Unethical, betrayal: Manmohan Singh’s daughter voices family anger

The accidental PM: Upinder Singh claims Baru told her book will be out after polls.

Written by Ritu Sarin | New Delhi | Updated: April 15, 2014 8:09 pm
Even as the PM’s family is preparing to move out of Race Course Road, it was the safekeep of his books that was uppermost in the Prime Ministers mind. Even as the PM’s family is preparing to move out of Race Course Road, it was the safekeep of his books that was uppermost in the Prime Ministers mind.

In the first reaction from the family of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, his eldest daughter Upinder Singh has severely criticised the book written by his former aide Sanjaya Baru, calling it “nothing but a stab in the back…a huge betrayal of trust’’ and a “mischievous, unethical’’ exercise.

Speaking to The Indian Express at her residence in Delhi University, where she teaches history, Upinder Singh said that the timing as well as the contents of the book raise issues of the author violating both the trust of the Prime Minister as well as the access he enjoyed.

“While I am not speaking on behalf of the Prime Minister, we are extremely angry at the exaggerated level of access the author has ascribed to himself,” she said. “It is an audacious account with so-called quotes, of even the Prime Minister, which have been recorded as facts. Reported speech has been used as direct speech. Is this ethical?’’

Clearly miffed at the timing of the publication of the book (titled The Accidental Prime Minister) the Prime Minister’s daughter said that since it hit the market in the middle of the general elections, it could hardly be described as an “unbiased or objective book”. She countered comments of the author that the publisher decided the timing of the release by saying, “I have written several books and know that authors have a say in the timing of the release. To me, there are other reasons for the timing. It is absurd to say there is no political motive. Sanjaya Baru cannot describe himself as a well-wisher of the Prime Minister.’’

She added: “We all knew a book was in the air and he (Sanjaya Baru) met me recently at a wedding. When I asked him when the book would be out, he said, ‘Naturally, after the elections.’ What we did not know is that he was going to piece together gossip and unverified quotes, including some of my father, and use them as statements of fact.’’

In an attempt to distance the Prime Minister from the events described in the book, Upinder pointed out that the author was never part of the decision-making process in the PMO. Her view: “He is holding forth and projecting himself in the centre of events which is not true and he had no access to files. It is not as if he was the Principal Secretary to the Prime Minister. So what are the sources he has used? I spot an element of self-promotion in these assertions.’’

Giving an indication that she had been following the controversies and talk-shows held after the launch of the book, Upinder said that the author has admitted he nursed a deep sense of resentment on not being re-inducted into the PMO in 2009. “If he himself felt betrayed how can he write an objective account? Even if he wants to gain politically by writing such a book everyone will see that he has betrayed the trust of one Prime Minister. He has provided fodder to his (Prime Minister’s) opponents. Will they trust him now? I would not.’’

While Upinder clarified that she did not want to discuss specific events or episodes described in the book she pointed out, “The impression I have is that the relation between the Prime Minister and Sonia Gandhi is one of utmost trust and respect. The book also gives an impression that the Prime Minister wanted to cling to office in his second term. This is such a misreading of his personality.’’

Meanwhile, even as the PM’s family is preparing to move out of Race Course Road, it was the safekeep of his books that was uppermost in the Prime Ministers mind, she said. “I do not think he is planning to write anything immediately but he is busy sorting out his books and papers. He has a huge book collection and wants each book to be taken care of in the new house.’’

She added that as Prime Minister, her father never took time off for holidays. They were all hoping to, finally, soon take off for a family holiday maybe to a hill station like Shimla. “My son is planning several things he can do with his grandfather once he retires…My mother is also looking forward to a period when the pressures of the job are no longer there.’’

