuine reason is treated like Dhobi ka Kutta. After independence the only thing this society had to learn again is defend itself, you are a country, you are part of United Nations, you try friendliness doesn't ensure anything. History is witness to all this, friendliness with China is a waste of time and so is that with Pakistan.
      1. A
        Jul 3, 2017 at 6:26 pm
        This gives me the feeling that Cross Border firing has to be increased and we need more precision attacks, every time increasing the casualties on the Pakistani side. Remember as many high officers we manage to kill, more the pressure will be felt on the other side. It should get to the bone of the people who are making policy. We should plan something big, this time we should kill more of them. Just on the side line can we find out ways to eliminate huddin, strategists and planner has to do that. If we can kill him using guided systems say located from Satellite and a missile fired from the Ground, he will have tough time dealing with the Situation.
        1. M
          Jul 3, 2017 at 12:53 pm
          An important role in the Indian epic story of the Mahabharata. In addition, there is the legend that the Pakistani city of Lahorewas first founded by Lava, while Kasur was founded by his twin Kusha, both of whom were the sons of Rama of the Ramayana. The Gandhara kingdom of the northwest, and the legendary Gandhara peoples, are also a major part of Hindu literature such as the Ramayana and the Mahabharata. Most Pakistani city names (such as Peshawar[9] and Multan[10]) can be traced back to Sanskrit roots.
          1. L
            l s
            Jul 3, 2017 at 11:13 am
            The J K govt is unfit for this data collection. In one way or the other, they will do things which will lower our guard and help the pakis. Not to be taken seriously.
            1. Mohammad Dar
              Jul 3, 2017 at 11:23 am
              Sure, who wants to be with the hogs of hinduism racism by faith, not the human being, but of their own hindu immoral low life kind, pretending to be, the human being. .
            2. Load More Comments