J&K parties spot another Gujarat factor: Protest to EC over EVMs ‘from that state’

The rumours was that EVMs were “manufactured” in Gujarat and were programmed to ensure BJP’s victory.

Written by Raghvendra Rao | New Delhi | Published:September 1, 2014 2:29 am

A routine administrative move by the Election Commission of India, to shift electronic voting machines (EVMs) from Gujarat to Jammu and Kashmir for the Assembly polls there, has taken a surprise political turn.

The controversy started with rumours that the EVMs had been “manufactured” in Gujarat and were programmed to ensure the BJP’s victory in the polls. Despite the EC clarifying that this was not true, and that the machines were only being moved for operational reasons, many in the Valley remain unconvinced.

“We have to be doubly sure. The people of J&K are already asking why EVMs are being brought from Gujarat. An NGO created quite a stir by claiming that these machines could be tampered with,” J&K Congress president Saifuddin Soz told The Indian Express.

“People are asking why the machines are being brought from Gujarat and not any other state. I have promised them that there will be no rigging or malpractice during polls,” Soz said, adding that he would approach the EC soon. “Why do something like this and let doubts creep in?”

Despite fears of EVM tampering having been proved wrong, the ruling National Conference too has joined the bandwagon and is planning to take up the issue with the EC. “There is no justification to bring these machines from Gujarat. Why can’t EVMs be sent from Punjab or Haryana or Himachal Pradesh or even Delhi?” party general secretary Ali Mohammad Sagar said. “Except the BJP, every single party in J&K has expressed reservations on this move.”

Asked what he feared, Sagar said, “There is a lot of distance between Gujarat and J&K. Anything can happen.”

A few days ago, Jammu & Kashmir National Panthers Party chief Bhim Singh sent a letter to Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) V S Sampath, saying that “importing Gujarat-manufactured EVMs to J&K shall prove counterproductive”. “Why have Gujarat manufacturers been chosen for this purpose, that too for J&K, which has a history of elections being rigged?” he wrote to the CEC.

The EC, however, is standing its ground. “It is a case of misunderstanding. All the EVMs are manufactured by BEL and ECIL in Bangalore and Hyderabad. Depending on the requirement, we move them from one state to another, taking factors like availability and distance into consideration. In case of J&K, we decided to move the EVMs from Gujarat. Similarly, we plan to move EVMs to Maharashtra from Uttar Pradesh,” Sampath told The Indian Express.

He added that there was no question of entertaining the request of J&K parties. “Doing that would mean we are acknowledging that the EVMs used in Gujarat could have been tampered with. It will be like accepting that polls in Gujarat were manipulated. We cannot entertain that request,” Sampath said.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. O
    Ovais Shah
    Jan 6, 2015 at 11:56 am
    We've not lost it nor our political leaders. We're not afraid of Modified and BJP.. Yes of course for sure an Evm can be tempered as BJP already has done it in past if u remember. BJP broke the seals of evm's before elections and even there is a case registered as well for that. So without knowledge one should not for god sake comment. I love modi ji though he has done nothing yet for country till date. If you think we're afraid that modi ji might remove art. 370, so remove this though from your mind Cuz it is impossible. It means we're tempering the basic structure of the consution. Be logical n take care
    1. I
      Sep 1, 2014 at 3:41 am
      Mr. Soz and his party is a national disaster. his petty mind is at work in tarnishing Modi. Kashmir is full of divisive leaders whether it is Omar, Mufti or Soz. Kashmirs will do good to get rid of rotten politicians if they want to prosper.
      1. S
        Sep 2, 2014 at 3:22 am
        These pea-brained Congressmen's brains have even shrunk further!!!
        1. A
          Anuradha Kalhan
          Sep 1, 2014 at 2:29 pm
          In J&K they should use paper ballots. It is 'sensitive' and small enough for that. Many people have expressed their concerns about EVMs in over the past few years in India and earlier in Florida! Also most of North plains in India consist of failed state specially when compared to Kashmir and the South so please don't go on about stan being a failed state look at your own country!
          1. I
            Sep 1, 2014 at 10:29 am
            Oh did they expect the machines to come from stan ?
            1. K
              Sep 1, 2014 at 5:13 am
              Most stupid reason to oppose
              1. M
                Mankuzhi Murali
                Sep 1, 2014 at 6:22 am
                The politicians of J&K have lost their brains altogether. How can the EC be partial and will they allow any EVM without inspection ? The name of Gujarat and Modi are allergic to anti BJP camps. They foresee their severe drubbing in next polls. They are now afraid of not only BJP,Modi and Gujarat, but also EVMs from that state. What a pity? Politically they all are bankrupted in governance and peaceful co-existence in the state of J&K, What a pity !!
                1. A
                  Aug 31, 2014 at 11:38 pm
                  o there it is because Gujarat was a trusted state J&K just think of what stan can offer you they cannot even handle their own existing citizens.
                  1. N
                    Nikhil Sheth
                    Dec 2, 2014 at 4:16 am
                    Why don't they use paper-audit-trail EVMs now... EC has promised to the Supreme Court since early 2013 after Dr.Subramanian Swamy proved in court that the EVMs can be tampered with. :post.jagran/at-last...Why is Election Commission refusing to fulfill its obligation made more than an year ago; and why has the reporter ended up lying here? "Despite fears of EVM tampering having been proved wrong" It has been proven in India's highest court that the opposite is the truth. Who gave the reporter the right to p off an opinion as fact without any proof? This amounts to lying and journalistic fraud. Repeated urance is not proof.
                    1. R
                      Raj gopal
                      Sep 1, 2014 at 4:24 pm
                      What else can one expect from politicians and their parties that harbour dreams of either merging with stan or creating an independent Kashmir?
                      1. R
                        Raj gopal
                        Sep 3, 2014 at 2:38 am
                        Why? If there are 100 problems and if you say we should stop thinking/ acting about a few, why should the country listen to you? stan is also a problem which takes more lives than hunger, poverty and most of the dreaded diseases. Why should India stop thinking about stan? Because you like it?
                        1. A
                          Sep 1, 2014 at 3:23 am
                          Ha ha ha! Yesterday Digvijay Sing accepted that defense deals involve loads of corruption. Acceptance at least means he acknowledges that they have done it. It was like Musharraf telling that both stan and India are exporting terrorism. Isnt that at full acknowledgment that at least Pak is doing it. Trust for other comes from your own up bringing. All political parties except BJP and a couple others are Personal fiefdom of their masters who have not allowed anything but the family to rule and they keep crying democracy is in danger?
                          1. S
                            Sachin Jagade
                            Sep 1, 2014 at 8:31 am
                            Wonder how the Election Commission will act in finality. Whether they will stick to their stand and allow the EVMs from Gujarat to be used will go a long way in showing their impartiality.
                            1. V
                              Sep 1, 2014 at 3:54 am
                              Parties which support stan know that they will lose the elections so they are blabbering some nonsense.
                              1. Y
                                yogesh patil
                                Sep 1, 2014 at 4:35 am
                                Fail to understand These parties and the people of kashmir who can even think of joining stan ,which is such a failed nation .look at what is going on. There is no such problem with Jammu and Laddakh .Good example of religious fanaticism
                                1. Load More Comments