• Associate Sponsor

Book review: Strictly Personal, Manmohan and Gursharan

Daman Singh’s biography of her father Manmohan offers interesting nuggets about her parents, but does not venture into his fraught life as leader of the nation

Written by Coomi Kapoor | Updated: August 18, 2014 1:42 pm
Singh with daughters Upinder and Daman, Coney Island, New York,1967 Singh with daughters Upinder and Daman, Coney Island, New York,1967

Book: Strictly Personal: Manmohan and Gursharan
Author: Daman Singh
Publisher: Harper Collins
Pages: 456
Price: Rs 699

The Narendra Modi biography industry was in full spate when the Prime Minister was still on the campaign trail. In contrast, Manmohan Singh was prime minister for 10 years, in which no one thought of bringing out a biography of the reclusive academician-turned-civil-servant-turned-politician. His daughter, Daman Singh, has now decided to fill the lacuna. Daman, a writer and rural development worker, had a tough time convincing her father to talk about the past. Her mother Gursharan Kaur was more forthcoming and provided her insights into Singh’s life, career and marriage. Unfortunately, since Daman has refrained from writing about her father’s crucial years as prime minister, her take on her parents’ lives loses much of its popular appeal.

However, Singh’s rise from the small village of Gah, now in Pakistan, to become a key economist and bureaucrat of the country, is as remarkable a progression as Modi’s much-touted makeover from humble chaiwalla to prime minister. Singh’s early education was in the village school at Gah, which could provide only rudimentary lessons. His father Gurmukh Singh had just about made it through middle school to become a clerk for a commission agent dealing in dry fruit. His grandfather was illiterate. At the age of 11, Singh moved to Peshawar, where his father remarried and had a second family.There was much tragedy in Singh’s early years. His mother died when he was very young. Partition uprooted the family, which lost what little it had. His father went missing for months, his stepmother lost her mental balance. But Singh seems to have borne his lot with stoicism. When he took his final school exams in Peshawar, he had to make his way to the examination centre through streets littered with corpses.

Throughout his student life, Singh established his academic brilliance. He topped the exams in Panjab University and later obtained a first in his Tripos in economics at St John’s College, Cambridge University.

Cambridge was a completely alien environment but he enjoyed himself, even though he was hard pressed for cash. Sometimes, he survived on chocolate bars till he received his meagre remittance from home. When he returned from England, Singh was quite a matrimonial catch. Gursharan Kaur was beautiful, loved music and had an outgoing personality. The first question Singh asked his prospective wife was, “What division did you get in BA?’’ The reply — “Second class’’ — seemed to have satisfied him, though he did go to her college to check out her academic credentials with the principal. The marriage blossomed despite their very different temperaments.

Singh’s doctoral thesis at Oxford was on Indian export trends. As an expert on international trade, he received job offers from both the government and international agencies. His distinguished career included stints with the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), the Delhi School of Economics, the Finance Ministry, the Planning Commission and the Reserve Bank of India. Remarkably, Singh worked in key positions in the Finance Ministry under different regimes, whose political and economic philosophies were sharply opposed. Even Charan Singh, who believed in cottage industries and not in large-scale industries, came to rely on him. Singh has a pronounced pragmatic streak, which made him an economist for all seasons. As he explained to his daughter, “Since I was working on economic policies I felt that one should write about things which would be considered for acceptance. There was no use talking in a language in which you would simply not be heard.’’

The turning point in Singh’s career was in 1991 when, in a surprise move, Prime Minister Narasimha Rao asked him to be finance minister. International confidence in the country was at an all-time low, Indian gold had to be pledged with the Bank of England, the rupee was in free fall and there was a danger of India defaulting on its payment commitments. It was Singh who, with Rao’s backing, led the country on the road to economic reform. The measures he advocated were against the fundamental economic principles which the Congress had stood for in the past.

Perhaps, because of her natural awe and regard for her father, Daman’s book fails to provide a flesh-and-blood portrayal of Singh’s enigmatic and retiring personality. She acknowledges that within the family, her dynamic mother is the focal point, acting as go-between between the taciturn father and his three lively daughters, each with a mind of her own. But it is hard to sustain the reader’s interest with dry accounts of the institutions for which Singh worked and the jobs he held without even a single mention of the much-debated relationship between Sonia Gandhi and the man she appointed prime minister.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App

  1. Kamalakant Chitnis
    Aug 26, 2014 at 1:51 pm
    It is indeed sorry _tale that the Indians are not open enough of their life path acknowledging the rights and wrongs done at their hands . The tale of the scholarly Ex_prime minister must be really mind catching to read him between the lines of his behaviour "UNDER" the illiterate lady of the por politics Mrs Sonia hi and become a laughing stock of her arrogant son and the political community as a w! The man Late Mr Narsihn Ro who promoted and invented him too got a rough deal though he is one who navigated India successfuly during the crises througj the economic upheavals!
    1. N
      Aug 23, 2014 at 7:29 am
      We can confidently say that Dr.MMS, when he left his post, looked a below average person who would do any thing to keep his job. He was careful through out his tenure to be on the right side of the high command and had remained a rubber stamp. Even at times when his authority was questioned he kept quiet. And at other times, when his actions were rubbished he could not be woken up from his avowed silence. What a great fall indeed!He is a perfect example of how a high position would alter a man! The PM post, being the most powerful job in India, carries a lot of perks with it. So, he was prepared to enjoy the perks even at the prospect of losing his authority. He had set a ver very wrong precedent.My being a former employee of public and private sector companies, I can say with absolute faith and confidence that I had seen several people, even at the lowest rung of the organisation, who had resisted forcefully when their authority (that went with their job) was tried to be taken away and had gotten them back by lawful means. Only cowards had yielded.
      1. Ramesh Kumar
        Oct 9, 2014 at 12:22 pm
        Unfortunately , we worship braggarts and flambuoyant personalities. The book is interesting as well as informative.
        1. S
          Aug 17, 2014 at 7:06 am
          The story told in the book is same as other hundreds of biographies in India: it has not to be Prime Ministership in each case. As a matter of fact there is not very extraordinary in it. What I was interested was an answer to the question: How it happened that a highly inteligent person could lend himself to be a puppet of Sonia hi and, henceforth, work not for the good of the country (which was his actuell job) but to serve the interests of a family. How could he close his eyes to the corrupt practices in his vicinity and thus became the head of the most corrupt government. What I wanted to read in this biography was on this aspect. Perhaps he was a wrong person for the wrong job. Why did he not resign, when he found out that he is not the "real PM". A true biography from inside the family should give true insights of the character of the person. But alas they remain unanswered.
          1. S
            Sunaina Panthy
            Aug 26, 2014 at 4:24 am
            India got the Change, when Dr. Man Mohan Singh was Finance minister in 1991.
            1. Load More Comments