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. R
    Rahul Singh
    Apr 15, 2014 at 5:05 am
    This man, Man Mohan has betra the trust of billions of Indians, to lick feet of Sonia. You should not try to defend a person like him. Get over it.
    Reply
    1. R
      Rahul Singh
      Apr 15, 2014 at 12:27 am
      Upinder. Sorry to say, but this man should have never our PM. We needed a leader, not a P***** on a leash.
      Reply
      1. I
        Indus
        Apr 15, 2014 at 5:02 am
        Madam Upinder Singh!! Actually Mr. Baru has done a great service and good for Manmohanji! At least some people now sympathise his plight! Why he not taken the option of quitting from the humiliations is anybody's guess.
        Reply
        1. R
          Rita
          Apr 15, 2014 at 9:54 am
          Wow, his daughter spoke more in the single interview than him in all 10 years put together. Such are the times when we automatically take a silent man as a weak man and a shouter as a strong man. More power to this lady!
          Reply
          1. p
            priyabrata_tripathy
            Apr 15, 2014 at 4:02 am
            A nation that has gone mad; dishonoring a PM who gave his w lifetime in the development of this diverse country, while heaping praise on a low grade man who can not even speak truth accidentally.We can not let temporary setbacks in the hand of such evil to the GOOD to overwhelm us. It should prop us to fight the EVIL with more conviction and vigor.
            Reply
            1. C
              Chandrasekharan K>R.
              Apr 15, 2014 at 5:38 am
              So PM's daughter knows about everything that happens in PMO.
              Reply
              1. J
                Jaggu
                Apr 15, 2014 at 7:18 am
                I salute you sir for your esteem service to the country.....Dr. Manmohan Singh, you are a gem this country can ever get....respect respect and only respect for you sir..
                Reply
                1. B
                  Bala
                  Apr 15, 2014 at 4:32 am
                  With all respects for Prime Minister Shri Manmohan Ji. For me no questions raises about his sincerity and integrity. He was elected as the Prime Minister and carried the trust of the w of Indian Potion along with him. Such information has broken the trust of the common Indian in him. If Mrs. Sonia hi is unnecessarily interfering in his governance, he should either demand his independence or relieve himself of the duties of PM. Accepting back then and resenting now is to no good. Mr. Baru serves the Indian Government, which was put in place by the People of India. Just because he works in PMO's office does not make his hide information. This information has to reach the people especially at this crucial juncture when they are making the decision for the new government. So ... Mr. Baru has done the right thing by being sincere to his job, by being sincere to the people of India. As long as the information he says he correct, he cannot be blamed for anything. Rather he should be thanked for guiding India in the right path.
                  Reply
                  1. B
                    Bharatiyq
                    Apr 15, 2014 at 6:22 am
                    Truth, specially truth about the country should always be told and no one should get angry.
                    Reply
                    1. B
                      Bubbly Wall
                      Apr 17, 2014 at 7:10 pm
                      What language?? You sound ugghhh woman.!! Sonia wasn't accepted in our country. So what if he took advice fron mrs. Sonia. She was the party president.
                      Reply
                      1. C
                        chintu
                        Apr 15, 2014 at 2:03 am
                        behenji.. apne papa ko thoda samjate to ye kitaab likhne ki naubat na aati
                        Reply
                        1. A
                          Ayyappa
                          Apr 15, 2014 at 5:15 am
                          Myself as a citizen of India living overseas also feel let down. What a lack lusture performance. The way he tried to induct Thomas as CVC and all the scams of himalayan proportions are very shameful. His not owning up reasponsibility is unpardonable. How can he be a PM when he dare not face the people in an election? Is he not accidental and owing graude to Italian madam?
                          Reply
                          1. G
                            Gautam
                            Apr 15, 2014 at 10:51 am
                            Manmohan singh is not a honest or good man. i dont hve any respect for him. he is equally responsible to push Country in of corruption ,inflation,public frustration,anger and many more problems
                            Reply
                            1. V
                              Viswa Gi
                              Apr 15, 2014 at 4:36 am
                              Now Upinder, daughter of MMS ,knows more than Sanjay Baru when she 'pointed out that the author was never part of the decision-making process in the PMO'. Why was she as silent as MMS when he worked as a puppet of Sonia and spoiled the great Indian Nation.
                              Reply
                              1. R
                                Ramsubramani Harihara Iyer
                                Apr 15, 2014 at 3:24 am
                                It appears that Ms Upinder is not against this book,but the timing of the publication.That means she indirectly agrees with the contents. Now that Mr Manmohan Singh has announced his retirement from politics,he is not going to hold any further postings. Then why the timing of publication should anger Ms Upinder?
                                Reply
                                1. N
                                  Never Again
                                  Apr 15, 2014 at 3:31 am
                                  I feel very sorry for MM. This is clearly a timed operation and suddenly everyone is gunning for the poor man. Its not like we did not know that he was an accidental PM.
                                  Reply
                                  1. K
                                    Kapil Dev Suri
                                    Apr 15, 2014 at 7:49 am
                                    Madam ji the truth is always bitter .
                                    Reply
                                    1. K
                                      KaranJatt
                                      Apr 15, 2014 at 4:38 am
                                      damage is already done, though its sad people like Baru stoop to such levels.
                                      Reply
                                      1. S
                                        swamy nk
                                        Apr 15, 2014 at 10:41 am
                                        No Indian new the name Upender singh and her relationship with MMS or her status as a teacher of history until she came out to defend the indefensible and pliable PM .Hope she may try to save her dad's prestige, if any, by writing a history booklet on his decade long self service in India.
                                        Reply
                                        1. T
                                          T J
                                          Apr 15, 2014 at 6:30 am
                                          This is my take itself.. As an unbiased commentator, even if I ume everything written there is true then too the book and the author looses his complete credibility by timing the release of the book in the middle of election.. No Ullu banawing...Mr Vinod Rai former CAG has also written a book but he said I will not release till elections are over..
                                          Reply
                                          1. N
                                            N Ram
                                            Apr 15, 2014 at 2:59 am
                                            Sanjay Baru might have back-stabbed your dad but your dad back-stabbed 125 crore Indians by being loyal to one Italian family. Vote for NaMo and save India!
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments