Landmark study lies buried: How Delhi’s poisonous air is damaging its children for life

Just under half of the 44 lakh schoolchildren studied are growing up into adults with irreversible lung damage.

Written by Aniruddha Ghosal , Pritha Chatterjee | New Delhi | Updated: April 2, 2015 5:20 pm
Delhi air pollution, Delhi pollution, air pollution, pollution delhi, schoolchildren pollution, pollution children health, pollution kids health, RSPM curve, respiratory ailments, respiratory diseases, air pollution disease, health problem pollution, pollution health problem, pollution lung disease, lung problem pollution, green delhi, delhi green, delhi pollution level, delhi environment pollution, environmental pollution, pollution city delhi, pollution delhi environment, delhi news, india news, nation news Children in Noida, Sector 32A, return from school last week. The study recommended schools be moved off arterial roads. (source: IE photo by Gajendra Yadav)

It doesn’t get bigger than this, in size, scale and rigour — scientists from one of India’s top cancer institutes tracked 11,000 schoolchildren in Delhi for three years. They were drawn from 36 schools, each within 3 km of a pollution-tracking station.

This unprecedented study, by the Kolkata-based Chittaranjan National Cancer Institute (CNCI), found that key indicators of respiratory health, lung function to palpitation, vision to blood pressure, children in Delhi, between four and 17 years of age, were worse off than their counterparts elsewhere — the figures were twice to four times as bad.

Also Read: ‘We made it clear kids were suffering… absolutely nothing was followed up’

The conclusion was chilling: “It is… unlikely that the deficits in lung function at the age of 17 years that has been found in a large number of schoolchildren of Delhi will be reversed as they complete the transition into adulthood.”

VIDEO: How Delhi’s poisonous air is damaging its children for life

In other words, just under half of the children studied — there are 44 lakh schoolchildren in the capital — are growing up into adults with irreversible lung damage.

And yet no one woke up.

An investigation by The Indian Express has found that the study gathered dust for two years since it was submitted to the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), which ironically had commissioned it. The study was handed over in 2010, the very year RSPM (the killer dust in the air, respirable suspended particulate matter) was zooming to record levels.

Also Read: Why Children: Lower immunity, shorter height and generally more vulnerable

Even the schools that were surveyed or parents of the children studied weren’t told about the findings because no one passed on the results. Or the recommendations which included radical steps such as moving schools off arterial roads.

For the scientists who did that study, nothing could have been more frustrating.

Starting 2002, they visited school after school in Delhi, often taking the Rajdhani Express all the way back to their institute in Kolkata with blood samples for testing. Its startling findings:
♦  In lung tests conducted on 5,718 students, 43.5% suffered from “poor or restrictive lungs”.
♦ About 15% of the children surveyed complained of frequent eye irritation, 27.4% of frequent headache, 11.2% of nausea, 7.2% of palpitation and 12.9% of fatigue.
♦  Delhi’s numbers were far higher than that among the ‘control group’ of 4,536 students selected from 17 schools spread across the “much less polluted” rural areas of Uttaranchal and West Bengal.

Also Read: What The Study Found: 2 times more asthma, 3 times more severe lung disorder

Kept in the dark about these facts, the schools surveyed in Delhi now want the government to “formulate an appropriate policy” to save their students. Even representatives from schools that were not part of that survey say they are now “extremely concerned” about how air pollution is affecting the health of their students.

‘Nobody from govt contacted us’

Dr Manas Ranjan Ray, the principal co-investigator of the study, said that the survey of schoolchildren was one of the two studies they had conducted in that period across different groups in Delhi — the other was on 6,000 adults that found 33.2% prevalence of symptoms indicating respiratory ailments.

While there have been a number of studies on the impact of air pollution on adults in Delhi —- as this newspaper reported on Tuesday —- the one on schoolchildren was the first of this magnitude that focused solely on this segment.

“We gave specific recommendations on when children should go out and play, in what periods schools should conduct outdoor activities, what medical checks students should be subjected to and where schools should be constructed to avoid vehicular air pollution. Absolutely nothing was followed up on. Nobody from the government ever contacted us,” Dr Ray told The Indian Express.

“We were never invited to any meetings related to policy reforms after we submitted the final report,” added Dr Ray.

The CNCI is a regional cancer institute governed jointly by the Union Health Ministry and West Bengal’s Department of Health. Dr Ray retired from the institute last year as assistant director in charge of research and head of its experimental hematology and neuroendocrinology wing.

“We made some practical and pointed recommendations, short and long term, after critically evaluating our findings vis-a-vis international studies. We hoped that even partial implementation of these proposals would improve the situation. Unfortunately, we are in complete darkness about the fate of these recommendations as nobody from the CPCB felt it necessary to contact us in the matter,” said Dr Ray.
He added that the report “came in the public domain after two years of submission to CPCB”.

“We heard that the report was sent to Indian Council for Medical Research (ICMR) and elsewhere for peer review. Usually, such reviews are done by the scientists who have done similar work and are recognised as authorities in the field based on their publications. The CPCB ultimately found some experts who took their own time. After a year or two, the experts made the comment that it was a good study. It was only then that the authority was convinced that the study was indeed not so bad, and decided to make it public without any editing,” Dr Ray said.

When contacted, CPCB member secretary, A B Akolkar, confirmed that the “study was commissioned and published by CPCB”. “After field work, publication takes natural time. CPCB has brought out several reports in this period,” he said.

Said Dr B Sengupta, who was the CPCB chairperson from 1998-2008 when the study was commissioned and conducted: “The government took the decision to get the study vetted by ICMR under the Ministry of Health before publishing it. It was due to this that the publication was delayed. But we always anticipated this; that pollutants have such an impact on health was always expected.”

Schools surveyed have no clue

The CPCB may have known it all along but officials from Ground Zero —- the 36 schools that participated in this survey —- said they still have no clue about what the scientists found 10 years ago.

chartS K Dahiya, principal, Lakshmi Public School, which had the highest number of children (971) participating in the survey, said he “was not with the school at that time”. “But I am sure that the school has not been made aware of any such findings,” he added.

Ajit Kumar, a member of the school’s Parent-Teacher Association, said, “This has never been raised in the school meetings. I don’t think school authorities or parents are aware of these findings.”

The school is located at one of Delhi’s prominent choke points —- the Vikas Marg intersection opposite Karkardooma court —- with work on a new Metro line adding to the pollution.

Of the 36 schools, the CNCI team found that at least six others were on main arterial roads: Kendriya Vidyalaya, East Arjun Nagar; Cambridge School, Srinivaspuri; Guru Harkrishan Public School, Karol Bagh; Bal Bharti Public School, Karol Bagh; DAV Model School, Yusuf Sarai; and DAV School, Pusa Road.

According to Kamalpreet Kaur, principal, Guru Harkrishan Public School, Karol Bagh, from where 335 students participated in the survey: “I joined the school in 2013, since then there has been no intimation from any authority but I will be following up on this. Air pollution is a big problem for students and teachers, we have so many asthmatic students who take leaves in winter months, I think it is time the government formulate an appropriate policy on this.”

L V Sehgal, principal, Bal Bharti Public School, Karol Bagh, from where 449 students participated in the study, confirmed that the findings were not “shared with us”.

A senior teacher from the school, who did not wish to be identified, said, “We had been one of the earliest schools to accept the proposal of the study. I remember our teachers helped two scientists who came here get consent letters from parents. We were in touch with the scientists till 2008-09, but after that we do not know when the report came out.”

A staff member from Kendriya Vidyalaya, East Arjun Nagar, from where 730 students participated in the study, said that the principal at the time had moved on. But he added, “The scientists spent almost a month here collecting samples, and interacting with students and parents in around 2005-06. But the results never came to the principal’s office.”

Now, even those who were not part of the survey are worried. Ameeta Wattal, principal, Springdales School, Pusa Road, said they set up an air pollution monitoring station at the school four years ago to “inculcate an awareness among children”.

Some of Delhi’s leading schools that were not part of the CNCI study say their students are suffering too:

“Our school is located in front of an intersection where there has always been very high traffic concentration. It is a problem we cannot ignore so we installed an air monitoring station at our school about four years ago. Children are encouraged to analyse trends, and check air quality, and we have been trying to inculcate an awareness among them about air pollution.”

— Ameeta Wattal, Principal, Springdales School, Pusa Road

.“We are very concerned about air pollution in Delhi. But there’s only so much that the students can do. Pollution in Delhi is mainly caused by vehicles and generators that use diesel. That is not something that students have control over, but we educate them and encourage them to tell their parents to take precautions.”

— D R Saini, Principal, DPS, R K Puram.

A year later, another warning

It’s not just the CNCI study that has red-flagged this danger: in 2013, a year after their report was published, the World Allergy Organisation Journal reported high respiratory disorder symptoms among students living in Chandni Chowk (66%) in North Delhi, Mayapuri (59%) in West Delhi and Sarojini Nagar (46%) in South Delhi.

Meanwhile, what’s the govt doing?

On January 7, the Supreme Court-nominated Environment Pollution Control Authority (EPCA), along with Centre for Science and Environment, suggested various measures to control air pollution in Delhi, including the closure of schools on ‘red alert’ days when pollution levels cross a specified limit.

But the government, in a joint affidavit by the ministries of environment, road transport and petroleum, responded: “With regard to closing of schools on red alert days, it is respectfully submitted that exposure of schoolgoing children to higher level of pollution occurs only for limited period, during travel. Moreover, most of the schools are closed for winter break.”

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

First Published on: April 2, 2015 3:53 am
  1. T
    Tanya P
    Aug 17, 2016 at 10:20 am
    I run an online support and discussion group around Paediatric Asthma and COPD. If you are a parent in India whose child is suffering from that, please whatsapp me at 7760998006 to get added. Thanks.
    Reply
    1. A
      Adrian Akau
      Apr 2, 2015 at 6:07 am
      The Delhi government seems more concerned about protecting cows than about the health and welfare of the children, most of whom are Hindu.
      Reply
      1. K
        Kashi Shah
        Apr 2, 2015 at 9:43 am
        Nice Article : Read this
        Reply
        1. K
          Kashi Shah
          Apr 2, 2015 at 9:43 am
          Nice Article : Read this Eden control the intensity of the fighting, casualties increased
          Reply
          1. S
            S. Sarkar
            Apr 2, 2015 at 1:41 pm
            This is the headline in NDTV site on February 17, 2015 - "AAP Government Sweeps Away Green Check for Small Businesses in Delhi" - just 2 days after forming Government. AAP should take Pollution control seriously and not swa by lobbies.
            Reply
            1. C
              Chavali
              Apr 2, 2015 at 6:37 pm
              As you sow shall thou shall reap! Every one is responsible for this poor state of affairs. The vehicles; illegal factories and chimneys in midst of Delhi and so called urbanization with fast dwindling green cover. Besides this the contractors and building industry is licenced in India to cause all sort of pollution without concern or care. It has to be a peoples movement. AAP being a volunteer based party the Government should do something to save for near future.
              Reply
              1. S
                Sudhakar
                Apr 2, 2015 at 8:45 pm
                To save children from pollution the first and foremost important thing is to relocate the schools to areas which are at walking distances from their houses. Then there will be no school buses which themselves cause air pollution. Also, offices and shops should also be made to come near residential areas so that there is reduction in the compulsory travelling using vehicles. Battery driven vehicles with batteries which can be recharged using solar power sholud be used.
                Reply
                1. M
                  MK
                  Apr 2, 2015 at 5:45 pm
                  If we don't take care of the environment, where will we all live? And speaking of mutations, government is already on a national nuclear agenda, proposing to build nuclear power plants in every state as if they don't know the hazards. Apparently, environmental authorities are not doing much.
                  Reply
                  1. D
                    Damaru Prasad
                    Apr 2, 2015 at 4:58 pm
                    I am sure Congis are responsible for it all. They messed up the nation for the last seven decade and now the national capital is inhabitable. When are Indian people going to chase Congis away to Italy?
                    Reply
                    1. G
                      ginololoya
                      Apr 2, 2015 at 8:05 am
                      You see, Mr. Kejriwal should be addressing these kinds of problems of Delhi rather than maneuvering his win all the time. He should walk into these smoke laden atmosphere and work out solutions that keep everyone happy. Where is he?
                      Reply
                      1. G
                        ginololoya
                        Apr 2, 2015 at 8:07 am
                        i do not know why these students do not do gherao or dharna against Kejriwal number six?
                        Reply
                        1. G
                          Gopal
                          Apr 2, 2015 at 9:26 am
                          This is what mive urbanization does. However, there are more than a billion people in India whose life in Delhi would still be better than their current life. So they keep coming. Illegal colonies pop up. Populist politicians keep regularizing them, along with free water and cheap electricity. AAP is only the latest party to use these sops to capture votes. It works even if it degrades the environment, ruins health and causes permanent damage with children. Sadly India's infatuation with left wing politics keeps this vicious cycle repeating.
                          Reply
                          1. R
                            Raghu Krishna
                            Apr 2, 2015 at 12:04 pm
                            What about the human beings outside New Delhi? People and press shall highlight air pollution issues in other states too. Supreme court shall take up the issue suo motto
                            Reply
                            1. G
                              Girish Rao
                              Apr 2, 2015 at 6:05 am
                              Please all hands on board in this tempest and save my kids my future. . . . If only mother nature has a voice. But question is who can listen to her agony.
                              Reply
                              1. R
                                R
                                Apr 2, 2015 at 5:18 pm
                                Dear Sir, I just escaped from the pollution in Chennai to Srirangam to find that this Temple City is seething with overflowing and stagnating sewage and enormous amounts of uncleared garbage. Here any place is an open air toilet and recently the rented Political crowds have done havoc.I have been suffering from allergy induced Asthma and at 78 I have lived in 30 different places. Can you suggest at least 10 clean places to live.I shall thank you for your valuable suggestions.
                                Reply
                                1. S
                                  SB
                                  Apr 2, 2015 at 6:45 pm
                                  I am really glad Indian Express has been covering the pollution issue for the last couple of days. Dont stop till something is done! I hope this is taken seriously by the government and the citizens.
                                  Reply
                                  1. M
                                    Mahesh Naik Mahesh Naik
                                    Apr 2, 2015 at 1:03 pm
                                    Nice study to find out how human being are also mutating as animals to survive in time of delhi pollution. Though mutations are already visible in how they behave ,this would be nice 'scientific' study based on lots of state of the mart 'statistical' sampling models.
                                    Reply
                                    1. M
                                      Mahesh Naik Mahesh Naik
                                      Apr 2, 2015 at 1:05 pm
                                      do not get scared. By the time you are effected your genes might have mutated to survive.
                                      Reply
                                      1. S
                                        Saurabh Vashist
                                        Apr 2, 2015 at 9:42 pm
                                        Nearly around 3000 highly polluted factories are running in Trinagar I have filed RTI no response from MCD .This can be done by taking strict action against highly polluted factories.Mcd is most corrupt department in India also they are putting normal Delhi Citizen health at stack and takes bribe from factory owners and run illegal factories in Delhi and pollute Clean and Fresh Air . Now Delhi is number one is pollution in W World credit goes to MCD and DPCC they can only mointer the data do not take any action against culprit.
                                        Reply
                                        1. S
                                          Sancan
                                          Apr 2, 2015 at 5:57 am
                                          People of delhi and AK what is your wish dirty air to pay for free water and electricity . AAP is promoting pollution to kill people of delhi. Clean air was committment of Namo so AK can not work on clean air .
                                          Reply
                                          1. V
                                            Venkat Sundaram
                                            Apr 2, 2015 at 11:32 pm
                                            Delhi govt that is AAP is busy with dousing the flames of rebellion.
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments